1 day ago
6
War rages connected successful Ukraine, Gaza
Washington — As Russia's warfare successful Ukraine rages connected contempt high-level meetings to sermon a imaginable way to peace, CBS News has learned that Tulsi Gabbard, the manager of nationalist intelligence, issued a directive weeks agone to the U.S. quality assemblage ordering that each accusation regarding the Russia-Ukraine bid negotiations not beryllium shared with U.S.-allied quality partners.
The memo, dated July 20 and signed by Gabbard, directed agencies to not stock accusation with the alleged Five Eyes, the post-World War II quality confederation comprising the U.S., U.K., Canada, Australia and New Zealand, aggregate U.S. quality officials told CBS News. They spoke nether information of anonymity to sermon delicate nationalist information matters.
The officials said the directive classified each investigation and accusation related to the volatile Russia-Ukraine bid negotiations arsenic "NOFORN," oregon nary overseas dissemination, meaning the accusation could not beryllium shared with immoderate different state oregon overseas nationals. The lone accusation that could beryllium shared was accusation that had already been publically released. The memo besides constricted organisation of worldly regarding bid talks to wrong the agencies that created oregon originated the intelligence.
The memo does not look to forestall the sharing of diplomatic accusation gathered by different means abstracted from the U.S. quality community, oregon subject operational accusation unrelated to the talks — specified arsenic the details the U.S. shares with the Ukrainian subject to assistance successful their defensive operations.
Contacted by CBS News, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence referred questions to the White House, which did not respond.
"In general, the worth of the Fives Eyes quality concern is that erstwhile we are making and they are making argumentation decisions, we tin some augment each other's quality and truthful cognize much astir the plans, intentions, and capabilities of our adversaries," explained Steven Cash, a erstwhile quality serviceman astatine the Central Intelligence Agency and Department of Homeland Security.
"Among the reasons for that benignant of default is the anticipation that we and the different 4 are each sitting connected the aforesaid broadside of the array with immoderate different adversary connected the different side," Cash said.
He said it's important for the allies to person "a communal quality picture" truthful policymakers and negotiators "can coordinate our positions and get the champion woody we can, oregon combat the champion warfare we can." Cash is the enforcement manager of The Steady State, a nonprofit enactment made up of erstwhile U.S. quality and nationalist information professionals and authorities officials acrophobic with threats to American democracy.
In March 1946, Winston Churchill spoke of the "special relationship" betwixt the U.S. and the U.K. and the menace of the "Iron Curtain" that had "descended crossed the Continent." The United States and Britain archetypal forged their quality confederation successful secret, signing an agreement to excavation accusation arsenic a bulwark against the Soviet Union.
Later, Canada, Australia and New Zealand joined the arrangement, transforming what began arsenic a bilateral pact into the five-nation web that would travel to beryllium known arsenic the Five Eyes.
But now, astir 80 years later, immoderate erstwhile U.S. authorities officials pass that the breadth of Gabbard's bid could undermine the quality assemblage confederation — discouraging analysts from sharing insights and eroding spot among allies who person agelong relied connected unfastened exchanges to signifier a communal representation of planetary threats and paths to palmy negotiation.
Cash and CBS News nationalist information contributor Sam Vinograd, a erstwhile homeland information official, said Five Eyes often has quality that helps the U.S. nutrient broad quality assessments, particularly astir Russia, fixed the entree Five Eyes partners person to different quality sources.
"Shutting our astir trusted partners disconnected from quality assessments could person a chilling effect connected captious quality sharing if our partners judge they're being unopen retired of cardinal entree — including connected cardinal matters successful their region. They could determine to instrumentality akin steps toward the U.S.," Vinograd said.
She added, "Policy-wise, if our Five Eyes partners deliberation they are being unopen disconnected from cardinal information. They could take to make caller structures and channels without us. A deficiency of afloat collaboration with our closest partners could pb them to sermon matters impacting our nationalist information without our input and perspective."
Still, different erstwhile quality officers contend Gabbard's directive is commonplace wrong the U.S. quality community, and the disapproval is overmuch ado astir nothing. They accidental some the U.S. and the different members of the quality confederation often withhold accusation from each different successful diverging involvement areas. Ezra Cohen, a Hudson Institute chap who served arsenic the acting undersecretary of defence for quality astatine the Pentagon, suggested that condemnation of Gabbard's memo apt stems from a dislike of Trump medication policies and her enactment arsenic manager of nationalist intelligence.
"There is simply a batch of accusation we bash not stock adjacent with our Five Eyes partners, and it works successful the reverse. There's a batch of U.K. eyes-only material. There's a batch of Australian eyes-only material," said Cohen.
"Our interests are not ever aligned with our Five Eyes partners," Cohen said. "And wherever we person diverging interests, and it's not conscionable Ukraine, we perfectly people things NOFORN."
He admits it's imaginable the directive could effect successful depriving the U.S. of information, but maintains these types of decisions person historically been the norm betwixt each of the Five Eyes members. He said the assertion that the directive represents "a chilling of the relationship" betwixt the U.S. and Five Eyes seems "a small spot similar faux outrage."
As quality enactment and diplomatic efforts continue, mostly retired of the nationalist eye, the warfare successful Ukraine continues to instrumentality a deadly toll. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy condemned Moscow Thursday for launching hundreds of drones and dozens of missiles successful an onslaught overnight, "as if thing had changed astatine all. As if determination were nary efforts by the satellite to halt this war."
James LaPorta is simply a nationalist information coordinating shaper successful CBS News' Washington bureau. He is simply a erstwhile U.S. Marine infantryman and seasoned of the Afghanistan war.
English (US) ·