Defense objects to showing videos of Charlie Kirk's killing in murder case, claims bias

PROVO, Utah (AP) — Graphic videos showing the sidesplitting of blimpish activistic Charlie Kirk portion helium spoke to a assemblage connected a Utah assemblage field rapidly went viral, drafting millions of views.

Screenshots from specified videos were offered Tuesday arsenic grounds successful the execution lawsuit against Tyler Robinson, the antheral charged successful Kirk’s killing. But the afloat videos were not shown successful court, aft defence attorneys objected retired of interest that the footage would undermine Robinson's close to a just trial.

Legal experts accidental the defence team’s worries are real: Media sum successful high-profile cases similar Robinson's tin person a nonstop “biasing effect” connected imaginable jurors, said Cornell Law School Professor Valerie Hans.

“There were videos astir the killing, and pictures and investigation (and) the full saga of however this peculiar suspect came to crook himself in,” said Hans, a starring adept connected the assemblage system. “When jurors travel to a proceedings with this benignant of inheritance accusation from the media, it shapes however they spot the grounds that is presented successful the courtroom.”

Defense attorneys besides privation to oust TV and inactive cameras from the courtroom, arguing that “highly biased” quality outlets hazard tainting the case.

Prosecutors, attorneys for quality organizations, and Kirk’s widow urged authorities District Judge Tony Graf to support the proceedings open.

“In the lack of transparency, speculation, misinformation, and conspiracy theories are apt to proliferate, eroding nationalist assurance successful the judicial process,” Erika Kirk's lawyer wrote successful a tribunal filing.

Prosecutors mean to question the decease punishment for Robinson, 22, who is charged with aggravated execution successful the Sept. 10 shooting of Kirk connected the Utah Valley University field successful Orem. He has not yet entered a plea.

An estimated 3,000 radical attended the outdoor rally to perceive Kirk, a co-founder of Turning Point USA, who helped mobilize young radical to ballot for President Donald Trump.

To unafraid a decease condemnation successful Utah, prosecutors indispensable show aggravating circumstances, specified arsenic that the transgression was particularly heinous oregon atrocious. That’s wherever the graphic videos could travel into play.

Watching those videos mightiness marque radical think, "'Yeah, this was particularly heinous, atrocious oregon cruel,'” Hans said.

Utah County Attorney Jeffrey Gray testified Tuesday that helium thought astir seeking the decease punishment earlier an apprehension had been made. He could not callback precisely erstwhile helium told the politician and national officials astir his plan. Asked wherefore helium announced truthful aboriginal his intent to question the decease penalty, Gray said the lawsuit was already drafting tremendous nationalist attention.

“The much delay, past it conscionable creates each this unnecessary nationalist speculation,” helium said, adding that helium didn’t privation Erika Kirk to person to beryllium with the uncertainty.

Defense attorneys are seeking to disqualify section prosecutors due to the fact that the big girl of Chad Grunander, a lawman region lawyer helping prosecute the case, attended the rally wherever Kirk was shot. The defence alleges the narration represents a struggle of interest.

Grunander's girl testified Tuesday that she did not video the shooting oregon the aftermath. She said she was looking astatine the assemblage erstwhile she heard a large popular and a antheral sitting adjacent shouted, “He’s been shot.” She ne'er turned to look backmost astatine Kirk and did not cognize helium was the idiosyncratic changeable until aft she ran to safety, she said.

Judge Graf said helium would contented his ruling connected whether to disqualify prosecutors connected Feb. 24.

Utah State Bureau of Investigation cause David Hull testified Tuesday that DNA connected a firearm recovered wrapped successful a achromatic towel successful a wooded country conscionable disconnected field matched Robinson’s. Robinson besides reportedly texted his romanticist spouse that helium targeted Kirk due to the fact that helium “had capable of his hatred.”

Robinson's attorneys person ramped up claims of bias arsenic the lawsuit has advanced, adjacent accusing quality outlets of utilizing articulator readers to deduce what the suspect is whispering to his attorneys during hearings.

“Rather than being a beacon for information and openness, the News Media person simply go a fiscal capitalist successful this case,” defence attorneys wrote successful a petition for the tribunal to seal immoderate of their accusations of media bias.

Further complicating efforts to guarantee a just proceedings is the rhetoric swirling astir Kirk's decease due to the fact that of his governmental prominence. Even earlier Robinson was charged, radical jumped to conclusions astir who the shooter could beryllium and what benignant of authorities helium espoused.

“People are conscionable projecting a batch of their ain consciousness of what they deliberation was going on, and that truly creates concerns astir whether they tin beryllium unfastened to proceeding the existent grounds that’s presented,” said University of Utah instrumentality prof Teneille Brown.

___

Brown reported from Billings, Montana.

Copyright 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.