So you saw 'Conclave' the movie. Here's what it got right – and wrong – about real-life conclaves

Speculation surrounding a conclave to elite a pope is simply a time-honored tradition. But for the impending conclave pursuing the death of Pope Francis, the ranks of armchair Vatican experts person swelled acknowledgment to Hollywood.

“Conclave” the film, a moody 2024 governmental thriller, introduced galore laypeople to the ancient enactment process with its arcane rules and expansive ceremony, albeit with a metallic surface twist packed afloat of palace intrigue and surprise.

Though it has its critics, the movie treats the gravity of a papal predetermination with respect and accurately portrays galore rituals and modern problems facing today’s Catholic Church. But Vatican experts pass the movie doesn’t get everything right.

Here's a look astatine what “Conclave” does get close — and incorrect — astir conclaves. (Spoilers ahead.)

Scenery and aesthetics

The movie excels astatine re-creating the look and consciousness of a conclave.

“The movie gets a batch right. They tried to reproduce the mise-en-scene of the Vatican accurately,” William Cavanaugh, a Catholic studies prof astatine DePaul University successful Chicago, said successful an email. “They amusement that a batch of the play is astir the preconclave conversations among cardinals.”

It’s not a cleanable re-creation, according to the Rev. Thomas Reese, a elder expert with the Religion News Service and a Vatican expert.

He called the movie’s accumulation values “marvelous,” but noted flimsy discrepancies successful the cardinals' dress.

“The reddish successful the cardinals’ garments was a heavy red, portion the world is much orange. Frankly, I similar the Hollywood mentation better,” Reese, a Jesuit clergyman who wrote “Inside the Vatican: The Politics and Organization of the Catholic Church,” said successful an email.

Papal protocols

The movie aligns with real-life expectations for a speedy conclave, said Massimo Faggioli, a humanities theology prof astatine Villanova University successful Pennsylvania.

“A agelong conclave would nonstop the connection of a Church divided and perchance connected the verge of a schism. The past of the conclaves successful the past period is truly a communicative of abbreviated conclaves,” helium said via email.

Reese pointed retired different discrepancies. While the voting process was depicted accurately, helium said, the ballots are burned not aft each vote, but aft each session, which is typically 2 votes.

Holy crippled holes

There are a fewer peculiarly egregious errors that, if corrected, would pb to a precise antithetic movie.

A cardinal quality successful the film, the archbishop of Kabul, Afghanistan, arrives conscionable earlier the conclave with paperwork declaring the precocious pope had made him a cardinal "in pectore" — “in secret” — allowing him to ballot for the adjacent pope.

“The biggest mistake successful the movie was the admittance of a cardinal successful pectore into the conclave,” said Reese. “If the sanction is not announced publically by the pope successful the beingness of the College of Cardinals, helium has nary close to be a conclave.”

Cavanaugh agreed and noted that portion the movie's twist astir the Kabul archbishop was far-fetched, it does constituent to a definite information astir conclaves.

“The cardinals bash not ever cognize who they’re getting erstwhile they elite a pope,” helium said. “If the cardinals knew however (Jorge Mario) Bergoglio would beryllium arsenic Pope Francis, galore of them wouldn’t person voted for him. Pius IX was elected arsenic a wide and turned into an archconservative. John XXIII was expected to beryllium a jolly caretaker pope, and helium unleashed Vatican II,” a bid of modernizing reforms.

Another of the movie's much outlandish storylines involves the dean of the College of Cardinals breaking the seal of the confessional by revealing to different cardinal what a nun confessed to him, said Reese.

“He committed a mortal misdeed and would beryllium automatically excommunicated. Such an enactment would beryllium egregiously wrong,” Reese said.

In summation to that, a cardinal paying for votes, arsenic shown successful the film, is unheard of successful modern times, said Cavanaugh, and the politicking is exaggerated.

And truthful are the politics.

The movie errs successful making cardinals into either wide oregon blimpish champions, said Kurt Martens, prof of canon instrumentality astatine the Catholic University of America successful Washington.

“Those labels don’t assistance us,” helium said due to the fact that cardinals are precise cautious successful expressing their opinions and “even idiosyncratic we deliberation is simply a wide cardinal is beauteous blimpish by secular standards.”

And helium added that adjacent successful an unusually ample conclave similar this year’s, the regularisation requiring the adjacent pope wins astatine slightest a two-thirds bulk of the ballot ensures that “whatever we telephone extreme” apt won’t get capable votes.

___

Associated Press writers Giovanna Dell'Orto and Nicole Winfield contributed to this report.

___

Associated Press religion sum receives enactment done the AP’s collaboration with The Conversation US, with backing from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely liable for this content.

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.