Experts Raise Doubts About Trump’s Dividend Payment Proposal

Q: Will U.S. citizens person stimulus oregon tariff-based checks of $2,000 successful November?

A: No checks are being issued. President Donald Trump said helium wants to usage tariff gross to springiness “dividend” payments of “at slightest $2,000″ to “middle-income radical and lower-income people.” But nary ceremonial program has been finalized and approved by Congress. Fiscal argumentation experts accidental there’s not capable tariff gross for that. 

FULL ANSWER

A bogus online post falsely claims that this period the national authorities volition contented “a $2,000 nonstop deposit outgo for eligible U.S. citizens” successful 3 phases from Nov. 10 done Nov. 30. 

There are nary specified nonstop deposits scheduled and nary checks successful the mail.

President Donald Trump has only talked about using gross collected from tariffs, oregon customs duties, connected imported overseas goods to trim the national indebtedness and marque “rebate” oregon “dividend” payments to Americans. He reiterated his wishes connected Nov. 9.

“People that are against Tariffs are FOOLS!,” Trump wrote connected Truth Social that day. “We are taking successful Trillions of Dollars and volition soon statesman paying down our ENORMOUS DEBT, $37 Trillion. Record Investment successful the USA, plants and factories going up each implicit the place. A dividend of astatine slightest $2000 a idiosyncratic (not including precocious income people!) volition beryllium paid to everyone.”

He made his transportation again the adjacent time while taking property questions successful the Oval Office.

“Without tariffs, we would beryllium — this state would beryllium successful specified trouble, arsenic they were for galore years,” helium said. “That’s wherefore we beryllium $38 trillion. And 1 of the things we’re going to do, we’re going to contented a dividend to our middle-income radical and lower-income radical of astir $2,000. And we’re going to usage the remaining tariffs to little our debt.

However, the U.S. has not made “trillions of dollars” from tariffs, arsenic the president’s remarks whitethorn suggest. He appears to get to “trillions” by counting unspecified fiscal investments successful the U.S. that companies oregon countries have pledged to make, which isn’t the aforesaid happening arsenic “trillions” successful gross for the national government. We asked the White House for an accounting of Trump’s “trillions” calculation, but we did not get a response.

Photo by Jeff McCollough / stock.adobe.com.

Multiple experts connected fiscal argumentation person pointed retired that, based connected tariff gross alone, the mathematics for Trump’s projected dividend and indebtedness outgo program doesn’t rather work.

“The President conscionable projected a $2,000 tariff ‘dividend’ for each person, excluding high-income earners,” Erica York, vice president of national taxation argumentation for the pro-business Tax Foundation, wrote successful an X thread that began connected Nov. 9. “If the cutoff is $100,000, 150M adults would qualify, for a outgo adjacent $300 billion. If kids qualify, that grows.”

“Only problem,” York said, “new tariffs person raised $120 cardinal truthful far,” though she noted that the Tax Foundation estimates that nett gross from Trump’s tariffs would adjacent astir $216 cardinal successful fiscal twelvemonth 2026, which began Oct. 1. (Including preexisting tariffs, the government, according to Treasury Department data, collected nearly $195 billion full successful customs duties successful fiscal twelvemonth 2025, which ended Sept. 30.)

The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget estimates that tariffs volition bring successful a spot much revenue: astir $300 cardinal per year, starting successful 2026. But the nonpartisan radical said that inactive whitethorn not beryllium capable depending connected who qualified for Trump’s payments.

“Assuming these dividends are designed similar the COVID-era Economic Impact Payments, which went to some adults and children, we estimation each circular of payments would outgo astir $600 billion,” CRFB said.

The afloat pandemic payments, which were made astatine 3 antithetic times betwixt 2020 and 2021, went to azygous taxation filers with little than $75,000 successful gross income and jointly filing joined couples who made little than $150,000. The payments began to signifier out, oregon were reduced, for individuals and couples earning much than those thresholds.

CRFB said that, connected a gross neutral basis, the dividend payments could beryllium made “every different year, starting successful aboriginal 2027,” if Trump planned to contented them connected a recurring basis. But if the Supreme Court agrees with little courts and rules that the bulk of the tariffs that Trump unilaterally imposed this twelvemonth are illegal, the remaining tariffs connected imports would lone rise capable wealth to marque payments aft 7 years, CRFB said.

In addition, utilizing each of the tariff gross for rebates oregon dividends would mean that determination would beryllium nary wealth near implicit to wage down the national debt, arsenic Trump besides said helium wants to do. In fact, issuing specified rebates would summation the indebtedness (which present totals $38 trillion, arsenic Trump said, including wealth the authorities owes to itself). 

“Using each the tariff gross for rebates would propulsion indebtedness to 127% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) by 2035 alternatively of 120% nether existent law; if $2,000 dividends are paid annually, indebtedness would scope 134% GDP,” CRFB said.

Furthermore, portion the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center besides estimates that tariffs Trump had announced done Oct. 23 volition rise adjacent to $300 cardinal successful 2026 ($299 billion), it said those aforesaid policies “will enforce an mean load of astir $2,600 per taxation portion successful calendar twelvemonth 2026,” reducing the economical interaction of immoderate dividend payments to individuals.

That load connected households is due to the fact that the tariffs are mostly paid by U.S. importers – not overseas countries, arsenic Trump has said – who often walk astatine slightest immoderate of their costs onto American consumers done higher prices connected goods.

The Tax Foundation estimates a little mean tariff load connected households, but it would inactive beryllium $1,600 successful 2026, the enactment says.

White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said successful a Nov. 12 property briefing that the Trump medication is superior astir trying to marque the dividend payments a reality.

“The White House is committed to making that happen, yes, and we are presently exploring each ineligible options to get that done,” she said erstwhile a newsman asked astir Trump’s caller comments. “I don’t person a timeline for you oregon immoderate further details, but I tin corroborate for you that the president made it wide helium wants to marque it happen.”

The president’s “team of economical advisers are looking into it,” she said.

In an interview connected Fox News connected Nov. 12, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said determination are “a batch of options present that the president’s talking about,” including $2,000 rebates for “families making little than, say, $100,000,” and those options are “in discussion” among White House officials.

Bessent besides suggested the taxation cuts successful the One Big Beautiful Bill Act should beryllium counted arsenic rebates to moving families.

“What we did with the taxation measure is really financing the president’s nary taxation connected tips, overtime, Social Security, and the large refunds you’re going to spot are a effect of that,” Bessent said. “So that’s different outgo to the American people.” In addition, helium said, starting adjacent year, the instrumentality volition supply $1,000 for concern accounts — alleged “Trump accounts” — for newborns. “So, that’s different $1,000 for moving families,” Bessent said.

We’d enactment that immoderate dividend payments, similar the three rounds of stimulus payments issued during the pandemic, would person to beryllium authorized by Congress.

---

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not judge advertising. We trust connected grants and idiosyncratic donations from radical similar you. Please see a donation. Credit paper donations whitethorn beryllium made through our “Donate” page. If you similar to springiness by check, nonstop to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The station Experts Raise Doubts About Trump’s Dividend Payment Proposal appeared archetypal connected FactCheck.org.