4 days ago
6
Follow ZDNET: Add america arsenic a preferred source on Google.
ZDNET's cardinal takeaways
- A erstwhile Microsoft developer thinks Windows sucks and explains why.
- Windows has go much of a selling instrumentality to merchantability Microsoft services.
- A Microsoft exec touts Windows arsenic an agentic OS, and the responses are brutal.
I've utilized Windows for much years than I attraction to count. Starting with Windows 95, I've worked with each caller version, some personally and professionally. And though I've sometimes been tempted to power to a Mac oregon Linux arsenic my main platform, I've stuck with Windows arsenic my OS of choice.
Also: Windows 11 AI agents volition enactment connected your behalf - however overmuch tin you spot them?
But my allegiance to Windows has been tested implicit the decades. That's ne'er been truer than implicit the past fewer years. And I'm not alone.
Windows needs a Pro mode
In a recent YouTube video, erstwhile Microsoft programmer Dave Plummer, who helped make the Windows Task Manager and the ZIP archive tool, shared his thoughts connected Windows. "It sucks," Plummer said close astatine the apical of the video. However, alternatively than leaving it with that provocative statement, helium went connected to explicate wherefore helium feels that way.
By trying to beryllium each things to each radical -- from beginners to powerfulness users to developers -- Windows takes a elemental approach, often trying to clasp your manus oregon steer you to different apps and services that you don't needfully need. In this regard, Plummer thinks determination should beryllium a "Professional" mode for powerfulness users that dispenses with the hand-holding and lets you usage the operating strategy the mode you want, not the mode Microsoft wants.
Also: Why Windows 11 requires a TPM - and however you tin get astir it
That's not a atrocious idea. Other products connection antithetic modes depending connected your acquisition and accomplishment level. I usage Adobe Photoshop Elements to edit photos and images. Here, Adobe provides 3 modes: Quick mode, which displays lone the basal tools; Guided mode, which guides you done circumstantial tasks; and Advanced mode, which displays each tools and features. I typically enactment successful Advanced mode, but I sometimes usage Guided mode erstwhile I request assistance with an unfamiliar feature. Why can't Windows follow the aforesaid concept?
Too overmuch telemetry
But Plummer's gripe goes beyond the existent plan of Windows. Rather, helium besides faults Microsoft for turning Windows into little of a usable OS and much of a telemetry instrumentality that doesn't respect your privacy.
"If you perceive to the gripes that make existent vigor today, determination are 3 oregon 4 large buckets," Plummer said successful the video. "Privacy and telemetry, being forced into a Microsoft relationship during setup, updates that astonishment similar a SWAT squad advance, and the wide feeling that your desktop is the past unmonetized aboveground successful a satellite that hates bare space."
Plummer argues that Microsoft needs telemetry connected however radical usage Windows to make the OS. That's a bully point. But helium besides believes the institution needs to beryllium much transparent astir each the information it wants to collect. Here, Plummer suggests that Windows should see a "privacy ledger," a strategy log that would database each portion of telemetry with wide details connected what it's for and wherefore Microsoft wants it.
Why nary section account?
Next up is the choice, oregon deficiency thereof, betwixt a Microsoft relationship and a section account. Certainly, determination are valid reasons for utilizing a Microsoft relationship successful Windows. However, the institution forces this enactment down your throat, progressively eliminating immoderate workarounds for going local. It's astir arsenic if Microsoft sees its users arsenic children, arsenic it takes distant their state of choice, insisting that it knows what's champion for them.
Also: Microsoft has mislaid its way
As Plummer suggests, wherefore can't the institution simply contiguous a wide surface with 2 choices: Continue with a Microsoft relationship oregon proceed with a section account?
"No tricks, nary link to the net to spot what your options are," Plummer said. No acheronian patterns. And if you take local, the OS should explicate erstwhile and past halt asking."
After discussing however Windows updates work, oregon don't work, Plummer moves connected to what helium calls "ads, nags, and suggestions." Here, helium argues that Microsoft has crossed the enactment to wherever the operating strategy feels similar a income transmission for each of the company's different products.
Stop disrespecting users
"When the OS suggests, hey, possibly you should power browsers aft you explicitly chose different one, that's not onboarding," Plummer said. "That's conscionable disrespect. When the Start paper shows sponsored apps, you enactment a terms connected my attraction connected my machine."
Also: How to upgrade your 'incompatible' Windows 10 PC to Windows 11 - for free
With Microsoft's tendency to monetize everything, including its users, idiosyncratic successful the institution would request to propulsion hard to crook Windows into little of a selling machine.
"But it's worthy it," according to Plummer. "Trust is much invaluable than immoderate click-through metric. And close now, this is what radical mean erstwhile they accidental Windows sucks. They're not complaining astir the anti-thread scheduler oregon the IO stack. They detest the acquisition of being sold to by your ain machine that you already own."
The eventual irony present is that Microsoft continues to beryllium Plummer's points, particularly the 1 astir promoting its ain products and services.
Who really wants an agentic OS?
In tweet posted Monday, Microsoft president Pavan Davuluri boasted that "Windows is evolving into an agentic OS, connecting devices, cloud, and AI to unlock intelligent productivity and unafraid enactment anywhere." He invited radical to articulation the institution astatine Microsoft Ignite to spot however "frontier firms are transforming with Windows and what's adjacent for the platform."
Also: How Microsoft yet makes bully connected its syncable passkey committedness - and what's coming next
Of course, erstwhile helium speaks of connecting devices, cloud, and AI, he's people referring to different Microsoft products. Yes, the income transportation is beardown here.
Undoubtedly, Davuluri expected his station to beryllium greeted with cheers and huzzahs. That did not happen. Instead, the station was inundated with hundreds of aggravated responses astir what Microsoft tin bash with its agentic OS.
"Here's a brainsick idea, however astir mmm…just springiness america Windows 7 back? Clean UI, cleanable icon, a unified power panel, nary bloat apps, nary ads, conscionable a axenic show OS," said 1 person.
"You can't adjacent correctly instrumentality tiny taskbar icons, which is thing users really want. You are getting overwhelmingly antagonistic feedback astir each this AI stuff. And yet you persevere. Why?" said another.
Also: I ditched Linux for Windows 11 for 1 week - and recovered 9 large problems
"I've been a Windows idiosyncratic for >35 years and it's inactive my go-to for productivity some astatine location and astatine work. This imaginativeness of the OS evolving isn't truly thing I want. Consider creating a robust, simple, lightweight, and distraction-free mentation and letting the lawsuit decide," said a 3rd person.
Bloated messiness of a selling instrumentality
Past versions of Windows surely had their flaws. But astatine slightest they served much arsenic basal platforms connected which to tally your applications and enactment with your files. That's the explanation of an operating strategy -- astatine slightest it should be. Now, Windows has turned into a bloated messiness of a selling instrumentality with promotions, come-ons and updates that interrupt your enactment alternatively of helping it.
So does Windows truly suck? Yeah, it does, astatine slightest successful definite ways. Of course, I'm inactive utilizing it aft each these years. Maybe it's go similar an old, worn footwear that inactive feels comfy contempt each the problems.
And Plummer's eventual take?
"So, does Windows suck?" helium asks. "Only erstwhile it forgets who it's moving for. Most days, it's for everybody, and that's fine. But immoderate days, it has to beryllium for the idiosyncratic who knows precisely what they privation and is consenting to instrumentality work for asking. Give that idiosyncratic a switch, springiness that idiosyncratic respect, and past get retired of the way."
English (US) ·