2 hours ago
3
In the US, falling commencement rates deed a record low past year, turning what mightiness different beryllium a demographic inclination into a benignant of motivation Rorschach test. Politicians pass of demographic collapse. Employers fret astir the aboriginal workforce. Commentators scold millennials and Gen Z for being selfish, immature, oregon irresponsible. The astir charitable explanation, however, is usually economic: radical would person children if they could spend them.
A Reddit post precocious distilled that statement bluntly. "The full kids versus no-kids statement isn't really astir kids," the thread opens. "It's astir resources."
The author, u/thetimechaser — a genitor who notes that childcare costs astir lucifer their owe — argues that the existent operator of "plummeting" commencement rates successful developed nations isn't shifting values oregon manner preferences, but economical strain. While acknowledging that parenthood isn't for everyone and shouldn't beryllium undertaken retired of obligation, they suggest that galore radical who presently take to beryllium childfree would marque a antithetic determination nether amended worldly conditions.
Here's the afloat station below:
"I'm conscionable going to accidental it: The full kids versus no-kids statement isn't really astir kids. It's astir resources.
I consciousness similar a sizeable information of our procreation feels similar we got rug-pulled by 'the system,' and understandably so. Hence, wherever we are today. Money, time, energy, emotions — everyone is feeling the squeeze, and that changes the intelligence calculus for everyone (as it should). I deliberation if each worldly needs were taken attraction of, a sizeable fig of radical would autumn into the pro-kids camp.
I person a kid. Childcare is astir the outgo of my mortgage. If it weren't for that, I'd person a second. That's virtually it (for me, astatine least). My kid is wonderful, and I'm inactive capable to fulfill myself with hobbies and instrumentality clip for my wife, etc.
I'm not saying that 'if you tin spend it, you should person kids.' No — inactive wholly up to you. In fact, unless you actively privation a kid, I don't deliberation you should person one. I can't ideate a sadder situation for a kid than 1 of resentment.
I'm conscionable saying that if much radical could spend kids without fundamentally kicking themselves down a fewer rungs connected the socioeconomic ladder, we wouldn't spot commencement rates successful developed nations plummeting astatine breakneck speed.
Just funny to spot much treatment arsenic it relates to resources and however that weighs connected people's decisions."
In response, their mentation drew much than 1,000 comments and reignited statement implicit whether the prime to beryllium childfree is truly a substance of affordability. To determination past the abstract, I pulled 31 substantive responses from the thread and grouped them into recurring themes — not arguments successful the ceremonial sense, but patterns radical returned to repeatedly, astatine times autarkic of 1 another.
What emerged wasn't a rebuttal of the "resources" mentation truthful overmuch arsenic a representation of however incomplete it is, offering a representation of however radical are really reasoning astir parenthood now. Taken together, the responses constituent to a deeper displacement than policymakers thin to acknowledge:
Theme 1: Many radical simply don't privation children — and present tin accidental so.
1. "Women are present comfy saying that they don't privation kids. I judge that's the main happening that's changed."
2. "It doesn't substance to maine if you gave maine 2 years paid maternity leave, a guaranteed job, afloat infirmary bills covered, a 24-hour nanny, escaped daycare, escaped babe supplies, cosmetic country to get escaped of the scars, and a idiosyncratic trainer to get escaped of the babe weight. I inactive don't privation kids, for immoderate reason, ever. Period."
3. "Many, galore women bash not privation kids. They ne'er did, but they had zero options adjacent 30 years back."
4. "Ten cardinal dollars could beryllium wired into my relationship tonight, and I would inactive not person children. For me, it is not resources. It is the lack of desire. There is thing astir it that appeals to me."
5. "I truly person zero tendency to ever woody with children, and gestation sounds horrific. I could person unlimited resources and inactive not privation to rise children. It has ne'er funny me. If I were rich, I'd commencement a feline rescue alternatively of procreating."
6. "I person children, but I deliberation immoderate radical don't privation children due to the fact that they conscionable don't. Some radical don't privation pets due to the fact that they simply don't privation them. Sometimes, it's due to the fact that they don't privation to walk connected familial issues. Sometimes, they don't person support. There's thing incorrect with not wanting children. We request to normalize this."
7. "It's really astir kids. You prioritize hobbies, kid, wife, etc. Other radical don't privation to acceptable a kid into that. Frankly, this isn't and shouldn't beryllium a statement beyond: you bash you. It's truly that simple."
Theme 2: Access to reliable commencement power changed everything.
8. "The interaction of entree to reliable commencement power cannot beryllium overstated. I travel from a agelong enactment of highly 'fertile' women, for deficiency of a amended word. Our kids were vaguely planned, but my hubby and I conceived aft 1 effort aggregate times. Without commencement control, each clip we slept unneurotic during my childbearing years would beryllium a risk. My great-grandmother endured galore abortions and horrific methods to bounds pregnancies. I was the archetypal pistillate connected my maternal broadside not to beryllium a teen mom. The adjacent procreation has zero teen moms. My parent is simply a retired caregiver practitioner who worked successful underprivileged communities. Before retiring successful 2010, she helped women 'sneak' commencement power successful the signifier of IUDs aft asking husbands to permission the country for a backstage exam. The full crippled tin beryllium changed with reliable and accessible commencement control."
9. "I travel from a 'fertile' enactment of women. One of my relatives, calved successful 1930, had 10 children successful 12 years. My ain children were conceived connected the archetypal try. I consciousness similar I could inactive easy get large astatine 44 — regular cycles, wide signs of ovulation, each of it. I'm truthful thankful for my husband's vasectomy. It gave america implicit a decennary without worrying astir an unwanted pregnancy. I can't ideate not having the enactment to program our household the mode we saw fit."
10. "Every azygous clip I mislaid wellness insurance, I couldn't spend commencement control. Every time, I got pregnant. I person 4 kids now. Yes, we tried condoms and the bushed method. Once we got security again aft the 4th was born, my hubby got snipped. It inactive outgo america $750 retired of pocket. An full week of wage gone. It was worthy it, though, due to the fact that the past babe and I some astir died during delivery."
Theme 3: The carnal toll connected women is underestimated.
11. "I deliberation much moms are sharing the harsh realities of pregnancy, childbirth, and motherhood. It utilized to not beryllium talked astir much."
12. "My person had the audio signaling of her giving commencement to her 3rd kid. That, positive a photograph of her afterward with blank eyes, made maine deliberation my impulse to not privation to springiness commencement is astir apt correct. To beryllium fair, she did a earthy commencement and said it was truthful horrible she couldn't adjacent enslaved with her babe close distant due to the fact that she was successful shock. She besides went done the gnarliest postpartum. She conscionable had babe fig four, and things look amended this clip around. Plus, celebrities are being overmuch much unfastened astir postpartum present — Jennifer Lawrence comes to mind. Growing up, women were unfastened astir the hardships of motherhood, but postpartum was framed arsenic thing that lone happened to unlucky women. Now radical are honorable astir it, which I'm thankful for, but it doesn't marque maine consciousness much unafraid astir having kids."
13. "My friends had kids earlier I did, and it wholly turned maine off. One mates went to a wedding erstwhile their archetypal kid was 3, and it was the archetypal 8 hours they'd had to themselves since the babe was born. That aforesaid person had a traumatic labour wherever the doc utilized aesculapian scissors to chopped her vagina to get the babe retired faster. She needed stitches and took months to recover. Another friend's gestation went fine, but their kid has a developmental disorder, and it's been incredibly stressful. Now ideate if the kid was calved sick oregon had a lifelong carnal disablement — aesculapian bills, perchance ne'er surviving independently. I similar the thought of having a kid, but there's conscionable nary script wherever it makes consciousness to me."
14. "If I could get a antheral oregon pistillate large with my vagina, I could spot myself having a kid if my spouse wanted 1 too. Kids are great! But I garbage to enactment myself done each that change. The thought of thing increasing wrong of maine and past having it travel retired of me, breaking and stretching worldly connected the mode out, freaks maine the fuck out. Hormones are conscionable wrecking you for months before, during, and after, past the healing, past the affectional value of it all. Yeah, no, convey you."
15. "The biggest costs of kids not good accounted for are the carnal costs to women's bodies, carnal health, and intelligence health. This is apt the No. 1 outgo and crushed the commencement rates person declined successful developed nations."
16. "It's worthy stating plainly that the hits women instrumentality are carnal from the precise beginning. Both parents of infants are sleep-deprived and stressed, but men are not the ones who are bleeding, recovering from a C-section, oregon who tore from clit to asshole. They are not the ones monitoring for mastitis, astatine hazard of hemorrhage, wearing Depends truthful they don't pee each clip they laughter oregon sneeze, oregon needing carnal therapy conscionable to consciousness mean again. Men with large partners oregon newborns are not the ones astatine accrued hazard of being beaten oregon killed by their partner. Even if the social, emotional, career, financial, and clip costs were afloat resolved, these carnal risks would inactive exist."
"Maybe if each different outgo were paid, immoderate women would person 2 oregon 3 kids alternatively of one. But determination is besides a important fig of women who volition take to ne'er person children astatine each — and others who mightiness privation much children but cannot judge the carnal hazard for the involvement of the ones they already have."
Theme 4: Nordic-style benefits don't lick it.
17. "In countries that person cosmopolitan healthcare, parental leave, and affordable childcare, the commencement complaint isn't overmuch higher. People conscionable aren't having kids if they don't privation to. And past I unrecorded successful a municipality with 20% surviving beneath the poorness line, and I hardly cognize anyone who's childfree."
18. "I unrecorded successful Finland. We person an highly beardown enactment system. You get kid benefits for 17 years, childcare is heavy subsidized, acquisition is escaped — adjacent assemblage — and parental permission is astir a twelvemonth long. And still, radical don't person kids. They springiness the aforesaid reasons radical bash successful the US: wealth and deficiency of benefits. 'Too expensive. Parental permission should beryllium longer. Child benefits should beryllium higher. Childcare should beryllium cheaper.' I deliberation the information is that radical conscionable don't privation kids that much. Kids are tiring and time-consuming, and gestation and childbirth usually aren't pleasant experiences. But radical are acrophobic to accidental they simply don't privation much kids. They privation hobbies, travel, and freedom. It's much socially acceptable to accidental you truly privation kids but can't due to the fact that of the government."
19. "What radical ever bring up arsenic a retort to this is that countries that are well-off besides person a decreased commencement rate."
20. "Frankly, I don't bargain that outgo is the superior crushed radical aren’t having kids. Nordic countries person the astir generous childcare benefits successful the world, yet their birth rates are adjacent lower than those successful the US. That makes maine skeptical that our commencement complaint would rebound simply by adopting those policies. If much radical were honest, they'd admit it's the time, stress, and work that deter them. That’s good — but let's not unreal it's lone astir money."
Theme 5: Modern parenting is exhausting successful caller ways.
21. "We're successful a cleanable tempest of circumstances that person made this a fraught topic. We person choices now. Just a mates of generations ago, determination was nary prime astatine all. As prime became possible, it was limited, and nine took clip to drawback up to the thought that the question isn't erstwhile oregon however many, but whether to person children astatine all. The system is simply a mess. In erstwhile generations, kids could assistance — if they didn't, excessively bad. When radical are successful endurance mode, it's easier to person thing foisted upon you than to take it. Choosing to person kids requires a level of stableness and foresight that galore radical don't person close now. Parenting is besides much progressive than it's ever been. We were raised by the 'do you cognize wherever your children are?' generation, who were raised the aforesaid way. My dada and his siblings were tied to a cinder artifact extracurricular my grandmother's spot of employment truthful they wouldn't tally disconnected portion she worked. That was normal."
"Now parents bash a batch much existent parenting. Working mothers contiguous walk much clip with their kids than stay-at-home moms did successful the 1970s. The anticipation that you request to beryllium everything for your kid — and walk tremendous amounts of clip with them — is new. And it's exhausting.
It besides requires much intelligence energy. Regulating your ain emotions and teaching a kid to modulate theirs is harder than terrifying them into submission. Our brains weren't designed to marque america consciousness harmless oregon happy; they were designed to support america alive. Teaching intelligence well-being is labor.
Immigration plays into this, astatine slightest wherever I live. Our colonisation can't prolong itself without immigration, and galore radical are aggravated astir immigrants coming here. On immoderate level, there's resentment toward younger generations for not "doing their part" to support colonisation maturation going, adjacent though infinite maturation is unsustainable.
A batch of would-be grandparents consciousness they upheld their extremity of the societal declaration and are aggravated their children aren't doing the same. This strategy has worked for millions of years, and our procreation is deviating from it. For immoderate people, that deviation is unacceptable.
As ever, it comes down to empathy. The thought that others mightiness not privation the aforesaid things — particularly erstwhile they're portion of the expected in-group — is profoundly unsettling to immoderate people."
Theme 6: The load falls disproportionately connected women.
22. "The treble modular is that a antheral tin marry, person kids with his wife, and fundamentally disregard them arsenic agelong arsenic they're provided for. The woman shows up to enactment events. She has her hobbies. The kids mightiness person immoderate daddy issues, but they get done it. Everyone moves on, and this behaviour is mostly accepted. No 1 judges these men due to the fact that they're 'hard-working, important men with engaged careers.' Meanwhile, women are expected to beryllium full-time moms and vocation women. That's excessively hard. Why would we take both, particularly if the vocation doesn't adjacent screen daycare and luxuries? When adjacent a antheral successful mid-level absorption has traditionally been allowed to enactment household connected the backmost burner?"
23. "For women, children correspond the accidental outgo of astir everything: financially, emotionally, socially, career-wise, and successful presumption of time. The mode we've structured things, the accidental outgo for women specifically is enormous. Unless — and until — we make a strategy successful which a pistillate tin support her vocation and her beingness successful a sustainable, semipermanent way, relationship for things similar retirement, and person a kid without everything becoming a precarious location of cards, this won’t change. Right now, women who person children are penalized hard, successful a batch of antithetic ways. For many, that outgo is simply excessively high. The accidental outgo of my maxing retired my status accounts for the past decennary alternatively of paying for daycare is immeasurable. And these trade-offs don't autumn connected fathers successful the aforesaid way. It isn't fair, but it is the reality."
24. "To beryllium honest, arsenic a woman, I've known possibly 1 antheral who really shared parenting responsibilities equally. It conscionable precise seldom ends up being an adjacent split, and I'm not consenting to springiness up my lifestyle, goals, etc., truthful my kid's begetter tin dick astir and bash what helium wants portion I'm stuck with our kids. I besides person nary tendency — but beyond that, I wouldn't spot 85% of fathers to really stock work equally."
Theme 7: Modern beingness leaves nary margin.
25. "There's an vigor cost. I'd similar to person kids, but I honestly don't deliberation I person the energy. It's exhausting to instrumentality basal attraction of myself and my dog, bash my job, effort to support a mates of inexpensive hobbies, and spot friends erstwhile successful a bluish moon. I don't deliberation it'd beryllium just to person a child. If we could spend for 1 genitor to spell part-time — conscionable 1 time little a week — to grip appointments, location stuff, and each the logistics, maybe. But a kid would outgo more, and I'd privation to beryllium capable to springiness them a bully childhood. I marque a decent amount, oregon astatine slightest what should beryllium a decent amount. The bigger occupation is that astir radical don't person a bully prime of beingness close now. It makes having kids hard successful applicable ways. People are sad, depressed, and moving to survive, which doesn't marque them consciousness susceptible of raising a child. Single radical who privation kids don't person the clip oregon vigor to conscionable someone, fto unsocial physique a beingness unchangeable capable for kids."
"It besides makes having kids consciousness morally complicated. The satellite seems to beryllium getting worse — much unstable, much fascist. Do I truly privation to bring a kid into that?
At the aforesaid time, it's getting harder to physique community. Everyone is overworked and overstressed, marinating successful dumb online sermon and true-crime motivation panic, to the constituent wherever knocking connected a neighbor's doorway with cookies feels suspicious alternatively of normal. All of this makes having children not conscionable harder, but little appealing."
26. "For me, it's chiefly the clip factor. I simply bash not person the vigor to enactment 40-plus hours a week and past travel location to what is efficaciously different full-time job. If we worked a batch less, similar 10-15 hours per week, I would beryllium overmuch much unfastened to having kids."
Theme 8: Children nary longer supply economical return.
27. "Historically, children served a utilitarian purpose. In agrarian and artisanal societies, they helped with gathering resources, hunting, fishing, and different labor, expanding the economical and worldly superior of the household and community. These days, kids are mostly a clip and wealth descend — fundamentally the world's astir costly hobby. If you privation to acquisition caregiving, you tin enactment arsenic a nurse, societal worker, teacher, oregon successful different helping profession. Compared to parenting, you're paid, you get benefits, and you person clip off. If you privation to 'make a quality successful a child's life,' you tin foster, manager younker sports, oregon beryllium a chill aunt oregon uncle to 1 of the billions of children who already exist. Unlike parenting, you aren't required to beryllium disposable 24/7. If what you privation is simply a close, loving relationship, you tin deepen friendships, get person to extended family, oregon participate a romanticist relationship."
"Unlike relationships with children, big relationships impact afloat consent, communal understanding, and reciprocal support.
People are besides much alert present of the risks of divorce, toxic oregon enmeshed household dynamics, and big estrangement from parents, each of which are connected the rise. Having kids guarantees thing but accent and inconvenience, and a increasing fig of radical don't spot it arsenic worthy lowering their prime of beingness successful each different country conscionable for a fewer Kodak moments the kid mightiness not adjacent retrieve — oregon retrieve fondly — arsenic an adult."
Theme 9: Pessimism astir the future.
28. "I erstwhile work that what declining commencement rates truly archer america is that radical consciousness that the satellite they're surviving successful isn't worthy continuing. That thought is inactive sticking with maine hours aboriginal for reasons I can't afloat articulate."
29. "I don't privation 2 decades of cooking for, cleaning up after, bathing, dressing, supervising, teaching, and perpetually transporting idiosyncratic to practices, doctors' offices, school, and friends' houses. I don't privation to springiness up astir everything I privation to bash oregon acquisition due to the fact that my beingness present revolves wholly astir my children. I'm a loving and liable person. I would beryllium a good parent. I simply don't privation to bash it. And I don't similar the satellite capable to bring idiosyncratic into it against their will. I don't judge my hypothetical children would person a amended beingness than I've had. If anything, it would apt beryllium harder — much costly education, little affordable housing, worse entree to wellness care, little privacy, and less rights — speaking arsenic idiosyncratic successful the US. I mightiness consciousness otherwise elsewhere, knowing my children wouldn't beryllium astatine hazard of being murdered astatine schoolhouse oregon church, oregon trapped successful a strategy of endless pupil indebtedness oregon possibly aesculapian debt."
30. "I bash privation kids. I besides unrecorded successful the US, and it's tragic that I do, really. Our state is truthful hostile to moving families, and it's lone going to get worse. The healthcare strategy unsocial is simply a perfectly bully crushed not to person children."
Theme 10: Society wants the benefits without supporting the labor.
31. "It's excessively constrictive to absorption connected idiosyncratic resources. Time, money, and vigor matter, but the bigger contented is structural. Women carnivore children, and to rise them successful ways nine deems successful, they request support. That enactment mostly doesn't exist. Women person small sustained assistance from partners, families, oregon the community. It was socially acceptable 30 years agone to fto children roam freely. Now, some partners are expected to work, yet childcare inactive defaults to women. As educational, social, and affectional expectations for children person grown, raising a kid unsocial has go a monolithic task. With the quality to take to person children, galore women determine it isn't worthy it. The blasted is past placed connected women due to the fact that they springiness birth. Societies facing declining commencement rates respond not by gathering enactment systems, but by restricting termination and commencement power oregon offering incentives — putting the unit connected women, adjacent though nine benefits astir from their labor."
"Even the richest women and couples outsource childcare by hiring nannies — radical who, if anyone, should person the resources to negociate connected their own. That unsocial tells you however overwhelming child-rearing has become.
There are 2 responses to this reality. One is to unit women to person children by stripping them of rights, which galore countries are already doing. The other, the amended one, is to materially and socially enactment women.
Instead, women are blamed for having children 'for the incorrect reasons,' oregon for not having them astatine all, portion men are not held to the aforesaid expectations oregon scrutiny. I don't privation men demonized. I privation a nine that understands and respects the load women instrumentality connected simply by having children astatine all.
Everyone says it takes a village. No 1 wants to beryllium a villager."
If the responses are immoderate indication, the question isn't simply whether radical tin spend children. What bash you deliberation is driving declining commencement rates wherever you live? Is it money, time, gendered expectations, the authorities of the world, oregon thing other entirely? Share your thoughts successful the comments oregon anonymous signifier below!
Note: Responses person been edited for length/clarity.
English (US) ·