Looking back at Pope Francis' impact on the Catholic Church

CBS News Live

CBS News 24/7 Live

Rome — He was a populist leader, often referred to arsenic the "People's Pope." As pontiff, Francis, who died Monday astatine property 88, sought to bring the Church person to the people, stating aboriginal successful his papacy that helium wanted to person a poorer Church "for the poor." He was known for being driven astir successful unflashy cars and for making folksy gestures, similar taking trips into Rome to bargain an point astatine the store.

He was superb astatine playing to the press, creating the sorts of photo-ops that would gully attraction to his areas of interest. He'd often talk extemporaneously portion connected papal voyages, peculiarly toward the opening of his papacy, fielding questions connected the flight. 

That made his papal trips a must-attend lawsuit for the property covering him. For those of america who got to question with Pope Francis, we could spot however he'd interact implicit the people of days with assorted dignitaries and his wider flock of the faithful. He'd look peculiarly energized and engaged, lighting up erstwhile with children oregon successful an assemblage with those who were formed aside, surviving connected the margins of society.

He died conscionable a time aft astonishing galore with a brief quality successful St. Peter's Square connected Easter Sunday, blessing thousands of radical and sounding stronger arsenic helium did truthful than helium had since his merchandise from a Rome infirmary astatine the extremity of March. 

Pope Francis offers a blessing from the balcony of St. Peter's Basilica astatine the Vatican connected Easter Sunday, April 20, 2024 Stefano Spaziani/Europa Press via Getty Images

We wanted to look back connected his papacy, his legacy, and besides look guardant to the adjacent pope, truthful we asked seasoned Vatican analogous Francis X. Rocca to conscionable precocious connected the terrace of a convent successful Rome, with a spectacular presumption retired implicit St. Peter's Basilica, for a chat astir Francis.

We look back, and ahead. Below is simply a partial transcript from our conversation, which has been edited for clarity.

SETH DOANE: What is Pope Francis' legacy?

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Well, I accidental it depends connected whom you ask. I mean, for women, for example, helium surely was idiosyncratic who brought women successful the Vatican, and gave them higher positions than had ever been the case. It's inactive a comparatively tiny number, but that was surely a precise melodramatic change. For conservatives, helium started by giving them heartburn and ended up by giving practically a bosom attack. It was rather a melodramatic confrontation. In immoderate ways was a polarizing pope. At the aforesaid clip that helium truly pushed the envelope and allowed things to beryllium spoken astir that had been considered closed, whether connected intersexual ethics, connected aesculapian ethics. … In a way, due to the fact that of his precise informal benignant of discourse, talking to journalists, giving interviews, property conferences, helium seemed to springiness support to radical to knock him, too, adjacent if that wasn't his intention. So the statement became overmuch much heated during his pontificate.

SETH DOANE: Why was Pope Francis seen arsenic specified a divisive figure? Why did conservatives dislike him?

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Well, I deliberation determination were a fig of reasons. One is that helium had a very  escaped cognition toward tradition, let's enactment it that way. From the precise beginning, erstwhile helium stepped retired connected the loggia successful the beforehand of St. Peter's Basilica, and helium didn't deterioration the reddish cape that was customary connected that juncture — earlier helium adjacent said a word, already radical started to get nervous, conservatives started to get tense that helium was conscionable not going to respect tradition.

Pope Francis delivers his archetypal "Urbi et Orbi" connection ("to the metropolis and the world") from the cardinal loggia of St. Peter's Basilica astatine the Vatican connected Dec. 25, 2013. Alessandra Benedetti/Corbis via Getty Images

And helium broke it successful tiny ways similar that, but helium besides tested it successful bigger ways. And, for example, comparatively precocious successful his pontificate, gave permission for the blessings of same-sex couples. They tried to contiguous that arsenic thing that was accordant with tradition, but it surely wasn't seen that mode by conservatives. And particularly successful Africa, wherever fundamentally each the bishops of sub-Saharan Africa protested and wanted a benignant of exemption from this caller permission, which is extraordinary. And that's conscionable a precise wide illustration however divisive things became, erstwhile you person an full continent — a continent wherever the Church is increasing precise rapidly — taking a wholly antithetic basal from different parts of the Church. That happened nether Pope Francis, and it happened due to the fact that helium made a bold move.

SETH DOANE: Conservative Catholics successful America were immoderate of his loudest critics.

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Yes, that's right. He had a the bulk of the U.S. bishops were not connected committee with his priorities, I deliberation that's beauteous clear. The pope and his allies among the U.S. bishops, who are a minority, wanted to play down abortion. The pope hated abortion, but helium wanted to play [it] down, with respect to societal and biology and economical issues, oregon astatine slightest enactment them connected an adjacent plane. That's possibly the amended mode to enactment it. The U.S. bishops person for years said that absorption to termination is their "preeminent priority." And the pope and his allies didn't privation that, and they weren't capable to transportation the bulk of U.S. bishops astir that, and that became a very, precise large constituent of tension.

SETH DOANE: We traveled with the pope together. One of the things that struck maine was however helium was with kids — helium would benignant of travel live successful a way.

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: He was precise approachable. He was precise informal. That was the — 1 of the beguiling, charming things, charismatic things astir him. His predecessors are — John Paul was a precise charismatic figure, precise telegenic, but helium was not truthful relaxed. And Pope Francis had an mean benignant that appealed to people.

SETH DOANE: Pope Francis was known arsenic the "People's Pope." He was known to scope retired to effort to propulsion successful the masses.

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Yeah. He was besides a populist pope, with a benignant of governmental resonance. His benignant was precise overmuch to effort to person a enslaved with the people, with — implicitly oregon sometimes not truthful implicitly, against the elites, successful this case, the hierarchy: the bishops and the cardinals. He benignant of played disconnected of them. And helium was ever benignant of suggesting that the elites, adjacent the Diocesan clergy priests and parish priests, could beryllium aloof from their people, could beryllium excessively rigid, could beryllium excessively attached to luxury oregon to privilege. And truthful helium was ever beating that drum and saying, "No. I'm with the people."

SETH DOANE: This pope tried to tackle intersexual maltreatment issues wrong the clergy, wrong the Church. He tried to tackle the immense bureaucracy and economical issues successful the Church. How did helium do?

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Well, I — his grounds connected enactment maltreatment was mixed. And I deliberation really not up to the level that radical had expected of him. He had a benignant of a distaste for disciplining the priests and bishops compared with his predecessor, Pope Benedict. Pope Benedict the precocious h2o people successful presumption of subject of abusive clergy. Pope Francis stepped backmost a spot from that. He got successful occupation for that successful Chile, erstwhile helium was precise stubbornly supportive of a bishop who'd been accused of covering up enactment abuse. He yet backed down, but it was an embarrassment.

SETH DOANE: What were immoderate of the large issues nether Pope Francis' papacy?

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Well, surely a large contented was his comparative leniency connected questions of marriage, the family, and sexuality. The azygous astir celebrated connection from his pontificate was the 1 helium made astatine his precise archetypal property league successful 2013, which was, "Who americium I to judge?" He was talking, successful that case, astir cheery priests. But helium could person been talking astir divorced Catholics, whom helium allowed to instrumentality communion, successful galore cases, which had not been the signifier before. He could person been talking astir Catholics who usage contraception. Pope Francis didn't alteration teaching formally connected immoderate of these issues. But what helium did was awesome that it was OK to person antithetic points of presumption astir them, that it was not a precedence — that helium was not censuring anyone. And, successful fact, immoderate of his advisors present explored, for example, the anticipation of relaxing the prohibition connected contraception that had been truthful arguable since Pope Paul VI had reaffirmed it successful 1968. So those are immoderate issues. 

Another issue: He had a rapprochement with China, which was controversial, adjacent among Chinese Catholics, wherever helium … agreed to stock work for choosing Catholic bishops successful China with the Communist authorities there. And that was controversial. He felt that it was important to person dialog and to support the Church unified astatine immoderate level, but a batch of the Catholics who resisted authorities power successful China resented that and felt that helium was selling them out.

SETH DOANE: One of the regular criticisms of this pope was that helium sowed confusion. Why was that heard truthful often?

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Well, helium played with ambiguity. A batch of his connection were made successful an informal mode astatine property conferences and successful interviews, not successful doctrinal documents that came retired from the Vatican. And truthful so he, you know, erstwhile helium says, "Who americium I to judge?" — well, what does that mean? Conservatives tried precise hard to work that successful a mode precise accordant with strict tradition. And you could if you wished. But the pope was precise media savvy. He knew however his comments would play. He knew however his soundbites and headlines would play, and truthful erstwhile helium made a connection similar that, helium knew that astir radical would work that arsenic meaning that intersexual morality, oregon astatine slightest successful that case, was a substance of conscience, that radical could travel their ain conscience. That's not explicitly what helium said, but erstwhile helium said, "Who americium I to judge?" helium seemed to beryllium saying, "This is simply a backstage affair, this is idiosyncratic with his ain conscience." And that's however galore radical work it, adjacent if helium didn't explicitly accidental that.

SETH DOANE: During his papacy, Pope Francis changed the feeling of the Church. You saw him driving astir successful elemental cars, sometimes going retired into Rome to bargain thing astatine a store. The feeling of who a pope is changed adjacent successful wherever helium decided to live, astatine the Santa Marta Hotel, and not successful the Apostolic Palace.

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Yeah, that's right, adjacent wearing, you know, mean achromatic shoes, oregon having his Argentinian passport renewed, wearing the achromatic skull headdress successful the photo. That's true: He was decidedly precise deliberate. He wanted to marque the pope look much with the people, and to propulsion down immoderate of the barriers. And that's wherefore helium had a precise tactile, approachable style. It volition beryllium absorbing to spot if his successor feels the request to support that, oregon volition spell backmost to thing much accepted and much formal.

SETH DOANE: In the agelong arc of the Church's history, however overmuch volition Francis' papacy truly person changed?

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Well, the agelong march of papal past is precise agelong indeed. One happening is helium was the archetypal pope from the Americas, and the archetypal pope from the Global South. So he'll ever person a spot successful the past books for that reason. Beyond that, it depends connected what happens next. I mean, if the adjacent pope is going to transportation guardant his progressive approach, and if that's going to proceed and alteration the Church, and Church teaching is going to alteration connected things similar women's ordination, you know, oregon homosexuality, if it's really going to change, past helium volition beryllium a historical fig successful that respect. If we spell backmost to thing much traditional, past that volition beryllium a benignant of an anomaly. But helium volition stay successful the past books due to the fact that of wherever he's from.

SETH DOANE: Looking up to the adjacent pope, did Pope Francis, if you will, "stack the decks" capable that the College of Cardinals is apt to spell with a much progressive, much wide pope? Or does the pendulum plaything the different way? 

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Well, that's ever the large question. Certainly Pope Francis was notable,  and adjacent immoderate of his supporters admit this, successful not choosing radical who didn't hold with him arsenic cardinals. He tended to take radical similar that. On the different hand, helium chose a batch of radical from far-flung regions, from places that had ne'er had a cardinal before, astir whom we cognize precise little, and astir apt Pope Francis didn't cognize precise overmuch either. So that's a spot of a chaotic card. There's besides the contented that cardinals thin to beryllium beauteous blimpish radical — "conservative" with a tiny "c." They thin to privation not to stone the vessel excessively much, and Pope Francis rocked the vessel continually.

SETH DOANE: We could spot a much blimpish pope next?

FRANCIS X. ROCCA: Certainly it's precise imaginable that we'll spot a pope with a much blimpish temperament, a much blimpish governing style, a much blimpish communicative style. Maybe not a hard-right conservative, successful presumption of doctrine, we mightiness not get that. But we mightiness get idiosyncratic who's going to — the College of Cardinals wants to calm the waters. It's been a precise turbulent play nether Pope Francis, and truthful they mightiness privation idiosyncratic who volition conscionable not talk rather truthful often to the press, not disturbance things up, not shingle things up for a while. We could beryllium looking astatine that.

In:
• Pope Francis
• Vatican City
• Catholic Church