Woman who responded 'Which one?' when cops asked her about 1 of her 2 dead ex-husbands could now face the death penalty: Prosecutors

A Florida pistillate who allegedly changeable some of her ex-husbands connected the aforesaid time faces the decease punishment successful 1 of their cases.

Susan Avalon, 51, faces execution charges successful 2 counties aft constabulary said she fatally changeable her 2 ex-husbands, 55-year-old Timothy Flecher and 54-year-old David Scott, connected Dec. 17, 2025. Flecher was recovered dormant of a gunshot wound astatine his location successful Tampa, and connected Tuesday, the Hillsborough County State's Attorney's Office said successful a property merchandise that it would question the decease penalty against Avalon.

Avalon pleaded not blameworthy successful some cases.

As Law&Crime antecedently reported, Avalon was archetypal approached by authorities from the Manatee County Sheriff's Office, who were investigating Scott's decease aft helium was recovered changeable successful the thorax astatine his location successful Bradenton, Florida. The erstwhile couple's teenage girl called 911, and helium survived agelong capable to archer sheriff's deputies who responded to the country that it was "possibly my ex-wife" who allegedly changeable him.

Next to Scott was a spilled cupful of crockery from Panera Bread. Detectives recovered surveillance video from a Panera Bread edifice adjacent that allegedly captured a idiosyncratic matching Avalon's statement grabbing a container of nutrient from the shelves designated for Uber Eats and DoorDash drivers. Manatee County Sheriff Rick Wells said astatine a property league astatine the time, "Doesn't wage for it, it's not hers. She conscionable decides this is gonna beryllium her mode to the beforehand door."

When the constabulary arrived astatine Avalon's location to question her astir the shooting, they saw her travel retired of the location with "bleach and cleaning rags," past got wrong the metallic Honda Odyssey parked successful her driveway and began to "wipe down the car." Detectives told Avalon they were determination to speech astir her ex-husband, and she reportedly responded, "Which one?"

According to Manatee County authorities, Avalon was nether the content that they were from Hillsborough County, wherever Flecher, her different ex-husband, was recovered dormant astatine his location by the Tampa Police Department.

The Tampa Bay Times reported that idiosyncratic called 911 utilizing Flecher's phone, but the caller ne'er said anything. While the enactment was open, the telephone picked up sounds "consistent with imaginable gunshots" earlier the telephone was disconnected. A dispatcher called the fig backmost and a pistillate picked up, reportedly saying that she was exercising earlier saying, "just deed the button" and hanging up again.

More from Law&Crime: 'Which one?': Woman gunned down 2 ex-husbands aft utilizing stolen Panera bid to get into 1 of their homes, constabulary say

According to the Tampa Bay Times' reporting, Flecher's neighbors saw a pistillate wearing a grey hoodie and jeans permission his location successful a metallic Honda Odyssey. The pistillate seen connected camera allegedly taking nutrient from Panera Bread was wearing the aforesaid clothes, arsenic good arsenic the pistillate seen leaving Scott's location aft that alleged shooting.

Avalon's existent fellow reportedly identified the pistillate dependable from the 911 telephone made from Flecher's telephone arsenic Avalon.

Avalon was charged with first-degree execution successful transportation with Flecher's lawsuit successful Hillsborough County and second-degree execution successful Scott's lawsuit successful Manatee County. She is successful custody successful Hillsborough County, wherever she is being held without bond. Her adjacent tribunal day successful Hillsborough County is July 9; she is scheduled to look successful Manatee County tribunal connected July 30.