South Korean truth commission halts probe into adoption fraud, hundreds of cases in limbo

SEOUL – The South Korean government’s fact-finding committee suspended its groundbreaking probe into the extended fraud and maltreatment that tainted the nation’s historical overseas adoption program, a determination stemming from interior disputes among commissioners regarding which cases warranted designation arsenic problematic.

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission confirmed quality rights violations successful conscionable 56 of the 367 complaints filed by adoptees earlier suspending its probe Wednesday night, conscionable 1 period earlier its May 26 deadline.

The destiny of the remaining 311 cases, either deferred oregon incompletely reviewed, present hinges connected whether lawmakers volition found a caller information committee done authorities during Seoul’s adjacent government, which takes bureau aft the statesmanlike by-election connected June 3.

After a astir three-year probe into adoption cases crossed Europe, the United States, and Australia, the committee concluded successful a March interim study that the authorities bears work for facilitating a overseas adoption programme riddled with fraud and abuse, driven by efforts to chopped payment costs and carried retired by backstage agencies that often manipulated children’s backgrounds and origins.

However, immoderate adoptees, and adjacent members of the commission, criticized the cautiously-worded report, arguing that it should person much forcefully established the government’s complicity. Disputes besides arose aft the commission’s nine-member decision-making panel, dominated by conservative-leaning members appointed by precocious ousted President Yoon Suk Yeol and his party, voted connected March 25 to defer the assessments of 42 adoptee cases, citing insufficient documentation to conclusively beryllium the adoptions were problematic.

Commission officials haven’t disclosed which documents were cardinal to the discussions. However, they suggested that immoderate commissioners were hesitant to admit cases wherever adoptees couldn’t definitively beryllium falsification of biologic details successful their adoption papers, either done gathering their commencement parents oregon verifying accusation astir them.

On Wednesday, the sheet resolved the standoff by unanimously agreeing to suspend, alternatively than wholly drop, the probe into the 42 cases. The attack leaves unfastened the doorway for the cases to beryllium reconsidered if a aboriginal information committee is established. The sheet besides agreed to suspend investigations into the remaining 269 cases, citing insufficient clip to implicit the reviews earlier the deadline, according to 3 committee sources who described the discussions to the Associated Press.

No further investigations into adoptions for present

It was unclear if and erstwhile different committee volition beryllium established . Political attraction is present focused connected the aboriginal statesmanlike election. South Korea’s law Court formally removed Yoon from bureau connected April 4, months aft the opposition-controlled legislature impeached him implicit his little imposition of martial instrumentality successful December. The ruling triggered a drawback statesmanlike predetermination acceptable for June 3. Park Geon Tae, a elder researcher who led the probe into adoptions, said the information committee would beryllium incapable to nutrient immoderate further probe reports connected adoptions earlier the extremity of its mandate, aft the presumption of 5 of the 9 commissioners ended pursuing Wednesday’s meeting. This perchance paralyzes the decision-making process, which requires the enactment of astatine slightest 5 members. Most Korean adoptees were registered by agencies arsenic abandoned orphans, adjacent though galore had relatives who could person been easy identified oregon located. This signifier has often made it difficult—or adjacent impossible—for them to hint their roots.

The reluctance of immoderate commissioners to judge cases successful which adoptees person been incapable to find accusation astir their commencement parents reflects a deficiency of knowing of the systemic problems successful adoption and contradicts the commission’s broader findings, which acknowledged the manipulation of children’s origins, said Philsik Shin, a student astatine South Korea’s Anyang University. Shin’s investigation of government, instrumentality enforcement, and adoption records concludes that much than 90% of Korean children sent to the West betwixt 1980 and 1987, erstwhile adoptions peaked, astir surely had known relatives.

The commission’s findings released successful March broadly aligned with erstwhile reporting by The Associated Press. The AP investigations, which were besides documented by Frontline (PBS), elaborate however South Korea’s government, Western countries and adoption agencies worked successful tandem to proviso immoderate 200,000 Korean children to parents overseas, contempt years of grounds that galore were being procured done questionable oregon outright unscrupulous means.

Military governments implemented peculiar laws aimed astatine promoting overseas adoptions, removing judicial oversight and granting immense powers to backstage agencies, which bypassed due kid relinquishment practices portion shipping thousands of children to the West each year. Western nations ignored these problems and sometimes pressured South Korea to support the kids coming arsenic they focused connected satisfying their immense home demands for babies.

South Korea’s authorities has ne'er acknowledged nonstop work for issues related to past adoptions and has truthful acold not responded to the commission’s proposal to contented an authoritative apology.

Korean efforts to analyse past quality rights violations

Modeled aft the South African committee established successful the 1990s to exposure apartheid-era injustices, South Korea primitively launched the Truth and Reconciliation Commission successful 2006 to analyse past quality rights violations. That ended its enactment successful 2010.

Following the passing of a instrumentality that allowed for much investigations, the committee was relaunched successful December 2020 nether South Korea’s erstwhile wide government, with a absorption connected cases that occurred during the country’s subject dictatorships from the 1960s to 1980s.

Foreign adoptions were a large taxable of the 2nd commission, on with the atrocities astatine Brothers Home, a government-funded installation successful Busan that kidnapped, abused and enslaved thousands of children and adults deemed arsenic vagrants for decades until the 1980s.

In January, the committee confirmed astatine slightest 31 cases successful which children from Brothers Home were adopted abroad, which came years aft The AP exposed adoptions from the installation arsenic portion of a vast, profit-driven operation.

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.