"On Paper It Sounded Wrong, But...": People Are Sharing The Actors They Thought Were Miscast, But Ended Up Blowing Them Away

Sometimes a movie casting doesn't lucifer up with however you envisioned the quality successful your head...but past the actor's show ends up completely blowing you away. Recently, Reddit idiosyncratic u/gypsytx asked, "Who are immoderate actors who were miscast but inactive gave a large performance?" Here are immoderate of the actors radical thought weren't close for the role, but ended up wholly sidesplitting it:

Note: Some of these responses person been edited for magnitude and/or clarity.

1. "Bob Hoskins arsenic Eddie Valiant successful Who framed Roger Rabbit. On insubstantial it looked terrible, but helium is cleanable for that role."

Buena Vista Pictures/Courtesy Everett Collection

2. "Hugh Jackman arsenic Wolverine successful the X-Men films. He was the third choice and a past infinitesimal replacement for Dougray Scott, but helium made america judge a 6'2" Australian philharmonic theatre histrion was a 5'3" Canadian mutant."

Joe Pugliese / TV Guide / TM & Copyright 20th Century Fox Film Corp. / Courtesy Everett Collection

3. "I'm not definite if this is simply a blistery instrumentality oregon not, but I thought Jennifer Lawrence was terribly miscast arsenic Katniss Everdeen successful The Hunger Games. She was excessively mature-looking, excessively pretty, and thing similar the scrawny, scrappy small teen Katniss is described as. That said, she’s a large histrion and gave an awesome performance."

4. "Michael Keaton arsenic Batman. It was specified an unusual prime astatine the time, and yet helium became the modular that each different Batmen are compared to."

5. "The screenwriter for My Cousin Vinny originally envisioned Vinny arsenic a six-foot-something ex-boxer. He was skeptical astir casting Joe Pesci astatine first, but a mates of months later, Goodfellas came retired and helium was sold."

6. "Keanu Reeves arsenic Constantine successful Constantine. He was thing astatine each similar the comics version, but helium sold the role. I emotion that movie."

7. "Michael Cera was specified a unusual prime for Scott Pilgrim successful Scott Pilgrim vs. the World, and I couldn’t ideate him being the lead. But goddamn, helium worked it. It's 1 of my apical 5 movies ever."

8. "Barbra Streisand was greatly miscast successful the relation of Dolly successful Hello, Dolly!. The quality is expected to beryllium an older, extravagant matchmaker. But Barbara is truthful talented passim the movie that you inactive emotion her performance."

9. "Alan Rickman arsenic Severus Snape successful the Harry Potter movies. He was excessively aged for the relation and ne'er genuinely felt menacing, but damn, helium was good."

10. "Emma Watson arsenic Hermione successful the Harry Potter movies. In the books, Hermione is chubby and has subordinate teeth. As a miss who was besides chubby with subordinate teeth (and a spot of a know-it-all similar Hermione arsenic well), I felt seen erstwhile I work the books. When I recovered retired they'd formed a bladed miss with normal-looking teeth, I was truthful disappointed! But the infinitesimal Emma Watson was connected screen, I had to admit, she wholly nailed Hermione's personality."

11. "Tom Cruise successful Interview with the Vampire is the archetypal 1 that comes to mind. On insubstantial it sounded wrong, but helium truly won radical over."

12. "Daniel Craig arsenic James Bond. He's not 'traditionally handsome,' he's excessively short, and helium has the incorrect physique and hairsbreadth color. There was a bully crushed determination was immoderate outcry erstwhile helium was announced, but his show successful Casino Royale was excellent. He carries himself similar Bond contempt the above."

13. "Rami Malek arsenic Freddie Mercury successful Bohemian Rhapsody. Rami came in, wholly rocked it, and won an Oscar. He played a much despondent mentation of what I imagined Freddie to be, but dues wherever dues are due. He gave a large performance."

14. "Naomi Scott was a small excessively aged to play Jasmine successful Aladdin (2019), but she truly did well. I was precise skeptical erstwhile I archetypal watched it, but it’s go 1 of the lone live-action movies I like."

15. "If you had told maine that Tom Hanks was going to beryllium formed arsenic Forrest Gump earlier the movie was made, I would person been surprised."

16. "Daniel Kaluuya successful Judas and the Black Messiah. He was astir 10 years older than Fred Hampton erstwhile helium died, and 1 of the astir astonishing and tragic things astir Hampton was his youth. But I deliberation helium gave a large performance."

17. "Charlize Theron arsenic Aileen Wuornos successful Monster. There's nary mode anyone could person known she could bash that."

18. "Heath Ledger arsenic the Joker successful The Dark Knight has to beryllium the astir evident choice. Nobody thought helium was a bully acceptable — tabloids and quality articles adjacent complained astir his casting — then, they saw the movie."

19. And lastly: "Steve Buscemi arsenic Romero successful Spy Kids. That is an Oscar-worthy performance."

Who's an histrion you thought was miscast, but ended up sidesplitting it successful the role? Tell america successful the comments! Or, if you'd similar to enactment anonymous, usage the signifier below.