Man charged in Utah killings wanted victims' cars and money to get home, prosecutors allege

TORREY, Utah (AP) — Two men whose wives did not instrumentality from a hike successful Utah's south-central godforsaken arrived astatine the trailhead Wednesday to find some women dormant and a car missing, spurring a multi-state hunt that led investigators to a 3rd assemblage earlier they arrested a fishy Thursday successful Colorado.

An Iowa antheral has been charged with aggravated execution successful the deaths of the 2 hikers and a 3rd pistillate authorities accidental helium killed wrong her location aft helium spent a nighttime successful a shed connected her property. There was nary denotation that the antheral had immoderate transportation to the victims, said Lt. Cameron Roden of the Utah Department of Public Safety.

Ivan Miller, 22, told investigators aft his apprehension that helium killed the 3 women to bargain their cars and recognition cards due to the fact that helium needed wealth to get backmost to Iowa, charging documents show. He had deed an elk a fewer days earlier successful a tiny Utah farming municipality adjacent Capitol Reef National Park and was without a conveyance aft selling his motortruck to the tow company.

After staying successful hotels for a fewer days, Miller slept successful the woman's shed. He stole her Buick aft shooting her from down portion she was watching TV, Wayne County prosecutors allege.

Miller, of Blakesburg, Iowa, told authorities that helium rapidly realized helium did not similar the Buick and wanted a antithetic vehicle, according to tribunal documents. He parked it astatine a trailhead astir 10 miles (16 kilometers) from the archetypal victim's home, saw 2 women get retired of a Subaru and killed them earlier taking the car, the documents state. He attempted to conceal their bodies successful a adust creek bed, prosecutors allege.

The husbands called 911 and waved down a ranger aft uncovering their wives changeable and stabbed astatine the trail, which is utilized mostly by locals and partially shielded from the roadworthy by piñon and juniper trees, according to officials and tribunal documents.

Officials identified the hikers arsenic aunt and niece Linda Dewey, 65, and Natalie Graves, 34, and the pistillate killed successful her location arsenic Margaret Oldroyd, 86. The hikers had nary known transportation to Oldroyd.

Victim remembered arsenic ‘the sweetest woman’

Authorities recovered Oldroyd's assemblage successful a cellar nether a shed connected her spot aft identifying the proprietor of the stolen Buick near astatine the trailhead, according to tribunal documents.

Police utilized yellowish portion to cordon disconnected the ceramic location successful Lyman and an outbuilding portion investigators gathered grounds Thursday.

Oldroyd's next-door neighbour of 20 years, Randy Jones, described her arsenic “the sweetest pistillate you’d ever meet” and said helium was shocked by her death.

Oldroyd had a emotion of gait work, ever keeping her flowers and tract watered and neatly manicured. She utilized to enactment astatine a section market store stocking shelves, Jones said. And erstwhile Jones helped escaped her gait of skunks, she’d bring him a barroom arsenic a convey you.

“Out present successful agrarian counties, we each instrumentality attraction of each other," Jones said.

In caller years, helium didn't spot his neighbour permission location overmuch but to be spiritual services and prime up groceries. But each present and then, she would travel implicit to Jones’ house, beryllium with him and sojourn his horses.

Suspect tracked crossed authorities lines

Investigators person not recovered a motive for the killings and bash not judge the fishy targeted the women for immoderate crushed different than “convenience,” Roden said. Investigators were inactive looking into erstwhile Miller arrived successful Utah and what helium was doing anterior to the killings.

Authorities utilized licence sheet readers and conveyance tracking services to travel Miller's path, from Utah done bluish Arizona and into the upland municipality of Pagosa Springs successful southwestern Colorado, wherever helium abandoned the stolen vehicle, Roden said. He was recovered aft a abbreviated search.

According to online jailhouse records, Miller was being held connected suspicion of carrying a concealed weapon, a misdemeanor. He was arrested successful Colorado with a ample weapon and a .45 caliber pistol, according to tribunal documents, and was scheduled to marque his archetypal tribunal quality successful the authorities Friday afternoon.

Miller is being represented astatine the proceeding by the Colorado Public Defender’s office, said Justin Bogan, who heads the bureau successful the judicial territory that covers Pagosa Springs. Bogan declined to remark further. Voicemail messages near astatine listings for imaginable relatives of Miller were not instantly returned connected Thursday.

Authorities were moving to bring Miller to Utah to look the execution charges.

The Associated Press near a connection for the nationalist defender's bureau successful Utah precocious Thursday afternoon.

Before a fishy was successful custody, Wayne County residents were asked to stay vigilant and schools were closed Thursday. Officials asked for assistance uncovering a achromatic Subaru Outback but warned radical not to attack it.

___

Slevin reported from Denver, Schoenbaum from Salt Lake City and Brumfield from Cockeysville, Maryland.

Copyright 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.