Trump’s Selective Comparison Overstates Trade Deficit Decline

Through President Donald Trump’s archetypal afloat 10 months successful office, the cumulative U.S. commercialized shortage successful goods and services was down 3.9% from the aforesaid play successful 2024. His assertion that helium has “slashed our commercialized shortage by 77%” appears to comparison the monthly commercialized shortage successful January 2025 to the shortage 9 months aboriginal successful October.

Economic experts told america that Trump’s method is not the preferable mode to measurement whether the wide commercialized imbalance with planetary trading partners is up oregon down.

“[L]ooking astatine changes from 1 period to different is not a reliable mode to measure whether the commercialized shortage is rising oregon falling successful immoderate meaningful sense,” Kyle Handley, a prof of economics astatine the University of California, San Diego, wrote successful an email to us.

He said “[m]onthly commercialized equilibrium figures are highly volatile” and “reflect timing of shipments, vigor prices, seasonal accommodation noise, and one-off transactions.” He suggested alternatively looking astatine commercialized trends implicit respective months or, erstwhile possible, a afloat year.

On aggregate occasions, however, Trump has claimed to person already reduced the commercialized shortage by a ample magnitude based connected conscionable 2 months of data.

“We had the largest commercialized shortage successful satellite history” nether erstwhile President Joe Biden, “but successful 1 twelvemonth I’ve slashed our gaping commercialized shortage by a staggering 77%,” Trump said successful Jan. 27 remarks successful Iowa, for example.

In a code astatine the World Economic Forum connected Jan. 21, Trump made it much wide that helium was comparing the commercialized shortage successful 1 period to another, saying, “In 1 year, I slashed our monthly commercialized shortage by a staggering 77% — and each of this with nary inflation, thing everyone said could not beryllium done.” The president highlighted the driblet successful the monthly commercialized shortage again successful a Jan. 30 Wall Street Journal op-ed, successful which helium attributed the “astonishing” alteration to “the assistance of tariffs.”

He adjacent predicted successful a Jan. 20 White House property conference: “Next twelvemonth we won’t person a commercialized deficit.”

To beryllium clear, the Bureau of Labor Statistics says that the yearly ostentation complaint has declined from 3% to 2.7% since Trump has been backmost successful office, but it’s not astatine 0%. So prices are inactive increasing, conscionable astatine a slower pace. His accent connected the monthly commercialized shortage could besides mislead radical proceeding oregon speechmaking his remarks.

“The monthly commercialized equilibrium has been unusually volatile this year, truthful I would beryllium cautious astir drafting conclusions from the information truthful far,” Robert Johnson, an planetary economist and subordinate economics prof astatine the University of Notre Dame, told america successful an email.

In October, U.S. imports of goods and services exceeded exports by astir $29.2 billion, the lowest one-month spread successful commercialized since 2009, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. The October fig was down astir 77.3% from the $128.8 cardinal shortage successful commercialized successful January past year. That appears to beryllium however Trump calculated the percentage, though the White House did not corroborate that erstwhile we asked.

But Johnson said that deficits were “unusually large” successful aboriginal 2025, betwixt astir $120 cardinal and $136 cardinal successful January, February and March, due to the fact that U.S. importers stocked up connected goods to physique their inventories earlier assorted tariffs connected imported products that Trump had said helium planned to instrumentality went into effect. “Then, aft the tariffs were enactment successful place, imports fell backmost to normal,” producing smaller monthly deficits successful aboriginal months.

“Whether this is simply a imperishable change, oregon simply reflecting the drawdown successful inventories, is excessively soon to tell,” Johnson said.

“If you conscionable instrumentality the fig from a period and you comparison it to a fig from different month, past you’re conscionable introducing a batch of each of the sound that’s successful the monthly data,” Monica de Bolle, a elder chap astatine the Peterson Institute for International Economics, told america successful an interview.

When the monthly commercialized shortage successful goods and services dipped to a 16-year debased successful October, some economists attributed the diminution mostly to an summation successful U.S. exports of golden and a alteration successful imports of pharmaceuticals. Meanwhile, BEA information released connected Jan. 29 amusement that the monthly shortage astir doubled to $56.8 cardinal successful November, which would beryllium a 55.9% driblet from January – and would marque the 77% fig outdated.

“Large month-to-month swings are common, adjacent successful periods with nary underlying structural alteration successful commercialized argumentation oregon economical conditions,” Handley, astatine UC San Diego, said. “For that reason, economists astir ne'er measure claims astir the ‘trade deficit’ based connected comparisons betwixt 2 idiosyncratic months.”

He listed different measurements that amended measure whether the commercialized shortage is rising oregon falling, specified arsenic comparing cumulative deficits wrong a twelvemonth oregon year-to-date totals compared with the aforesaid play successful anterior years.

“On those measures, the assertion that the shortage fell sharply successful 2025 does not clasp up,” helium said.

As we noted, erstwhile totaling the commercialized shortage successful each of Trump’s archetypal afloat 10 months successful bureau successful 2025, from February to November, the most caller data available, the spread betwixt imports and exports was $710.7 cardinal – a 3.9% diminution from the aforesaid play successful 2024. On the different hand, the commercialized shortage including each months from January to November past twelvemonth was $839.5 cardinal – up 4.1% from the aforesaid 11 months successful 2024.

Trump didn’t instrumentality bureau until Jan. 20, but to reemphasize Johnson’s point, determination was a ample commercialized shortage successful the archetypal 4th of 2025 arsenic importers rushed to get goods up of Trump’s projected tariffs.

Trade information for December, and frankincense each of 2025, should beryllium published connected Feb. 19, according to the Census Bureau’s merchandise schedule. The largest yearly U.S. commercialized shortage successful goods and services connected grounds was astir $923.7 cardinal successful 2022, during the Biden administration, according to BEA information going backmost to 1960. (The Census Bureau and BEA jointly supply this data.)

Although Trump whitethorn presumption a commercialized shortage arsenic thing negative, many economists don’t spot it that way.

“A commercialized shortage sounds bad, but it is neither bully nor bad,” Tarek Alexander Hassan, a prof of economics astatine Boston University, wrote successful an April 2025 sentiment post. “It doesn’t mean the US is losing money. It simply means foreigners are sending the US much goods than the US is sending them.”

Trade Deficit Not Going Away Soon

The experts we consulted besides told america that the commercialized shortage is improbable to beryllium eliminated “next year,” arsenic Trump claimed.

“It is inactive the lawsuit that the U.S. is not self-sufficient successful everything,” de Bolle, astatine PIIE, said. “It whitethorn beryllium capable to export a lot, but it inactive imports mode much than it exports.”

She said connected a macroeconomic level, the U.S. consumes much than it saves, and “that is going to construe into a commercialized shortage astir of the time, not a commercialized surplus.”

Handley said to proceed “very cautiously” with predictions that the commercialized shortage volition extremity owed to tariffs, arsenic Trump suggested successful his Jan. 20 White House remarks.

“Trade deficits bespeak redeeming and concern balances, speech rates, and macroeconomic conditions, not conscionable tariffs,” Handley said, adding that tariffs could trim the exports of U.S. manufacturing firms by expanding the outgo of goods imported for production, “and frankincense the shortage volition not improve.”

He noted that astir of the tariffs that Trump imposed successful 2018 and 2019, during his archetypal statesmanlike term, applied to goods that American manufacturers imported for accumulation purposes. “When their inputs got much expensive, their exports slowed down arsenic well,” helium said. “We are seeing those aforesaid dynamics close now.”

The past clip that the U.S. did not person an yearly commercialized shortage successful goods and services was 1975. That year, determination was a commercialized surplus of $12.4 billion, according to BEA records.

There is besides the contented of whether each of Trump’s second-term tariffs volition proceed arsenic implemented. 

The Supreme Court is expected to regularisation this twelvemonth connected the legality of immoderate Trump tariff policies. That volition find whether the tariffs stay successful spot successful their existent form.

---

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station Trump’s Selective Comparison Overstates Trade Deficit Decline appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.