Former Trump Administration Health Adviser Misleads About mRNA Flu Vaccine

1 day ago 6

Former Health and Human Services Department advisor Calley Means has misleadingly suggested that the caller mRNA influenza vaccine from Moderna isn’t harmless and doesn’t enactment well. Less is known astir it due to the fact that it is simply a caller vaccine, but proceedings information suggest it works amended than modular flu vaccines and does not person immoderate superior information risks.

For the archetypal time, immoderate Americans person the enactment to person an mRNA vaccine to support against seasonal influenza. In August, aft a reappraisal that recovered the benefits of the vaccine outweighed the risks, the Food and Drug Administration approved the changeable for radical ages 50 and up. 

The American Academy of Family Physicians has besides endorsed it arsenic 1 of respective recommended flu vaccines, including it among preferred options for those 65 years of property and older.

The caller vaccine was tested successful a large, randomized controlled clinical trial against a modular flu vaccine. The proceedings included 40,703 people. The radical that received the Moderna vaccine had astir 27% less cases of lab-confirmed unwellness from influenza than the radical that received the regular vaccine, with nary evident large information risks. 

Means, a salient figure wrong the “Make America Healthy Again” question and member of withdrawn surgeon wide nominee Dr. Casey Means, has distorted proceedings information and immoderate circumstances surrounding the vaccine’s support to connote successful caller interviews that the vaccine is unsafe and ineffective.

Speaking connected Joe Rogan’s podcast connected Nov. 6 aft resigning from his HHS relation past month, Means said the vaccine “didn’t work,” with an “almost negligible” simplification successful flu, and came with “massive broadside effects.” When Rogan asked him what these broadside effects were, Means replied, “It can’t beryllium definitively said, but determination were deaths.” Means did not close Rogan when, successful pursuing on with Means’ commentary, the podcast big said the vaccine would “kill people.” 

“The FDA sent a survey backmost connected the Moderna mRNA vaccine showing that determination were deaths successful the survey group, and showing that it had a paltry implicit benefit, and that determination were terrible broadside effects, and they asked for different survey to begin,” Means besides said successful a Nov. 8 interview connected CBS News’ “Face the Nation.” An advisory committee yet “approved a vaccine that the FDA thought was not harmless and effective,” helium continued.

Dr. Anna Durbin, manager of the Center for Immunization Research astatine Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, told america that Means’ statements “are not accurately reflecting the information oregon efficacy of the vaccine.” Durbin is simply a member of the FDA advisory committee that reviewed information connected the vaccine and voted unanimously that the benefits outweighed the risks.

The FDA did not find that deaths successful the proceedings were vaccine-related, arsenic we’ll explain. The bureau besides recovered the vaccine was effectual compared with a standard-dose vaccine. But due to the fact that the modular vaccine already works to trim unwellness from flu, the implicit quality was comparatively tiny — adjacent though the results showed Moderna’s vaccine was superior. In summation to providing different flu vaccine enactment now, having an approved mRNA flu vaccine level could help successful the aboriginal if determination is simply a flu pandemic, since mRNA vaccines tin beryllium rapidly updated.

Screenshot of Calley Means from CBS News’ “Face the Nation.”

Means’ remarks are besides contradicted by reporting astir the events astatine the FDA. In February, Dr. Vinay Prasad, past the Trump medication appointee successful complaint of vaccines astatine the FDA, initially prevented the bureau from reviewing Moderna’s vaccine submission, reportedly implicit the objections of FDA staff, according to STAT. Prasad objected to the plan of the superior objective proceedings utilized to trial the vaccine. The proceedings compared the mRNA vaccine to a standard-dose flu vaccine, and not the vaccines preferentially recommended for adults 65 and older.

The FDA, however, had antecedently approved Moderna’s plans, and the institution was seeking an support for radical 50 years of property and older, not lone those 65 and older. Prasad did not cite information concerns erstwhile helium initially rejected Moderna’s submission, and helium reversed his decision aft complaints from Moderna and, according to reporting from multiple news outlets, White House intervention. (The White House has denied being involved.)

Once reappraisal was permitted to begin, FDA unit and a committee of autarkic vaccine experts reviewed the information connected Moderna’s vaccine and each concluded it supported the vaccine’s approval. The committee does not o.k. vaccines but makes recommendations that the FDA past tin judge oregon reject. 

In this case, the Moderna vaccine was given afloat FDA support for those betwixt ages 50 and 64, for whom the regular vaccine is simply a modular option. The bureau gave the vaccine an accelerated support for adults 65 and up connected the ground of immune effect data, with afloat support pending a nonstop objective examination to high-dose flu vaccines. Under an accelerated approval, a vaccine is approved for usage based connected anticipation of a objective benefit, but that support tin beryllium pulled if further information bash not corroborate the benefit. That information is expected successful 2030.

We reached retired to Means, Moderna and the FDA for comment, but we did not person replies.

How Well Does the mRNA Flu Vaccine Work?

Experts acknowledged gaps successful the information connected the mRNA flu vaccine’s efficacy compared with enhanced flu vaccines, but they pushed backmost against the conception that the vaccine was approved contempt being ineffective.

“It’s different effectual influenza vaccine, arsenic acold arsenic we tin tell,” Dr. William Schaffner, a prof of infectious diseases astatine the Vanderbilt University Medical Center, told us.

Dr. Céline Gounder, an infectious illness specializer and epidemiologist and editor-at-large for nationalist wellness astatine KFF Health News, said successful comments shared via email that Means’ characterization of the vaccine arsenic having a “paltry implicit benefit” was misleading.

Photo by KMPZZZ / stock.adobe.com.

On the Joe Rogan podcast, Means specifically mentioned that the caller Moderna vaccine “had a 0.8% implicit hazard reduction, which is astir nothing.” This is simply a fig from a clinical trial that tested the shots.

“About 2% of the mRNA radical got flu versus 2.8% of the standard-shot group,” Gounder explained. “That is nether 1 percent constituent successful implicit terms, but it is measured against different vaccine, NOT against placebo.” That is to say, the mRNA vaccine successful objective trials was much effectual than modular flu shots, which already enactment to trim a person’s hazard of getting sick with flu.

Dr. Margot Savoy, main aesculapian serviceman of the American Academy of Family Physicians, told america that this works retired to the mRNA vaccine preventing “about 1 successful 4 of the flu cases that occurred contempt vaccination with an existing, FDA-licensed flu vaccine.” 

Dr. Keipp Talbot, a prof of medicine astatine Vanderbilt University who studies viral respiratory diseases successful older adults, called the betterment “modest” but told america that adjacent incremental gains successful flu vaccine efficacy tin person a “big impact,” fixed the fig of deaths and hospitalizations flu continues to cause.

Flu play successful the U.S. is underway, and the AAFP recommends that radical 6 months of property and older get a flu vaccine. The enactment has endorsed the Moderna mRNA vaccine arsenic an “age-appropriate option” for radical betwixt 50 and 64, without giving it immoderate preferential presumption implicit different disposable flu vaccines for that property group.

“A tiny implicit quality successful a azygous flu play is not astonishing erstwhile some groups person a flu vaccine,” Savoy said. “For my patients, the added payment is simply a little accidental of getting flu connected apical of the extortion a modular changeable already gives.” She said that the objective proceedings information besides bespeak radical who got the mRNA vaccine were little apt to request to question aesculapian attraction oregon get higher-level attraction for flu, though the survey “was not designed to found those outcomes definitively.” 

Talbot explained that this benignant of information connected much superior flu outcomes would travel arsenic the vaccine is utilized successful larger numbers of people.

For those 65 and up, the mRNA vaccine joins 3 preferentially recommended vaccines: 2 higher-dose shots, high-dose Fluzone and Flublok; and Fluad, a flu vaccine with an adjuvant, which boosts the immune response. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s vaccine advisory committee archetypal preferentially recommended these vaccines for this older property radical successful 2022, based connected information indicating they were much effectual than the modular shots arsenic radical aged. Older people, who are astatine higher risk of terrible complications from flu, often don’t equine arsenic beardown of an immune effect to vaccines due to the fact that the immune strategy weakens with age.

It remains unclear precisely however the mRNA vaccine compares to these preferentially recommended vaccines successful older people. Moderna tested immune responses successful astir 3,000 radical successful this older property radical randomly assigned to either get its caller vaccine oregon high-dose Fluzone, uncovering amended immune responses to the mRNA vaccine.

“I deliberation the messenger RNA vaccine astir apt is precise similar” successful efficacy to the enhanced flu vaccines already recommended for older adults, Talbot said. She explained that compared with modular flu vaccines, the mRNA vaccine offers a akin comparative betterment successful efficacy to the high-dose Fluzone vaccine. Talbot was the pb writer of the superior study demonstrating that this high-dose vaccine works amended than modular flu vaccines successful this older property group. 

The AAFP guidelines, unneurotic with guidance from different aesculapian organizations, capable a spread near by changes to the CDC’s vaccine advisory committee that would ordinarily reappraisal the information connected caller vaccines and contented recommendations connected who should instrumentality them.

In June 2025, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. disbanded and reconstituted the group, which proceeded to marque various vaccine recommendations that vaccine experts said were not rooted successful the technological evidence. A justice subsequently recovered that the caller committee had not been decently assembled nether administrative procedures and temporarily blocked its changes to vaccine recommendations. Since then, the committee has not met, and the CDC website says that recommendations for seasonal flu vaccines arsenic of July 2025 stay successful place.

Not everyone agrees that the mRNA vaccine should needfully beryllium placed connected par with the existing enhanced flu vaccines for older adults.

Schaffner, who has served connected the CDC advisory committee and its enactment groups successful the past, said helium thought that the sheet would not person included the caller vaccine among the preferred options this twelvemonth “because we don’t person capable efficacy information implicit a bid of years.”

“The nonstop examination with high-dose vaccine showed amended immune responses with the mRNA vaccine, but it wasn’t a clinical-efficacy trial,” Dr. Paul E. Sax, objective manager of infectious diseases astatine Brigham and Women’s Hospital and a prof of medicine astatine Harvard Medical School, wrote successful an opinion piece successful NEJM Voices, portion noting the accrued broadside effects aft vaccination specified arsenic soreness and headache, called reactogenicity. 

“Until we person objective grounds showing that this accrued reactogenicity buys america thing implicit the enhanced vaccines we already have, I’m sticking with those established options for my patients implicit 65,” helium said.

What’s Known About the mRNA Flu Vaccine’s Safety?

While the mRNA flu vaccine does travel with much expected and impermanent broadside effects and vaccine information monitoring is ongoing, the objective trials did not uncover superior information issues.

“We person been telling doctors that if your patients privation the mRNA vaccine, fto them cognize that they’re going to expect a spot much of a sore arm, redness and tenderness successful the arm, and possibly a small spot of fever oregon feeling puny for a time oregon so,” Schaffner said. 

In the New England Journal of Medicine article describing the objective proceedings results, the researchers reported that much than 65% of radical who got the mRNA vaccine had symptom astatine the injection site, versus conscionable astir 30% of those who got a modular vaccine, for example. About 45% of radical who received the mRNA vaccine reported fatigue, versus astir 20% of those getting the modular shot, and 38% versus 18% reported headache. 

Savoy said that accrued broadside effects specified arsenic a sore limb oregon feeling “tired oregon achy for a time oregon two” are “trade-offs” that she discusses with patients considering the caller vaccine. “Serious adverse-event rates were akin successful the published trial, though that does not mean each uncommon hazard has been ruled out,” she added.

The New England Journal of Medicine nonfiction noted that 0.2% of the radical participating successful each limb of the proceedings died, but that these deaths were not believed to beryllium related to vaccination. Some deaths are expected to hap people successful vaccine trials for reasons unrelated to the vaccines, peculiarly successful a survey colonisation with radical who are older and person assorted wellness conditions, Talbot said.

In reviewing the vaccine, FDA unit pooled information information from aggregate objective trials including much than 70,000 people, again uncovering akin rates of superior adverse events and decease among radical getting the mRNA vaccine versus the modular dose. However, aft drilling down into much circumstantial categories of death, the FDA found determination were 23 deaths from unspecified causes among radical who got the mRNA vaccine versus 9 among those who got the modular vaccine. 

“Sometimes our accusation connected decease is not precise good,” Talbot explained, and determination is nary listed cause. In the lawsuit of the unspecified deaths successful radical who received the mRNA vaccine, determination was nary autopsy information oregon systematic reappraisal of the origin of death, making it hard to find definitively what caused them, the FDA reviewers wrote.

However, the FDA reviewers noted that these deaths occurred a median of 131 days aft vaccination and determination was nary clustering of erstwhile the deaths occurred. As we’ve said, they concluded it was “unlikely” the deaths represented a information awesome related to vaccination with the mRNA vaccine, based connected the timing of the deaths, the deficiency of a quality successful full mortality betwixt proceedings arms, and the precocious complaint of wellness conditions among those who died. The FDA noted that Moderna has committed to further survey to show for deaths and definite different superior problems.

If determination were an imbalance successful full deaths among radical getting the mRNA vaccine versus the modular vaccine, “I would beryllium overmuch much concerned” than lone seeing an imbalance successful unspecified deaths, Talbot said. 

Because objective trials are not ample capable to seizure precise uncommon superior problems pursuing vaccination, she said, specified arsenic an lawsuit happening successful 1 successful a cardinal people, continued information monitoring is “really important.”

But contrary to Means’ suggestions, determination is nary overt information occupation with the Moderna vaccine, according to the objective proceedings data.


Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station Former Trump Administration Health Adviser Misleads About mRNA Flu Vaccine appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.

Read Entire Article