The Menendez brothers case reflects a shifting culture across decades

LOS ANGELES – The trials of Lyle and Erik Menendez came astatine a clip of taste obsession with courts, transgression and murder, erstwhile unrecorded televised trials captivated a nationalist audience.

Their resentencing — and the present precise existent anticipation of their state — came astatine another, erstwhile existent transgression documentaries and docudramas person proliferated and brought renewed attraction to the family.

A justice made the Menendez brothers eligible for parole Tuesday erstwhile helium reduced their sentences from beingness without parole to 50 years to beingness for the 1989 execution of their begetter Jose Menendez and parent Kitty Menendez successful their Beverly Hills home. The authorities parole committee volition present find whether they tin beryllium released.

Their 2 trials bookended the O.J. Simpson trial, creating a mid-1990s improvement wherever courts subsumed soap operas arsenic riveting daytime television.

“People were not utilized to having cameras successful the courtroom. For the archetypal clip we were seeing the play of justness successful existent time,” said Vinnie Politan, a Court TV anchor who hosts the nightly “Closing Arguments” connected the network. "Everyone was watching cablegram and everyone had that communal experience. Today there’s a existent transgression bonanza happening, but it's splintered disconnected into truthful galore antithetic places.”

The brothers became an contiguous sensation with their 1990 arrest. They represented a pre-tech-boom representation of young affluent men arsenic portrayed successful galore a 1980s movie: the tennis-playing, Princeton-bound prep.

For galore viewers, this representation was confirmed by the spending spree they went connected aft the killings. Their lawsuit continued a fascination with the dark, backstage lives of the young and affluent that goes backmost astatine slightest to the Leopold and Loeb execution lawsuit of the 1930s, but had been successful the aerial successful cases similar the Billionaire Boys Club, a 1980s Ponzi strategy that spurred a murder.

The archetypal Menendez proceedings becomes compelling unrecorded TV

Their archetypal trials successful 1993 and 1994 became a landmark for then-new Court TV, which aired it astir successful its entirety. Defense lawyers conceded that they had changeable their parents. The jury, and the public, past had to see whether the brothers' grounds astir intersexual and different maltreatment from their begetter was plausible, and should mean condemnation connected a lesser charge.

The lasting representation from the proceedings was Lyle Menendez crying connected the basal arsenic helium described the abuse.

At the clip determination had been immoderate nationalist reckoning with the effects of enactment abuse, but not astir to the grade of today.

The 2 juries — 1 for each member — deadlocked, mostly on sex lines. It reflected the broader taste absorption — with women supporting a manslaughter condemnation and men a blameworthy verdict for first-degree murder.

A tough-on-crime era, and a Menendez proceedings sequel

The trials came astatine a clip erstwhile transgression successful the U.S. was astatine an all-time high, a tough-on-crime stance was a prerequisite for holding large governmental office, and a question of authorities mandating harsher sentences was passed.

That cognition appeared to prevail when, astatine their 2nd trial, the brothers were some convicted of first-degree murder.

As Associated Press proceedings newsman Linda Deutsch, who covered some trials on with Simpson’s and countless others, wrote successful 1996:

“This time, the assemblage rejected the defence assertion that the brothers murdered their parents aft years of intersexual abuse. Instead, it embraced the prosecution mentation that the killings were planned and that the brothers were greedy, spoiled brats who murdered to get their parents’ $14 cardinal fortune.”

The 2nd proceedings was not televised and got little attention.

“There were nary cameras, it was successful the shadiness of O.J. truthful it didn’t person the aforesaid spark and popular arsenic the archetypal one,” Politan said.

The Menendez brothers go a distant representation

They had go excessively well-known to beryllium forgotten, but for decades, the Menendez brothers faded into the background. Occasional stories emerged astir the brothers losing their appeals, arsenic did mugshots of them aging successful prison.

“The public’s representation of them was, ‘Yeah, I retrieve that trial, the guys with the sweaters successful court,’” Politan said.

That would alteration successful the epoch of true-crime TV, podcasts and streamers.

True transgression goes large

The 2017 NBC play bid “Law & Order True Crime: The Menendez Murders," wasn't wide watched, but inactive brought the lawsuit caller attention. The adjacent decennary would beryllium much important.

The 2022 Max docuseries “Menudo: Forever Young" included a erstwhile subordinate saying helium was raped by Jose Menendez erstwhile helium was 14. At astir the aforesaid time, the brothers submitted a missive that Erik wrote to his relative astir his father’s maltreatment earlier the killings.

The caller true-crime question would proceed to beforehand them, adjacent if the portrayal wasn't ever flattering.

" Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story," a play created by Ryan Murphy connected Netflix, made them beauteous and vain buffoons, and the actors were shown shirtless connected provocative billboards. Javier Bardem arsenic Jose Menendez brought Oscar-winning prima powerfulness to the task that dropped successful September of past year.

That was followed a period aboriginal by a documentary connected Netflix, “The Menendez Brothers.”

Together, the shows had the nationalist paying much attraction to the lawsuit than it had since the trials. Almost simultaneously came a real-life turning point, erstwhile then- Los Angeles District Attorney George Gascón said helium was reviewing caller grounds successful the case.

The bureau of Gascón's successor, Nathan Hochman, opposed the resentencing.

Deputy District Attorney Habib Balian perpetually sought astatine hearings to marque definite the “carnage” caused by the brothers wasn't forgotten, and repeatedly emphasized that they “shotgunned, brutally, their parents to death.”

But the shifts successful nationalist cognition and ineligible actions were already successful motion. The judge's determination to trim their charges came not with the play of the televised trial, but successful a abbreviated proceeding successful a national courtroom that wouldn't let cameras. The broader nationalist ne'er saw.

Despite his opposition, Hochman was reflective successful a connection aft the resentencing.

“The lawsuit of the Menendez brothers has agelong been a model for the nationalist to amended recognize the judicial system,” Hochman said. “This case, similar each cases — particularly those that captivate the nationalist — indispensable beryllium viewed with a captious eye. Our absorption and investigation ensured that the Court received a implicit and close grounds of the facts. Justice should ne'er beryllium swayed by spectacle.”

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.