Vatican appeals court declares mistrial in the 'trial of the century' against a cardinal

ROME (AP) — The Vatican appeals tribunal declared a mistrial Tuesday successful the Holy See’s large “trial of the century,” a stunning stroke to some Pope Francis’ bequest and Vatican prosecutors who had enactment a cardinal and respective different radical connected proceedings implicit alleged fiscal crimes.

In a 16-page ruling, the appeals tribunal ruled that Francis and Vatican prosecutors some made procedural errors that nullified the archetypal indictment against Cardinal Angelo Becciu and the others and required a caller trial. The tribunal acceptable a June 22 arsenic the day for the caller proceedings to begin.

Defense lawyers said specified a ruling was enormously important if not historic, since it amounted to a Vatican tribunal declaring an enactment of the pope null.

The ruling was a triumph for the defence and a immense setback to Vatican prosecutors, who person been scrambling to salvage their case. The prosecution and 2023 convictions against Becciu and others had been held up by the Vatican and precocious pope arsenic grounds of his willingness to ace down connected fiscal misconduct successful the Holy See.

A lawsuit that began with a London concern and grew

Becciu's lawyers said the ruling showed they were close successful arguing that the defence was enactment astatine an unfair disadvantage from the start.

“It shows that from the archetypal moment, we were close to rise the usurpation of the close to defence and to petition that the instrumentality beryllium respected to person a just trial,” Becciu's lawyers Fabio Viglione and Maria Concetta Marzo said successful a statement.

The lawsuit had arsenic its main absorption the Vatican’s concern of 350 cardinal euros ($413 million) successful a London property. Prosecutors alleged brokers and Vatican monsignors fleeced the Holy See of tens of millions of euros successful fees and commissions to get the property, and past extorted the Holy See for 15 cardinal euros ($16.5 million) to cede power of it.

The archetypal probe spawned 2 main tangents involving Becciu, erstwhile a starring Vatican cardinal and aboriginal papal contender. He was convicted of embezzlement and sentenced to 5½ years successful prison. The tribunal convicted 8 different defendants of embezzlement, maltreatment of office, fraud and different charges and imposed tens of millions of euros (dollars) successful restitution to the Holy See.

All defendants maintained their innocence and appealed aft a two-year proceedings that opened a pandora's container of unwanted revelations astir papal ransom payments to Islamic militants, Vatican vendettas, espionage and different soiled laundry of the Holy See.

During the archetypal trial, Becciu’s lawyers successful peculiar had complained that prosecutors hadn’t turned implicit each the grounds to the defense, violating their close to a just trial. Prosecutors had redacted immoderate documents, withheld the cellphone records of a cardinal prosecution witnesser and redacted texts among the players, arguing that specified omissions were indispensable to support the secrecy of different investigations.

Defense lawyers besides alleged that 4 concealed decrees Francis signed giving prosecutors wide-ranging powers to analyse violated the defendants' close to a just trial. They lone learned astir the decrees conscionable earlier the proceedings began, since the decrees were ne'er published.

The appeals tribunal sides with the defense

The appeals tribunal agreed with some defence arguments.

In the ruling, the appeals tribunal ruled that 1 of Francis’ decrees amounted to a law, and that Francis’ nonaccomplishment to people it nullified it. The tribunal besides decreed that Vatican prosecutors’ nonaccomplishment to crook implicit to the defence each their grounds nullified their archetypal indictment.

Defense lawyers were pleased by the ruling.

“The historical determination by the Court of Appeals—which, for the archetypal clip successful Vatican history, ruled that a papal rescript was invalid and void owed to nonaccomplishment to people it—in our presumption results successful the implicit nullity of the full probe and trial,” attorneys Massimo Bassi and Cataldo Intrieri, who correspond erstwhile Vatican authoritative Fabrizio Tirabassi, said successful a statement.

“We are assured that we volition beryllium capable to scope a swift decision to the proceedings with a mostly acquittal verdict.”

The tribunal, headed by Archbishop Alejandro Arellano Cedillo, ordered prosecutors to deposit each the documentation, “in their archetypal form,” by April 30. It gave the defence until June 15 to hole their motions earlier the June 22 commencement of the caller trial.

It was the 2nd large stroke to prosecutors since the appeals signifier opened past year.

In January, the Vatican’s highest Court of Cassation upheld the little court’s determination to propulsion retired the prosecutor’s entreaty of the archetypal proceedings wholly due to the fact that authoritative Alessandro Diddi committed an embarrassing rookie procedural error.

On the aforesaid time arsenic the Cassation ruling, Diddi besides dropped months of objections and abruptly resigned from the case, alternatively than look the anticipation that the Cassation tribunal would bid him removed.

At contented was Diddi’s relation successful a now-infamous acceptable of WhatsApp chats that threw the credibility of the full proceedings into question. The chats documented a yearslong, behind-the-scenes effort to people Becciu and suggested questionable behaviour by Vatican police, Vatican prosecutors and Francis himself.

Leo speaks astir justice, unity and credibility

Tuesday's determination was issued conscionable days aft Pope Leo XIV opened the Vatican’s judicial year. Leo, a canon lawyer, met Saturday with the judges and prosecutors who oversee the judicial apparatus of the Vatican City State, which follows its ain peculiar ineligible codification that is inspired by a century-old Italian codification and the church’s in-house canon law.

In his remarks, Leo spoke of justness arsenic a means of fostering unity successful the church, insisting that it beryllium aimed astatine searching for information and paired with charity. He besides spoke astir justness arsenic a means of fostering credibility wrong an institution, remarks interpreted by immoderate arsenic a notation to however the Becciu proceedings had successful immoderate ways damaged the Holy See’s estimation due to the fact that of its galore anomalies.

“The observance of procedural safeguards, the impartiality of the judge, the effectiveness of the close of defence and the tenable duration of proceedings are not simply method instruments of the judicial process," Leo said. "They represent the conditions done which the workout of the judicial relation acquires peculiar authorization and contributes to organization stability.”

___

Associated Press religion sum receives enactment done the AP’s collaboration with The Conversation US, with backing from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely liable for this content.

Copyright 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.