56 minutes ago
3
It utilized to beryllium a moving gag that men were acrophobic of committedness — the woman was the "ball and chain," and kids were thing women had to unit them into. But lately, an expanding fig of women accidental the publication has flipped entirely. Now, they're the ones opting retired of parenthood, portion men are the ones pushing for matrimony and babies.
"As a pistillate myself, I retrieve erstwhile I was a kid/teenager, everyone said that matrimony and kids were a shot and concatenation to a antheral — ne'er archer a antheral you privation kids, oregon he'd tally away," u/CrystallizedKoi wrote successful r/childfree. "Now it seems similar women are mostly the ones who don't privation children, and men are determined to find a woman who wants their babies. They privation a accepted matrimony and a atomic family. Meanwhile, I spot a batch of women who consciousness similar men prevarication to them astir not wanting kids (and inevitably power up connected them, reasoning they volition alteration their minds), being called selfish, oregon being told they're not pursuing God's word."
Read the afloat station here.
The station racked up astir 800 upvotes and 178 comments earlier it was locked. However, the responses painted a beauteous accordant picture. People shared their theories, idiosyncratic stories, conversations with their grandmothers, and more. Here's what they had to say:
1. "The archetypal connection itself is worthy questioning to statesman with. Did women successful wide privation kids? Or was determination — adjacent conscionable a fewer decades agone — often adjacent much pressure, little information, and less resources for radical to marque their ain informed choices for their lives and bodies? The aforesaid question is inactive often applicable today: Do radical privation kids, oregon bash they privation everything they've been taught that having kids volition get them? With much disposable accusation and resources, much radical are capable to recognize the responsibility successful that logic and measurement distant from it. And successful the property of societal media, it's besides easier than ever for them to speech publically astir it, adjacent if it's inactive seen arsenic taboo."
"Similarly, did men successful wide usage to not privation kids? Or were they conscionable capable to much conveniently cull the work portion inactive getting the expected benefits of having a child, due to the fact that they could offload that work connected the pistillate who much outwardly wanted it?"
"If you look nether the hood, you'll spot that adjacent successful the past, galore women didn't really privation kids, conscionable similar galore don't today. But their options for realizing that and pursuing done with it were worse than today. For those men who presumption kids arsenic a presumption symbol, it's a occupation if present they request to proactively explicit wanting a kid and find a pistillate who volition privation to person kids with them, due to the fact that they'd similar a satellite wherever each women privation kids and they tin get the result they privation without really lifting a digit for it.
It shifted from thing they didn't request to privation due to the fact that it was guaranteed to hap inevitably, to thing that's nary longer a certainty — truthful the ones conscionable determination to beverage the benefits are present panicking astatine the imaginable of losing them."
2. "It's often said men privation kids similar kids privation a puppy. Until recently, men didn't have to privation kids — it was conscionable benignant of assumed that a pistillate they were romantically progressive with would privation them archetypal and unit them into it astatine immoderate point. Then slowly, less women started pressuring less men, and thing they assumed would conscionable yet hap was nary longer inevitable. And suddenly, men looked astir and realized they were successful their 30s and 40s, and nary 1 was pressuring them into it anymore. And lo, men realized they really did privation kids, but lone aft a capable fig of women had yet realized what a earthy woody it was."
3. "'Men privation kids the mode a toddler wants a puppy.' The 'puppy' happening was my spouse erstwhile we archetypal started dating. He said helium wanted kids, but helium had ne'er adjacent been astir a babe for much than a day. I've told him a fewer stories astir surviving with my nephew from ages zero to 4, and helium rapidly changed his mind."
4. "I judge astir men person ever wanted babies arsenic a presumption awesome and 'legacy.' They utilized to beryllium capable to get distant from work portion inactive being the leader by pretending it was their wife's thought and they reluctantly agreed to 'make her happy.' Example: 'But you're changing the diapers since I didn't privation it successful the archetypal place!' Now that galore women don't privation kids, they person to person america to. So they had to springiness up that passive role. Different context, caller strategy, aforesaid goal."
5. "It's 100% a bequest thing. I conscionable spoke to my hubby astir this. A ample bulk of men consciousness their lives volition beryllium insignificant if they don't person kids. That nary 1 volition retrieve them oregon they volition person had nary impact, truthful their lives were worthless. Why bash they consciousness this way? I person nary idea. It's a testosterone thing, a antheral ego thing, whatever. Women don't person this. I don't consciousness similar my beingness has amounted to thing due to the fact that I don't person children. Or really, I don't attraction if my beingness has amounted to nothing. Men do. Must beryllium an ego thing. My hubby is thankfully intelligent capable to recognize this is foolish and not fto it override his consciousness of not wanting children, but helium inactive feels it sometimes arsenic well, and galore men conscionable springiness successful to this basal impulse."
6. "I sat down with my grandma — calved successful the 1930s — a fewer months earlier she died and truly asked her astir her life: her experiences, her choices, her reflections. One of the questions I asked her was what she would bash otherwise if she could bash it each again, and she said person less kids. Five kids was mode excessively many. My grandma felt similar she had nary prime successful the matter, and if fixed afloat autonomy, wouldn't person chosen to person anyplace adjacent that galore kids. I besides asked her what immoderate of her favourite memories were, and did she notation thing astir her hubby oregon her kids? Absolutely not. She said seeing the play Cats successful New York was her all-time favourite memory. All of this is to accidental — women utilized to look societal pressures, obligations, and obstacles that restricted their quality to determine whether oregon not to person kids. Today, we person much choices, and we spot that having kids is not an vantage but alternatively a monolithic disadvantage to a blessed life."
7. "Men feeling insignificant without kids feels similar a earthy grounds of however we archer the communicative of humanity and men's relation successful it. We are each taught immoderate saltation of 'Great Man' past — singular men who allegedly changed the people of past done their solitary efforts alone. In that context, what tin the slightly-above-average antheral bash to permission his 'mark connected the world'? The illogic goes: A large antheral changed the world, astir large men had children, therefore, if I person children, I volition besides alteration the world. Rinse and repetition for respective generations until today's men are lone near with 'real men person legacies,' which means buildings with their names connected them oregon children with their names connected them. By contrast, determination has ne'er been that anticipation oregon humanities communicative for women."
"Historically, the astir a pistillate could anticipation for was to wed good to a large man, carnivore his children, and wield his power for her ain constricted purposes. Being mean oregon stellar had nary existent bearing connected her perceived imaginable interaction connected the world."
8. "I enactment successful convalescent homes and speech with the older women each the clip astir their lives, choices, wants, et cetera. And support successful mind, these women person been surviving successful these nursing homes for years with nary smartphones, truthful they're not proceeding each the opinions astir being childfree that galore women contiguous hear. But each clip I inquire them what they would've done otherwise successful life, truthful galore of them accidental 'not person kids if they had the enactment to' and 'not get joined if they had the enactment to.' Even backmost 70, 80, and 90 years ago, women inactive didn't privation to oregon regretted getting joined and having kids. They conscionable didn't person a prime if they wanted a unchangeable life."
9. "I'm a nurse, and aged ladies inquire maine each the clip if I'm joined and if I person kids. When I accidental no, I'm not and I don't, astir 50% of the clip they look maine close successful the oculus and say, 'Good for you.'"
10. "My grandma has been precise unfastened for arsenic agelong arsenic I tin retrieve astir the information that if it had been an enactment for her, she ne'er would've had kids. Her parents were not astatine each supportive of her education. She asked to spell to the backstage schoolhouse her member went to and was told, 'Why would we wage for that? You're conscionable going to get joined and person babies.' She didn't adjacent cognize parents could travel to a precocious schoolhouse graduation until she got to hers and saw each her classmates' parents there. She joined my gramps conscionable to get retired of her parents' house, and kids were portion of the terms she paid to get distant from them."
11. "My grandma — really some of them, but the grandma I spot much often — has ever maintained that I request to enactment azygous and unrecorded my beingness for maine arsenic agelong arsenic I perchance can. She'll accidental it astatine random times, whether we're driving oregon conscionable hanging out. She genuinely hates her life, and it's not due to the fact that my gramps was a atrocious guy. He perfectly adores her. But you tin archer she didn't person a prime astatine each successful however her beingness unfolded. Women truly did not basal a accidental successful galore cases. Get married. Have babies. And deity forbid you didn't person a day connected a Saturday nighttime during your young, azygous years — you were viewed arsenic thing wrong."
12. "The aged stereotype that I grew up with was that men were escaped spirits and women were ever trying to marque them 'settle down' and 'be responsible.' The woman was the aged shot and chain, bachelor parties were truthful the feline could observe the past days of his freedom, and truthful on. Guys didn't privation their friends to get joined due to the fact that the amusive feline they knew would disappear, and inevitably wouldn't beryllium capable to person a bully clip anymore due to the fact that 'the woman won't fto him.' I deliberation men mostly liked this because, successful a way, it elevated them supra women and gave them a crushed to mock and look down connected women arsenic lesser beings who conscionable ruin everything. They bonded implicit it. Ha ha, it's funny, right? So, truthful galore aged boomer jokes astir however men really hatred their wives."
"Then things changed, and dilatory women stopped pursuing matrimony and kids, and the guys were near hanging like, 'Hey, wait, aren't you expected to privation to wed me? And person my babies? What bash you mean you don't privation that beingness with me? What's the substance with you?'
They privation america backmost successful that acquainted role, the idiosyncratic who is 'under' them, the taxable of their mockery. That's what I think."
13. "When I was increasing up, a woman and kids were seen arsenic a man's 'ball and chain.' The amusement Married With Children was fashionable astatine the time, and Al would ever insult his woman and children similar they were burdens successful his life. Even erstwhile I was partying successful the precocious '90s, you'd perceive guys saying women were trying to 'babytrap' them oregon that they were dating women who were 'too clingy' — adjacent though she was conscionable behaving usually successful a relationship. I deliberation the media decidedly plays a relation successful the perception, but also, radical spot however a definite mindset messed up their parents, and they privation to bash the opposite. Children who turn up with a begetter who treats his household similar a 'ball and chain' whitethorn respond successful antithetic ways — sons whitethorn consciousness driven to go his opposite, portion daughters whitethorn go wary of relationships with men and much hesitant astir having children."
15. "Somehow, the 'provider' inactive expects the pistillate to bash fractional of the 'providing,' and women are like, 'Nope. No thanks. You don't get to financially enactment america halfway portion I bash 100% of everything else. That's not the agreement.' So now, some sides are conscionable much honorable astir what they want."
16. "Women utilized to privation kids due to the fact that kids utilized to mean security. We couldn't work, we couldn't spell to school, we couldn't person recognition cards, we couldn't person slope accounts. We had to beryllium connected men, and men could conscionable permission america oregon wounded america arsenic they pleased. Having kids meant that determination was much societal unit for them to enactment and a flimsy deterrent to support them from abusing us. That carried implicit to aboriginal generations of women who didn't needfully request men, but they were fundamentally groomed into believing kids were needed, and they were meant to beryllium mothers. Absolutely, a batch of women really wanted to person kids, but acold less than those who conscionable said they wanted kids. It's what women did, and it's what women were meant to do. Now accelerated guardant to contiguous — women don't request men."
"We tin person slope accounts, degrees, enactment — each of it. We're educated and person seen however our mothers were treated increasing up. But present there's the anticipation for women to enactment and besides beryllium mothers. Men, meanwhile, get to spell to work, travel location to a bully home, and bash perfectly thing to assistance retired with the kids. We benignant of realized there's nary constituent successful having kids anymore, consciously oregon subconsciously, and dropped it arsenic a large beingness extremity we request to meet. Now the tables person turned. Now, babies mean information for men.
"Men person mislaid their quality to power women financially, politically, and physically. Now they're losing their power implicit women done children. Fatherhood was ever historically casual for men — they were lone expected to wage the bills. They got a bangmaid and their 'legacy' retired of it, but each they truly had to bash was bring location a check, and women were conditioned to instrumentality attraction of everything else. That's wherefore men privation kids truthful atrocious now, due to the fact that it's the lone casual mode to power women. And women don't privation them for that aforesaid crushed — connected apical of not wanting to beryllium a azygous joined parent."
17. "Now that child-rearing costs are the woman's occupation and don't devour up his full 'provider paycheck,' wherefore wouldn't helium privation them?"
18. "We became educated, person acceptable entree to commencement control, and our ancestors from the aboriginal 1900s fought for america to get rights. One of those rights is the prime to person kids oregon not."
19. "Education is beauteous overmuch my answer. We got to larn everything astir child-rearing and pregnancy, and chose to opt retired of it. The bully aged 'you volition cognize however it is erstwhile you're going done it yourself' doesn't truly enactment arsenic good arsenic it utilized to erstwhile you tin Google it successful little than 5 seconds and marque up your caput yourself."
20. "I deliberation societal media has allowed women thing they ne'er had for years — a voice. Women are sharing the realities of childbirth, labor, and raising a kid with a man, often with the anticipation of besides moving and paying 50/50. They've realized there's much to beingness than indentured servitude. Also, much women are graduating and buying their ain homes than men. Women nary longer request to wed and person kids for fiscal information oregon worldly gain, but connected the ground of a man's quality — and truthful galore men are failing miserably."
21. "Fifteen years ago, I retrieve the online manosphere pushing men to enactment blistery condiment successful condoms due to the fact that women were supposedly gold-digging whores who would bargain them retired of the trash aft a hookup — due to the fact that apparently, babies were immoderate benignant of repast ticket. The full civilization was astir barroom pickups, fake names, and nary cohabitation. RooshV was their patron saint, and I retrieve erstwhile helium himself 'hit the wall' and wanted to settee down with a Christian trad wife. Now, it's wholly flipped. The propulsion is to person a live-in enactment nanny who besides needs to wage her way, due to the fact that astir of them inactive don't privation to really wage for a trad wife, and they've realized babies are the existent mode to support women around."
22. "I saw a German documentary a fewer years agone — I don't retrieve what it was astir — but 1 happening stood out: a idiosyncratic addressed the displacement successful men's tendency to person offspring betwixt the past period and now. The mentation is that it relates to our changing economical systems. Men utilized to deduce a batch of designation and validation from their nonrecreational lives. Even 'simple' jobs could marque a hubby the azygous breadwinner and adjacent wage for a vacation. Nowadays, astir men are burned retired by their jobs much quickly, validation is adjacent zero, and there's often small position connected amended times ahead. Becoming a manager is nary longer arsenic awesome arsenic it utilized to be. So the caller presumption awesome became wifey and kids, alternatively than nonrecreational achievement. It's besides a adjacent unit happening — men tin beryllium conscionable arsenic dogmatic toward each different arsenic women, and often instill feelings of guilt and shame successful others who don't travel the caller golden modular of the atomic household 2.0."
What bash you deliberation caused the displacement — oregon bash you deliberation determination adjacent was one? Have you noticed this dynamic successful your ain dating life, oregon heard thing akin from the women successful your family? Share your thoughts successful the comments oregon anonymous signifier below.
Note: Responses person been edited for length/clarity.
English (US) ·