Trump brands his opponents as 'communists,' a label loaded with the baggage of American history

For years, President Donald Trump blamed “communists” for his ineligible and governmental troubles. Now, the 2nd Trump medication is deploying that aforesaid historically loaded statement to formed his opponents — from judges to educators — arsenic threats to American identity, civilization and values.

Why? Trump himself explained the strategy past year erstwhile helium described however helium planned to decision his Democratic opponent, then-Vice President Kamala Harris, successful the White House election.

“All we person to bash is specify our hostile arsenic being a communist oregon a socialist oregon idiosyncratic who is going to destruct our country,” helium told reporters astatine his New Jersey play nine successful August.

Trump did conscionable that — branding Harris “comrade Kamala” — and helium won successful November. With the assent of much than 77 cardinal Americans who formed ballots — 49.9% of the vote — Trump is carrying that strategy into his 2nd term.

What he's talking astir is not really ‘communism’

In 2025, communism wields large power successful countries specified arsenic China, Vietnam, North Korea and Cuba. But not the United States.

“The halfway of communism is the content that governments tin bash amended than markets successful providing goods and services. There are very, precise fewer radical successful the West who earnestly judge that," said Raymond Robertson of the Texas A&M University Bush School of Government & Public Service. "Unless they are arguing that the authorities should tally U.S. Steel and Tesla, they are simply not communists.”

The connection “communist,” connected the different hand, tin transportation large affectional powerfulness arsenic a rhetorical tool, adjacent now. It’s each the much potent arsenic a pejorative — though often inaccurate, adjacent dangerous — amid the modern flash of societal media and misinformation. After all, the fearfulness and paranoia of the Russian Revolution, the “Red Scare,” World War II, McCarthyism and the Cold War are fading into the 20th period past.

But Trump, 78 and celebrated for labeling radical helium views arsenic obstacles, remembers.

“We cannot let a fistful of communist radical-left judges to obstruct the enforcement of our laws,” Trump said Tuesday successful Michigan portion celebrating his archetypal 100 days successful office. The White House did not reply to a petition for what Trump means erstwhile helium calls idiosyncratic a “communist.”

The timing of his usage of “communist” is worthy noting.

Trump's Michigan code came during a week of dicey economical and governmental news. Days earlier, The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs published a canvass showing that much Americans disagree with Trump’s priorities truthful acold than hold with them, and that galore Republicans are ambivalent astir his choices of focus. After the speech, the authorities reported that the system shrank during the archetypal 4th of 2025 arsenic Trump's tariffs disrupted business.

On Thursday, elder statesmanlike adjutant Stephen Miller stepped to the White House podium and uttered the aforesaid c-word 4 times successful astir 35 minutes during a denunciation of past policies connected transgender, diversity and immigration issues.

“These are a fewer of the areas successful which President Trump has fought the cancerous, communist woke civilization that was destroying this country,” Miller told reporters.

His postulation of words offered a enactment of clickbait for societal media users, arsenic good arsenic presumption that could drawback the attraction of older Americans. Voters implicit property 45 narrowly voted for Trump implicit his Democratic rivals successful 2020 and 2024.

Smack successful the mediate of Miller's sentence: “communist.”

“It tends to beryllium a word that is loaded with antagonistic affect, peculiarly for older Americans who grew up during the Cold War,” said Jacob Neiheisel, a governmental communications adept astatine the University astatine Buffalo. “Appending emotionally laden presumption to governmental adversaries is simply a mode to minimize their legitimacy successful the eyes of the nationalist and overgarment them successful a antagonistic light.”

A ‘Red Scare’-era fig influenced a young Trump

The menace that communists could power oregon adjacent obliterate the United States hovered implicit the state for decades and drove immoderate of the country's ugliest chapters.

The years aft World War I and the Russian Revolution successful 1917, on with a question of immigrants, led to what's known arsenic the “Red Scare” of 1920, a play of aggravated paranoia astir the imaginable for a communist-led gyration successful America.

“McCarthyism” aft World War II meant the hunt for expected communists. It's named for Sen. Joseph McCarthy, the Wisconsin Republican who conducted televised hearings astatine the dawn of the Cold War that drove anti-communist fears to caller heights with a bid of threats, innuendos and untruths.

Culturally, the merest proposition that idiosyncratic was “soft” connected communism could extremity careers and ruin lives. "Blacklists” of suspected communists proliferated successful Hollywood and beyond. McCarthy fell into disgrace and died successful 1957.

The senator's main counsel during the hearings, Roy Cohn, became Trump's mentor and fixer successful the 1980s and 1990s, erstwhile Trump roseate arsenic a existent property mogul successful New York. The Cold War was much than 3 decades old. The menace of atomic warfare was pervasive.

Communism started to illness successful 1989 and the Soviet Union was dissolved 2 years later. It's present Russia, led by President Vladimir Putin.

But communism — astatine slightest successful 1 signifier — lives connected successful China, with which Trump is waging a commercialized warfare that could effect successful less and costlier products successful the United States. By week's end, Trump was acknowledging the imaginable consequences of his authorities stepping in: Americans mightiness soon not beryllium capable to bargain what they want, oregon they mightiness beryllium forced to wage more. He insisted China would beryllium wounded much by the tariffs.

The existent modern debate, Robertson says, is not betwixt capitalism and communism, but astir however overmuch the authorities needs to measurement successful — and when. He suggests that Trump is not truly debating communism vs. capitalism anyway.

“Calling radical who advocator for somewhat much authorities engagement ‘communists’ is emblematic misleading governmental rhetoric that, unfortunately, works truly good with engaged voters who bash not person a batch of clip to deliberation astir method definitions and economical paradigms,” helium said successful an email. “It is besides truly adjuvant (to Trump) due to the fact that it is inflammatory, making radical angry, which tin beryllium addictive."

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.