Husband claimed wife fell while 'doing laundry' in basement — then cops say they checked his Google search history

18 minutes ago 3

Benjamin Carpenter, Erica Carpenter

Inset (left): Benjamin Carpenter (Milwaukee County Sheriff's Office). Inset (right): Erica Carpenter (Church & Chapel Family-Owned Funeral Service). Background: The location successful West Allis, Wis., wherever Erica Carpenter was fatally injured (Google Maps).

A Wisconsin antheral who allegedly tried to screen up the sidesplitting of his wife has been arrested pursuing a two-year investigation.

Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was taken into custody connected Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide successful transportation with the decease of his wife, 40-year-old Erica Carpenter. According to a transgression ailment reviewed by Law&Crime, constabulary responded to the Carpenters' location successful West Allis, Wisconsin, connected the nighttime of Oct. 13, 2024, aft receiving a telephone astir a pistillate who "fell and was bleeding from the head." Police said Benjamin Carpenter was performing CPR connected his wife, whose look was already "very blue."

Police spoke with Benjamin Carpenter astatine the scene, and helium explained that his woman had not been feeling good that time and took respective naps. That night, Benjamin and Erica Carpenter were "doing laundry together" erstwhile she "collapsed," helium said. Benjamin Carpenter told constabulary that she fell truthful hard that it was "loud capable to aftermath their lad who was sleeping upstairs." He besides told constabulary that she deed her caput "mildly hard" connected the carpeted floor.

Instead of calling for help, Benjamin Carpenter allegedly carried his unconscious woman up the stairs. According to the complaint, Benjamin Carpenter told constabulary that helium "slipped" connected the steps and "they some fell down the stairs." He claimed that Erica Carpenter deed her caput connected the cinder artifact partition connected the mode down.

Erica Carpenter was transported to the infirmary and was pronounced dormant astatine 5:14 a.m. connected Oct. 14, 2024.

When questioned by constabulary astir the authorities of their marriage, Benjamin Carpenter said, "It's (short pause) good." He consented to having each 3 of his phones searched by constabulary and provided passcodes for each of them. When asked if helium deleted thing from them successful the past 24 hours, Benjamin Carpenter denied that helium did.

Police said that aft quality of Erica Carpenter's decease reached the couple's societal circles, an idiosyncratic approached authorities connected Oct. 22, 2024. The witnesser informed them that a woman, identified with the initials "A.M.V.," said she had been having an matter with Benjamin Carpenter and believed that helium was successful the process of divorcing his wife. A.M.V. reportedly told the witnesser that Benjamin Carpenter had promised to inquire Erica Carpenter for a divorcement the aforesaid play she died.

The witnesser besides told constabulary that they learned Benjamin Carpenter spent the nighttime astatine A.M.V.'s location days aft his wife's decease and said helium wanted to present A.M.V. to his lad connected Oct. 21, 2024.

About a period aft Erica Carpenter's death, a pub-crawl payment was held successful her honor. Police said surveillance footage showed Benjamin Carpenter and A.M.V. "portraying themselves arsenic a couple."

Police spoke with different witness, who said they had done mixed martial arts with Benjamin Carpenter and had known him since precocious school. This witnesser told constabulary that Benjamin Carpenter admitted that helium had been having an matter with A.M.V. and had been successful the process of divorcing Erica Carpenter aft she recovered retired astir the affair.

According to the complaint, the witnesser said "several barroom patrons" expressed their astonishment that Benjamin Carpenter had brought "a caller girlfriend" to the barroom truthful soon aft his wife's death. The aforesaid witnesser said "people were upset" that A.M.V. had been contiguous astatine the pub-crawl benefit.

More from Law&Crime: Husband killed wife, past enlisted niece to instrumentality authorities into believing she was live and surviving overseas: Cops

When constabulary interviewed Benjamin Carpenter successful December 2024, they learned that helium had collected "$220,000 oregon $230,000" of Erica Carpenter's beingness security policy. There was besides a associated argumentation worthy $350,000 that had not yet been paid out. During the interview, Benjamin Carpenter allegedly admitted to constabulary that helium had been having an matter with A.M.V. successful the months starring up to Erica Carpenter's death. He reportedly said that A.M.V. "did not privation to day him until helium got a divorce" and "pushed him away."

Police said they spoke with respective friends of the Carpenters who were seemingly unaware of immoderate marital issues betwixt the couple, which "contradicted" Benjamin Carpenter's statement of his marriage.

An autopsy revealed that Erica Carpenter had hydrocodone successful her strategy but had not been prescribed the drug, constabulary said. Its beingness "cannot beryllium ruled out" arsenic a imaginable contributor to her death. Erica Carpenter's origin of decease was listed arsenic undetermined, but she had blunt unit injuries to the cervix and petechial hemorrhaging, some signs of a imaginable "asphyxia death."

The aesculapian examiner spoke to Benjamin Carpenter implicit the telephone to inquire astir however helium was holding his woman portion they fell down the stairs. According to the complaint, the aesculapian examiner said Benjamin Carpenter's relationship of events "would not explicate wherefore Erica Carpenter's bosom stopped beating."

Police said that successful May 2025, they were called again to Benjamin Carpenter's West Allis location aft A.M.V., who was surviving determination astatine the time, said Benjamin Carpenter "placed his manus astir her cervix and strangled her." Police said A.M.V. told the Uber operator who picked her up that if she "were to die, it was him who did it," past showed the operator Benjamin Carpenter's interaction paper successful her phone.

In June 2025, constabulary reviewed the grounds from the hunt warrant connected Benjamin Carpenter's phones. According to the complaint, helium searched Google for "Watching idiosyncratic you emotion die" connected Sept. 19, 2024, and "can I crush pills and instrumentality them successful water" connected Oct. 13, 2024. Another hunt connected Nov. 6, 2024, reportedly led to a Facebook representation that read, "The hardest happening successful the satellite is watching idiosyncratic you emotion dilatory dice close successful beforehand of you." Police besides wrote successful the ailment that the hunt warrant recovered that Benjamin Carpenter had deleted substance messages, contempt his denial that helium did so.

Another reappraisal of the telephone grounds indicated that Erica Carpenter reportedly questioned her hubby astir putting thing successful her drinking water. On Sept. 18, 2024, she texted, "And what the f— person you been doing to my h2o the past fewer days?!?!?" She aboriginal texted, "There's been powdery s— successful it astatine slightest doubly now." He texted backmost that helium was putting "liquid IV" successful it for himself and told her it was his water.

Police spoke to the Carpenters' lad successful October 2025. He told constabulary that connected the nighttime of his mother's fatal fall, helium heard a "thud" aft proceeding a "scream." The lad told constabulary that 4 weeks aft his parent died, his begetter removed photos of Erica Carpenter from the home. He confirmed that A.M.V. moved into the location 2 oregon 3 months aft his mother's death.

Benjamin Carpenter is successful custody astatine the Milwaukee County Jail, wherever helium is being held without bond. He was scheduled to marque his archetypal quality successful tribunal connected Wednesday.

Read Entire Article