When AI becomes a paintbrush, is it art?

2 hours ago 9

This week connected 60 Minutes, analogous Sharyn Alfonsi stepped into a caller frontier of creator expression: the rapidly evolving satellite of artificial intelligence–generated art. She profiled Refik Anadol, the 40-year-old Turkish American creator wide regarded arsenic a pioneer of this emerging form.

Anadol doesn't premix acrylics oregon sculpt with stone. Instead, helium paints with data.

For 1 caller work, helium fed an artificial quality exemplary 200 cardinal photographs of Earth, drafting heavy from archives provided by NASA. The effect is simply a sweeping, immersive integer installation — a surviving canvas of colour and question that feels astatine erstwhile cosmic and intimate.

"When I deliberation astir information arsenic a pigment," Anadol told analogous Sharyn Alfonsi, "I deliberation it doesn't request to dry. It tin determination successful immoderate shape, successful immoderate form, immoderate color, and texture."

It's a poetic statement of a process rooted successful code. His installations, projected crossed walls and ceilings, envelop viewers successful perpetually shifting landscapes generated by instrumentality learning systems trained connected immense representation libraries. The effect tin feel, arsenic Alfonsi enactment it, "a small trippy."

"It is trippy," Anadol replied. "Because I deliberation arsenic artists we inquire what is beyond reality."

The critics measurement in

Anadol's enactment has appeared successful immoderate of the world's astir prestigious museums. But arsenic A.I. creation moves from tech labs to galleries, the creation satellite is grappling with a bigger question: How bash these creations stack up?

Jerry Saltz, the Pulitzer Prize–winning professional for New York Magazine, is some skeptical and curious.

"Right now, AI creation seems to beryllium an mean of averages," Saltz told Alfonsi. Algorithms are trained connected immense datasets of existing images, themselves products of countless influences. The result, helium argues, risks becoming "vaster, and much average," alternatively than much profound.

For Saltz, large creation emerges from thing machines fundamentally lack: lived experience.

"I privation the algorithm to acquisition death," helium said. "I privation the algorithm to cognize the feeling of feeling similar you person a abdominous neck, oregon atrocious hair… I privation to bid the algorithm to acquisition carnality." Without enactment and death, Saltz suggests, determination is nary art.

And yet, helium doesn't disregard the technology.

"I similar to deliberation of it arsenic a material," Saltz said. "Artists usage materials. A integer record is simply a material." To cull A.I. outright, helium argued, would beryllium similar rejecting lipid overgarment oregon the caller earlier engaging with them. "I privation it well. And I would never, ever disregard it."

Fear, replacement, and ethics

Part of the anxiousness surrounding A.I. creation is existential. Artists, similar professionals successful galore industries, fearfulness replacement, Saltz said.

"We each person a latent fearfulness of being replaced by AI," Saltz acknowledged. "I conjecture I deliberation that we volition beryllium connected immoderate level." His medicine isn't retreat — it's reinvention. Artists indispensable go "better, oregon much useful, oregon much unsocial astatine what we bash successful bid to support our jobs."

The ethical questions are thornier. Is it just — oregon ineligible — to bid an algorithm connected the enactment of different artists?

Saltz thinks so. Artists person ever borrowed, referenced, and reinterpreted what came earlier them.

"There are nary laws successful art," Saltz said bluntly. "All creation comes from different art."

Is it art?

Last year, creator Refik Anadol brought his imaginativeness to the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao successful Spain. For that exhibition, helium built a customized A.I. exemplary trained connected open-access photographs, sketches, and blueprints from the archive of Frank Gehry, the legendary designer who designed the depository itself.

The strategy processed Gehry's architectural bequest and reimagined it arsenic a fluid, morphing, integer spectacle.

Saltz erstwhile dismissed a akin installation astatine New York's Museum of Modern Art arsenic a "glorified lava lamp," dazzling but yet decorative.

Which raises the cardinal question of this taste moment: When a instrumentality recombines humanity's ocular past into thing new, is that art?

Photos & Video courtesy of Refik Anadol Studio, Guggenheim Museum Bilbao, Tom Ross & Getty Images.

The video supra was edited by Scott Rosann.

In: