Flaws in Government Tool to ID Noncitizen Voters

Republican Sen. Mike Lee said that helium believes determination are “at slightest tens of thousands, astir apt hundreds of thousands” of noncitizens illegally registered to ballot successful the U.S., adding that a national instrumentality utilized successful astir 2 twelve states would assistance place the number. But the instrumentality has wrongly flagged galore arsenic being noncitizens, and there’s nary grounds of wide noncitizen voting. 

The data-matching programme employed successful those states implicit the past twelvemonth identified astir 10,000 imaginable noncitizens connected elector registration lists, retired of astir 49 cardinal elector registrations checked, according to reporting by the New York Times citing national officials. But upon further investigation, region officials recovered U.S. citizens were among those identified.

In addition, predetermination officials determined immoderate noncitizens were inadvertently added by region officials to elector lists, and inactive others were noncitizens who mistakenly checked a container for elector registration adjacent aft acknowledging connected the aforesaid forms that they were noncitizens.

Experts and authorities audits refute the thought of wide noncitizen voting.

The SAVE America Act championed by Lee — and touted by President Donald Trump arsenic indispensable to halt amerciable voting by noncitizens — would necessitate each states to taxable their elector registration lists to the Department of Homeland Security to beryllium tally done this tool, called the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements, oregon SAVE, program. The measure passed the House and is being debated successful the Senate. Lee made his comments astir noncitizens being registered to ballot successful a March 22 interrogation connected Fox News’ “Sunday Morning Futures.”

Jasleen Singh, a elder counsel and manager successful the Brennan Center for Justice’s ideology program, said that Lee’s speculation astir the fig of noncitizens connected elector registration lists amounts to “another outlandish assertion without evidence.” The reality, Singh said, is that “noncitizen voting is vanishingly rare.”

The SAVE program, Singh said, “is 1 of galore tools that predetermination officials person successful their toolbox to use. It comes with a myriad of information flaws, and immoderate results that travel straight from a hunt to the SAVE programme request to beryllium viewed with that lens and with a bully grade of skepticism.”

Acting upon an executive order from Trump successful March 2025, DHS overhauled the SAVE programme past outpouring to see Social Security data. Trump besides waived fees to states to entree the database, allowing bulk searches.

“What we bash cognize is that successful states that person started reviewing the elector registration files successful bid to weed retired those [ineligible people] who mightiness person registered, possibly inadvertently … already determination person been thousands of elector registration files identified successful conscionable the fistful of states doing their ain reviews,” Lee told the Hill connected March 20.

We reached retired to Lee’s bureau but did not get a response.

Many states — predominantly ones tally by Democrats — person refused to stock their voting lists with the SAVE program. U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi has sued 29 states and the District of Columbia for failing to supply the national authorities with their lists.

But astir 2 twelve states person utilized the SAVE program. Lee is close that “thousands” of radical person been flagged arsenic perchance being noncitizens. As we said, of the 49.5 cardinal elector registrations checked, DHS referred astir 10,000 cases to investigators, according to a Jan. 14 New York Times report that attributed the figures to a spokesperson for U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. (There were 174 cardinal radical registered to ballot successful the U.S. for the 2024 election, according to the U.S. Census. In different words, little than a 3rd of each names connected authorities elector registration lists nationwide person been tally done the SAVE program.)

But the Times reported that section predetermination officials began to observe that immoderate of the names flagged by the SAVE programme turned retired to beryllium citizens. That appeared to beryllium peculiarly existent for precocious naturalized citizens. Tens of thousands of radical are naturalized arsenic citizens each month, according to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services data.

A joint investigation by ProPublica and the Texas Tribune recovered that successful summation to galore citizens being wrongly flagged arsenic noncitizens, respective predetermination officials “came crossed instances successful which voters marked connected registration forms that they weren’t citizens, but were registered by predetermination bureau staffers successful error. Clerks besides said voters person told them they’d misunderstood questions astir eligibility erstwhile getting drivers’ licenses.”

Ongoing research by the Center for Election Innovation & Research “continues to find that sweeping allegations astir noncitizen registrations oregon voting look to originate from misunderstandings, mischaracterizations, oregon outright fabrications astir analyzable elector data. In each examined case, erstwhile claims astir ample numbers of noncitizens connected voting rolls are taxable to scrutiny and decently investigated, the fig of alleged instances falls drastically.”

Even successful the states that person utilized the national SAVE program, “Claims of ample numbers of imaginable noncitizens connected elector records are revised importantly downward aft due probe and scrutiny. Most often, investigations into ample claims uncover that astatine slightest immoderate aboriginal flags were based connected outdated, incomplete, oregon improperly matched information that incorrectly labeled eligible citizens arsenic imaginable noncitizens,” CEIR reported successful February. Those smaller, revised numbers “generally person acold little nationalist attention.”

Lee’s Home State of Utah

Interestingly, the SAVE America Act faces important absorption from the apical Republican predetermination authoritative successful Lee’s location authorities of Utah, which past twelvemonth initiated a citizenship reappraisal of each registered voters successful the state. Ultimately, officials announced successful January that they were lone capable to corroborate the authorities elector rolls included 1 noncitizen, and that idiosyncratic did not vote.

State officials archetypal compared elector records against driver’s licence data, which records citizenship status. The conclusion: 99.9% of the state’s 2 cardinal voters were citizens. But that near the presumption of 71,314 radical unclear, truthful officials checked those against the SAVE database, which narrowed the imaginable fig of noncitizens to 8,836. Staff successful the authorities elections bureau past reviewed the remaining voters’ information. That narrowed the database to 486 they could not instantly verify were citizens. Officials sent letters to everyone successful that radical and got backmost 52 responses, including galore from older voters who registered earlier the authorities required a driver’s licence oregon Social Security number.

“The bottommost enactment is, determination is not a wide problem,” Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson, a Republican, said astatine the time. “You perceive radical accidental hundreds oregon thousands — it’s conscionable not.”

Henderson, who oversees elections successful the state, wrote successful a January press release that done Utah’s citizenship review, “We besides learned that the national authorities does not support close databases.”

The SAVE program, she said, “is notoriously inaccurate and often flags individuals who are, successful fact, citizens.”

Henderson and others person besides raised concerns astir the SAVE America Act requiring states to usage the DHS database immediately, successful the midst of a midterm predetermination year.

“If we privation a national instrumentality mandating elector ID oregon DPOC [documentary impervious of citizenship], and it’s truly not astir disenfranchising a clump of voters, past states and voters request an onramp with clip to hole — get the documents, get the close ID, acceptable up the system,” Henderson wrote successful a societal media post connected March 17. “That’s not what’s happening with the SAVE America Act. This measure would beryllium effectual instantly successful the mediate of an predetermination year.”

SAVE Flaws Found successful Other States

Similar stories person played retired successful different states that utilized the SAVE program.

One of the archetypal states to instrumentality the SAVE programme was Texas, and connected Oct. 22, Texas’ caput of state, Jane Nelson, announced that it had completed a afloat examination of the state’s elector registration database against citizenship information successful the SAVE database. Calling it a “game changer,” Nelson said the SAVE programme identified 2,724 imaginable noncitizens connected the state’s elector registration rolls — oregon little than 0.02% of much than 18 cardinal voters.

Nelson said the database of those imaginable noncitizens was sent to Texas counties to behaviour investigations, with the knowing that those deemed to beryllium noncitizens would beryllium purged from elector registration lists and those who were recovered to person voted illegally would beryllium referred to the Texas lawyer wide for prosecution.

“Everyone’s close to ballot is ineffable and indispensable beryllium protected. We promote counties to behaviour rigorous investigations to find if immoderate elector is ineligible — conscionable arsenic they bash with immoderate different information acceptable we provide,” Nelson said.

But that’s wherever things began to autumn apart.

As a joint investigation by ProPublica and the Texas Tribune documented, lacking wide guidance, immoderate counties investigated; others didn’t. Some sent letters to radical connected the database and purged those who failed to respond; others didn’t purge immoderate names.

Some counties compared the names connected their database to databases kept by the Department of Public Safety, which requires impervious of citizenship if residents registry to ballot erstwhile obtaining a driver’s license. Those checks recovered galore of those connected the database identified arsenic perchance noncitizens were citizens.

In Potter County, for example, 3 of 9 voters connected the database had impervious of citizenship connected file, the ProPublica/Texas Tribune probe found. In Travis County, it was 11 of the 97 voters flagged by the SAVE program. Overall, the counties that checked the SAVE-generated database against DPS records recovered “more than 5% of the voters SAVE identified arsenic noncitizens proved to beryllium citizens,” the probe concluded.

“It has proven to beryllium inaccurate,” Travis County’s elector registrar, Celia Israel, told the publications. “Why would I trust connected it?”

While the SAVE programme accurately identified galore connected the elector registration rolls who were ineligible to vote, “Several [counties] came crossed instances successful which voters marked connected registration forms that they weren’t citizens, but were registered by predetermination bureau staffers successful error. Clerks besides said voters person told them they’d misunderstood questions astir eligibility erstwhile getting drivers’ licenses,” the ProPublica/Texas Tribune study said.

In Louisiana, the SAVE programme identified 403 imaginable noncitizens registered to vote, retired of 2.96 cardinal registered voters. That’s astir 0.014%. Of those imaginable noncitizens, 83 formed astatine slightest 1 ballot going backmost to the 1980s (though it was not wide however galore of those were aboriginal verified to beryllium noncitizens). In 2024, 2,006,975 radical voted successful the statesmanlike predetermination successful Louisiana. Even if each 83 of them voted that year, that would construe to astir 0.004% of each votes formed successful the state.

“I privation to beryllium clear: noncitizens illegally registering oregon voting is not a systemic occupation successful Louisiana,” Louisiana Secretary of State Nancy Landry said erstwhile the preliminary results were revealed past September.

Missouri besides employed the SAVE programme and generated lists of imaginable noncitizens, which it past circulated to section officials.

On Dec. 3, much than 70 region predetermination clerks from some parties wrote a letter to the state’s talker of the House warning, “These lists are profoundly flawed: they are outdated, inaccurate, and see individuals we cognize to beryllium U.S. citizens—our neighbors, colleagues, and adjacent voters we person personally registered astatine naturalization ceremonies.”

It’s not wide however galore noncitizens flagged by the SAVE database really voted. But determination person been comparatively fewer arrests nationwide for amerciable voting by noncitizens.

That makes sense, Singh told us, considering the stiff consequences for convictions for voting illegally arsenic a noncitizen. Current federal law requires those registering to ballot to attest that they are citizens nether punishment of perjury. Noncitizens convicted of voting successful national elections look fines, jailhouse clip and deportation.

“Someone who is successful this country, who whitethorn not person documents, oregon who has a ineligible beingness and is not a national yet, immoderate it is, they’re not going to hazard their quality to beryllium successful this state to formed a ballot, due to the fact that they volition beryllium taxable to deportation,” Singh said. “And it’s conscionable not a hazard that folks are, if we deliberation astir it logically and reasonably, that folks are going to beryllium consenting to take.”

According to the blimpish Heritage Foundation’s election fraud database, conscionable nether 100 noncitizens person been convicted of illegally voting oregon registering to ballot since 1982.

There whitethorn beryllium truthful fewer prosecutions, Singh said, due to the fact that by and large, erstwhile noncitizens are connected registration rolls “it’s apt a mistake oregon due to the fact that of an mistake by the idiosyncratic registering, oregon possibly the DMV … immoderate it is, it’s a mistake alternatively than an existent intentional act.”

“The grounds is that the fig of noncitizens illegally voting successful national elections is highly low, not precocious capable to person changed the enactment result of immoderate national predetermination successful caller years,” Walter Olson, a elder chap astatine the libertarian Cato Institute, told us past April. “Audits and investigations successful states similar Ohio, Nevada, and North Carolina person recovered the numbers to beryllium tiny successful narration to votes cast. … The accordant acquisition has been that precise fewer persons successful this class mistakenly oregon deliberately vote.”

---

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station Flaws successful Government Tool to ID Noncitizen Voters appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.