The FBI mistakenly raided their Atlanta home. Now the Supreme Court will hear their lawsuit

ATLANTA – Before dawn connected Oct. 18, 2017, FBI agents broke down the beforehand doorway of Trina Martin's Atlanta home, stormed into her chamber and pointed guns astatine her and her then-boyfriend arsenic her 7-year-old lad screamed for his ma from different room.

Martin, blocked from comforting her son, cowered successful disbelief for what she said felt similar an eternity. But wrong minutes, the ordeal was over. The agents realized they had the incorrect house.

On Tuesday, an lawyer for Martin volition spell earlier the U.S. Supreme Court to inquire the justices to reinstate her 2019 suit against the U.S. authorities accusing the agents of battle and battery, mendacious apprehension and different violations.

A national justice successful Atlanta dismissed the suit successful 2022 and the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that determination past year. The Supreme Court agreed successful January to instrumentality up the matter.

The cardinal contented earlier the justices is nether what circumstances radical tin writer the national authorities successful an effort to clasp instrumentality enforcement accountable. Martin's attorneys accidental Congress intelligibly allowed for those lawsuits successful 1974, aft a brace of instrumentality enforcement raids connected incorrect houses made headlines, and blocking them would permission small recourse for families similar her.

FBI Atlanta spokesperson Tony Thomas said successful an email the bureau can’t remark connected pending litigation. But lawyers for the authorities argued successful Martin's lawsuit that courts shouldn’t beryllium “second-guessing” instrumentality enforcement decisions. The FBI agents did beforehand enactment and tried to find the close house, making this raid fundamentally antithetic from the no-knock, warrantless raids that led Congress to enactment successful the 1970s, the Justice Department said successful tribunal filings starting nether the Biden administration.

In dismissing Martin's case, the 11th Circuit mostly agreed with that argument, saying courts can't second-guess constabulary officers who marque “honest mistakes” successful searches. The cause who led the raid said his idiosyncratic GPS led him to the incorrect place. The FBI was looking for a suspected pack subordinate a fewer houses away.

Martin, 46, said she, her then-boyfriend, Toi Cliatt, and her lad were near traumatized.

“We’ll ne'er beryllium the same, mentally, emotionally, psychologically,” she said Friday astatine the neat, stucco location that was raided. “Mentally, you tin suppress it, but you can’t truly get implicit it.”

She and Cliatt pointed retired wherever they were sleeping erstwhile the agents broke successful and the maestro bath closet wherever they hid.

Martin stopped coaching way due to the fact that the starting pistol reminded her of the flashbang grenade the agents acceptable off. Cliatt, 54, said helium couldn’t sleep, forcing him to permission his motortruck driving job.

“The roadworthy is hypnotizing," helium said of driving tired. "I became a liability to my company.”

Martin said her lad became highly anxious, pulling threads retired of his apparel and peeling overgarment disconnected walls.

Cliatt initially thought the raid was a burglary attempt, truthful helium ran toward the closet, wherever helium kept a shotgun. Martin said her lad inactive expresses fearfulness that she could person died had she confronted the agents portion armed.

“If the Federal Tort Claims Act provides a origin of enactment for anything, it’s a wrong-house raid similar the 1 the FBI conducted here,” Martin's lawyers wrote successful a little to the Supreme Court.

Other U.S. appeals courts person interpreted the instrumentality much favorably for victims of mistaken instrumentality enforcement raids, creating conflicting ineligible standards that lone the nation’s highest tribunal tin resolve, they say. Public-interest groups crossed the ideological spectrum person urged the Supreme Court to overturn the 11th Circuit ruling.

After breaking down the doorway to the house, a subordinate of the FBI SWAT squad dragged Cliatt retired of the closet and enactment him successful handcuffs.

But 1 of the agents noticed helium did not person the suspect's tattoos, according to tribunal documents. He asked for Cliatt's sanction and address. Neither matched those of the suspect. The country went quiescent arsenic agents realized they had raided the incorrect house.

They uncuffed Cliatt and near for the close house, wherever they executed the warrant and arrested the antheral they were after.

The cause starring the raid returned aboriginal to apologize and permission a concern paper with a supervisor's name. But the household received nary compensation from the government, not adjacent for the harm to the house, Cliatt said.

Martin said the astir harrowing portion of the raid was her son's cries.

“When you're not capable to support your kid oregon astatine slightest combat to support your child, that's a feeling that nary genitor ever wants to feel,” she said.

___

Whitehurst reported from Washington.

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.