Trump Video Doesn’t Show ‘Burial Sites’ in South Africa

Este artículo estará disponible en español en El Tiempo Latino.

In a salient infinitesimal with the person of South Africa, President Donald Trump played a video that helium said showed “burial sites” for a 1000 achromatic farmers — the victims of what helium has called a genocide — on a roadside successful South Africa.

It really showed a 2020 objection bringing attraction to the contented of unit against farmers of each races successful South Africa.

Trump made his comments during a May 21 Oval Office meeting with South African President Cyril Ramaphosa a week aft the U.S. accepted the archetypal achromatic South African refugees, whom Trump has described arsenic victims of genocide. Ramaphosa pushed backmost against the assertion that determination is simply a achromatic genocide happening successful South Africa, and successful response, Trump had a staffer dim the lights to play a video.

Pointing to the screen, which showed an aerial presumption of a agrarian road dotted connected each broadside with achromatic crosses, Trump said, “These are burial sites, close here. Burial sites — implicit a 1000 of achromatic farmers. And those cars are lined up to wage emotion connected a Sunday morning. Each 1 of those achromatic things you spot is simply a transverse and there’s astir a 1000 of them. They’re each achromatic farmers. The household of achromatic farmers.”

“I’d similar to cognize wherever that is, because, this — I’ve ne'er seen,” Ramaphosa said.

“I mean, it’s successful South Africa,” Trump said.

Rather than burial sites, arsenic Trump claimed, the video showed a objection pursuing the August 2020 murder of Glen and Vida Rafferty, who had been killed during a robbery astatine their farmhouse in Normandien, a agrarian country astir 200 miles southeast of Johannesburg. The crosses on the roadworthy were meant to memorialize and gully attraction to the galore farmers who person been killed implicit the years.

There is simply a existent contented with South African farmers being killed. Although immoderate have cast the killings arsenic a “white genocide,” experts accidental that’s not accurate, as we wrote recently. Rather, they said, astir of the convulsive acts are committed during robberies successful a state wherever astir of the wealthiness and onshore post-apartheid are inactive owned by a comparatively tiny achromatic minority. White radical ain astir 72% of the workplace and cultivation holdings contempt making up about 7% of the population, according to a 2017 land audit report commissioned by the South African government.

And, experts told us, portion determination is simply a precocious complaint of execution and unit successful the country, determination is nary grounds that achromatic farmers are being singled out. According to police data, murders of farmers are little than 1% of each murders successful South Africa. There were 51 murders connected farms successful 2022-23, figures that aren’t delineated by race, retired of a full of astir 27,500 murders successful the country.

“On average, 76 radical are murdered successful South Africa each time according to 2023/2024 authoritative constabulary statistics,” Lizette Lancaster, of the Institute for Security Studies successful South Africa, told america successful an email.

“Robberies and murders connected farms are recognised arsenic a superior occupation by each sectors of society,” she said, going connected to explain, though, that “almost each South Africans from each walks of beingness volition hold that determination is nary achromatic genocide. The authorities has reacted to persistent claims of a achromatic genocide and the conflation of that with workplace murders since Democracy successful 1994.”

In an interview with South Africa’s public broadcasting quality service, Darell Brown, a husbandman who helped signifier the objection featured successful the video Trump showed, said, “The connection we’re trying to convey is: workplace murders indispensable stop. I don’t mean conscionable murders of achromatic commercialized farmers. Farm murders indispensable stop.” He explained that the roadside crosses were typical of farmers who had been killed and called connected the authorities to instrumentality the contented seriously.

The demonstration was held connected Saturday, Sept. 5, 2020, and took spot on the P39 highway betwixt the Raffertys’ location and the adjacent municipality of Newcastle.

The South African news website IOL quoted a subordinate successful the demonstration, Bob Hoatson, arsenic saying that the inaugural was not astir achromatic farmers: “It was for radical from each walks of beingness who were acrophobic astir workplace murders,” helium said.

During the Oval Office exchange, Trump asserted, “When they termination the achromatic farmer, thing happens to them.”

But according to Lancaster, it’s not existent that “the authorities is willfully ignorant (e.g. police) oregon the information assemblage is actively complicit successful the crimes committed against susceptible groups.” In South Africa, she said, “government, nationalist assemblage and assemblage partnerships are yielding results. Farm murders person gone down, agrarian information strategies are present successful place, and determination is thing peculiarly exceptional astir however gruesome these murders are erstwhile you look astatine the standard of unit successful townships, for example.”

In the lawsuit of the Rafferty murders, three men person been convicted and are serving clip successful prison.

“The lives of farmers, workplace workers and workplace dwellers arsenic good arsenic each national of the country, achromatic and white, matters,” past Deputy President David Mabuza said aft the Rafferty murders, arsenic helium convened a meeting to sermon programs to curb unit against farmers. “It is for this crushed that authorities volition proceed to enactment with the Justice, Crime Prevention and Security Cluster to guarantee prevention arsenic a precedence successful dealing with workplace murders.”

While unit remains a superior contented successful South Africa, the video Trump played did not amusement 1,000 “burial sites” oregon beryllium determination is simply a achromatic genocide successful the country.

---

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station Trump Video Doesn’t Show ‘Burial Sites’ successful South Africa appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.