Prosecutors to retry Alex Murdaugh in deaths of wife and son after high court overturned convictions

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — The execution convictions and beingness condemnation of Alex Murdaugh were overturned Wednesday by the South Carolina Supreme Court due to the fact that the tribunal clerk astatine his proceedings suggested helium was guilty, but the disgraced lawyer won’t beryllium leaving situation immoderate clip soon.

Prosecutors accidental they program to retry Murdaugh, which apt means determination volition beryllium different lengthy proceedings for the lawsuit that due to the fact that of the operation of money, power, Southern accents and treachery has go a existent transgression sensation with respective streaming miniseries, champion selling books and dozens of existent transgression podcasts.

Murdaugh, 57, volition stay successful prison. He pleaded blameworthy to stealing astir $12 cardinal from his clients and presently is serving a 40-year national sentence.

Prosecutors committedness a retrial that volition look different

Prosecutors said they would aggressively question to effort Murdaugh again connected the execution charges with authorities Attorney General Alan Wilson saying helium respected the court's determination but nary 1 is supra the law.

Murdaugh's lawyers pointed retired that proceedings volition look a batch different, arsenic the justices besides ruled days of grounds astatine the execution proceedings astir however Murdaugh stole from clients, galore of them successful dire straights, shouldn't beryllium allowed adjacent time.

Still, the ruling is simply a triumph for Murdaugh, who admits to being a thief, liar, security cheat and atrocious lawyer, but has adamantly denied sidesplitting his woman Maggie and younger lad Paul since helium recovered their bodies extracurricular their location successful 2021.

“Alex has said from time 1 that helium did not termination his woman and son. We look guardant to a caller trial,” Murdaugh’s lawyers Dick Harpootlian and Jim Griffin said successful a associated statement.

Court said clerk attacked Murdaugh's credibility with jurors

In their unanimous ruling Wednesday, the South Carolina Supreme Court said the behaviour by Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill “egregiously attacked Murdaugh’s credibility” by suggesting to jurors his grounds could not beryllium trusted.

A fewer jurors said Hill, assigned to oversee the grounds and the assemblage during the trial, told them to ticker Murdaugh's assemblage connection erstwhile helium testified successful his ain defence and to not beryllium fooled, confused oregon thrown disconnected by what helium mightiness say.

“By urging the jurors not to beryllium fooled oregon convinced by Murdaugh’s defense, Hill fundamentally implored the jurors to find him guilty, the eventual contented successful the case,” the justices wrote, adding that the comments insinuated determination was thing antithetic and suspicious astir his determination to testify.

Hill “placed her fingers connected the scales of justice, thereby denying Murdaugh his close to a just proceedings by an impartial jury,” the justices wrote. “Our justness strategy provides — so demands — that each idiosyncratic is entitled to a just trial."

The tribunal said Hill's information was the “siren telephone of celebrity” and her extremity was to summation income of her publication connected the proceedings called “Behind the Doors of Justice: The Murdaugh Murders.” It was pulled from work aft plagiarism allegations were made.

“As her book’s rubric suggests, it turns retired Hill was rather engaged down the doors of justice, thwarting the integrity of the justness strategy she was sworn to support and uphold,” the justices wrote successful an unsigned 27-page ruling.

Hill’s lawyer successful her transgression lawsuit didn’t instrumentality a telephone telephone oregon email seeking comment.

Hill has pleaded blameworthy to lying astir what she said and did during the Murdaugh trial, including showing graphic transgression country photos to respective media members. The journalists were not named and the photos were not described astatine her December hearing.

“The tribunal rightly described her behaviour arsenic "‘breathtaking,’ ‘disgraceful,’ and ‘unprecedented successful South Carolina,'” Murdaugh's lawyers said.

Prosecutors argued that the clerk’s comments were fleeting and the grounds against Murdaugh was overwhelming.

Justices accidental fiscal transgression grounds besides improperly used

The justices besides had a informing for the adjacent justice to effort the execution lawsuit — beryllium cautious connected however overmuch grounds of Murdaugh's thefts from his instrumentality steadfast and clients to let those jurors to hear.

Some little grounds of however Mudaugh stole is good and however it mightiness link to him sidesplitting his woman and son. But the tribunal said details similar however immoderate of the radical Murdaugh stole from were disabled oregon susceptible could unfairly crook against him jurors who should beryllium focused conscionable connected whether helium killed his family.

Investigators said Murdaugh was addicted to opioids and his analyzable schemes to bargain wealth from clients and his family’s instrumentality steadfast were starting to unravel erstwhile helium changeable his younger son, Paul, with a shotgun and his wife, Maggie, with a rifle, astatine their location successful Colleton County successful 2021.

Murdaugh told investigators helium hadn’t seen them for an hr oregon truthful earlier helium discovered their bodies, but his dependable was recorded successful a video connected his son’s telephone made astir 5 minutes earlier the killing.

The weapons utilized successful the killings person not been recovered and prosecutors did not contiguous immoderate apparel with DNA oregon humor evidence.

Copyright 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.