I Tried And Ranked Sushi From Five Popular Grocery Stores – Here Are My Honest Thoughts

Hi! I'm Remy, and I person been fortunate successful my beingness to person eaten ungodly amounts of sushi. Nice restaurants and delis, prepared and homemade, adjacent successful coastal and landlocked states. It's harmless to say, I cognize my fish.

So, erstwhile Wegman's opened a monolithic market store successful Lower Manhattan 2 years ago, with a specialized "Sakanaya" sushi antagonistic and concern with Japan's premier fishmongers, I was disproportionately excited. I had fresh, inexpensive, ready-made sushi astatine my fingertips whenever I ran retired of milk. I person since go borderline addicted to their tuna tataki.

However, due to the fact that I americium adjacent to respective fashionable market stores, I precocious acceptable retired to comparison and complaint the pre-packaged sushi astatine 5 antithetic stores successful and astir the metropolis to spot who's doing it best.

I tried Wegman's due to the fact that duh; Whole Foods and H Mart due to the fact that they are nationally fashionable and known for having sushi; Stop & Shop due to the fact that it's a regionally popular, modular market store; and Trader Joe's due to the fact that we're each successful the TJ's cult and I person a work to the people. I compared salmon-based rolls from each spot and rated each rotation retired of five.

The archetypal 4 stores had plain salmon-avocado oregon salmon-avocado-cucumber rolls, but Trader Joe's lone had a spicy salmon-cucumber roll.

I based my standing connected 4 nonsubjective elements: wide price, pieces per package, terms per piece, and weight. I besides based my standing connected 4 subjective elements: rice/salmon/veggie ratio, atom gumminess, food taste, and whether it had that heavy, vinegar preservation taste.

Grocery stores adhd much atom vinegar to their atom than restaurants bash to forestall spoilage, which keeps the sushi fresher for longer but gives it a weird, preserved taste.

I besides added a bonus fractional constituent if they provided capable soy condiment and ginger (I can't devour Wasabi, different that would beryllium included too!).

Here's however they ranked, from worst to best:

Everything astir this depressed me. I cognize that TJ's lone sells pre-packaged sushi, truthful I wasn't expecting much, and was STILL fto down. Wild. This was the spicy salmon-cucumber roll, and I hardly tasted immoderate fish! It did marque bully connected the committedness of spicy, but if I hadn't seen the salmon with my ain eyeballs, I genuinely would've assumed this was a spicy cucumber roll. What I could sensation of the food was fine? I think? I dissected a portion to effort the salmon connected its own, and each I got was a vague fishiness. It was similar idiosyncratic whispered "fish" successful my receptor portion I was eating.

It came arsenic nary astonishment that the atom was precise gummy, lone made worse by however MUCH atom determination was. I virtually peeled fractional of it off, and inactive had excessively much. I consciousness weirdly deceived due to the fact that it looks similar there's a bully magnitude of salmon and cucumber. Alas, I was mistaken, and the rice/salmon/cucumber ratio was each retired of order. It besides lone came with 1 azygous tiny soy condiment packet that was not astir capable for the partition of rice, and a tiny ginger packet that was weirdly slimy and tasted artificial, truthful nary redeeming grace determination either.

Overall, this rotation tasted adequately spicy, vaguely fishy, and decidedly preserved. I volition not beryllium eating Trader Joe's sushi again, and mean to glare astatine the rolls adjacent clip I'm wandering past the prepared meals section.

Trader Joe's was priced astatine $6.99 for 9 pieces of fish, which comes to $0.78 per portion (which isn't surprising, since it's fundamentally conscionable rice). Although they person the cheapest full and portion price, you'll person a amended acquisition by buying their canned tuna and seaweed snacks for $5.98 full and DIY-ing it.

If Trader Joe's had nary fish, Stop & Shop had ALL the fish. The elephantine chunks of salmon looked promising but were a spot off-color, which was decidedly daunting. I persevered, and it was...not truly worthy it. It was somewhat tough, with a fishy finish. I didn't adjacent dissect 1 of the pieces, some due to the fact that the elephantine rotation made it precise casual to sensation and consciousness everything, and besides due to the fact that I gave up halfway through, retired of fear. You mightiness deliberation this should automatically enactment Stop & Shop astatine the bottommost of the list, but the sheer magnitude of food was truthful awesome — and Trader Joe's sushi was truthful atrocious — that it deserved a higher ranking.

The atom was beautifully minimal, if not comparatively gummy. Not ideal. Although the rice-to-salmon ratio was sensational, I wanted much of the avocado, and what was determination was truthful bittersweet and squished to the side. The container came with a elephantine heap of caller pickled ginger and a good-sized soy condiment packet, positive the store antagonistic had further packets to grab. The ginger was the champion retired of immoderate store, but inactive couldn't prevention the weird fish.

Overall, this rotation had a strong, unpleasant, preserved flavor. Maybe it'd beryllium amended different day, but I don't truly consciousness similar uncovering out.

Stop & Shop was priced astatine $9.99 for 9 pieces, which comes to $1.11 per piece. Their sushi is prepared in-house and connected the little extremity of the terms spectrum, some successful full and per unit, but it's inactive not truly worthy it, successful my opinion. I'll conscionable instrumentality to their cooked salmon, which is consistently truly good.

To me, Whole Foods is the OG market store sushi. This is really wherever I tried sushi for the archetypal clip erstwhile I was 7 years aged (it was a cucumber roll, and it was perfect). Returning to the sushi antagonistic conscionable felt right, similar coming location aft a agelong trip. And fto maine archer you: the salmon successful their salmon-avocado rotation was the champion connected this database and amended than immoderate of the salmon I've had astatine costly sushi restaurants. Oh my god, it was flavorful, buttery, and perfect. After eating a fewer afloat rolls for this ranking, I conscionable popped retired the food and ate it connected its own. I was blown away!

Of course, I'm ranking the full roll, not conscionable the fish, truthful let's speech astir different criteria. This was the astir costly roll, truthful theoretically, it should beryllium the best. This was not the case. Unfortunately, the atom was a blistery mess. It was gummy, determination was mode excessively overmuch of it, and it had truthful overmuch vinegar. The salmon and avocado were nicely sized, though. It came with a ample packet of ~reduced sodium~ soy sauce, but they usage the aforesaid weird ginger packet arsenic Trader Joe's, truthful they don't get the fractional constituent either.

Overall, this rotation tasted fresh, though the atom was beauteous vinegar-heavy. I would bargain this again, but I would alternatively conscionable person it sashimi-style.

Whole Foods was priced astatine $11.99 for 8 pieces, which comes to $1.50 per piece. At the highest full and portion price, situation I say...worth it? The food was fantastic, adjacent if the atom was bad. It's made in-store and tin adjacent beryllium made to order. It's a bully prime if you're already determination for groceries and person a hankering, but I wouldn't accidental it's worthy going retired of your mode for.

I'm conscionable arsenic amazed arsenic you are that Wegman's wasn't my fig one. They didn't person salmon-avocado rolls, but they had salmon avocado-cucumber rolls, and unfortunately, they were conscionable a spot lacking successful a fewer cardinal areas. The food was great, nary ifs, ands, oregon buts. Upon dissection, Wegman's salmon had a spot little spirit than Whole Foods and was excessively bedewed (yes, I cognize earthy food is wet, IT WAS TOO WET), but inactive truly good.

Similar to Whole Foods, the main setback present is the rice. It's precise caller and decidedly NOT gummy, but the atom ratio is excessively high, and it's vinegar-heavy, which detracts from the different affirmative qualities. They really merchantability made-to-order sushi atom astatine the sushi counter, which is little vinegar-tasting (but inactive much than sushi atom should be), truthful I'm not definite wherefore the sushi rolls person vinegar overkill. My different contented is, erstwhile again, that damned ginger packet. Wegman's virtually flies successful a 200-lb tuna from Japan each week, but can't get pickled ginger that isn't weirdly slimy and artificial tasting. They do, however, person hoards of soy condiment packets disposable and containers of caller pickled ginger for merchantability astatine the aforesaid counter. Make it marque sense.

Overall, I person bought Wegman's sushi galore times and would bargain it again. Honestly, Wegman's lone beats Whole Foods due to the fact that its atom is somewhat better. I didn't deliberation these 2 would beryllium this intimately comparable.

Wegman's is priced astatine $9.49 for 8 pieces, which comes to $1.19 per piece. Similar to Whole Foods, it is made in-store and tin beryllium made to order, not to notation the 2 GIANT cases of freshly-made sushi to take from. Falling successful the halfway of the terms range, this is decidedly worthy it!

Winner, winner, salmon-avocado dinner! I ate 1 portion and instantly declared this atrocious lad the fig 1 market store sushi. H Mart's food was LESS WET than Wegman's, but again, not arsenic sensational arsenic Whole Foods. I besides would person liked determination to beryllium much fish, TBH. It was inactive precise flavorful and buttery erstwhile I dissected it, but the pieces were a tad small.

Even with the smaller pieces of fish, H Mart inactive pulled up due to the fact that the wide acquisition was the best. The atom was minimal successful the ratio, and determination was nary overpowering vinegar taste. H Mart won due to the fact that its sushi tasted similar restaurant-grade. Of course, the devil is successful the details, and other points were rewarded for their incredibly caller ginger and sizable soy condiment packets (and the small soy condiment crockery it came with).

Overall, this sushi rotation has maine singing a antithetic market tune, and I'm genuinely shocked. If this rotation had bigger pieces of food and/or the food from Whole Foods, it would person been an casual 5/5, but 4.5/5 is thing to sneeze at!

H Mart is priced astatine $10 for 8 pieces, which comes to $1.25 per piece. The second-highest full and portion price, this is edifice prime astatine a little terms and so, truthful worthy it.

To recap, the last ranking from worst to champion is:

Thanks for tagging on connected my fishy journey! I don't deliberation I'll ever beryllium capable to look astatine a portion of salmon again, but it was worthy it for the investigation. Let maine cognize if determination are immoderate different foods I should rank!

May is AAPI Heritage Month! Support your section Asian-owned supermarkets and brands, and cheque retired much AAPI contented here!