Intelligence Memo Undercuts Trump’s Immigration Argument

Este artículo estará disponible en español en El Tiempo Latino.

When the Washington Post reported via anonymous sources that a authorities quality appraisal concluded the Venezuelan authorities was not directing the migration of members of the Trenreport de Aragua pack to the United States, Tulsi Gabbard, the manager of nationalist intelligence, dismissed specified reports and said those “behind this amerciable leak of classified intelligence” had “twisted and manipulated [the information] to convey the nonstop other finding.”

But a redacted transcript of the quality memo shows that the Washington Post’s reporting was accurate. 

The April 7 quality appraisal broadly concluded that Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro’s “regime astir apt does not person a argumentation of cooperating with TDA and is not directing TDA question to and operations successful the United States.”

The six-page memo from the National Intelligence Council, “Venezuela: Examining Regime Ties to Tren de Aragua,” was released by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence connected May 5 successful effect to a Freedom of Information Act petition from the Freedom of the Press Foundation. The instauration provided america a copy of that memo.

The conclusions successful the National Intelligence Council memo — the shared appraisal of 18 U.S. quality organizations — undercut the ground for President Donald Trump’s March 15 invocation of the Alien Enemies Act to summarily deport Venezuelan immigrants suspected of affiliation with Tren de Aragua. In that proclamation, the Trump medication argued that TdA is “conducting irregular warfare” successful the U.S. and operating “in conjunction” with the Maduro regime, and successful enactment of “the Maduro regime’s extremity of destabilizing antiauthoritarian nations successful the Americas, including the United States.”

As we person written, the Alien Enemies Act is an 18th century instrumentality that says that successful times of warfare oregon during an “invasion oregon predatory incursion … by immoderate overseas federation oregon government,” the president tin apprehend, restrain, unafraid and region immoderate immigrants who came from the force country.

Trump’s usage of the Alien Enemies Act hinges connected 2 assertions: that TdA is “perpetrating, attempting, and threatening an penetration oregon predatory incursion against the territory of the United States” and that it is acting “at the direction, clandestine oregon otherwise, of the Maduro authorities successful Venezuela.”

As we said, the National Intelligence Council memorandum broadly contradicted that 2nd statement.

What the Memo Says

According to the NIC memo, “While Venezuela’s permissive situation enables TDA to operate, the Maduro authorities astir apt does not person a argumentation of cooperating with TDA and is not directing TDA question to and operations successful the United States.”

The NIC memo listed respective reasons for its conclusion.

First, it said, “Venezuelan intelligence, military, and constabulary services presumption TDA arsenic a information menace and run against it successful ways that marque it highly improbable the 2 sides would cooperate successful a strategical oregon accordant way.” The memo noted that successful precocious January, “at slightest 2 Venezuelan National Guard units arrested TDA members successful Venezuela successful abstracted operations.”

The memo further noted — citing property reports and redacted sources — that “[s]ince astatine slightest 2016, Venezuelan information forces person periodically engaged successful equipped confrontations with TDA, resulting successful the sidesplitting of immoderate TDA members.”

The memo stated that the quality assemblage “has not observed the authorities directing TDA, including to propulsion migrants to the United States, which astir apt would necessitate extended coordination, and backing betwixt authorities entities and TDA leaders that we would collect.” The memo stated that “the decentralized constitution of TDA … would marque specified a narration logistically challenging.” The memo besides noted that the IC “recognizes the authorities appreciates migration arsenic a information valve, allowing discontented Venezuelans to leave.”

In her April 21 social media post criticizing property reports astir the past unreleased memo, Gabbard contradicted those assessments, saying, “The Office of the Director of National Intelligence afloat supports the appraisal that the overseas violent organization, Tren De Aragua, is acting with the enactment of the Maduro Regime, and frankincense taxable to arrest, detention and removal arsenic alien enemies of the United States.”

“Illegal migrant criminals person raped, tortured, and murdered Americans, and still, the propaganda media continues to run arsenic apologists for them,” Gabbard said successful a released statement. “It is outrageous that arsenic President Trump and his medication enactment hard each time to marque America harmless by deporting these convulsive criminals, immoderate successful the media stay intent connected twisting and manipulating quality assessments to undermine the President’s docket to support the American radical safe.”

But the released NIC memo shows the media reports were not twisting the quality assessments. As the Washington Post reported connected April 17, “The quality merchandise recovered that though determination are immoderate low-level contacts betwixt the Maduro authorities and Tren de Aragua, oregon TdA, the pack does not run astatine the absorption of Venezuela’s leader. The merchandise builds connected U.S. quality findings successful February, archetypal reported by the New York Times, that the pack is not controlled by Venezuela.”

The FBI’s Position

The FBI was the lone bureau among the 18 U.S. quality organizations connected the National Intelligence Council that offered partial dissent. (Other NIC organizations see the CIA, the 5 Department of Defense equipped services, the Department of Homeland Security’s Office of Intelligence, and the Department of State’s Bureau of Intelligence and Research.)

According to the memo, “While FBI analysts hold with the supra assessment, they measure some Venezuelan authorities officials facilitate TDA members’ migration from Venezuela to the United States and usage members arsenic proxies successful Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, and the United States to beforehand what they spot arsenic the Maduro regime’s extremity of destabilizing governments and undermining nationalist information successful these countries, based connected DHS [Department of Homeland Security] and FBI reporting arsenic of February 2024.” (The italics are the memo’s emphasis.)

On April 23, Fox News Digital said it talked to an unnamed “senior medication official” who shared unclassified portions of an FBI study successful which “[t]he FBI assesses that successful the adjacent six to 18 months, Venezuelan authorities officials apt volition effort to leverage Tren de Aragua members successful the United States arsenic proxy actors to threaten, abduct and termination members of the Venezuelan diaspora successful the United States who are vocal critics of Maduro and his regime.”

In a code successful Michigan connected April 29, Trump referenced that report, saying, “The FBI precocious assessed that these vicious gangs person been sent by the overseas authorities successful Venezuela to foment unit and instability successful the United States of America.”

The NIC memo, however, said that “most of the IC” has concluded that “intelligence indicating that authorities leaders are directing oregon enabling TDA migration to the United States is not credible.”

“Some authorities officials are astir apt consenting to capitalize connected migration for idiosyncratic fiscal oregon different benefits, adjacent though the Maduro authorities astir apt is not systematically directing Venezuelan outflows, specified arsenic to sow chaos successful receiving countries,” the NIC memo stated. “The quality grounds indicates Venezuelans person migrated voluntarily, often astatine large idiosyncratic risk, to fly governmental instability and near-collapse of Venezuela’s economy. The IC attributes accrued migration flows, including the spike successful US arrivals from 2021 to 2024 of Venezuelan nationals –which could see immoderate TDA members — to a assortment of propulsion and propulsion factors including socioeconomic conditions, household ties to the United States, and migrants’ perceptions of US and determination enforcement.”

But the NIC said that portion Maduro whitethorn not person been directing the migration of Venezuelans, neither has helium sought to stem it, saying that migration “helped him clasp powerfulness by having dissidents permission the country.”

“The Maduro authorities whitethorn person besides welcomed the logistical, financial, and governmental headaches that unregulated migration has caused for the US Government, its perceived main adversary, adjacent if not a main intent,” the memo stated.

Even successful cases of “limited IC reporting suggesting a nexus betwixt TDA and immoderate Venezuelan officials aimed astatine facilitating TDA migration to the United States,” the memo noted that “in immoderate cases, reporting warns that these sources could besides beryllium motivated to fabricate information.”

An authoritative successful Gabbard’s ODNI, however, said there’s crushed to enactment much credence successful the FBI quality than the appraisal from the umbrella National Intelligence Council. The FBI appraisal is based connected its home instrumentality enforcement operations against TdA successful the U.S., an ODNI authoritative told us. “This accusation and quality are the astir robust and close fixed their absorption connected home information and crimes, versus constricted quality assessments from different quality elements who by instrumentality absorption solely connected overseas quality collection, and who until President Trump took office, had precise constricted resources focused connected TdA,” the authoritative said.

The ODNI authoritative argued that the Venezuelan authorities is “aiding and abetting” TdA by creating conditions successful the state that alteration it to thrive — overmuch the aforesaid mode that the Taliban authorities successful Afghanistan was providing sanctuary to al Qaeda, and thereby enabling al Qaeda to transportation retired its Sept. 11, 2001, onslaught successful the U.S. The authoritative besides pointed to comments that José Gustavo Arocha, a erstwhile lieutenant colonel successful the Venezuelan army, made to Fox News Digital successful December. Arocha said that TdA is “a state-sponsored Maduro authorities organization. The existent brag of the Tren de Aragua is successful Caracas, Venezuela. It is the Maduro regime, due to the fact that they created TdA, and they usage the TdA arsenic a blackmail [tool] for immoderate situation.”

The NIC memo acknowledged, “The deficiency of transparency and accountability successful Venezuela has created an situation for wide corruption and for authorities officials to payment from a assortment of illicit activities, an situation fueled by Maduro’s illegitimate and autocratic grip connected power. This persistent outflow of migrants astir apt offers opportunities for immoderate authorities officials successful capacities to facilitate migration question to look for and person idiosyncratic kickbacks for their services, and to conceal the benefits they receive.”

The memo noted that U.S. instrumentality enforcement reports assertion members of the authorities “have cooperated with TDA by providing fiscal oregon worldly support, but we cannot verify the sources’ access. Even so, these reports bash not assertion that these figures nonstop the group.”

And, the NIC memo warned, “Some reports travel from radical detained for engagement successful transgression enactment successful the United States oregon for entering the state illegally, which could motivate them to marque mendacious allegations astir their ties to the Venezuelan authorities successful an effort to deflect work for their crimes and to lessen punishment by providing exculpatory oregon different ‘valuable’ accusation to US prosecutors.”

Courts connected Use of Alien Enemies Act

The question of whether the Maduro authorities successful Venezuela is coordinating with TdA is cardinal to the Trump administration’s statement for invoking the Alien Enemies Act successful bid to — arsenic Trump enactment it — “expel each overseas violent from our ungraded arsenic rapidly arsenic possible.” As we said, the enactment pertains to times of warfare oregon an “invasion” by a “foreign federation oregon government.”

The enactment has been utilized 3 times successful U.S. history, during the War of 1812, World War I and World War II.

In his March 15 proclamation invoking the Alien Enemies Act, Trump declared that “TdA is perpetrating, attempting, and threatening an penetration oregon predatory incursion against the territory of the United States. TdA is undertaking hostile actions and conducting irregular warfare against the territory of the United States some straight and astatine the direction, clandestine oregon otherwise, of the Maduro authorities successful Venezuela.” And arsenic a result, the proclamation said, “all Venezuelan citizens 14 years of property oregon older who are members of TdA, are wrong the United States, and are not really naturalized oregon lawful imperishable residents of the United States are liable to beryllium apprehended, restrained, secured, and removed arsenic Alien Enemies.”

Trump invoked the enactment successful March to summarily deport 238 Venezuelan migrants alleged to beryllium members of TdA, who were past sent to a mega situation successful El Salvador. But the New York Times found nary grounds that a immense bulk of the men had immoderate transportation to Tren de Aragua.

Some national judges person ruled that the medication can’t usage the Alien Enemies Act successful this way.

On May 1, a national territory justice successful Texas — who was appointed by Trump — concluded that Trump had improperly applied the Alien Enemies Act.

“[T]he humanities grounds renders wide that the President’s invocation of the AEA done the Proclamation exceeds the scope of the statute and is contrary to the plain, mean meaning of the statute’s terms,” U.S. District Judge Fernando Rodriguez Jr. wrote. “As a result, the Court concludes that arsenic a substance of law, the Executive Branch cannot trust connected the AEA, based connected the Proclamation, to detain the Named Petitioners and the certified class, oregon to region them from the country.”

In akin cases successful different states, 2 much national judges person since concurred.

“Since Respondents person not demonstrated the beingness of a ‘war,’ ‘invasion’ oregon ‘predatory incursion,’ the AEA was not validly invoked by the Presidential Proclamation,” Judge Alvin Hellerstein, a national justice successful the Southern District of New York who was appointed by President Bill Clinton, wrote successful a May 6 ruling.

“Petitioners person not been fixed announcement of what they allegedly did to articulation TdA, erstwhile they joined, and what they did successful the United States, oregon anyplace else, to stock oregon further the illicit objectives of the TdA,” Hellerstein wrote. “Without specified proof, Petitioners are taxable to removal by the Executive’s dictate alone, successful contravention of the AEA and the Constitutional requirements of owed process.”

The aforesaid day, a national territory justice successful Colorado, an appointee of President Joe Biden, said she recovered “unpersuasive” the Trump administration’s explanation of “invasion” to broadly see “hostile entrance,” oregon “hostile encroachment.” U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney said she agreed the connection “invasion” meant subject enactment against the U.S.

These decisions tin each beryllium appealed by the Trump administration, and the question of whether the president tin usage the Alien Enemies Act may yet extremity up earlier the Supreme Court.

---

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station Intelligence Memo Undercuts Trump’s Immigration Argument appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.