What's missing from the Epstein files?

1 day ago 11

When the Department of Justice released more than 3 cardinal pages of documents nether the Epstein Files Transparency Act, survivors, advocates and lawmakers rapidly raised questions astir an evident discrepancy: the DOJ had said it collected much than 6 cardinal pages of worldly during its probe but was lone releasing fractional that number.

The Justice Department tells CBS News it "has released each papers required by the Epstein Files Transparency Act," and maintains that those unreleased 3 cardinal documents were either duplicative, unrelated to Epstein oregon protected by ineligible privilege.

But concerns persist astir grounds that important documents are inactive being withheld. At the aforesaid time, the Government Accountability Office precocious announced it was launching an probe into the mode documents that were released had accusation blacked out. That determination comes astatine the request of respective members of Congress.

Rep. Robert Garcia, the apical Democrat connected the House Oversight Committee, says that if determination are duplicates, "OK, that's fine, let's spot them." He adds, "I deliberation what radical request to recognize is … we're not definite what's successful the 3 million."

CBS News has analyzed the archive not lone for what has been disclosed, but besides for documents that look to beryllium absent. Despite the unprecedented measurement of worldly present available, it's evident that galore gaps stay successful the nationalist grounds surrounding Epstein's activities, his communication, the national investigations into him and the circumstances surrounding his death down bars.

Our reappraisal identified respective areas wherever important questions stay unanswered oregon documents look to stay unreleased.

Redaction issues

The Epstein Files Transparency Act provides lone constricted grounds for withholding accusation oregon redacting names. Its superior intent is to support victims. The bill specifically excluded "reputational harm, oregon governmental sensitivity" arsenic a crushed for redacting. Yet successful galore instances salient individuals' names were redacted portion victims' names were not.

Some redactions look hard to justify. In 1 example, a substance wherever Epstein sent Steve Bannon a nexus to an article, Bannon's look was blacked retired successful a photograph that had already been publically posted online.

Elsewhere, the names of concern contacts and acquaintances of Epstein look to person been redacted without an evident crushed nether the presumption of the law.

In different wide cited example, a 2002 email with the signoff "Love, Melania" had the afloat sanction and email of the sender and receiver redacted. In April, archetypal woman Melania Trump acknowledged having exchanged emails with Ghislaine Maxwell, saying successful a connection that it "cannot beryllium categorized arsenic thing much than casual correspondence. My polite reply to her email doesn't magnitude to thing much than a trivial note."

The Epstein Files Transparency Act requires the DOJ to supply a justification for each redaction. It permits withholding accusation that "would represent a intelligibly unwarranted penetration of idiosyncratic privacy," but besides states that each redactions indispensable beryllium accompanied by a written justification published successful the Federal Register and submitted to Congress. The Department of Justice has made nary effort to code circumstantial redactions and alternatively issued a general statement saying its redactions were "[c]onsistent with the Act."

Members of Congress person been fixed the accidental to reappraisal redacted material, but the process is clip consuming and immoderate person complained their searches are being monitored by the DOJ.

After CBS News reached retired to the DOJ for remark connected these redactions, the photograph of Bannon and 2 of the emails were softly un-redacted. After 1 of those was un-redacted, it revealed the sender was erstwhile U.K. diplomat Peter Mandelson, who was arrested earlier this year connected suspicion of mishandling delicate authorities documents, which BBC News reports helium denies. Mandelson has said helium regrets his relationship with Epstein and says helium ne'er witnessed transgression activity.

A spread successful email communications

The DOJ released millions of Epstein's emails. Nearly each originate from an email relationship helium created astir the clip helium went to jailhouse successful 2008: jeevacation@gmail.com.

Missing from the Epstein files are emails from his other, earlier accounts, including astir 20,000 messages from Epstein's jeeproject@yahoo.com account, which were antecedently obtained by hackers and aboriginal archived by the nonprofit Distributed Denial of Secrets. It's unclear if the DOJ itself ever obtained those emails.

Some older email messages bash look successful records seemingly obtained from Ghislaine Maxwell's accounts oregon different sources, but the DOJ's merchandise is missing astir of Epstein's earliest communications.

However, a batch of documents raises questions astir what the DOJ does have; a bid of screengrab images of Epstein's inbox for an email relationship littlestjeff@yahoo.com (a notation to his island, Little St. James) from the aboriginal 2000s — notably a play of clip erstwhile Epstein was successful interaction with Donald Trump, whom helium knew done New York and Palm Beach societal circles. The sender and recipient fields connected those records are heavy redacted. Mr. Trump has repeatedly claimed helium has ne'er utilized email, but those communications could perchance person references to Epstein's narration with Mr. Trump and others. This was besides the play successful which Epstein was recovered to person been recruiting underage girls for intersexual massages, and would apt person been of precocious involvement to investigators.

Mr. Trump has consistently denied immoderate wrongdoing successful transportation with Epstein.

Despite the DOJ seemingly having access to Epstein's inbox, lone a fistful of emails from that relationship were included successful the release.

Internal FBI communications

The merchandise includes a important magnitude of interior DOJ and FBI correspondence. The names of galore DOJ and FBI officials progressive successful those communications person been redacted, making it hard to reconstruct who was liable for cardinal investigative actions.

Missing email attachments

Numerous emails successful the archive notation attached documents that bash not look to person been included successful the release.

One illustration concerns the theft of astir 30 firearms from Epstein's Zorro Ranch property successful New Mexico. In August 2018, an worker emailed Epstein a record titled "ZMC_-_Gun_Inventory.pdf," which contained accusation astir the weapons, including their serial numbers. According to a New Mexico State Police study obtained by CBS News, those serial numbers were withheld from investigators during the theft investigation. CBS News was incapable to find immoderate papers containing firearm serial numbers successful the released archive.

Even wherever attachments whitethorn person been released, linking them backmost to the emails from which they originated is astir impossible; the DOJ replaced archetypal record names with its ain papers numbering system, making it hard to find whether specified attachments were included elsewhere successful the archive, oregon which email a record whitethorn person been primitively attached to.

The DEA investigation

One notable document successful the files is simply a 69-page study produced by the Organized Crime Drug Enforcement Task Force Fusion Center identifying Epstein and 14 others arsenic targets of a DEA investigation into alleged wealth laundering connected to ecstasy oregon ketamine trafficking.

An probe of that scope would apt person generated important records, including investigative reports, emails and fiscal analyses. None of that worldly was released.

The DEA denied CBS News' requests for related records nether the Freedom of Information Act and besides declined a petition from Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden seeking further accusation astir the investigation, the senator's bureau told CBS News.

Other agencies and investigations

Previous reporting by the Washington Post revealed that Epstein had been named successful an probe successful the 1990s into Towers Financial, a notorious Ponzi scheme, but was ne'er charged. Documents related to that probe were not included successful the merchandise contempt it having been conducted by the DOJ.

One notable regulation of the instrumentality requiring the Epstein files' merchandise is that it lone applies to the DOJ. Other agencies whitethorn person documents relating to Epstein that they person not released.

The papers astir the DEA probe revealed 3 abstracted Immigration and Customs Enforcement investigations, 2 of which had already been closed by the clip of the 2015 study and 1 that was listed arsenic pending. But ICE, which falls nether the Department of Homeland Security, is not covered by the Epstein Files Transparency Act. Neither are different authorities agencies including the State Department, Treasury Department, CIA oregon NSA, which whitethorn person collected worldly connected Epstein implicit the past respective decades. (With his planetary web of governmental and concern contacts, Epstein himself wondered if U.S. quality had files connected him.)

Index issues

CBS News spent weeks analyzing indexes of files provided to Ghislaine Maxwell by the DOJ during her transgression case. This aforesaid scale had been utilized antecedently by media outlets to place 3 missing FBI interrogation records, known arsenic 302s, successful which agents documented what they were told by Epstein accusers who made claims astir Mr. Trump.

This scale utilized a Bates numbering — a communal ineligible papers indexing strategy — to catalog records. More than 70% of the astir 5,000 documents listed successful the scale could not beryllium located done searches of the released archive utilizing their assigned papers numbers, according to a CBS News analysis.

The DOJ told CBS News that galore of the missing entries whitethorn person been identified arsenic duplicates, and truthful were excluded from publication. Using contextual clues, including witnesser interrogation dates and papers descriptions, immoderate files could beryllium located elsewhere, but for galore that was not possible.

One illustration involves an idiosyncratic named Joseph Alvarez, besides known arsenic "Gypsy Gita." Gita had antecedently reportedly been named by 1 Epstein subsister arsenic idiosyncratic who introduced her to Ghislaine Maxwell. Alvarez died successful 2021.

CBS News was incapable to find 4 of 8 documents associated with Alvarez successful the index. Of the documents that were present, 1 was a representation of Alvarez with Mr. Trump, 1 was Alvarez' concern paper and 2 were photographs of ample bags of cash. The 4 missing documents were listed arsenic "alvarez plus report," "alvarez instrumentality enforcement report," "alvarez interaction paper report" and "screenshot of [redacted] facebook." It's unclear from the documents wherefore these photos were included successful the lawsuit files.

Massage scheduling communications

One of the astir conspicuous absences is connection relating to the scheduling of massages successful the years anterior to Epstein's death.

Epstein was known to person aggregate massages each day, a signifier that helium utilized arsenic a mechanics for recruiting and exploiting young women and girls. When authorities searched his Palm Beach residence successful 2005, investigators recovered hundreds of messages from women and girls that they said referred to the scheduling of massage appointments.

Yet the released archive contains small correspondence astir however appointments were arranged aft his merchandise from jailhouse successful 2009.

Signal messages

Epstein often encouraged associates to pass utilizing the encrypted messaging app Signal.

No Signal messages person been included successful the release; it is imaginable that investigators were incapable to get them.

Among those who seemingly utilized Signal to pass with Epstein were exertion capitalist Peter Thiel and existent property capitalist Thomas Barrack. Barrack, a longtime person of Mr. Trump, is present U.S. ambassador to Turkey and peculiar envoy to Iraq. Both Thiel and Barrack were progressive successful Mr. Trump's 2016 statesmanlike campaign. They person not been accused of immoderate wrongdoing successful the Epstein case.

Suspicious enactment reports

Suspicious enactment reports, which papers millions of dollars successful transactions made by Epstein that were flagged by fiscal institutions, were released, retracted and past re-released successful an wholly redacted form. They originated from the Treasury Department but were utilized successful the DOJ's probe of Epstein's and Maxwell's crimes.

Prison videos

One document from the Epstein files revealed that the DOJ had footage from 147 cameras from the Metropolitan Correctional Center covering a 24-hour play earlier and aft Epstein died, totaling implicit 8 terabytes of data. The interior documents bespeak that the footage does not uncover thing important "since the cameras successful the Special Housing Unit … were not progressive astatine the time." Even so, by law, those videos should person been released.

Also missing are videos from July 23, 2019, the nighttime Epstein seemingly archetypal tried to instrumentality his life.

Lawsuits and hearings

The autarkic writer Katie Phang is presently suing the Department of Justice to unit it to supply justifications for galore of the redactions and merchandise further documents. According to erstwhile Attorney General Pam Bondi, her lawman and present Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche was liable for handling the redaction and merchandise of the Epstein files.

The House Committee connected Oversight and Government Reform has requested that Blanche appear earlier the committee and reply questions astir that process.

In:

Read Entire Article