How Trump’s Preliminary Deal with Iran Compares with His Rhetoric

President Donald Trump signed a preliminary statement to extremity the warfare with Iran connected June 17. The 14-point memorandum of understanding outlines the conditions nether which the U.S. and Iran person initially agreed, and gives them 60 days to negociate further terms.

But immoderate of what is included successful the model — oregon not — is astatine likelihood with what Trump said astir a imaginable woody anterior to approving the memorandum of knowing past week.

For example, successful an NBC News interview earlier successful June, Trump said that helium would not “unfreeze immoderate Iranian assets” oregon “lift immoderate sanctions” against Iran “upfront” arsenic portion of a woody to extremity the conflict. But the statement says that the U.S. Treasury Department volition “immediately” assistance waivers permitting Iran to resume exports of crude lipid and different petroleum products, allowing Iran to marque billions of dollars successful revenue. A docket for perchance billions of dollars successful further sanctions alleviation is to beryllium worked retired implicit the adjacent 2 months.

Also, Trump initially called quality reports that the statement included a $300 cardinal reconstruction money for Iran “false.” However, the money is mentioned successful the memorandum of understanding, and Reuters, citing an unnamed source, has reported that “more than half” of that wealth “has already been committed” by private-sector investors astir the world, including successful the U.S.

Furthermore, the statement says small astir the aboriginal of Iran’s atomic programme — a cardinal root of contention betwixt the 2 countries, and portion of Trump’s justification for launching airstrikes connected Iran successful February. During his archetypal word arsenic president, Trump withdrew the U.S. from a atomic woody with Iran, called the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, that was negotiated and implemented during the Obama administration.

For years, Trump has lambasted the Obama-era pact arsenic “horrible,” “defective” and 1 of the “dumbest” ever. But Trump’s existent statement says Iran “reaffirms that it shall not procure oregon make atomic weapons” conscionable arsenic erstwhile President Barack Obama’s woody said Iran “under nary circumstances” would “ever seek, make oregon get immoderate atomic weapons.”

Sanctions Relief, Unfreezing Assets

In a June 5 interview connected NBC’s “Meet the Press,” Trump said “no” erstwhile asked if helium would “unfreeze immoderate Iranian assets oregon assistance immoderate sanctions upfront arsenic a portion of immoderate deal” with Iran.

“If they behave, if they bash a bully job, we commencement talking,” Trump said astir aboriginal negotiations.

But Trump didn’t wholly instrumentality to that promise.

The memorandum of knowing that helium signed has lifted U.S. sanctions that were limiting however overmuch crude lipid and different petroleum products Iran could merchantability connected the planetary market. The statement says the U.S. “undertakes that instantly upon the signing of this MoU, and until the termination of sanctions, the U.S. Department of Treasury volition contented waivers for the export of Iranian crude oil, petroleum products, and derivatives, and each associated services including banking transactions, insurances, transportation, etc.”

The Wall Street Journal reported that Iran could present marque $60 cardinal per twelvemonth from lipid and substance income astatine existent prices, assuming that it returns to pre-war accumulation levels. Iran could gain $8 cardinal successful conscionable the archetypal 2 months nether the deal, the Journal said, according to estimates from Richard Nephew, a elder probe student with Columbia University’s Center connected Global Energy Policy and a erstwhile U.S. lawman peculiar envoy for Iran successful the Biden administration.

In addition, the statement says, “The United States of America undertakes to marque afloat disposable for use, the frozen oregon restricted funds and assets of the Islamic Republic of Iran upon the implementation of this MoU.” Iran has tens of billions of dollars successful frozen assets astir the world, including an estimated $20 cardinal to $50 cardinal successful China, according to the Wall Street Journal, which said Iran’s “priority is to unblock an archetypal $24 cardinal successful phases.”

As for the timing of the merchandise of those assets – which a elder medication authoritative reportedly said was contingent connected “good behavior” from Iran – the statement says, “The United States of America and the Islamic Republic of Iran volition mutually hold connected the procedures related to the merchandise of these funds during the negotiations.”

“We person taken their money, it’s not our money, it’s their money, and we froze it,” Trump told reporters astatine a June 17 property league during the acme of G-7 nations successful France. “At a definite constituent successful time, I conjecture we’re going to person to springiness it back.”

But successful November 2015, portion campaigning successful Iowa, Trump criticized billions of dollars of Iranian assets that were unfrozen arsenic portion of the Obama administration’s atomic woody with Iran. 

“I would person ne'er fixed them backmost the money,” Trump said. “I would person said, “The wealth is disconnected the table. Let’s commencement negotiating.’”

Also, the statement that Trump signed says that the U.S. “undertakes to terminate each types of sanctions against the Islamic Republic of Iran,” including “all unilateral U.S. sanctions … successful an agreed upon docket arsenic portion of the last deal.”

It remains to beryllium seen which sanctions volition beryllium removed and when.

$300 Billion Fund

The statement further says, “The United States of America undertakes, with determination partners, to make a definitive mutually agreed program with astatine slightest USD 300 Billion, for the reconstruction and economical improvement of the Islamic Republic of Iran. The mechanics for the implementation of this program volition beryllium finalized arsenic portion of last Deal wrong 60 days.”

But Trump initially denied that the money was portion of the woody during a June 17 property conference with the Egyptian president successful France. 

“Well, it’s false,” Trump said successful effect to a newsman who asked astir the $300 cardinal fund, which was mentioned successful a draft of the memorandum of knowing that had been leaked to members of the press.

“It’s false. People, you tin put if you want. What americium I going to do, accidental nobody’s ever allowed to invest? We’re not invest[ing]. We’re not putting up 10 cents. People tin determine to bash that, but that’s up to them,” Trump said. “We are not investing successful it, and we bash not person a fund.”

While the memorandum of knowing says that the U.S. volition assistance make the program for the $300 billion, and assistance each “required licenses, waivers and permissions needed for the applicable fiscal transactions,” Trump and Vice President JD Vance person insisted that nary of the wealth intended for Iran’s reconstruction and economical improvement volition travel from U.S. taxpayers.

“We’re not investing immoderate money,” Trump said successful a June 16 gathering with the emir of Qatar. “We didn’t wage for it similar Obama did. He paid billions of dollars. He paid 1.7 cardinal from an airplane, each greenish cash. It was crazy.”

In an exclusive connected June 16, Reuters – citing an anonymous root acquainted with the negotiations – reported that “more than half” of the $300 cardinal “has already been committed and that it volition beryllium comprised wholly of private-sector funds.” Private companies successful the U.S., the Gulf Arab states, Asia, South America and Africa person already agreed to perpetrate financing, a root told Reuters, adding that nary authorities ⁠money oregon grants would beryllium included. 

As for the $1.7 cardinal that Trump has repeatedly said Obama “paid” to Iran successful 2016, we’ve written that that was to formally settee a decades-old quality implicit Iran paying the U.S. $400 cardinal for subject instrumentality that was ne'er delivered. The U.S. refused to supply the instrumentality aft the Shah of Iran was overthrown during the Iranian Revolution successful 1979.

The $1.7 cardinal that Iran received, all successful cash, but not successful U.S. currency, included the archetypal $400 cardinal and an further $1.3 cardinal for interest. 

The $1.7 cardinal is sometimes conflated with the sanctions alleviation that Iran received for complying with the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action negotiated nether Obama.

As we’ve written, arsenic portion of that deal, the U.S., China, France, Germany, Russia, the United Kingdom and the European Union agreed to assistance sanctions connected Iranian assets that were frozen and being held mostly successful overseas banks. In a September 2015 op-ed astir Obama’s deal, Trump claimed that the U.S. had fixed Iran “a windfall of $150 billion, which volition nary uncertainty money coercion astir the world.” 

But the U.S. Treasury Department estimated that Iran would extremity up with a batch little – astir $50 cardinal successful “usable liquid assets,” according to 2015 testimony from Adam Szubin, who was past the acting nether caput of treasury for coercion and fiscal intelligence.

Iran’s Nuclear Program

Trump has repeatedly derided the JCPOA, claiming that it would person enactment Iran connected “a way to a atomic weapon.” (We have written about that before.) By comparison, Trump said his woody would beryllium “a partition to a atomic weapon.”

“The Obama deal was 1 of the dumbest deals I’ve ever seen; it was a road to a atomic weapon,” Trump said connected June 17, referring to the JCPOA, which helium pulled retired of successful 2018. “My woody is simply a partition to a nuclear — you’re not going to person it, it’s a partition to a atomic weapon.”

But that remains to beryllium seen. The memorandum of knowing says only: “The Islamic Republic of Iran reaffirms that it shall not procure oregon make atomic weapons.”

That intimately mirrors the connection successful the JCPOA, which stated, “Iran reaffirms that nether nary circumstances volition Iran ever seek, make oregon get immoderate atomic weapons.”

The existent statement goes connected to say, “The Islamic Republic of Iran and the United States of America person agreed to resoluteness the disposition of stockpiled, enriched worldly pursuant to a mechanics that volition beryllium mutually agreed upon … with the minimum methodology to beryllium down-blending connected tract nether the supervision of the [International Atomic Energy Agency],” which is simply a notation to Iran’s enriched uranium, up to 60%, according to the IAEA conscionable earlier the bombing of Iran’s atomic sites past year. Uranium enriched to 60% is just short of weapons people material.

“The 2 parties besides agreed to sermon the contented of enrichment and different mutually agreed matters related to the Islamic Republic of Iran’s atomic needs, based connected the statutory model being agreed upon successful the last deal,” the memorandum of knowing states. “The last woody volition corroborate the provisions of this paragraph. The Islamic Republic of Iran and the United States of America admit the captious value of the atomic issues supra mentioned, and explicit their volition to instantly code these issues successful the dialog successful bid to execute communal statement connected them.”

While Trump stated connected June 15 that “the main happening is that Iran volition not person a atomic weapon,” and that Iran “fully agreed to that, with beardown policing powers,” determination are nary details astatine each successful the statement astir Iran agreeing to “strong policing” of their atomic program, oregon what that mightiness entail.

The details of what the 2 countries volition hold to regarding Iran’s atomic programme are to beryllium determined implicit the people of the 60-day dialog period, Kelsey Davenport and Daryl G. Kimball, of the Arms Control Association, explained successful June 22 brief. “The MOU is, fundamentally, a non-nuclear woody that leaves cardinal atomic issues unresolved,” they wrote.

Similarly, Nephew, the planetary and nationalist affairs student astatine Columbia University, told america successful an email, “The JCPOA had detailed, circumstantial requirements for verification and what Iran would do. The closest this has is that Iran agrees to support its atomic programme static, successful speech for static sanctions, but determination is nary verification and determination is nary specificity.”

“Everything other is to hap successful the aboriginal arsenic portion of a longer word deal,” helium said. “I accidental you could accidental that this longer word woody already has a guardant looking committedness connected managing Iran’s enriched uranium stocks, but everything other is ‘for discussion.’”

So, until firmer details are negotiated with Iran regarding its atomic program, it’s premature for Trump to assertion his woody is “a partition to a atomic weapon,” peculiarly erstwhile it lacks verification requirements that were successful already spot with JCPOA, anterior to immoderate caller struggle with Iran.

---

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station How Trump’s Preliminary Deal with Iran Compares with His Rhetoric appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.