Gig Work Is Invading Nursing Homes. The Risks Can Be Deadly

2 days ago 11

Within hours of being injected with insulin that was meant for her roommate, 93-year-old Emma Lewis’ humor sweetener plummeted, and she was rushed to a adjacent aesculapian center.

Twelve days later, she died.

Felicia Kaye, the licensed applicable caregiver who gave the injection successful May 2022, was not an worker of Peachtree Centre, wherever Lewis lived. She was a gig idiosyncratic who picked up her displacement connected the nursing app ShiftKey. She wasn’t acquainted with Lewis oregon her roommate and ne'er received predisposition connected immoderate of the facility’s policies and procedures.

“It’s beauteous overmuch you get the keys [to the medicine cart] and conscionable fig it retired yourself,” Kaye testified this August. Kaye declined to remark for this story.

Gig workers are flooding America’s understaffed nursing homes, resulting successful a revolving doorway of unit caring for the nation’s aged and infirm. ShiftKey boasts a web of much than 10,000 facilities—many of them nursing homes—and much than 200,000 wellness attraction workers hoping to capable shifts.

An probe by Proof News and WIRED recovered that the gig nursing exemplary is putting lives astatine risk: Numerous tribunal filings, national inspection reports, and interviews with erstwhile employees of the company, attorneys, and gig nurses themselves picture however ShiftKey thrusts workers into understaffed nursing homes with small to nary onboarding—leading to unsafe situations.

In January, a national surveyor from the US Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services noted that a ShiftKey idiosyncratic made a mistake inserting a PICC line, a catheter threaded successful a patient's limb to their heart. No 1 astatine the nursing location had checked that they were trained connected the procedure. In 2025, a CMS surveyor wrote that a Texas nursing location didn’t orient impermanent workers connected however to provender residents earlier a ShiftKey idiosyncratic tried to unit provender 1 with a syringe. Later that year, a nursing location successful Texas banned a ShiftKey idiosyncratic aft a nonmigratory who was expected to beryllium nether her attraction was recovered sitting successful urine and feces.

Inspection reports besides uncover alleged maltreatment and theft. This summertime astatine Hillsboro Rehab successful Illinois, a ShiftKey idiosyncratic allegedly stole the debit cards of 2 residents and utilized 1 of them astatine a section fume store and crystal pick store.

According to the inspection report, the nursing location notified ShiftKey astir the incidental and blocked the idiosyncratic successful the app truthful they couldn’t prime up shifts determination successful the future. The idiosyncratic was aboriginal arrested, and residents repaid, according to Tim Blythe, determination vice president of operations for Tutera, Hillsboro Rehab’s genitor company.

“We sincerely regret this unfortunate incident,” Blythe wrote successful an email. “We completed an interior probe and notified the individual's employer, instrumentality enforcement, the Office of Inspector General, and due regulatory agencies.”

One ShiftKey idiosyncratic was accused of slapping a nonmigratory successful the look successful Texas successful 2022, and different of “verbal abuse” of a nonmigratory successful Tennessee successful 2023. At the Center astatine Grande successful Texas, a 3rd was accused of stealing hundreds of dollars from 4 residents successful February 2025. None of the facilities responded to a petition for comment.

ShiftKey pitches itself arsenic the Uber for nursing. “We applied exertion to the caregiver staffing industry,” reads an interior “selling points” memo obtained by Proof and WIRED. “What Uber did was link the lawsuit straight with drivers. ShiftKey connects facilities straight with providers.”

“Our exertion is portion of the solution to [the] diligent attraction situation by allowing highly experienced nurses to enactment connected the schedules they take and by enabling healthcare facilities to rapidly capable attraction gaps and present diligent care,” ShiftKey CEO Mike Vitek said successful a connection to Proof News and WIRED.

Though ShiftKey advertises unfastened shifts for a assortment of facilities—including those for addiction treatment, psychiatric hospitals, and correctional institutions —a Proof News and WIRED investigation of 108,706 disposable shifts collected successful March, July, and August 2026 recovered that 89 percent of unfastened shifts were astatine nursing homes.

The app offers shifts for mostly lower-paid nursing staff. A bulk of the unfastened shifts Proof New and WIRED reviewed called for licensed applicable nurses oregon certified nursing assistants, careers that don’t necessitate a bachelor’s grade and are paid betwixt $20 and $30 an hr connected average, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

In his statement, Vitek disputed that the exemplary is “harmful to the industry” fixed “long-standing, systemic issues wrong the healthcare ecosystem.” He emphasized that ShiftKey verifies credentials, conducts inheritance checks, checks maltreatment registries, and makes that accusation disposable to facilities.

“Importantly, grooming oregon predisposition required by immoderate installation to run wrong its policies is conducted by that idiosyncratic facility,” Vitek said. “At ShiftKey, we bash not employment nurses—we simply alteration their entree to flexible shifts.”

Like a increasing fig of platforms built to automate workforce management, ShiftKey relies connected a assortment of automation tools. The bundle allows facilities the enactment to automatically station and accept shifts; the app uses a “formula-based calculation” to delegate workers a “reliability score,” according to Vitek, which nurses said affects their quality to get shifts; and it offers displacement scoring, last-minute pricing, and dynamic pricing based connected request and supply, according to the company’s occupation postings and employees’ nonrecreational profiles.

But erstwhile a interest is raised, Vitek said, a quality reviews it. He said they measure claims of “medical malpractice oregon abuse, neglect, oregon exploitation of a diligent arsenic soon arsenic ShiftKey receives it” and determine if deactivating the idiosyncratic is “appropriate.” He declined to remark connected these circumstantial events, citing reasons of privateness and ongoing litigation. He added determination whitethorn beryllium instances wherever ShiftKey is not promptly notified, which tin hold action.

Emma Lewis successful  furniture  astatine  Peachtree Centre

Emma Lewis astatine Peachtree Centre, March 2022.Courtesy Emma Lewis Family

After the insulin incident, Kaye testified, she wasn’t prevented from moving connected the platform.

In tribunal filings, some ShiftKey and Peachtree support they shouldn’t beryllium held liable for Lewis’ death. ShiftKey argued that it is not liable due to the fact that Kaye “has ne'er been its employee,” portion Peachtree said it “cannot beryllium held liable for the acts of an autarkic contractor.” Kaye is not named arsenic a defendant, and ShiftKey is paying $40,000 to settee with Lewis’ family.

A typical for Peachtree Centre declined to remark citing pending litigation. In court, the location pointed retired Lewis was admitted to the infirmary with galore conditions too effects from the injection, and her decease certificate lists “senile degeneration of the brain” arsenic the cause.

As portion of the case, Kaye testified that she drove much than 250 miles from Myrtle Beach to enactment the Peachtree overnight shift. She had implicit 2 years of acquisition astatine the clip and said she wasn’t fixed truthful overmuch arsenic a circuit earlier being the lone caregiver posted to oversee a level of 22 patients.

“This peculiar displacement I had a batch of patients,” she testified successful the August deposition. “It was precise overwhelming.”

In their ailment against Peachtree and ShiftKey, Lewis’ household said they’d entrusted their “vulnerable” parent to a location they expected to “properly bid staff.”

“I’ll ne'er get Mom back,” said Lewis’ son, James Lewis, successful a deposition earlier this year. “I conscionable don't privation it to hap to anybody else.”

“Walking Into a Shit Show”

Kara Smith can’t archer you wherever she’ll beryllium moving adjacent week. A certified nursing assistant, Smith logs into the ShiftKey app astir mornings to browse eight-hour shifts astatine much than a twelve semipermanent attraction facilities wrong driving region from her West Virginia home.

Certified Nursing Assistant Kara Smith astatine  her location  with her cats successful  Mount Hope West Virginia. In kitchen

Certified Nursing Assistant Kara Smith astatine her location with her cats successful Mount Hope, West Virginia.Photograph: Clara Haizlett

Lured by the committedness of scheduling state and premium wage for hard-to-fill shifts, Smith became a ShiftKey contractor successful 2022. She claims she soon learned it's not unheard of to enactment nighttime shifts astatine nursing homes staffed wholly by ShiftKey.

Founded successful 2016 successful Texas, ShiftKey grew rapidly during the COVID-19 pandemic, arsenic unprepared nursing homes reeled from rolling outbreaks that could assertion dozens of lives successful a azygous facility. Health attraction workers sought higher wage arsenic their risks mounted, and homes scrambled to capable shifts.

Backed by backstage equity, ShiftKey and its competitors Clipboard Health and IntelyCare benefited. According to an analysis by the US Department of Health and Human Services, from 2019 to 2022, the usage of declaration unit successful nursing homes tripled from 4 to 12 percent of each nursing hours. Though it’s since declined, the complaint remains higher than prepandemic.

In 2023, ShiftKey’s past CEO told Axios that the institution was valued astatine much than $2 billion.

Nursing homes wage ShiftKey acceptable rates for workers. The level past “mathematically” calculates a “suggested” complaint for each displacement posted, Vitek said successful a statement, emphasizing that dynamic pricing tools are lone utilized to summation wage for “difficult-to-fill” shifts—and ne'er to alteration rates.

Workers past bid to assertion it. This bidding strategy is what got Smith hooked: Instead of accepting immoderate wage a installation would offer, Smith haggled for higher pay.

“If I tin adjacent marque 25 other cents, I'm going to effort to propulsion for that,” said Smith, a 47-year-old azygous mom. “Every penny counts.”

Since the pandemic, however, wages connected ShiftKey person plummeted, according to respective nurses who spoke with Proof News and WIRED. Teresa, an LPN who declined to springiness her past name, joined ShiftKey successful 2019. She stopped utilizing the level past twelvemonth erstwhile she noticed contention for shifts growing—and wage rates declining.

“People were warring implicit trash shifts for nether $20 an hour,” said Teresa, a azygous parent of 3 kids.

Smith remembers being capable to bid $3 to $4 much an hr supra the facility’s suggested complaint erstwhile she archetypal joined, but this twelvemonth she said she’s been forced to judge little wealth oregon hazard nary enactment astatine all.

According to her ShiftKey outgo records that she shared with Proof News and Wired, 1 installation paid her $32.50 an hr successful the summertime of 2025 and astir $26 a twelvemonth later. Payments from different nursing location showed the aforesaid downward trend. On Facebook groups, galore ShiftKey workers person posted astir a akin dip successful earnings.

“The starting bids are shamefully low,” said Smith. “It’s not worthy the workload oregon the drive.”

During her 4 years with ShiftKey, Smith said she routinely felt “thrown in” astatine caller facilities without orientation, wide instructions, oregon logins. She said she had to enactment hard to familiarize herself with the residents’ conditions, due to the fact that captious details, specified arsenic who is simply a autumn hazard oregon who has a catheter oregon an ostomy, are often missing. Hours in, she felt similar she was successful “an water and nobody’s astir me.”

“We're coming determination due to the fact that they're short-handed,” said Smith. “So we are automatically going to beryllium walking into a crap show.”

Smith said a deficiency of predisposition led to scary adjacent calls. Last year, she says she arrived astatine a Virginia nursing location with nary beforehand information, not adjacent the doorway code. She didn’t cognize thing astir the patients, and that made her “very stressed out.”

“I cognize my humor unit went up due to the fact that of it,” she said.

Another time, Smith said she dropped disconnected a regular portion to a nonmigratory lone to aboriginal larn that they were prescribed lone thickened liquids to debar choking.

“What if they choked and died?” said Smith.

Facilities connected ShiftKey person the option to necessitate that workers be a paid “orientation shift” earlier picking up a regular one. But 4 ShiftKey workers told Proof News and WIRED that they've often picked up nursing location shifts without doing an predisposition displacement first.

Inspection reports from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services dating backmost to 2023 and obtained by Proof News and WIRED uncover ShiftKey workers making unsafe mistakes.

In Ohio, aft a ShiftKey caregiver made a PICC enactment mistake astatine Stellar Care Center, a national inspection study noted that the nursing home’s administrators had ne'er checked to spot whether she was trained to bash IV therapy.

The study noted that an head had spoken with idiosyncratic astatine ShiftKey, who told her that due to the fact that they see everyone connected the app an autarkic contractor, the institution didn’t trial for what skills they knew.

In different cases, the predisposition was inadequate. At Woodway Rehabilitation and Healthcare Center successful Texas, a national wellness surveyor spotted a ShiftKey idiosyncratic trying to force-feed a nonmigratory a wellness shingle utilizing an oral syringe. The ShiftKey idiosyncratic said it was her archetypal clip astatine the facility, according to the 2025 inspection report. She received immoderate predisposition for the installation connected the app earlier she started her shift, the study said, but couldn’t retrieve if feeding was included.

In 2024, different CMS surveyor wrote that a ShiftKey caregiver astatine the Medical Suites astatine Oak Creek successful Wisconsin told the surveyor she was not shown immoderate attraction plans for residents connected her archetypal day. According to the report, the surveyor spoke with an administrator, who handed the surveyor an undated predisposition checklist. The head said they did not presently person a argumentation regarding predisposition for gig nurses, but that she'd beryllium implementing 1 successful 30 minutes.

Neither Stellar Care, Woodway Rehab, nor the Medical Suites astatine Oak Creek responded to requests for remark connected this story.

Researchers pass that gig nurses who aren’t decently oriented and who determination perpetually betwixt facilities tin disrupt the continuity of care. Jasmine Travers Altizer, an adjunct prof astatine New York University’s Rory Meyers College of Nursing, conducted a qualitative survey of 22 nursing location administrators this twelvemonth and recovered that they felt relying connected impermanent workers led to “less accordant care, much infirmary transfers, perchance unnecessary treatments and antibiotic use, and accrued falls.” Administrators besides reported unit having little quality to enactment 1 different crossed the facility.

Gig nursing “shouldn't beryllium a hole for chronic understaffing,” said Travers Altizer successful an email. It's critical, she said, to “have accordant unit who cognize the residents.”

Certified Nursing Assistant Kara Smith has been picking up   shifts done  ShiftKey since 2022. looking astatine  camera

Certified Nursing Assistant Kara Smith has been picking up shifts done ShiftKey since 2022.Photograph: Clara Haizlett

In response, Vitek, the ShiftKey CEO, said, “Continuity of attraction is an important information successful nursing location quality, but the contented predates platforms similar ours.”

ShiftKey says its exemplary keeps much nurses connected the occupation during a clip of captious shortage. Vitek said a survey of workers connected ShiftKey recovered that much than a 3rd stated they would not beryllium capable to enactment successful the wellness attraction manufacture without specified a platform.

“We cull the premise that enabling autarkic flexible nursing enactment is harmful to the industry, due to the fact that the situation successful addressing these issues is not astir the prime betwixt full-time unit versus impermanent displacement support,” helium said.

Short-Staffed to Gig-Staffed

Katie Wells, a researcher who tracks gig nursing, said a operation of factors made platforms similar ShiftKey an charismatic enactment for nursing homes. Health attraction facilities were struggling financially, and galore of them had been taken implicit by backstage equity, which Wells said “contributed to thin staffing models that marque facilities much apt to privation to conscionable plug the spread alternatively than put successful a larger staff.”

According to CMS data, the mean clip worked by nursing unit per nonmigratory astatine Peachtree, wherever Lewis was accidentally injected, is little than the authorities mean and little than minimum requirements acceptable by the US Department of Health and Human Services nether the Biden medication that are nary longer successful effect. The American Health Care Association, a nonprofit radical that represents nursing homes, successfully challenged the regularisation successful tribunal successful 2025, and the Trump medication yet withdrew the rule, stating that the determination would prevention nursing homes $55.1 cardinal implicit the people of 10 years.

“We request to person minimum harmless staffing levels,” said Hannah Garden-Monheit, who worked connected nursing location betterment astatine the White House National Economic Council and present is enforcement manager of Columbia Law School’s Center for Law and the Economy. “The patients request that continuity of care.”

Half a twelve ShiftKey nurses and the 2 erstwhile firm employees told Proof News and WIRED that galore of the facilities that usage ShiftKey person a past of mediocre prime of attraction and staffing issues.

One ShiftKey caregiver recalled rats scurrying successful the ceiling and roaches falling from lights astatine 1 nursing home.

Constance Hicks, a longtime certified nursing adjunct successful Connecticut, said that astir nursing homes she worked astatine done ShiftKey were successful unspeakable condition: nary obstruction cream, nary soap, nary supplies. Some places had nary blistery water. Not erstwhile successful much than a twelvemonth of picking up shifts done ShiftKey does she retrieve receiving immoderate grooming astatine the homes.

In November 2023, portion moving a treble displacement astatine Cobalt Lodge Healthcare, Hicks discovered an aged diligent with their caput and cervix trapped successful a furniture rail, their forehead compressed against the metal, according to tribunal records. She checked the patient’s vitals and, uncovering dangerously precocious humor pressure, called 911. Even though her displacement had ended, Hicks stayed until exigency workers arrived.

Hicks said she documented everything and sent it to ShiftKey. She besides tried reaching retired to the company’s representatives but said nary 1 responded. By the adjacent day, her ShiftKey relationship was deactivated.

Hicks, who says the incidental with the diligent caused “a full batch of intelligence trauma,” tried to record a suit against ShiftKey implicit the deactivation and different issues, but tribunal records amusement the institution successfully moved her lawsuit to backstage arbitration.

Cobalt Lodge Healthcare did not respond to a petition for comment, and ShiftKey declined, citing ongoing litigation.

Regarding the prime of the facilities, Vitek said, “When professionals rise a concern, we promote them to usage the ceremonial reporting channels, and punctual them that they tin take whether they tin judge aboriginal shifts there.”

Some lawmakers person begun scrutinizing platforms similar ShiftKey, successful portion implicit concerns that it’s misclassifying its workers arsenic autarkic contractors.

Shiftkey login surface  connected  phone

A gig caregiver logs into ShiftKey.

Photograph: Clara Haizlett

“It's not similar they're coming in, bringing their ain tools, fixing a pipe, and leaving,” says Emma Greenman, a Minnesota authorities representative, of gig nurses. “They are being managed by somebody.”

ShiftKey disputes that characterization. “ShiftKey, arsenic a exertion marketplace, does not employment healthcare professionals but connects them with healthcare facilities that person gaps successful their schedule,” said Vitek, adding that the institution works “tirelessly” to guarantee its exemplary complies with the law.

Greenman is moving connected a measure that she said would curb idiosyncratic misclassification successful Minnesota, including successful gig nursing.

“What they’re doing is gathering concern models to evade, break, and distort labour instrumentality for profit,” Greenman said.

There’s besides the contented of whether to let nursing homes to unit mostly with gig workers. The twelvemonth Lewis died, an investigation of staffing information submitted to CMS shows that astir a 3rd of the full nursing unit hours astatine Peachtree were performed by impermanent workers.

Gary Poliakoff, 1 of the attorneys representing Lewis’ family, said that immoderate weeks, the complaint of temp workers including ShiftKey roseate to arsenic precocious arsenic 50 percent of each nursing staff.

With small orientation, Poliakoff said, the exemplary puts some patients—and workers—at a “great disadvantage.”

After the mistaken insulin injection, James Lewis said helium got the telephone from Peachtree letting him cognize his parent was successful the hospital. According to his deposition, helium was getting acceptable to spell to religion to preach and planned to sojourn her later. He often went each day. They’d devour luncheon unneurotic and ticker The Price Is Right, but that time helium was looking guardant to spending immoderate clip outside. It was Mother’s Day.

When asked if helium knew that Peachtree sometimes had impermanent workers, helium responded that helium wasn’t aware.

“I don't cognize if it was a traveling caregiver oregon what,” helium said successful the deposition. “But I cognize it wasn't a regular person.”

In her testimony, Kaye blamed understaffing for her insulin mix-up. She remembered moving astatine Peachtree doubly successful November 2021 but went six months without returning due to the fact that she thought it was a “shithole.”

“It was not a bully installation by immoderate means,” Kaye said.

She testified she was already an hr precocious giving the insulin, having excessively overmuch connected her plate.

“I retrieve being not helped astatine each by administration, not knowing who anyone was,” said Kaye. “And beauteous overmuch being by myself.”

Read Entire Article