Trump’s Immediate Speculation on Shootings Bucks Presidential Norms

President Donald Trump wasted nary clip successful responding to the deaths of 2 U.S. citizens this period during protests against an migration crackdown successful Minneapolis. Trump and different apical medication officials made inaccurate oregon unsupported statements wrong hours of the incidents, a departure from however erstwhile presidents responded successful akin situations, experts told us.

Hours aft an Immigration and Customs Enforcement cause changeable and killed Renee Good connected Jan. 7, Trump claimed that Good was “very disorderly, obstructing and resisting, who past violently, willfully, and viciously ran implicit the ICE Officer, who seems to person changeable her successful aforesaid defense.” The president included a video clip of the shooting, captured from a distance, but person video showed the cause wasn’t tally over.

Then, hours aft national agents changeable and killed Alex Pretti connected Jan. 24, Trump posted a representation of a handgun and wrote, “This is the gunman’s gun, loaded (with 2 further afloat magazines!), and acceptable to spell – What is that each about? Where are the section Police? Why weren’t they allowed to support ICE Officers? The Mayor and the Governor called them off? It is stated that galore of these Police were not allowed to bash their job, that ICE had to support themselves — Not an casual happening to do!”

Department of Homeland Security officials besides made statements that Pretti “approached” officers with a handgun, “violently resisted” an effort to “disarm” him, and “wanted to bash maximum harm and massacre instrumentality enforcement.” As we’ve explained, successful the contiguous aftermath of a shooting, it’s hard to cognize precisely what happened, but bystander videos contradicted DHS’ account. They don’t amusement Pretti holding the weapon oregon threatening officers with it.

The president, himself, softened his remarks, saying the adjacent day, “We’re reviewing everything and volition travel retired with a determination” connected whether the national agent’s actions were justified. And the civilian rights part of the Justice Department is present investigating the Pretti killing.

All 4 of the experts we spoke to — a radical that included governmental communications researchers and historians — said that Trump’s remarks pursuing these deaths marked a displacement from erstwhile presidents, and adjacent from immoderate of his ain rhetoric during his archetypal term.

“As with truthful overmuch other Trump, yes — he’s highly different,” Matt Dallek, a governmental historiographer and prof astatine George Washington University’s Graduate School of Political Management, told america successful an interview.

“He’s overmuch much utmost and acold much untethered from facts and the world connected the ground,” Dallek said, noting that, importantly, it’s not conscionable the president, but besides his officials who person taken this tack.

Others we spoke to made the aforesaid point.

“Without question,” determination has been a shift, Roderick Hart, a prof emeritus of connection astatine the University of Texas astatine Austin with expertise successful authorities and the wide media, told us. “And it has precise small to bash with this peculiar concern successful Minneapolis. He’s a rhetoric-first guy. … And he’s chosen his radical who person precisely the aforesaid instincts,” Hart said.

Presidents are usually judicious, peculiarly erstwhile reacting to an event, Hart said. But, “Trump talks earlier the lawsuit is adjacent finished.”

The Minnesota fatal shootings, however, progressive national agents, portion examples from past presidencies interest authorities oregon section officers. 

For example, erstwhile President Barack Obama — who was successful bureau astatine a moment erstwhile the ubiquity of camera phones and the emergence of societal media converged to radiance airy connected the killings of unarmed Black men and boys — took much clip earlier publically expressing his thoughts.

One of the archetypal illustrations of this infinitesimal didn’t really diagnostic an officer, but alternatively a vicinity ticker unpaid successful cardinal Florida, who changeable and killed 17-year-old Trayvon Martin connected Feb. 26, 2012. About a period aft that, successful effect to a reporter’s question, Obama said, successful part, “Well, I’m the caput of the enforcement branch, and the lawyer wide reports to me, truthful I’ve got to beryllium cautious astir my statements to marque definite that we’re not impairing immoderate probe that’s taking spot close now. But obviously, this is simply a tragedy. I tin lone ideate what these parents are going through. And erstwhile I deliberation astir this boy, I deliberation astir my ain kids. And I deliberation each genitor successful America should beryllium capable to recognize wherefore it is perfectly imperative that we analyse each facet of this and that everybody pulls unneurotic — federal, state, and section — to fig retired precisely however this calamity happened.”

Obama continued: “But my main connection is to the parents of Trayvon Martin. If I had a son, he’d look similar Trayvon. And I deliberation they are close to expect that each of america arsenic Americans are going to instrumentality this with the seriousness it deserves and that we’re going to get to the bottommost of precisely what happened.”

In 2014, a year that saw respective high-profile constabulary killings, Obama waited 3 days to publically respond to the Aug. 9 death of 18-year-old Michael Brown, who was changeable and killed by a section constabulary serviceman successful Ferguson, Missouri, sparking widespread protests.

Then, Obama said successful a statement: “The decease of Michael Brown is heartbreaking, and Michelle and I nonstop our deepest condolences to his household and his assemblage astatine this precise hard time. As Attorney General Holder has indicated, the Department of Justice is investigating the concern on with section officials, and they volition proceed to nonstop resources to the lawsuit arsenic needed. I cognize the events of the past fewer days person prompted beardown passions, but arsenic details unfold, I impulse everyone successful Ferguson, Missouri, and crossed the country, to retrieve this young antheral done reflection and understanding. We should comfortableness each different and speech with 1 different successful a mode that heals, not successful a mode that wounds. Along with our prayers, that’s what Michael and his family, and our broader American community, deserve.”

The erstwhile president waited 3 weeks — erstwhile helium was asked astir it successful an interrogation — to remark connected the shooting decease that twelvemonth of 12-year-old Tamir Rice successful Cleveland. In a lengthy reply to a question astir however liable helium felt his medication was for addressing constabulary shootings, Obama said, “Well, I deliberation an tremendous amount. Not conscionable because, arsenic president, you’re ever liable for what happens successful this state and you’ve got to beryllium portion of the solution, not portion of the problem, but due to the fact that of my peculiar experiences that I bring to this office.”

And Obama took much than 4 months to marque remarks connected the July 17, 2014, decease of Eric Garner successful New York — the erstwhile president had waited until a expansive assemblage decided not to indict the constabulary serviceman who had choked Garner. In December 2014, Obama said, successful part, “My contented is not to remark connected cases wherever determination whitethorn inactive beryllium an investigation. But I privation everybody to recognize that this week, successful the aftermath of Ferguson, we initiated a Task Force whose occupation it is to travel backmost to maine with circumstantial recommendations astir however we fortify the narration betwixt instrumentality enforcement and communities of colour and number communities that consciousness that bias is taking place; that we are going to instrumentality circumstantial steps to amended the grooming and the enactment with State and section governments erstwhile it comes to policing successful communities of color; that we are going to beryllium scrupulous successful investigating cases wherever we are acrophobic astir the impartiality and accountability that’s taking place.”

Before the epoch of the camera phone, the Rodney King lawsuit successful 1991 grabbed nationalist attraction erstwhile a antheral successful a adjacent flat videotaped Los Angeles constabulary beating King during a postulation stop.

Then-President George H.W. Bush waited astir 3 weeks earlier commenting. Then, successful a prepared connection connected March 21, 1991, helium said, successful part, “We’ve each seen those shocking videotapes and person seen transcripts of the incidental successful Los Angeles. And without getting into the specifics of the case, those unspeakable scenes disturbance america each to request an extremity to gratuitous unit and brutality. Law enforcement officials cannot spot themselves supra the instrumentality that they are sworn to defend. This medication volition analyse imaginable breaches of national instrumentality aggressively and volition prosecute violators to the afloat grade of the law. … I was shocked by what I saw successful that tape–that violence. And to the grade there’s a national relation here, I’m assured we volition spell the other mile to spot that that is fulfilled.”

Going backmost adjacent further, to the 1970s, Dallek said, “Even Nixon’s comments successful the aftermath of the Kent State killings were acold much restrained and measured than thing Trump has offered the American people.”

On May 4, 1970, the aforesaid time that the National Guard changeable and killed 4 students during a protestation of the Vietnam War astatine Kent State University successful Ohio, then-President Richard Nixon issued a statement that said, “This should punctual america each erstwhile again that erstwhile dissent turns to violence, it invites tragedy. It is my anticipation that this tragic and unfortunate incidental volition fortify the determination of each the Nation’s campuses–administrators, faculty, and students alike–to basal firmly for the close which exists successful this state of peaceful dissent and conscionable arsenic powerfully against the edifice to unit arsenic a means of specified expression.”

When helium was asked astir the due relation of the National Guard — which, successful this case, had been called successful by the state’s politician — astatine a property league 4 days later, Nixon said, “I privation to cognize what the facts are. I person asked for the facts. When I get them, I volition person thing to accidental astir it. But I bash cognize erstwhile you bash person a concern of a assemblage throwing rocks and the National Guard is called in, that determination is ever the accidental that it volition escalate into the benignant of a calamity that happened astatine Kent State. If determination is 1 happening I americium personally committed to, it is this: I saw the pictures of those 4 youngsters successful the Evening Star the time aft that tragedy, and I vowed past that we were going to find methods that would beryllium much effectual to woody with these problems of violence, methods that would woody with those who would usage unit and unit and endanger others, but, astatine the aforesaid time, would not instrumentality the lives of guiltless people.”

“There are immoderate echoes, I think,” Dallek said, comparing Trump’s caller statements with Nixon’s. But Nixon was overmuch much measured successful the aftermath, Dallek said, adding that “he ne'er branded [the students] arsenic traitors oregon home terrorists.” (After the Good killing, DHS Secretary Kristi Noem called Good’s actions “domestic terrorism,” and Noem used the aforesaid phrase to picture Pretti’s actions.)

Minneapolis Cases Involved Federal Agents

One favoritism betwixt these erstwhile examples and the existent concern is that agents deployed successful Minneapolis are federal, alternatively than authorities oregon local, Barbara Perry, a prof of governance astatine the University of Virginia’s Miller Center, which focuses connected the American presidency, told america successful an interview.

Since astir erstwhile cases of officer-involved shootings implicated authorities oregon section police, presidents could region themselves, she said, and accidental that the Justice Department would investigate.

“So they could support astatine arms magnitude the ineligible process portion expressing their sorrow,” Perry said.

Similarly, Guian A. McKee, a prof of nationalist affairs astatine the Miller Center, told america successful an email, “Trump medication statements astir the caller killings successful Minneapolis person been immediate, they person been political, and they person had small respect for facts oregon willingness to hold until grounds is clear.”

He went connected to explicate that 1 crushed for this whitethorn beryllium that “the caller killings person been done by national agents acting arsenic instruments of the president’s ain policies and the tactics chosen to instrumentality them. This has not been the lawsuit successful astir different instrumentality enforcement-involved deaths, wherever the officers were authorities oregon local. So the actions and their consequences autumn overmuch person to the president.”

Near the extremity of his archetypal term, Trump made conciliatory remarks astir a high-profile lawsuit that progressive section constabulary officers, not national agents.

Two days aft the May 25, 2020, sidesplitting of George Floyd, whose decease nether the genu of a Minneapolis constabulary serviceman led to wide protests, Trump wrote connected Twitter, “At my request, the FBI and the Department of Justice are already good into an probe arsenic to the precise bittersweet and tragic decease successful Minnesota of George Floyd.”

And, 2 days aft that, connected May 29, helium said astatine the commencement of an lawsuit for concern leaders, “I privation to explicit our nation’s deepest condolences and astir heartfelt sympathies to the household of George Floyd. A unspeakable event. Terrible, unspeakable happening that happened. I’ve asked that the Department of Justice expedite the national probe into his decease and bash it immediately, bash it arsenic rapidly arsenic perfectly possible. … It should ne'er beryllium allowed to happen, a happening similar that.”

---

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station Trump’s Immediate Speculation connected Shootings Bucks Presidential Norms appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.