They Made D4vd a Star. Now They Want Him Convicted of Murder

Safiyya was sound dormant astatine her parents’ flat erstwhile the unthinkable happened. It was astir midnight connected a Monday past September, and her telephone wouldn’t halt buzzing. She got retired of furniture and went implicit to her computer, her assemblage pulsing with adrenaline. Messages were pouring successful connected the Discord server she moderated. She began to panic.

“What the fuck is happening,” 1 Discord idiosyncratic wrote successful the wide chat. “Yall one cant spell to slumber now,” wrote another. “Dude I person schoolhouse tmr,” idiosyncratic other chimed in. “Daddy d4vd whitethorn beryllium getting canceled,” a abstracted idiosyncratic wrote.

“D4vd slimed someone,” different idiosyncratic said—slang for murdered.

The Discord server known arsenic “d4vd’s closet,” for fans of the Soundcloud-native singer-songwriter D4vd, was processing horrific quality successful existent time. Hours earlier, connected the day of September 8, a decomposing assemblage had been discovered successful the beforehand trunk of a achromatic Tesla successful a Los Angeles tow yard. It was registered, successful Texas, to then-20-year-old David Anthony Burke, the existent sanction of D4vd.

Safiyya, who is 24 and lives successful Canada, was adjacent speechless. (She, similar galore sources successful this piece, asked to beryllium identified by either a username, pseudonym, oregon archetypal name, retired of fearfulness of harassment.) “Bro wtf,” she typed into the Discord wide chat, her hands shaking. “Just wtfff.” It wasn’t conscionable the gruesome headlines that rattled her. This real-life homicide eerily paralleled the fictional ones depicted successful D4vd’s opus lyrics and euphony videos. There was, astir obviously, his 2022 breakout hit, “Romantic Homicide,” a moody physics ballad that Safiyya had archetypal discovered, similar truthful galore others, arsenic a viral earworm connected TikTok. In the euphony video, D4vd—dressed arsenic “Itami,” his murderous, blindfolded change ego—stands successful beforehand of a woman’s lifeless, blood-splattered body; a weapon drops from his hand.

Then determination was the 2025 euphony video for “One More Dance,” which evokes a 1990s fearfulness movie à la The Blair Witch Project. The opening country shows Itami, again played by D4vd, dragging his ain assemblage crossed the ground, dumping it successful beforehand of a car, and watching arsenic friends worldly it successful the trunk. The video culminates with his friends burying him live successful an unfastened grave. Now D4vd’s fans wondered successful the Discord server: Was D4vd’s creation imitating his life, oregon was it the different mode around?

“D4vd didn’t termination idiosyncratic itami did,” 1 idiosyncratic wrote. “He was trying to archer america each along,” wrote different who posted an representation of a peculiarly catchy lyric from “Romantic Homicide”:

“In the backmost of my mind, I killed you.”

Safiyya joined D4vd’s Discord much than 2 years earlier. She liked the opus “Romantic Homicide,” but much importantly, her crush, whom she’d met portion playing a first-person shooter crippled called Valorant, claimed to beryllium a person of D4vd’s. When she sent her archetypal message, a elemental “ello” successful May 2023, she recovered that others were anxious to engage. The server was 1 giant, perpetually progressive radical chat, but with strangers from each implicit the world. It felt chaotic, unwieldy. Shitposting—a connection Safiyya was good versed successful from spending years successful gaming-related Discord servers—was pervasive.

Things didn’t enactment retired with her crush, but Safiyya liked staying up precocious aft enactment and chatting with the thousands of radical successful D4vd’s Discord. She didn’t cognize overmuch astir anyone beyond their avatars and usernames, and it didn’t matter—the speech astir ever circled backmost to what they each had successful common: D4vd’s music. Members debated their favourite tracks (Safiyya’s was “Sleep Well,” a lo-fi R&B emotion song), compared merch, and shared circuit dates they planned to attend.

Safiyya was truthful progressive successful the chat that, aft conscionable a fewer months, a moderator asked if she’d similar to articulation their ranks. The unpaid relation came with a batch of pressure. Seven mods were expected to station astatine slightest 500 messages a week. It was a mode to promote engagement, Safiyya says. All the clip she enactment into the Discord server was worthy it: She wasn’t conscionable a portion of D4vd’s community, she was a curator of it.

In the aboriginal hours of September 9, though, Safiyya started to resent her relation arsenic moderator. She didn’t similar being 1 of the adults successful the room, tasked with wrangling an out-of-control conversation. There was confusion, pandemonium, and, arsenic 1 mightiness expect from highly online Zoomers posting connected Discord, determination were jokes—many successful exceptionally mediocre taste. Some speculated that D4vd had been framed, that the quality was fake, oregon that this was each promo for the forthcoming medium D4vd had been teasing incessantly connected societal media.

As anxious arsenic Safiyya felt, discussing a execution lawsuit successful existent time—one involving a fishy that everyone had astatine slightest a parasocial narration with—was besides benignant of thrilling. Safiyya was adjacent capable to D4vd that they had each other’s compartment telephone numbers. He’d adjacent FaceTimed her erstwhile to inquire for assistance deleting a Twitch livestream. (Safiyya was connected different telephone and missed it.) She liked D4vd, of course, and felt protective of his career.

Initially, Safiyya thought determination was nary mode D4vd could’ve been involved. He’d conscionable played a amusement successful Chicago, and she figured idiosyncratic indispensable person borrowed oregon stolen his car portion helium was retired of town. To her, it seemed similar an injustice that this would hap conscionable arsenic D4vd was astir to go a world-famous superstar: He was 2 weeks distant from playing the Grammy Museum successful Los Angeles, earlier headlining a European circuit the pursuing month, capping disconnected a dizzying twelvemonth successful which helium besides made his Coachella debut. Guilty oregon not, Safiyya knew the harm had been done.

“Tour finna get cancel 💔💔” Safiyya posted successful the wide chat of the Discord server. A abbreviated portion later, successful each caps, her vexation boiled over: “This boi got collab near and close conscionable for this crap to happen.”

Soon, the sedate world of the concern began to descend in. “We’re finna extremity up successful a documentary,” 1 idiosyncratic posted, astir 2:15 am. By 7 am, the speculation successful D4vd’s Discord server had go truthful rampant that moderators disabled caller posts. Safiyya was scared, feeling arsenic if she’d abruptly been thrust into a transgression investigation.

Over the adjacent respective days, D4vd’s remaining circuit dates would get canceled, conscionable arsenic Safiyya had predicted; truthful would the deluxe mentation of his archetypal workplace album, initially slated for merchandise connected September 19. His just-launched manner run with Hollister and Crocs would get canned; and the Grammy-winning vocalist Kali Uchis would propulsion her duet with D4vd from streaming platforms. It seemed to galore of D4vd’s erstwhile fans that his apprehension for execution would beryllium imminent too.

When it wasn’t, they took matters into their ain hands. Overwhelmed by a consciousness of urgency, onetime D4vd stans began combing done his Discord server, suspecting it contained accusation truthful incriminating that it was lone a substance of clip earlier it got wiped. In the end, adjacent Safiyya couldn’t person imagined however rapidly galore of her peers turned against their favourite musician, splintering and spiraling into a feverish—and often personal—quest for justice.

Like astir people his age, David Burke grew up connected the net and learned from a young property however to weaponize it. He was calved successful 2005, the aforesaid twelvemonth YouTube launched, and has been posting videos to the level since astatine slightest the property of 13—around the aforesaid clip helium moved with his devout Christian household from Queens, New York, to a middle-class suburb of Houston. Some of his earliest uploads are surface recordings of his plays connected Fortnite, a battle-royale-style video crippled helium was obsessed with. They offered him the attraction and societal enactment helium seemed to beryllium different lacking.

“He was grinding. He was posting each day, playing each day, helium was trying his hardest to get somewhere,” says a 21-year-old New York–based gamer who goes by the username Sacred WTF. “Bro, I would conscionable aftermath up sometimes and it would conscionable beryllium aggregate posts from him. He was conscionable trying to popular off, conscionable get 1 bully video.”

By 2021, D4vd was 16 and already gathering a marque arsenic a socially awkward outcast who spent astir each of his clip online. (It helped that helium was homeschooled.) Sometimes, it paid off: When helium started catering to the YouTube algorithm by adding fashionable songs to his Fortnite videos, they racked up hundreds of thousands of views and generated “a batch of money” successful advertisement revenue, he’d aboriginal archer instrumentalist Benny Blanco successful an interview. But those monolithic views besides brought copyright strikes—warnings from YouTube, prompted by grounds labels, to region the songs oregon hazard getting booted from the platform. That’s when, according to the present mythic root communicative that D4vd has relayed successful the press, his ma had a life-altering suggestion: Why didn’t her lad marque his ain damn music?

Using his iPhone, a brace of earbuds, and a mobile app called Bandlab, D4vd—he adopted the moniker astir this time, successful portion for hunt motor optimization—huddled successful his sister’s closet and recorded himself freestyling implicit a royalty-free soft bushed helium recovered connected YouTube. He uploaded the track, called “Run Away,” to Soundcloud successful December 2021 and tagged it with keywords that helped it spell viral: #emo #chill #lowfi #slowedandreverb #blowthisup #foryoupage.

But it wasn’t until July 2022, erstwhile helium self-released the brooding ballad “Romantic Homicide,” that the then-17-year-old truly blew up. Two months later, D4vd signed a woody with Interscope Records’ Darkroom imprint. The comparisons to Billie Eilish, who besides scored a woody with Darkroom arsenic a teen aft uploading tracks to Soundcloud, were immediate. In mag profiles, D4vd was heralded arsenic a caller benignant of wunderkind: a sheltered gamer who accidentally became a popular star, seemingly overnight. GQ dubbed him a “mouthpiece for Gen-Z heartache.” NME declared helium was a “multi-genre visionary.” And Billboard christened D4vd “one of alternate music’s astir promising caller artists.”

“When I recovered him, it was like, ‘Wow, helium made this successful his closet connected headphones, connected Bandlab. That’s truthful cool. I could bash that, too,’” says Ykare, a fashionable TikTokker who utilized to imagination astir collaborating with D4vd. “That was his full thing. That was his assertion to fame. I deliberation that’s truly what brought successful a batch of younger audiences.”

Before Ykare recovered his niche—dressing arsenic a Teletubby and singing successful the shower—he was inspired by D4vd’s humble beginnings. “People looked up to him,” Ykare says, due to the fact that of D4vd’s explosive breakout from a “homemade, ‘I made this successful my bedroom’ niche. That’s wherever D4vd lived, and helium benignant of was the astir palmy to bash that.”

D4vd communicated with his super-young fans done his Discord. His server was created by a instrumentality named Moji astir the clip helium signed his grounds deal. Though not officially affiliated with Darkroom, the Discord had a wide payment to the label: It was a mode to beforehand releases, circuit dates, and merchandise straight to superfans. Moderators, which were mostly different fans but besides included astatine slightest 1 subordinate of D4vd’s absorption team, Mogul Vision, and occasionally D4vd himself, shared links to caller contented and encouraged members to subscribe to D4vd’s email database for presale summons codes. (Neither Mogul Vision, Darkroom, Interscope Geffen A&M Records, nor its genitor company, Universal Music Group, responded to a petition for comment.) The tactics besides cemented D4vd’s perceived authenticity arsenic a chronically online teen without overmuch media training.

In February 2023, 3 months earlier helium dropped his debut EP and kicked disconnected his archetypal European tour, D4vd popped into the Discord with an announcement: He’d “officially named the blindfold character” he’d portrayed successful the video for “Romantic Homicide.” His sanction was Itami, the Japanese connection for pain, D4vd explained, and helium was lone the archetypal quality of galore to travel successful his ain cinematic universe, which helium called the “d4vdverse.” A fewer days later, helium posted astir Itami connected X, telling fans to “feel escaped to permission conspiracy theories.” In the YouTube caption for a euphony video featuring the character, D4vd took the conception a measurement further, instructing his fans to look for Easter eggs.

“He wears a blindfold for the sole intent of not being held accountable for the symptom helium causes,” reads the caption. “He’s been planted successful each of my euphony videos but it’s not wide what his motive is … You volition soon find out.”

When Sarah, who is 30 and works successful veterinary medicine successful Oregon, archetypal heard astir the assemblage uncovered from D4vd’s car, she had the aforesaid thought arsenic Safiyya: D4vd indispensable person been framed. Sarah had joined the musician’s Discord server aft proceeding “Romantic Homicide” connected TikTok and loving its slow-building melody and evocative lyrics. But she’d ever interpreted them arsenic metaphorical: “Like, you’re dormant emotionally to me, you know?”

Then she came crossed a Reddit station and began to fearfulness that D4vd’s lyrics were much literal. The station was written by a since-deleted idiosyncratic who worried, successful the days earlier the quality remains successful D4vd’s Tesla had been identified, that they already knew who the unfortunate was. “A adjacent friends [sic] small sister from the [Inland Empire] ran distant past twelvemonth and this is who she was with,” the message, which has besides since been deleted, reads successful part. “I’m terrified that’s who is successful the car- cipher has heard from her successful months. I won’t merchandise names arsenic shes [sic] inactive a insignificant but she was from Lake Elsinore.”

On September 18, erstwhile the Los Angeles Police Department publically released the sanction of the victim, Sarah felt sick to her stomach. It was 14-year-old Celeste Rivas Hernandez. As the Reddit station had suggested, she was from Lake Elsinore, a working-class metropolis astir 75 miles southeast of Los Angeles. She had so been reported missing by her family. In photos of Rivas Hernandez splashed crossed the news, she had large brownish eyes, a cleft chin, and middle-parted achromatic ringlets that fell past her shoulders. She wore a golden transverse astir her cervix and dressed similar the mediate schooler she was, successful jeans, sneakers, and zip-up hoodies from the Gap.

For Sarah, who says she was groomed arsenic a teen by an big successful a gaming chat room, it was not hard to ideate that Rivas Hernandez whitethorn person met D4vd online, possibly adjacent successful a Discord server. Sarah remembers thinking: “I’ve been Celeste. I’ve been successful her shoes.”

It wasn’t the archetypal clip that Sarah—who enjoyed sleuthing and had grown up watching the 2010s world amusement Catfish, astir radical utilizing fake online identities—had empathized with a young, pistillate execution victim. In the summertime of 2021, she followed the online probe into the disappearance of 22-year-old Gabby Petito. After weeks of searching, and a near-endless watercourse of viral YouTube and TikTok videos, Petito’s remains were recovered successful a nationalist wood successful Wyoming. Soon after, her fiancé killed himself, leaving down a notebook successful which helium confessed to her murder. Sarah was little than 3 years older than Petito astatine the time, and she’d besides been successful an abusive relationship. “I thought that I would extremity up similar her,” Sarah says.

Fueled by her choler astir Rivas Hernandez’s execution and her ain experiences with men, Sarah, similar legions of others who erstwhile streamed “Romantic Homicide” connected repeat, turned connected D4vd. Sarah blocked his euphony connected Spotify and joined recently created Discord servers with names similar “The David Case” and “David Leaks,” wherever erstwhile fans were present scouring the artist’s integer footprint for traces of Rivas Hernandez. True-crime buffs, galore of whom had ne'er antecedently heard of D4vd but were present scandalized by his morbid lyrics, became engrossed with the execution enigma too.

They swarmed r/d4vd, a subreddit wherever fans erstwhile posted interpretations of opus lyrics and D4vd’s societal media posts. Only now, the speculation was unified and turbo-charged by a shared theory: That D4vd groomed Rivas Hernandez online, engaged successful a intersexual narration with her, and housed her erstwhile she ran distant from location astatine conscionable 13 years old.

Rivas Hernandez was reported missing to the Riverside County Sheriff’s Office astatine slightest doubly successful 2024: once, connected Valentine’s Day, and again successful April, pursuing a little instrumentality home. 911 telephone logs obtained by WIRED suggest Rivas Hernandez’s location beingness whitethorn person been tumultuous. Roughly 3 weeks aft her 2nd disappearance, the Riverside County Sheriff’s Office received a telephone reporting a suspicious condition astatine her family’s home, which sits connected the aforesaid artifact arsenic a liquor store and an car repair shop. On Christmas Eve, the sheriff’s bureau fielded a telephone reporting an alleged artillery that had conscionable occurred astatine her home; a study was not taken, and the Riverside County Sheriff’s Office declined to connection specifics. A lawyer representing Rivas Hernandez’s parents did not respond to a petition for comment.

The enigma surrounding Rivas Hernandez’s decease made quality globally. “It truly hits connected a batch of issues, similar the exploitation and maltreatment of minors successful Hollywood specifically and the strategy and however it protects oregon fails to support minors,” says Amanda, a 30-year-old speech-language pathologist who grew up adjacent to D4vd’s Texas hometown and became intrigued by the lawsuit aft proceeding astir it connected TikTok. “She was a minor, she was vulnerable, a runaway successful the streets of Hollywood, you know? Like, could you beryllium much vulnerable?”

In fast-growing subreddits similar r/d4vd2, r/CelesteRivasHernandez, r/JusticeforCeleste, and r/d4vdiots, Rivas Hernandez became a martyr astir overnight. There were illustrations of her arsenic a saint and avatars of her face, taken from missing person’s flyers her household erstwhile posted connected Facebook. Sleuths saw her everywhere: successful screenshots of Instagram stories, wherever a dainty manus showed disconnected what appeared to beryllium an engagement ringing and an scale digit tattoo that work “Shhh” (D4vd, they alleged, has a matching one); connected Twitch, wherever a sassy miss successful a hoodie and oversized glasses appeared to taunt and embarrass D4vd during a livestream, adjacent accusing him of “raping kids”; and successful D4vd’s ain euphony videos, which often featured actors who shared a resemblance to Rivas Hernandez, with olive tegument and curly acheronian hair.

When sleuths noticed that Aysia Collins, a 23-year-old exemplary and histrion who played D4vd’s emotion involvement successful the video for “Sleep Well,” had besides appeared successful his Instagram photos and Twitch streams, they flooded her societal media pages with accusations relating to Rivas Hernandez. Anyone and everyone who had been photographed regularly alongside D4vd, including the video crippled streamer Neo Langston—better known by his handle, NeoTheAsian—became just crippled to online interrogators.

On Reddit and TikTok, astir each facet of the lawsuit was debated endlessly, including the magnitude of clip Rivas Hernandez’s remains had been successful the Tesla and the nonstop day she died. There were adjacent much grisly questions: Had her assemblage been dismembered oregon simply decomposed? (It would beryllium different respective months until the LA County District Attorney confirmed some were true.) Meanwhile, conspiracies proliferated astir D4vd having hired doppelgängers arsenic a mode to fell his alleged narration with an underage runaway.

These theories whitethorn person seemed outlandish if D4vd hadn’t explicitly trained his fans, done his instauration of Itami and the alleged d4vdverse, to analyse his euphony for hidden meanings. Symbolism, fantasy, and mythology—much of it inspired by Japanese anime and world-building video games similar Fortnite—were truthful cardinal to D4vd’s marque that 1 of his moderators adjacent created a transmission successful his Discord server to promote conjecture. The transmission was described arsenic a spot “to sermon your theories and immoderate you deliberation the lore is going to beryllium successful the aboriginal projects.”

It was a chilly September afternoon, but Ghost felt flush. Glued to the machine successful his chamber successful New Jersey, he’d conscionable stumbled upon what helium considered a bombshell portion of evidence. Ghost had joined D4vd’s Discord server successful 2022, not agelong aft it was created; helium and D4vd were successful the aforesaid Fortnite-related Discord servers previously, Ghost says, and erstwhile helium recovered retired that D4vd was a musician, helium was excited to beryllium among the archetypal to cognize astir caller releases. But wrong a mates of years, Ghost, on with galore different aboriginal fans, had grown impatient with the singer, whom they felt was spending excessively overmuch clip connected TikTok and not capable successful the studio.

In 1 TikTok from aboriginal 2024, D4vd professed to beryllium consumed with a “Hello Kitty girl” he’d met 3 years earlier. In another, posted aboriginal that year, conscionable earlier D4vd acquired astir fractional a twelve caller facial piercings, helium trolled his fans by captioning a video of himself driving a Tesla and listening to caller euphony from Tyler, the Creator: “im excessively engaged playing fortnite to decorativeness my medium 😭” When D4vd’s archetypal workplace album, Withered, yet dropped successful April 2025, Ghost was thrilled.

But his feelings changed wholly 5 months later, erstwhile helium heard astir Rivas Hernandez’s execution from a video that autoplayed connected his YouTube feed. “It’s similar a power was flipped,” helium says. Imagining that Rivas Hernandez indispensable person been the “Hello kitty girl,” Ghost surged with choler and a tendency for vengeance. He could consciousness himself slipping into detective mode; it was, arsenic his online alias mightiness suggest, 1 that helium peculiarly enjoyed.

Ghost, contempt being conscionable 16 years old, is simply a self-described ethical hacker who taught himself however to usage unfastened root intelligence. It each started erstwhile 1 of his friends successful mediate schoolhouse was “blackmailed by a catfish relationship connected Instagram” that threatened to merchandise embarrassing photos. Ghost considered himself computer-savvy and wanted to help. When helium verified the IP code and individuality of the catfisher, Ghost says, helium realized, “Hey, I’m really truly bully astatine this.”

But adjacent Ghost was startled astatine however seemingly casual it was to excavation up a notation of Rivas Hernandez successful D4vd’s Discord server. When helium and a person typed the connection “Celeste” into the hunt bar, they were flabbergasted to find an speech from August 2024, much than a twelvemonth earlier her assemblage was found. D4vd had posted successful the wide chat: “Im successful a opus situation close now.” It was unclear whether helium was looking for suggestions, conscionable venting, oregon trying to disturbance up conversation, but the server lit up successful response. It was a rare, breathtaking occurrence. One of the dozens of responses was from a idiosyncratic whose relationship has since been deleted. It read: “Drop the 1 with the missing miss celeste rivas hernandez.”

Ghost stared astatine his machine screen, eyes wide similar saucers, feeling the value of a girl’s decease connected his shoulders. There was nary different mode helium could construe the message: At slightest 1 idiosyncratic successful the Discord server knew Rivas Hernandez by name—and they knew she’d been missing. “I was like, ‘Oh my God. This is big,’” Ghost says.

Beads of sweat dripped onto his mousepad arsenic Ghost realized that immoderate messages successful the server were being deleted successful existent time. He wondered what benignant of incriminating accusation moderators, oregon adjacent D4vd himself, mightiness beryllium trying to hide. They’d already disabled the chat, and Ghost disquieted it was lone a substance of clip earlier they wiped the server completely. He remembers thinking: “I person entree to the server that’s being constricted arsenic we speak, and I’m gonna bash everything successful my powerfulness to archive it. My lone accidental is now. If I miss that chance, I won’t beryllium capable to bash anything.”

From his chamber successful his parents’ home, Ghost utilized his information token connected Discord to extract information from the server. The full download of immoderate 3.7 gigabytes took astir 9 hours. Ghost spent overmuch of that clip nervously pacing backmost and distant crossed his room. When the download was complete, helium uploaded the HTML codification to the Internet Archive and shared it connected r/d4vd. The subreddit went chaotic with speculation.

A fewer days later, May, a 22-year-old instrumentality pupil successful the Netherlands, was snooping astir d4vd’s closet erstwhile she noticed the aforesaid happening arsenic Ghost. “That was precise suspicious to me. Why are determination messages getting deleted?” she wondered. Seeking to validate her suspicions and crowdsource intelligence, May sounded the alarm connected r/d4vd. “My station blew up. I got implicit 550,000 views connected it. A clump of radical started DMing me,” May says. “People started sending maine information.”

May, a research-obsessed paralegal, considered herself a rational idiosyncratic who cares profoundly astir the truth. She was ne'er a instrumentality of D4vd’s, but thing astir the mythology of his euphony and the brutality of Rivas Hernandez’s decease nagged astatine her. She became determined to get to the bottommost of it.

Scrolling done r/d4vd 1 night, May landed connected a screenshot that made her gasp. It showed a connection Safiyya had sent successful the wide chat of D4vd’s Discord server successful precocious 2024, astir a twelvemonth earlier. Members had been lamenting that D4vd had gotten excessively fashionable and wasn’t engaging with them online the mode helium erstwhile did. One subordinate said that she utilized to chat with D4vd implicit Instagram and Snapchat DMs. Safiyya, who noted that she’d seen D4vd’s Twitch streams spell from attracting 10,000 viewers to much than 100,000, had a flex of her own: “One time, helium called maine origin helium tryna delete that watercourse with his gf.”

May believed, similar a batch of different redditors who had been snooping around, that the woman successful question was Rivas Hernandez. She pored implicit different screenshots of messages Safiyya had sent successful the Discord chat implicit the years—including immoderate that referenced Epstein and pedophilia—and began to presumption her with aggravated suspicion. Why was Safiyya asked to delete the livestream? Had she known that D4vd’s woman was a minor? And however could she person ignored the chilling connection successful the chat astir “the missing miss Celeste Rivas Hernandez?”

Two weeks after D4vd’s Discord erupted into chaos, Safiyya felt her beingness was spiraling retired of control. Before, the server had been a changeless companion and root of comfort: a near-endless watercourse of conversations that she could ever driblet successful and retired of erstwhile she needed a laughter oregon wanted to distract herself with memes. Plus, it had fixed her a purpose, a work and absorption extracurricular of work. Now the Discord server was locked, and Safiyya’s nonstop messages were brimming with questions from suspicious outsiders who had joined the erstwhile insular online community. All of them, it seemed, felt called to hunt for answers successful the lack of immoderate updates, property conferences, oregon authoritative statements astir the lawsuit from the LAPD.

At first, Safiyya shrugged disconnected immoderate of the messages she received arsenic harmless, if not creepy, trolling. When a alien demanded she confess “everything you cognize astir Celeste and David,” Safiyya responded glibly. “Idk david successful idiosyncratic 😭😭” she wrote. “Lmfaooo.” She was telling the truth, she says: As overmuch arsenic she’d yearned to person a existent relationship with D4vd, she hardly knew him astatine all. For the astir part, helium ignored her erstwhile she messaged him connected Discord oregon responded to his Instagram stories. He’d lone ever tried to FaceTime her that 1 time, she says.

“Do not uncover immoderate accusation with others,” the alien responded, assuming an aerial of authority. “Bet,” she wrote back, attempting to telephone their bluff. The connection speech had taken spot connected September 13, 5 days earlier Rivas Hernandez had been publically identified by the LAPD. But aft the 14-year-old was confirmed arsenic the deceased, it began to descend successful for Safiyya that D4vd mightiness not beryllium arsenic guiltless arsenic she’d erstwhile assumed. She’d agelong heard that helium had a woman named Celeste, and she’d adjacent seen a idiosyncratic with the show sanction “Celeste” interact with him successful the server. “Celeste successful here??” D4vd, who had a crown emoji adjacent to this show sanction and a badge signifying helium was the proprietor of the server, posted successful the chat successful October 2022. “HI DAVID BARKKK,” this idiosyncratic wrote back, riffing connected D4vd’s afloat name, David Burke.

According to their profile, “Celeste” had created a Discord relationship successful January 2021 and belonged to 2 of the aforesaid servers arsenic Safiyya: d4vd’s closet and 1 called E-Girl Paradise, which bills itself arsenic a forum for socializing and dating (channels successful that server see “freaky-chat,” “match-making” and “goon-corner”). Safiyya maintains that she didn’t cognize this user’s existent age; aft all, their illustration displayed a badge—granted by moderators of servers—showing that they were implicit the property of 18. Another badge proclaimed: “Number 1 Fan.” (A spokesperson for Discord said these “server roles” are not determined oregon verified by the company. “We necessitate each users to beryllium astatine slightest 13 years aged and judge that obscurity is our information enactment much important than with teens,” the institution said successful a connection to WIRED).

As sleuths sifted done the Discord server, Safiyya’s username came up clip and again. In 1 speech from precocious 2024, Safiyya seemed to person cognition of a idiosyncratic named Celeste, referring to her arsenic D4vd’s ex. She had theorized that D4vd’s bitter elegy, “My House Is Not a Home,” with lyrics similar “You didn’t privation to autumn successful emotion / You’re looking retired for yourself now,” indispensable person been written astir their breakup. At the time, she says, she believed that D4vd had a caller girlfriend, with a antithetic username connected Discord. Online investigators were convinced that this expected caller woman was really the aforesaid person—a subversion of the doppelgänger conspiracy—and it looked to immoderate of them, May and Ghost included, similar Safiyya was covering for D4vd.

The assertive messages Safiyya had been receiving, she realized, weren’t conscionable trolling. They were serious; immoderate of them were adjacent decease threats. Every clip her telephone pinged, Safiyya’s assemblage filled with dread. She became terrified to permission her parents’ house. She hadn’t told them astir the online harassment—she didn’t privation to interest them—but possibly determination were signs: She’d dyed her hairsbreadth a antithetic colour aft redditors posted a photograph of her from D4vd’s Discord server. She’d thought astir getting a lawyer, but she couldn’t spend one. Instead, she resigned herself to mounting her ain defence online.

On the nighttime of September 22, she took a heavy enactment and began responding to accusations connected r/d4vd. She tried to explicate that she helped D4vd delete a Twitch livestream due to the fact that the video had violated Twitch’s assemblage guidelines: The miss successful it, whom Safiyya knew to beryllium D4vd’s woman “Celeste,” had made a notation to the intersexual battle of children. Safiyya had shrugged it disconnected arsenic an awkward gag successful mediocre taste. It ne'er occurred to her that the miss successful the video mightiness person been a insignificant herself. As for the connection astir “the missing girl,” Safiyya insisted, she simply didn’t spot it. She says she erstwhile believed that D4vd and the Discord idiosyncratic named “Celeste” had breached up. But now, she excessively subscribed to the mentation that D4vd, increasing progressively paranoid, had convinced Rivas Hernandez to rejoin the server nether a antithetic username, to conceal her existent property and identity.

Redditors, including May, followed the thread with skepticism. They began piling into the comments. She and others challenged Safiyya’s explanations. Safiyya was flustered and exhausted. English isn’t her archetypal language, and each clip she tried to articulate her thoughts, they came retired similar sludge for others to fling backmost astatine her. Never caput that it felt astir intolerable to construe the mostly meaningless wrong jokes successful D4vd’s Discord server—like the clip a fistful of members inexplicably made their show names identical to 1 another, truthful nary 1 could archer who was who.

Others mightiness person logged off, but Safiyya doubled down. She invited her online haters to articulation her idiosyncratic Discord server and inquire her questions directly. The thought of it made her buzz with anxiety: She describes herself arsenic “antisocial,” but she was hopeless to beryllium understood. She was upset, too, astir Rivas Hernandez’s decease and however astatine slightest 1 subordinate of d4vd’s closet had known she’d been reported missing. Safiyya disquieted that she’d failed this 14-year-old miss she’d ne'er met but present recovered herself reasoning of constantly. She remembered the dependable of the miss successful the hoodie’s rambunctious laughter successful the Twitch livestream, the assurance successful her voice. Safiyya wondered if possibly the laughter had been masking fear.

Safiyya, similar Sarah, knew what it was similar to beryllium preyed upon online. Safiyya wasn’t overmuch older than Rivas Hernandez—15 oregon 16, she thinks—when she was propositioned by an big connected an anonymous video chat tract called Omegle. (The institution unopen down successful 2023 aft settling aggregate lawsuits connected behalf of minors who alleged they’d met intersexual predators connected the platform.) Safiyya hoped that by continuing to speech astir D4vd’s Discord server publically she mightiness promote different moderators to travel guardant and stock what they knew, if anything, astir Rivas Hernandez.

May, successful the Netherlands, and Sarah, successful Oregon, were among the tiny radical of redditors who joined Safiyya’s server, bare for answers. At first, Sarah wasn’t definite what to deliberation of Safiyya’s defense. But erstwhile she started responding by audio call, Sarah recognized the symptom successful her soft, shaky voice. She felt Safiyya indispensable beryllium telling the truth. “I could archer that she was truly wounded ’cause she was moderating for this idiosyncratic that she looked up to, and past each this came retired and present she’s wholly crushed,” says Sarah. “She was truthful overwhelmed, and I felt truthful atrocious ’cause she’s young too.”

Because Sarah had been successful D4vd’s Discord server since aboriginal 2024, she was acquainted with the marque of off-color wit that dominated it. She felt that Safiyya’s posts astir Epstein had been taken retired of context. “I knew she was conscionable making edgy jokes, you know, trying to acceptable successful with this radical of people,” Sarah says. “People person been trying to overgarment her arsenic this evil protector of a kid predator, which she’s not.”

May, too, softened aft discovering that Safiyya wasn’t an all-knowing insider. In hindsight, the thought seemed astir absurd, impervious of however the net tin distort reality. The mode Safiyya tells it, she’d spent countless hours helping to cultivate a instrumentality basal for idiosyncratic she’d ne'er met and who astir uniformly ignored her online. Even Safiyya’s attempts to people escaped merchandise from D4vd’s label, a perk she’d heard different Discord moderators received, were rebuffed. “I’m not adjacent gonna lie; I enactment excessively overmuch effort into reviving his server,” says Safiyya, adding that she sometimes spent her ain wealth buying upgrades, similar a Minecraft plug-in, for it. “He didn’t admit my work.”

Safiyya had, astatine 1 time, hoped to articulation the unpaid squad of Discord mods that worked straight withD4vd’s statement to assistance with selling efforts, she says. Finding retired astir caller releases earlier anyone other would’ve been exciting, Safiyya thought, and possibly she’d larn thing that could assistance boost her nascent vocation arsenic a gaming streamer. But Safiyya was ne'er accepted arsenic a subordinate of the team. In retrospect, she sees it arsenic a immense relief: She’s gladsome she didn’t cognize what was truly going connected down the scenes. Then again, she thinks, possibly if she’d known thing astir Rivas Hernandez, she could’ve helped her.

As the months dragged on, sleuths grew frustrated and disillusioned with the deficiency of disposable advancement from the justness system. Some started to suffer hope. Others, citing D4vd’s macabre lyrics and his knife-wielding Itami character, feared helium mightiness termination himself earlier helium faced transgression charges. To a batch of amateur investigators, the online grounds was glaring—and what of the imaginable DNA that professionals are tasked with collecting? Or the surveillance footage that whitethorn person been captured by Tesla cameras? Whatever was causing the lawsuit to linger, the LAPD, astatine slightest during the people of its investigation, wasn’t saying.

In fact, the bureau had actively taken steps to conceal accusation astir the case. In precocious November 2025, it placed a information clasp connected Rivas Hernandez’s autopsy, preventing it from being released to the public. In a statement, the LA County main aesculapian examiner, Odey Ukpo, sharply rebuked the decision. “Since becoming the section head, I’ve worked connected eradicating the signifier of placing information holds connected aesculapian examiner cases simply by instrumentality enforcement request,” helium said. “The signifier of information holds is virtually unheard of successful different counties and has not been proven to amended outcomes successful the ineligible system.”

By the commencement of 2026, immoderate true-crime enthusiasts, similar Amanda, the speech-language pathologist successful Texas, had already stepped distant from the case, feeling arsenic if determination mightiness ne'er beryllium a satisfying resolution. Amanda had erstwhile been an progressive subordinate of r/CelesteRivasHernandez, adjacent going truthful acold arsenic to compile and stock a seven-page, single-spaced timeline of events perchance related to the crime. But she hasn’t posted connected Reddit successful months; she felt alienated by redditors she thinks went excessively acold by harassing anyone associated with D4vd.

In precocious February, Collins, the exemplary and histrion who appeared successful 1 of D4vd’s euphony videos and successful galore of his photos, posted a connection connected r/d4vdiots successful which she stressed that she is nary longer friends with D4vd and asked for privacy. “You guys bash not cognize everything going connected arsenic overmuch arsenic you person done digging. I americium besides mislaid arsenic well. The harassment has gotten horrible,” she wrote. “I person had radical way maine down astatine work, stalk me, endanger to termination me, endanger to devour me, chop maine up, you sanction it. Yet radical don’t cognize however hard I americium moving successful soundlessness to bring justness to Celeste Rivas successful the ways that I can.”

All the while, Sarah and May kept digging. They’d been chatting successful a Discord radical for months, swapping intel with Safiyya and a backstage researcher named Steve Fischer, whom Sarah had connected with connected X aft noticing his viral tweets astir the case. Together, they shared theories, scrutinized societal media posts, and speculated astir accounts they believed were secretly D4vd. (They accidental D4vd has been known to usage burners and back-up accounts nether antithetic aliases).

When unreleased tracks from D4vd’s deluxe medium leaked online successful mid-March, they wondered if helium himself had been responsible. Sarah enactment unneurotic a papers cataloging the astir suspicious of the caller opus lyrics. Among them: “I’ve been trying to erase you, it makes maine consciousness similar an asshole. Just got escaped of my tattoo, I ever knew it wouldn’t past long.” Often, the radical bemoaned the deficiency of connection from instrumentality enforcement. “Why the silence? Why nary transparency? Why nary charges? What are they hiding? Is this a blown investigation?” Fischer posted connected X conscionable earlier noon connected Thursday, April 16.

Less than six hours later, Safiyya was having meal with immoderate friends erstwhile she got a caller Discord connection from May: D4vd had been arrested.

The infinitesimal they disquieted mightiness ne'er materialize was yet here, suddenly, and without warning. Safiyya was flooded with relief, but she besides had a ton of questions. Among them: Why had it taken the LAPD 7 months to instrumentality D4vd into custody? And had helium been hiding retired successful the Hollywood Hills mansion wherever helium was arrested that full time? Safiyya assumed he’d gone backmost to Texas oregon possibly adjacent fled the country, similar she’d seen different suspected murderers bash successful true-crime documentaries.

The pursuing Monday, Safiyya, Sarah, and May each watched, from 3 antithetic countries and clip zones, the livestream of the Los Angeles County territory attorney’s property conference—the archetypal 1 held by authorities successful the lawsuit involving Rivas Hernandez. The sleuths soon discovered, on with the remainder of the world, that the lawsuit was adjacent much twisted than they’d imagined: According to LA County territory lawyer Nathan Hochman, the LAPD had been investigating D4vd for lewd and lascivious intersexual acts astatine the clip of Rivas Hernandez’s murder. The 14-year-old had been a witnesser successful the investigation, and she was killed by D4vd, Hochman alleged, arsenic a mode “to support his precise lucrative euphony vocation that Celeste was threatening” erstwhile she came implicit to his location connected the nighttime of April 23, 2025. She “was ne'er heard from again.”

Hochman announced that his bureau was charging D4vd with first-degree execution with peculiar circumstances, which carries a maximum condemnation of either beingness without the anticipation of parole oregon the decease penalty, on with further charges related to intersexual maltreatment and mutilating quality remains. D4vd has pleaded not guilty. “The existent grounds successful this lawsuit volition amusement that David Burke did not execution Celeste Rivas Hernandez and helium was not the origin of her death,” his attorneys said successful a statement. “We volition vigorously support David’s innocence.” When it was his crook astatine the podium, LAPD main Jim McDonnell defended his department’s probe and its deficiency of connection with the public. “My work is not to substance speculation. It’s to present justice, and that requires patience and subject connected everybody’s part,” helium said, flanked by an easel connected either broadside of him: On one, a poster of Rivas Hernandez; connected the other, a poster of David Burke’s booking photo. “We had to beryllium definite that thing we did oregon said would ever jeopardize this case.”

The time aft the property conference, Rivas Hernandez’s household issued their archetypal nationalist connection successful the 7 months since their girl had been murdered. (They, similar the LAPD, had been publically criticized for their soundlessness during the investigation.) “Celeste was a beautiful, beardown miss who loved to sing and dance. Every Friday was movie nighttime and we spent fantastic times together,” they said done their lawyer. “We emotion her precise overmuch and she ever told america that she loved us. We miss her deeply. All we privation is Justice for Celeste.” The pursuing day, connected April 22, the Medical Examiner released a study stating that Rivas Hernandez’s origin of decease was aggregate penetrating injuries, including a stab coiled connected her close abdomen and different connected her near chest, “caused by object(s).”

May had watched the livestream from her laptop astatine her schoolhouse library, wherever she’d been studying for an upcoming exam. She knew she wasn’t going to get immoderate much schoolwork done that night. May couldn’t get implicit the day that Rivas Hernandez was allegedly killed. The timing of it, May realized, coincided with D4vd’s assertive promotion of his latest album: On April 23, 2025, allegedly the past time of Rivas-Hernandez’s abbreviated life, D4vd had posted a TikTok of himself dancing and pointing to the vinyl variation of Withered. “Your prayers person been answered it’s yet here,” helium captioned it. His giddy front-facing camera videos continued implicit the adjacent respective days. “It’s really truthful disgusting to deliberation astir that,” May says.

May and Sarah inactive haven’t fixed up connected their ain DIY investigation. Armed with caller accusation from the property conference, they program to support scouring D4vd’s Discord server and reviewing his aged societal media posts to spot what other they tin find.

Safiyya, connected the different hand, is trying to log off. Sometimes it feels similar weaning herself disconnected a drug. “At first, it was so, truthful hard,” she says. But it’s gotten a small easier with time. She inactive gets tense a lot, but she’s been making an effort to spell extracurricular more, to interaction grass, to get exercise. Simple things. Things she ne'er utilized to bash overmuch of. Even erstwhile she was successful college, she says, her net habits—between gaming and streaming and Discord—became truthful time-consuming that she stopped going to people and yet dropped out.

Lately, she’s been reasoning astir going backmost to schoolhouse to decorativeness her degree. She utilized to privation to beryllium a ineligible adjunct oregon possibly a journalist. She likes writing, but not truthful overmuch talking to people. Now she’s reasoning possibly a teacher oregon nurse. “I similar kids,” Safiyya says. “Not successful a weird way. I similar taking attraction of kids. Someday, I privation to beryllium a bully mom, if I ever person kids.” If she does, she thinks, she’ll privation to support them disconnected the net for arsenic agelong arsenic possible.

Let america cognize what you deliberation astir this article. Submit a missive to the exertion at [email protected].