Trump Confirms His Disparaging Remark About ‘Shithole Countries’ at Immigration Meeting

Nearly 8 years ago, President Donald Trump denied utilizing the connection “shitholes” to picture African countries during an Oval Office gathering connected immigration. 

But present helium has fessed up.   

In a code Tuesday night successful Pennsylvania, Trump boasted astir pausing migration from what helium called “Third World” countries, erstwhile helium was interrupted by an assemblage subordinate who yelled retired “shithole.” That triggered Trump to callback a White House gathering during his archetypal word that caused a disturbance implicit whether the president utilized a vulgar word to picture African countries. 

Trump, Dec. 9: I’ve besides announced a imperishable intermission connected Third World migration, including from hellholes similar Afghanistan, Haiti, Somalia and galore different countries. 

Audience member: Shithole. 

Trump: I didn’t accidental shithole, you did. [Laughter.] Remember, I said that to the senators. They came in, the Democrats. They wanted to beryllium bipartisan. So, they came in, and they said this is wholly disconnected the record. Nothing mentioned here. We wanted to beryllium honest, due to the fact that our state was going to hell, and we had a gathering and I say, “why is it we lone instrumentality radical from shithole countries,” right? Why can’t we person immoderate radical from Norway, Sweden — conscionable a fewer — fto america person a few, from Denmark. Do you caput sending america a fewer people? Send america immoderate bully people, bash you mind? But we ever instrumentality radical from Somalia, places that are a disaster, right? Filthy, dirty, disgusting, ridden with crime.

Trump’s caller relationship of the Jan. 11, 2018, gathering confirms what Democratic Sen. Dick Durbin said astatine the time.

A time aft the meeting, Durbin – who was astatine that gathering — said the president was commenting connected migration from Africa erstwhile helium said, “‘Those shitholes nonstop america the radical that they don’t want.’” Durbin added, “He repeated that. He didn’t accidental that conscionable 1 time.” 

Durbin besides quoted Trump arsenic saying, “‘We don’t request much Haitians.’”

As we wrote astatine the time, Trump repeatedly denied Durbin’s account. 

In societal media posts connected Jan. 12, 2018, Trump said his words astatine the gathering were “tough,” but “this was not the connection used,” and helium claimed that helium “[n]ever said thing derogatory astir Haitians.” Two days later, the president told reporters that the remarks attributed to him “weren’t made,” and helium tweeted that Durbin “totally misrepresented what was said astatine the DACA meeting,” referring to the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program.

(DACA prevents the deportation of more than 500,000 U.S. residents who were illegally brought to the United States arsenic children. At the 2018 meeting, Durbin and Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham met with Trump to sermon their bipartisan program to prevention DACA, which Trump was trying to phase out.)

In our Jan. 16, 2018, article, we were incapable to definitively authorities what was said astatine the migration meeting. There was nary signaling of the backstage meeting. Instead, we provided firsthand accounts from immoderate of those who attended.

There were astatine slightest 7 members of Congress astatine the gathering and then-Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen. In summation to Durbin, 4 different members of Congress and Nielsen made nationalist statements astir the meeting, which we included successful our 2018 nonfiction and summarize here:

• Like Trump, Nielsen said determination was an “impassioned conversation” connected migration astatine the meeting, but she did not perceive “that circumstantial operation being used.”

• Sen. Tom Cotton and then-Sen. David Perdue, some Republicans, initially besides said successful a joint statement that they “do not callback the President saying these comments specifically.” Perdue said days aboriginal that Trump “did not usage that word,” calling Durbin’s relationship a “gross misrepresentation.” (The Washington Post reported, based connected accounts from anonymous White House officials, that Perdue and Cotton told the White House that they heard “shithouse” alternatively than “shithole,” which the Post wrote allowed some men to contradict Durbin’s relationship of the president’s comments.)

• In a statement astatine the time, Graham initially did not corroborate oregon contradict the allegations astir Trump’s language. But days later, helium appeared to knock Cotton and Perdue for their selective memories of the meeting. “My representation hasn’t evolved,” helium told reporters successful South Carolina connected Jan. 15. “I cognize what was said and I cognize what I said.”

• Rep. Mario Diaz-Balart, a Florida Republican, would neither corroborate nor deny whether Trump utilized the obscenity astatine the gathering to picture African nations.

As fact-checkers, we indispensable trust connected irrefutable evidence, specified arsenic memos, emails and recordings, to render a judgement erstwhile trying to settee a quality similar this betwixt 2 parties. All we tin bash – and what we did successful this lawsuit – is laic retired what we cognize and fto readers gully their ain views of what whitethorn person happened.

But present determination is nary disagreement. Trump admitted that helium said, “why is it we lone instrumentality radical from shithole countries?”

Asked for comment, White House Deputy Press Secretary Abigail Jackson told america the contention implicit Trump’s connection astatine the 2018 gathering is “another Fake News communicative peddled by Democrats.”

“Instead of digging up different Fake News communicative peddled by Democrats astir 10 years ago, the media should absorption connected the substance of what President Trump correctly pointed out: Aliens who travel to our country, kick astir however overmuch they hatred America, neglect to lend to our economy, and garbage to assimilate into our nine should not beryllium here,” Jackson said successful an email.

But based connected Trump’s ain account, this wasn’t “another Fake News narrative.” Instead, his denials astatine the clip were false. 

---

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station Trump Confirms His Disparaging Remark About ‘Shithole Countries’ astatine Immigration Meeting appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.