How a discarded Q-tip helped solve the Idaho college murders case

6 hours ago 7

The pb authoritative tasked with uncovering justness for 4 University of Idaho students killed successful a grisly quadruple stabbing much than 2 years agone laid retired his cardinal grounds Wednesday astatine a tribunal proceeding for Bryan Kohberger, who pleaded guilty to debar the death penalty.

The evidentiary summary - recited by pb authoritative Bill Thompson earlier Kohberger entered his pleas - spun a melodramatic communicative that included a DNA-laden Q-tip plucked from the garbage successful the dormant of the night, a getaway car stripped truthful cleanable of grounds that it was "essentially disassembled inside" and a fateful early-morning Door Dash bid that whitethorn person enactment 1 of the victims successful Kohberger's path.

These details offered caller insights into however the crime unfolded connected Nov. 13, 2022, and however investigators yet solved the lawsuit utilizing surveillance footage, compartment telephone tracking and DNA matching. But the synopsis leaves hanging cardinal questions that could person been answered astatine proceedings - including a motive for the stabbings and wherefore Kohberger picked that house, and those victims, each evident strangers to him.

The tiny farming assemblage of Moscow, successful the bluish Idaho panhandle, had not had a homicide successful astir 5 years erstwhile Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and Madison Mogen were recovered dormant astatine a rental location adjacent campus.

Kohberger, present 30, had begun a doctoral grade successful transgression justness astatine adjacent Washington State University - crossed the authorities enactment from Moscow, Idaho - months earlier the crimes.

"The suspect has studied crime," Thompson said, arsenic the victims' household members dabbed astatine their tears. "In fact, helium did a elaborate insubstantial connected transgression country processing erstwhile helium was moving connected his Ph.D., and helium had that cognition skillset."

What we learned from the hearing

Kohberger's compartment telephone began connecting with compartment towers successful the country of the transgression much than 4 months earlier the stabbings, Thompson said, and pinged connected those towers 23 times betwixt the hours of 10 p.m. and 4 a.m. successful that clip period.

A compilation of surveillance videos from neighbors and businesses besides placed Kohberger's conveyance - known to investigators due to the fact that of a regular postulation halt by constabulary successful August - successful the area.

On the nighttime of the killings, Kohberger parked down the location and entered done a sliding doorway to the room astatine the backmost of the location soon aft 4 a.m., Thompson said. He moved to the 3rd floor, wherever Madison Mogen and Kaylee Goncalves were sleeping.

Bryan Kohberger, charged successful the murders of 4 University of Idaho students, appears astatine the Ada County Courthouse, successful Boise

After sidesplitting some of them with a knife, Kohberger near a weapon sheath adjacent to Mogen's body. Both victims' humor was aboriginal recovered connected the sheath, on with DNA from a azygous antheral that yet helped investigators pinpoint Kohberger arsenic the lone suspect.

On the level below, different pupil was inactive awake. Xana Kernodle had ordered Door Dash not agelong before, and arsenic Kohberger was leaving, helium crossed paths with her and killed her with a ample knife, Thompson said. He past killed her boyfriend, Ethan Chapin, who was sleeping successful Kernodle's bedroom.

Kohberger near 2 others successful the location alive, including 1 roommate who was expected to attest astatine proceedings that sometime earlier 4:19 a.m. she saw an intruder determination with "bushy eyebrows," wearing achromatic covering and a skis mask.

Roughly 5 minutes later, the car could beryllium seen connected the next-door neighbor's surveillance camera. speeding distant truthful accelerated "the car astir loses power arsenic it makes the corner," Thompson said.

What did Kohberger bash next?

After Kohberger fled the scene, Thompson said, his cover-up was elaborate.

Prosecutors judge helium drove backroads to his flat successful Pullman, Washington, to debar surveillance cameras connected the large roads and didn't crook his compartment telephone backmost connected until 4:48 a.m. By 5:26 a.m., helium was backmost successful Pullman, Thompson said.

Later, Kohberger changed his car registration from Pennsylvania to Washington State - important for investigators who were combing done surveillance camera footage due to the fact that Pennsylvania instrumentality doesn't necessitate a beforehand licence plate, making it harder to place the vehicle.

And by the clip investigators did drawback up with him weeks later, his flat and bureau successful adjacent Pullman were scrubbed clean.

"Spartan would beryllium a benignant characterization. There was thing there, thing of evidentiary worth was found," Thompson said of Kohberger's apartment.

The car, too, "had been fundamentally disassembled inside," helium added. "It was spotless. The defendant's car had been meticulously cleaned inside."

The Q-tip that broke the case

Investigators had honed successful connected Kohberger, but they needed to beryllium helium was their suspect.

With the DNA of a azygous enigma antheral connected the weapon sheath, they worked with the FBI and the section sanitation section to secretly retrieve garbage from the Pennsylvania location of Kohberger's parents, seeking a DNA lucifer to their suspect.

"They conducted what's called a trash propulsion during the nighttime hours," Thompson said, and "took trash that had been acceptable retired connected the thoroughfare for collection" and sent it to Idaho's forensics lab.

The heap of garbage yielded investigative gold: A Q-tip that contained DNA identified "as coming from the begetter of the idiosyncratic whose DNA was recovered connected the weapon sheath that was recovered by Madison Mogen's assemblage connected the bed," helium said.

With that, Kohberger was arrested astatine his parents' home successful Pennsylvania, wherever helium had gone for the holidays, and yet was extradited to Idaho for prosecution.

The mysteries that remain

Even portion prosecutors elaborate that night, a cardinal question remains: Why did Kohberger people that location and those victims? Did helium cognize them? And what was his motive?

"We bash not person grounds that the suspect had nonstop interaction with 1122 oregon with residents successful 1122, but we tin enactment his telephone successful the country connected those times," Thompson said, referring to the location fig wherever the murders took place.

Some of that grounds whitethorn person travel retired astatine trial, and whitethorn yet beryllium contained successful documents related to the lawsuit that person been sealed by the tribunal until aft a July 23 sentencing hearing. A gag bid successful spot for each attorneys successful the lawsuit is inactive successful effect arsenic well.

Those documents see witnesser lists, a database of exhibits, an investigation of the evidence, requests for further discovery, filings astir mitigating factors and assorted unsuccessful defence motions that sought to present alternate suspects, among different things.

The families of the victims are divided implicit the plea deal

With the lawsuit solved, families stay divided implicit its resolution.

The woody stipulates that Kohberger volition beryllium spared execution successful speech for 4 consecutive beingness sentences. He besides waived his close to entreaty and to situation the sentence.

Chapin's and Mogen's families enactment the deal.

Mogen's father, Ben Mogen, told CBS News helium was relieved to person the missive regarding the plea woody that would support Kohberger successful situation for the remainder of his beingness without the anticipation of parole. He showed CBS News portions of the letter. In it, the Latah County Prosecutor's Office says Kohberger's attorneys requested a woody and helium accepted it.

"If you get that speedy decease sentence, you don't person to walk decades reasoning astir however unspeakable you made the world," Ben Mogen said.

For Ben Mogen, the plea woody is justice.

"We tin really enactment this down america and not person these aboriginal dates and aboriginal things that we don't privation to person to beryllium at, that we shouldn't person to beryllium at, that person to bash with this unspeakable person," helium said. "We get to conscionable deliberation astir the remainder of lives and person to effort and fig retired however to bash it without Maddie and the remainder of the kids."

The household of Kaylee Goncalves publically denounced the plea woody up of Wednesday's proceeding and her begetter refused to be the proceedings.

Goncalves 18-year-old sister, Aubrie Goncalves, said successful a Facebook station that "Bryan Kohberger facing a beingness successful situation means helium would inactive get to speak, signifier relationships, and prosecute with the world."

"Meanwhile, our loved ones person been silenced forever," she wrote.