Hits and Misses in RFK Jr.’s Comments on Food Dyes

Este artículo estará disponible en español en El Tiempo Latino.

In caller weeks, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has said that “very, precise beardown studies” nexus nutrient dyes to crab and ADHD. Experts are acrophobic astir the impacts of unhealthy diets and obesity successful the U.S., but immoderate accidental Kennedy overstates the relation of nutrient dyes successful chronic disease.

The dyes haven’t been shown to origin crab successful humans. Studies amusement a imaginable nexus to symptoms of attention-deficit/hyperactivity upset successful children.

Recently, Kennedy has taken his “Make America Healthy Again” run connected the road, appearing successful immoderate states that person passed authorities to bounds nutrient dyes and different additives. So far, governors successful California, Arizona, Utah, Virginia and West Virginia person signed laws disallowing definite nutrient dyes from schoolhouse meals, immoderate opening arsenic soon arsenic aboriginal this year, and West Virginia besides enacted a instrumentality that volition prohibition 7 synthetic nutrient dyes outright from merchantability successful the authorities opening successful 2028. Lawmakers successful 2 twelve further states person introduced oregon passed bills that would restrict synthetic nutrient dyes, which are contiguous successful a assortment of foods, from brushed drinks to cereal.

“So the loneliness, the dispossession, the situation that we person successful intelligence health, successful suicide, successful ADD, ADHD, each of these are linked — and peculiarly to the dyes,” Kennedy said in a March 28 code successful West Virginia, fixed alongside Gov. Patrick Morrisey. “It’s precise wide the dyes that Gov. Morrisey is banning, each of them are linked successful very, precise beardown studies to ADHD and to cancers. So we’re seeing an detonation successful cancers successful this country.”

Kennedy besides spoke astir nutrient dyes successful an April 8 interview on CBS News, following a halt successful Arizona to celebrate legislation to prohibition nutrient dyes and different additives successful schoolhouse lunches, arsenic good arsenic a instrumentality aiming to prohibition usage of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program funds to acquisition sodas. “The nutrient dyes are benignant of the astir egregious,” Kennedy told CBS. “They don’t usage them successful immoderate different country. They’re intelligibly associated with a assortment — a grim inventory — of diseases, including cancers and behavioral illness and neurological illness similar ADHD, and it’s very, precise well-documented.”

We reached retired to HHS to inquire astir the probe Kennedy was referring to, but we did not person a reply.

The grounds linking nutrient dyes and crab comes from studies successful animals and cells. There isn’t grounds nutrient dyes are driving an summation successful crab successful humans, Susan Mayne, who served as manager of the Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition astatine the U.S. Food and Drug Administration betwixt 2015 and 2023, told us.

“We are seeing rising rates of the obesity-related cancers, and particularly successful young people, and that is concerning,” she said. “But focusing successful connected hazard factors wherever there’s truly nary important technological grounds indicating that they are causing these cancers portion omitting ones we cognize are is truly undermining nationalist health.” Mayne spent overmuch of her vocation studying nutrition, epidemiology and crab astatine Yale School of Public Health, wherever she is present an adjunct professor.

Some probe suggests that nutrient dyes pb to neurobehavioral changes successful immoderate children. But the lit is mixed and opinions alteration connected the spot of the evidence.

“The totality of technological grounds indicates that astir children person nary adverse effects erstwhile consuming foods containing colour additives, but immoderate grounds suggests that definite children whitethorn beryllium delicate to them,” the FDA says connected its website in the reply to a question astir nutrient dyes and kid behavior.

Kennedy is besides incorrect successful categorically stating that nutrient dyes aren’t used successful any other country. Regulations connected nutrient dyes alteration astir the world, and companies person reformulated immoderate foods to destruct synthetic dyes for definite markets. The European Union, for example, requires that foods containing definite nutrient colors person informing labels stating that they “may person an adverse effect connected enactment and attraction successful children.” However, synthetic food dyes are allowed outside the U.S.

Some researchers and advocacy groups person said the barroom for grounds connected nutrient dyes’ harms should beryllium low, based connected their deficiency of benefits for consumers.

“These are wholly unnecessary erstwhile we are talking astir nutrition and nutrient safety,” Thomas Galligan, main idiosyncratic for nutrient additives and supplements astatine the nonprofit Center for Science successful the Public Interest, told us, differentiating them from additives with immoderate use, specified arsenic preservatives that support nutrient from going bad. “They are strictly a money-making instrumentality for nutrient companies, and truthful our tolerance for the risk, truthful to speak, is highly debased successful the lawsuit of nutrient dyes.” CSPI has advocated a ban on synthetic nutrient dyes. 

The enactment besides has advocated the tightening of the GRAS, oregon mostly recognized arsenic safe, pathway — a mode for nutrient companies to adhd caller ingredients to their foods without undergoing FDA review. Kennedy has told the FDA to research revising the GRAS pathway.

“Colorants are unnecessary … truthful they should beryllium retired totally,” Dr. John O. Warner, a pediatrician and prof emeritus astatine Imperial College London who has studied the effects of synthetic nutrient dyes and different additives connected children’s behavior, told us. He said a power to earthy colors would beryllium affirmative but that it is indispensable to displacement people’s diets wide to much earthy foods and little ultraprocessed foods. “It’s not lone the additives which are being shown to person the imaginable for adverse effects” successful ultraprocessed foods, helium said. “It’s the archetypal nutrient and the mode it’s processed that could besides beryllium having an adverse effect.”

“I americium each for getting escaped of artificial colors and closing the GRAS loophole but neither of those is simply a large origin of obesity and its wellness consequences,” Marion Nestle, a prof emerita of nutrition, nutrient studies and nationalist wellness astatine New York University, wrote on April 2 connected her blog, Food Politics.

Other researchers person expressed interest that an overly narrow absorption connected nutrient dyes oregon different circumstantial additives — combined with cuts to the federal workforce and programs, and the weakening of biology regulations — volition not meaningfully alteration Americans’ health. 

“We’re proceeding each this rhetoric from RFK Jr. astir however helium wants to hole the nutrient system, but past he’s making monolithic cuts wrong HHS and FDA that volition straight impede his quality to hole the nutrient system,” Galligan said.

Food Dyes Not Established to Cause Human Cancers

Kennedy’s comments springiness the incorrect content that FDA-approved synthetic nutrient dyes are a well-established origin of cancer.

“The lone nutrient additives for which grounds has shown a nexus with crab are nitrites and nitrates, which are utilized arsenic preservatives successful processed meat,” the American Institute for Cancer Research states on its website. “Eating processed nutrient is powerfully associated with an accrued hazard of colorectal cancer. There is presently nary different beardown grounds linking nutrient additives to an accrued crab risk.”

“I deliberation the grounds that the approved nutrient colorings origin crab is precise slim,” Dr. Ronald Kleinman, a pediatrician who studies nutrition astatine MassGeneral Hospital for Children, told us.

Two studies whose results were published successful 1987 indicated that Red 3 caused crab successful antheral laboratory rats. Based connected this probe and following a 2022 petition from user advocacy groups, the FDA connected Jan. 15 announced a prohibition of Red 3 successful nutrient and drugs, which volition instrumentality effect successful 2027 for nutrient and 2028 for drugs. But the bureau said that it was banning the dye owed to a request nether instrumentality to prohibition immoderate nutrient additive that has been shown to origin crab successful animals — and not owed to interest that the dye caused crab successful people. 

The dye caused crab “due to a rat circumstantial hormonal mechanism” that does not use successful humans, according to the agency, and radical are not usually exposed to the levels of dye shown to origin crab successful antheral rats. Claims that the dye’s beingness successful nutrient oregon drugs “puts radical astatine hazard are not supported by the disposable technological information,” the FDA website says.

“I deliberation there’s a bully process successful spot to reappraisal whether the … dyes origin cancer,” Kleinman said. “For each of those that person been approved, we tin beryllium beauteous definite astatine this constituent that determination is nary grounds that they origin crab and determination on.”

The wide information besides bash not enactment Kennedy’s connection that determination has been an “explosion” successful cancers. Cancer mortality has been declining in the U.S. since the 1990s, successful some men and women. Incidence besides has declined in men since its highest successful the 1990s, though it has risen gradually successful women implicit this period. (A large origin driving a crab spike successful the 1990s successful men was the emergence of PSA testing, which tin place slow-growing prostate cancers that would person ne'er gone connected to origin harm.)

The mortality rates “went up precise precocious immoderate decades ago, and that was due to the fact that of the immense interaction of smoking connected lung crab successful some men and women, and that dominated the full mortality information due to the fact that lung crab was truthful communal and truthful lethal,” Mayne explained. “And past with nationalist wellness interventions to trim smoking, we saw a alteration successful crab mortality. First it started successful men, followed down that successful women.” The diminution successful crab deaths has besides been driven by improvements successful crab screening and treatment, according to the American Cancer Society.

Cancers person varied hazard factors, Mayne said, and immoderate cancers — specified arsenic adenocarcinoma of the esophagus and uterine cancer — person risen successful caller decades. There is besides a signifier of accrued crab hazard emerging successful younger generations, owed to a emergence successful obesity and different known and chartless factors, according to the ACS.

“The fantastic nationalist wellness gains we made with baccy power person been eroded by the increasing prevalence of obesity successful this country,” Mayne said. 

What radical devour and portion besides tin summation the hazard for circumstantial cancers autarkic of obesity. For instance, probe “very consistently” shows that diets debased successful fiber-containing foods, specified arsenic fruits, vegetables and full grains, are associated with a higher hazard of colon cancer, Mayne said. Consuming much nutrient — and peculiarly processed nutrient — is associated with an accrued hazard of colorectal cancer, she said. And drinking much intoxicant is associated with accrued hazard of a assortment of cancers.

To trim hazard of crab overall, Mayne emphasized the value of avoiding excess alcohol, avoiding tobacco, vaccinating against quality papillomavirus for younger people, maintaining a steadfast assemblage value and eating a high-quality diet.

Other researchers acknowledged the probe connected nutrient dyes and crab successful humans is constricted but expressed interest astir imaginable risks.

Galligan of CSPI agreed that “we don’t person nonstop grounds Red 3 causes crab successful humans,” but helium said that studies to analyse this successful humans would beryllium “hard to conduct” and argued that the disposable grounds supported banning the dye. His enactment was among those that petitioned to prohibition Red 3 based connected the rat data.

Lorne Hofseth, manager of the Center for Colon Cancer Research astatine the University of South Carolina, expressed concern that approved dyes could origin inflammation and DNA damage, which are mechanisms for expanding the hazard of cancer. The dyes “tickle the players progressive successful carcinogenesis,” helium told us.

A Possible Link Between Food Dyes and ADHD Symptoms

Joel Nigg, a objective scientist astatine Oregon Health & Science University, told america successful an email that ADHD has galore causes moving successful concert. Perhaps the largest azygous contributing origin is genetics, helium said, but determination are besides aggregate biology factors that either support against oregon assistance origin ADHD, “especially aboriginal successful development.”

Some studies person recovered a transportation betwixt consuming synthetic nutrient dyes and ADHD symptoms, which see inattention, impulsivity and hyperactivity.

“Thus, it is just to accidental that nutrient dyes are associated with ADHD and bash marque a humble publication to it, but are not the large cause,” Nigg said.

These see challenge studies, successful which children avoided nutrient dyes and sometimes different additives for a play and past were randomly assigned astatine definite intervals to devour drinks oregon foods containing either these additives oregon a placebo.

Researchers astatine the University of Southampton successful the U.K. successful the aboriginal 2000s, for example, had astir 1,800 3-year-old children from the wide colonisation halt consuming synthetic nutrient colorings and a benignant of preservative for a week, earlier randomly assigning them to devour drinks either containing the substances oregon not. The children’s parents reported an summation successful hyperactivity with some the placebo drinks and the additive-containing drinks, but the summation successful hyperactivity was greater with the drinks containing the additives. Clinicians unrelated to the children did not observe a quality successful behaviour successful children who did versus did not person the additives.

Subsequently, the researchers did a similar study in astir 300 further 3-year-olds and 8- and 9-year-olds, utilizing 2 mixtures of nutrient dyes and additives. This survey relied connected genitor and teacher reports, arsenic good arsenic results of a computerized trial for the older children. One premix had a tiny but statistically important power connected behavioral changes successful some property groups. A antithetic premix showed an power successful the older children, but not the younger ones.

Other studies, however, person not identified immoderate effect of nutrient dyes connected behavior. Overall, the lit is mixed, with studies arriving astatine varying conclusions, possibly due to the fact that of differences successful methodology, the populations studied and the additives included.

Some reappraisal studies person nevertheless recovered the nexus betwixt nutrient dyes and behavioral changes to beryllium convincing.

“Overall, our reappraisal of quality studies suggests that synthetic nutrient dyes are associated with adverse neurobehavioral effects, specified arsenic inattentiveness, hyperactivity and restlessness successful delicate children,” a 2021 report from California’s Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment concluded.

Nigg successful 2012 co-authored a meta-analysis that recovered that an “estimated 8% of children with ADHD whitethorn person symptoms related to synthetic nutrient colors.” He told america helium believed that eliminating synthetic nutrient dyes successful the U.S. “would person a tiny effect connected reducing symptoms of inattention and cases of ADHD.” 

However, Nigg said that to “really trim biology contributors to ADHD, it would beryllium important to besides code different arsenic if not much important factors.” These see reducing vulnerability to pb successful the environment, definite types of aerial pollution, different chemicals, and perchance pesticides and herbicides. 

And helium emphasized the value of preventing exposures successful the womb, adding that debased birthweight “is a large contributor to ADHD.”

“Overall, dietary factors are relevant, but are surely not the full story,” helium said. “Given that immoderate of these different contributors are hard to address, possibly a lawsuit tin beryllium made for ‘doing what we can’ to trim exposures.”

Other researchers pointed retired weaknesses successful the information showing a nexus betwixt nutrient dyes and children’s behavior.

Mayne said that cardinal studies wherever children were randomly assigned to devour nutrient dyes progressive dosing children with aggregate ingredients astatine the aforesaid time, which makes it hard to find which ingredients caused the reported behavioral changes.

Kleinman said that weaknesses of the probe connected nutrient dyes and attraction shortage see a deficiency of “rigorous criteria for defining attraction deficit,” the tiny size of the studies, the little play the children were followed and the trouble of separating the effects of nutrient colors from different factors that power behavior, including erstwhile the children were observed and what different things they consumed.

“I deliberation that taken arsenic a whole, determination truly is precise small convincing grounds that nutrient coloring contributes to attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, and banning them for that crushed seems to maine to beryllium retired mode up of wherever the grounds is close now,” Kleinman said.

---

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station Hits and Misses successful RFK Jr.’s Comments connected Food Dyes appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.