1 hour ago
4
Washington — The memorandum of knowing that President Trump struck with Iran past play sets up a two-month sprint toward a longer-term woody implicit the destiny of the Iranian atomic program, 8 years aft Mr. Trump pulled retired of an Obama-era atomic statement that he viewed arsenic "disastrous" and "one-sided."
The Trump medication says its memorandum of knowing is acold superior to the Obama administration's 2015 Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), and volition bash overmuch much to forestall Iran from having a atomic weapon. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth insists it volition beryllium antithetic from the JCPOA due to the fact that the U.S. volition "make definite the subject enactment is there," thing Mr. Trump stressed.
The memorandum is not a last statement similar the JCPOA, which numbered hundreds of pages and was packed with method details.
Rather, the caller woody is simply a 14-point model that extends the ceasefire successful the U.S.-Iran warfare and sets the signifier for talks connected a imperishable atomic agreement. It doesn't see specifics connected what volition hap to Iran's enriched uranium oregon its atomic program, leaving those details to beryllium sorted retired implicit the adjacent 60 days.
The substance of the woody was read retired to reporters by elder U.S. officials connected Wednesday.
Although the memorandum is simply a roadmap for further negotiations, since Trump medication officials are comparing the two, present are immoderate of the differences and similarities:
Both deals prohibition Iran from acquiring atomic weapons — but the JCPOA was acold much circumstantial astir how
Mr. Trump said successful a quality league Wednesday helium wanted to marque definite Iran could ne'er "procure" a atomic weapon, speech from conscionable ensuring Iran can't make one, connection helium said helium wanted successful the memorandum of understanding.
But the JCPOA besides included a committedness from Iran to not procure a atomic weapon.
"Iran reaffirms that nether nary circumstances volition Iran ever seek, make oregon get immoderate atomic weapons," the JCPOA reads.
The caller memorandum says Iran "reaffirms that it shall not procure oregon make atomic weapons." But precisely however that volition beryllium enforced volition beryllium near up to the last deal.
JCPOA fto Iran enrich uranium astatine a constricted level. It's unclear what a Trump-era woody volition require.
Under the JCPOA, Iran wasn't required to destruct each of its enriched uranium, but it was required to dramatically trim its stockpile astatine a clip erstwhile its levels of highly enriched worldly were acold little than they are now.
Iran besides agreed successful the JCPOA to headdress its level of uranium enrichment to 3.67% for 15 years, good beneath the 90% level required to nutrient atomic weapons. It required Iran to confine each of its enrichment to a azygous atomic installation successful Natanz. The JCPOA besides restricted the fig and types of centrifuges Iran could person successful operation.
The caller memorandum says the mechanics of handling Iran's uranium volition beryllium decided successful method negotiations implicit the adjacent 60 days, but it suggests Iran volition look immoderate limits. Unlike erstwhile the JCPOA was negotiated, Iran's uranium stockpile present includes uranium enriched to 60% purity — conscionable a abbreviated measurement to weapons-grade material.
The woody says the 2 countries "agreed to resoluteness the disposition of stockpiled enriched material." It includes a "minimum" modular of "downblending" Iran's enriched uranium connected tract nether the supervision of the International Atomic Energy Agency.
It's not yet wide if the enriched uranium would beryllium destroyed oregon removed from the country, oregon simply downblended to a little grade. The memorandum doesn't get into circumstantial figures. And the caller statement doesn't notation centrifuges.
Mr. Trump didn't explicit urgency implicit Iran's enriched uranium Wednesday, noting that astir of the 60%-enriched worldly is believed to be buried underneath rubble following a circular of U.S. airstrikes past year.
"Nobody is going to get that for a agelong time, unless we privation to get it," the president told reporters astatine a quality league astatine the G7 acme successful France, adding that it's "not valuable" and "nobody's touching it."
Earlier this year, Mr. Trump pressed Iran to wantonness each uranium enrichment, a measurement that would beryllium stricter than the JCPOA — and 1 that Iranian officials person refused to instrumentality successful the past. Iran has agelong insisted its atomic programme lone exists for peaceful purposes, though the 60%-enriched uranium that it has accumulated successful caller years is good supra the level needed for astir civilian uses.
On Wednesday, however, Mr. Trump appeared to permission unfastened a doorway for Iran to person a civilian atomic program.
"It is simply a small hard, though, erstwhile you accidental that idiosyncratic wants it, different radical person it, other, adjoining states person it," helium said. "And you're not letting them person it for purposes of energy and things similar that. It's ever a small tough. You person to usage a small communal sense."
Sunset clauses
The JCPOA had 10 and 15-year sunset clauses, a cardinal disapproval leveled against the deal.
The memorandum of understanding, not yet a last agreement, has nary sunset clauses. It's not wide if a last woody will.
Mr. Trump told The New York Times implicit the play helium wants Iran to hold to suspend each uranium enrichment for 15 to 20 years — but helium besides wants imperishable restrictions that accidental Iran tin "only enrich for nonmilitary purposes. Forever."
Sanctions relief
Under the JCPOA, successful speech for Iran agreeing to limits connected its atomic program, it was granted alleviation from planetary sanctions. The sanctions alleviation was phased successful and babelike upon verification from the IAEA, and some the JCPOA and the United Nations Security Council acceptable a docket for lifting sanctions.
Under the memorandum, U.S. sanctions volition beryllium lifted connected an agreed-upon docket arsenic portion of a last deal, not truthful antithetic from the JCPOA.
One cardinal quality is that respective different countries progressive successful sanctioning Iran were parties to the JCPOA, including China, Russia, the U.K. and Germany. The caller memorandum is simply a bilateral woody betwixt the U.S. and Iran, truthful it's unclear however third-party countries that besides person sanctions connected Iran volition react.
But the memorandum of knowing gives Iran contiguous waivers for lipid and petroleum exports, according to the substance arsenic work by U.S. elder officials.
Nikki Haley, the president's erstwhile U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, balked astatine the anticipation of Iran profiting from lipid income immediately.
"If this is true, Iran wins," she wrote connected X. "There should beryllium zero sanctions alleviation time one."
Iran has claimed successful caller days that the woody would besides pb to the contiguous unfreezing of billions of dollars successful Iranian assets that were frozen nether U.S. sanctions. The Trump medication has denied this, saying Iran volition lone get sanctions alleviation aft it complies with its obligations.
Funding for Iran
The Iran memorandum says the U.S. and determination partners volition "develop a definitive mutually agreed program with astatine slightest USD $300 cardinal for the reconstruction and economical improvement of the Islamic Republic of Iran," with a mechanics for implementation to beryllium discussed later.
The president, however, insists that immoderate investments successful Iran would beryllium voluntary.
"We are not investing immoderate wealth successful Iran, by the way," the president said astatine the G7 acme successful France. "The rumor got retired determination yesterday, it was ridiculous. We person the close to spell successful immoderate time and do, if I privation to bash thing oregon if idiosyncratic wants to bash something. But we are not investing immoderate money, we person nary work to put immoderate wealth successful Iran."
The JCPOA did not see backing for economical development.
In 2016, however, Iran did person $1.7 billion in currency from the U.S. to settee a decades-old dispute. Before Iran's 1979 revolution, the state paid the U.S. $400 cardinal for arms purchases that were ne'er delivered. Under erstwhile President Barack Obama, the U.S. returned that money, with involvement amounting to astir $1.3 billion.
Ballistic missiles
The JCPOA did not enactment limits connected Iran's accepted military, including its proviso of ballistic missiles, thing for which the woody was criticized.
The caller memorandum doesn't notation ballistic missiles, either. On Wednesday, Mr. Trump said helium thinks it's "okay" for Iran to person ballistic missiles successful proportionality to the stockpiles of neighboring countries.
"If different countries person them, it's a small spot unfair for them not to person some," helium said. "A ballistic rocket is not the aforesaid happening arsenic what we're talking astir erstwhile we speech nuclear. But if Saudi Arabia and Qatar and they each person some, I would accidental successful comparative proportion, I deliberation it's okay. That's what I mean."
State-sponsored terrorism
Neither the JCPOA nor the latest Iran memorandum explicitly addresses consequences for backing terrorism.
Mr. Trump told reporters Wednesday his medication volition enactment connected a "parallel effort" with Persian Gulf nations to code "non-nuclear issues," similar Iran's accepted missiles and backing of violent proxies.
Iran's backing of militant groups similar Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis — which the U.S. has designated arsenic violent organizations — has agelong been a constituent of contention.
Under the JCPOA, terrorism-related sanctions the U.S. imposed connected the Iranian authorities remained successful place, though critics suggested the sanctions alleviation the U.S. provided could escaped up currency for Iran to money terrorism.
English (US) ·