4 hours ago
6
VATICAN CITY – He called maine “la prima della classe,” oregon “the archetypal successful class.” It wasn’t needfully a compliment.
I had earned the nickname from Pope Francis successful 2018, a twelvemonth that marked a debased constituent in his papacy, and a turning constituent successful however helium handled cases of priests who sexually abused children.
The pope had conscionable bungled a large maltreatment lawsuit successful Chile and I, similar galore successful the Vatican property corps, reported the ungraded during Francis’ problematic travel to the South American country. Francis had discredited maltreatment victims, defended a bishop implicated successful covering up their lawsuit and showed himself to beryllium insensitive to their trauma.
A turbulent quality conference
Returning to Rome, Francis was inundated with questions about the Chile scandal during the accepted in-flight quality conference. Turbulence temporarily halted the session, but erstwhile it resumed, I picked up wherever others had near off, pressing the contented and incredulous that helium seemed truthful unaware of the victims' pain.
Francis insisted nary victims had travel guardant to impeach Bishop Juan Barros of protecting the abuser priest, Fernando Karadima. I knew otherwise, and told Francis arsenic overmuch successful a code of dependable that inactive shocks maine today.
“It's the victims who are saying this,” I told him.
“I haven’t heard from immoderate unfortunate of Barros,” Francis responded.
“There are! There are!” I insisted. The pope interrupted, but I chopped him off, my dependable rising. “No! There are victims of Karadima who accidental that Barros was there!”
“But they didn’t travel forward," Francis replied. "They didn’t springiness grounds for a judgment. You, with bully intentions, archer maine that determination are victims, but I haven’t seen them due to the fact that they didn’t contiguous themselves.”
By the genteel standards of Vatican protocol, it was a stunningly crisp exchange. Francis could person dug successful oregon retaliated against maine and different journalists who challenged him truthful publicly.
But helium didn’t. His effect — commissioning an probe and, erstwhile finished, apologizing to the victims for discrediting them — underscored what friends and foes alike saw arsenic 1 of Francis' astir singular attributes: a willingness to admit mistakes and alteration course.
In a 2023 interrogation with The Associated Press, Francis acknowledged the 2018 airborne quality league was a turning constituent — the infinitesimal helium understood the depths of the maltreatment scandal.
“I couldn’t judge it. You were the 1 connected the level who told me, ‘No, that’s not the mode it is, Father,’” Francis told me.
“That’s erstwhile the weaponry went off, erstwhile I saw the corruption of galore bishops successful this,” helium said, making a motion indicating his caput had exploded.
A nickname emerges
By then, Francis already had bestowed the nickname connected me, coming up with it successful August 2018, portion the Chilean ungraded was inactive fresh.
AP workfellow Eva Vergara and I had followed up with a communicative that Francis had so received a letter from a Chilean unfortunate detailing the maltreatment and cover-up helium endured.
Again aboard Air Pope One heading to Ireland, Francis came backmost to greet journalists. When helium got to my row, Francis smiled, shook my manus and said, “Ahh, la prima della classe. La prima della classe.”
I wondered what helium meant. In Italian it tin beryllium translated arsenic “the archetypal successful class.” But it tin besides transportation a antagonistic connotation: a know-it-all, goody-goody oregon teacher’s pet.
I saw the nickname arsenic Francis' grudging acknowledgement that AP and I had accurately called him retired and corrected him.
As reporters, we had to support a nonrecreational distance, covering him successful the pugnacious but just mode that met our standards and which was possibly down his respect for our work.
An evolving narration with the press
The nickname stuck, and Francis utilized it whenever we met. In galore ways, it showed however his narration with the property evolved implicit time.
When helium was elected, Francis made wide his discomfort with journalists. He had had antagonistic experiences successful Argentina, wherever his grounds arsenic caput of the Jesuits successful the 1970s during the subject dictatorship and his tenure arsenic Buenos Aires archbishop had enactment him successful the media crosshairs.
“Truly, I don’t springiness interviews. Why, I don’t know, it’s conscionable that way,” Francis told reporters traveling to Brazil successful 2013 for his archetypal overseas travel arsenic pope.
Over time, Francis loosened up and his airborne quality conferences became a caller section successful papal communication. His comments sometimes required authoritative clarifications, but they pushed the envelope successful ways helium couldn’t successful speeches oregon documents connected issues similar LGBTQ+ outreach oregon the relation of women successful the church.
Francis granted much interviews than his 2 predecessors combined, utilizing the media to talk to his flock successful the informal, idiosyncratic benignant that characterized his papacy.
A work-life dilemma arises
Our past substantive brushwood came successful January 2024, erstwhile reporters met with him successful the Apostolic Palace. At the time, I was acrophobic with an impending work-life conflict: My girl would beryllium starting assemblage successful precocious August and our household was readying to beryllium successful New England to be predisposition and determination her into her dorm.
At the aforesaid time, rumors were circulating that Francis would embark connected his longest, astir ambitious trip: a four-nation circuit of Asia that, successful each likelihood, would hap successful precocious August.
I couldn’t miss either.
At the extremity of the audience, Francis greeted the journalists individually. To this day, I cannot judge what I said, but I laid retired my dilemma, summoning some maternal desperation and nothing-to-lose chutzpah. Ever polite, Francis listened intently — helium often asked astir my children — arsenic I suggested, somewhat cheekily, that delaying the Asia travel would alteration maine to screen it.
Francis didn’t disregard it outright, and I figured I could astatine slightest archer my girl I had tried, knowing I'd inevitably person to archer her the Asia travel would instrumentality precedence.
A last surprise
Months later, to my astonishment, the day of the travel was announced: Sept. 2-13. I could bash both.
I didn’t situation deliberation my impromptu speech arsenic Francis met scores of journalists could person entered into the analyzable calculations of organizing a papal trip.
But I aboriginal received a breathless voicemail from idiosyncratic adjacent to Francis who had conscionable met with him. “You volition not judge what helium told me,“ helium said. The pope said helium changed the dates of the travel to guarantee I could come, helium said.
I inactive don’t cognize if different factors affected what became the past large overseas travel of Francis' life.
I'm grateful I was capable to go. I was a witnesser arsenic Francis, hobbled and successful a wheelchair, ministered to his flock successful Indonesia and Singapore, the jungles of Papua New Guinea and steamy East Timor, wherever fractional the colonisation attended his last Mass successful Dili.
On the agelong level thrust home, I wrote astir his resilience.
“There was Francis, defying the doubters who had questioned if helium could, would oregon should marque specified an arduous travel to Asia fixed everything that could spell wrong,” my communicative said. “The infinitesimal seemed to service arsenic impervious that, contempt his age, ailments and 7 hours of pitchy lag, Pope Francis inactive could pope, inactive likes to pope and has it successful him to pope similar helium utilized to astatine the commencement of his pontificate.”
I'd similar to deliberation helium mightiness person work it, knowing it came from “la prima della classe.”
___
Associated Press religion sum receives enactment done the AP’s collaboration with The Conversation US, with backing from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely liable for this content.
Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.
English (US) ·