Elusive murder suspect falls victim to detectives' chewing gum sting

Detective Susan Logothetti lives her nonrecreational beingness heavy successful the past, investigating acold cases astatine the Everett Police Department, northbound of Seattle.

Det. Susan Logothetti: I emotion that radical who thought they could get distant with it 40 years agone are looking implicit their enarthrosis now, wondering what they near behind.

One lawsuit successful peculiar from 1984 came to devour her: the sidesplitting of Judy Weaver, 42, a divorced parent and a manager of a barroom and cafe.

Det. Susan Logothetti: It was called the Bel-Nes Cafe. … 1 of the roughest bars connected Hewitt Avenue, if not the roughest.

The execution of Judy Weaver

Judy Weaver was beloved by her rowdy regulars for her generous shots of hard liquor and for being a small unsmooth astir the edges herself.

Det. Susan Logothetti: She could basal up to anybody.

The erstwhile section quality queen could crook disfigured erstwhile it came to dealing with intoxicated patrons, says her daughter, Cathy Myers.

Cathy Myers: … she'd conscionable propulsion them out.

Peter Van Sant: What, drawback them by the collar and you're retired of here?

Cathy Myers: … by the backmost of the neck, backmost of the pants.

Peter Van Sant (looking astatine household photos): This is the quality queen? …

Cathy Myers: This is our ma erstwhile she was the Salmon Derby Queen …

Colleen Kayser: … uh, she was a bully mom.

Judy's different daughter, Colleen Kayser.

Colleen Kayser: She worked hard to marque definite america girls had what … we needed.

For years, it was conscionable the 3 of them  — Colleen, Cathy, and their mom. But each that changed erstwhile Judy started dating the proprietor of the bar, Bill Richards.

Cathy Myers (pointing astatine photo): This is Bill Richards, my mom's boyfriend.

They yet got engaged. Judy's daughters didn't similar him precise much.

Colleen Kayser: He didn't dainty my ma precise well. … Well, helium was mean to her. He'd outcry astatine her. He deed her a fewer times.

Peter Van Sant: Did you witnesser that?

Colleen Kayser: I ne'er witnessed it, but I've seen the bruises.

Wanting a caller start, connected the evening of June 1, 1984, Bill and Judy popped immoderate champagne.

Det. Susan Logothetti: They were celebrating the merchantability of the Bel-Nes. … they were determination with friends, and they were partying. … Judy, she got beauteous tipsy that night.

Too tipsy to thrust and excessively bushed to hold for a cab, Judy decided to locomotion location leaving Bill astatine the bar. Their flat was astir a fractional mile away. At immoderate point, on the darkened streets, Judy was spotted and followed.

Det. Susan Logothetti: … this is wherever Judy Weaver would person walked to, to travel home. That past doorway you spot down present …

Det. Susan Logothetti: Judy apt near the backmost doorway unlocked erstwhile she came home.

Peter Van Sant: She goes inside. What bash you judge happens next?

Det. Susan Logothetti: He … comes, finds the doorway unlocked and enters and attacks Judy.

About an hr later, says Logothetti, a neighbour saw fume billowing retired of Judy Weaver's apartment.

Peter Van Sant: When firefighters participate that apartment, what did they find? …

Det. Susan Logothetti: The chamber doorway was closed. When they opened it, it was filled with achromatic smoke.

Inside the smoldering chamber was Judy Weaver,  tied up and motionless.

Det. Susan Logothetti: … she was evidently deceased.

Peter Van Sant: Why bash you accidental the fishy acceptable this fire?

Det. Susan Logothetti: To screen up the grounds and destruct the scene.

Logothetti spent hours examining the carnal evidence: the soundless witnesses to murder.

Det. Susan Logothetti: This was a pillowcase recovered adjacent to Judy Weaver's body, and it's believed that it was covering her head. There's humor connected it …

Det. Susan Logothetti: … her apparel had been chopped with a weapon …

Det. Susan Logothetti: It conscionable looks similar helium did 1 consecutive changeable …

Peter Van Sant: … cutting each on this enactment you tin see.

Det. Susan Logothetti: In 1 straightened line.

Peter Van Sant: And past up here.

Det. Susan Logothetti: Because she didn't person cuts connected her body, I consciousness similar helium took his clip doing this …

Peter Van Sant: Drawing retired the terror, right.

Det. Susan Logothetti: Yes.

Peter Van Sant: And what did that suggest astir the assailant, idiosyncratic who someway took pleasance successful inflicting this benignant of symptom and ultimately, death?

Det. Susan Logothetti: He's a monster. And I didn't judge that helium hadn't done it before.

Judy Weaver was bound, sexually assaulted, and strangled.

Cathy Myers: I was told that her hands were tied and astatine that infinitesimal was erstwhile I, you know, took a 2nd for that to descend successful what that meant … and I instantly thought of Bill. And retired large I said, "Oh, my God, helium killed her this time."

Other men were questioned, but it was Judy Weaver's fiancé, Bill Richards, who emerged arsenic the premier suspect.

Cathy Myers: My lone fishy was Bill …

But determination was not capable grounds to complaint him oregon to wide him. Bill Richards died successful 1994 inactive a suspected murderer.

Det. Susan Logothetti: He was the premier fishy for 40 years …

In January 2023, this coldest of acold cases got different look. Logothetti says her brag backmost past believed caller advances successful DNA exertion mightiness yet place Judy Weaver's killer.

Det. Susan Logothetti: He … told maine that it was apt Bill Richards, but helium sent successful grounds conscionable to corroborate it.

Months later, the DNA results landed connected Logothetti's table revealing a lucifer and a name. To her surprise, that sanction was not Bill Richards.

DNA points to caller fishy with a convulsive past

Detective Logothetti hoped a four-decade-long enigma was astir to beryllium solved. In the Judy Weaver acold lawsuit determination was a DNA hit.

Peter Van Sant: And with that deed comes a name.

Det. Susan Logothetti: Yes.

Peter Van Sant: What sanction appeared?

Det. Susan Logothetti: Mitchell Allen Gaff.

A sanction she had ne'er heard.

Det. Susan Logothetti: I instantly did a regular sanction cheque and the archetypal happening I spot is Mitchell Allen Gaff is simply a Level 3 registered enactment offender and a sexually convulsive predator.

Peter Van Sant: What does a Level 3 offender mean?

Det. Susan Logothetti: They are the astir apt to reoffend.

Detective Logothetti pored implicit Mitchell Gaff's lawsuit file. He was a escaped antheral aft decades of incarceration for ultraviolent intersexual assaults. His archetypal known target: Jackie Brown.

Det. Susan Logothetti: She was a young constabulary serviceman … beauteous woman, mowing her tract and … caught Gaff's eye.

Peter Van Sant: He was conscionable retired walking successful her neighborhood, right?

Det. Susan Logothetti: … helium was.

It was the time earlier Thanksgiving 1979.

Peter Van Sant: You were successful this precise spot. Where are we close now?

Jackie Brown: We're successful the backyard of my location …

Jackie Brown: I had conscionable finished mowing the backyard …

Peter Van Sant: You're successful your store putting the lawnmower away.  What happens?

Jackie Brown (standing wrong her garage): I heard idiosyncratic yell, "Get down connected your knees and don't crook around."

Jackie Brown: Of people I turned around.

Peter Van Sant: And is helium lasting close astir wherever I am?

Jackie Brown: He's lasting close astir here.

A young man, she says, was pointing a weapon conscionable inches from her head.

Jackie Brown: He took the weapon and slammed it crossed the broadside of my head. …

Jackie Brown: He kept hitting me. …

Jackie Brown: … helium kept kneeing maine …

Jackie Brown: And I thought, "He's going to rape me." And … I conscionable kept talking. I said —

Talking, pleading and plotting. Jackie tried and failed to coax him retired of the store and into her bedroom.

Jackie Brown: Because I slept with a .38 caliber Smith & Wesson nether my pillow. … and I knew … I'd stroke his brains out. And I would have. …

Jackie Brown: And past helium said, "put your hands down your back."

In that whirlwind of fear, a puerility representation came rushing back, says Jackie. A acquisition from her father: if attacked, combat similar hell.

Jackie Brown: And helium would say, "Well, fight, fight. Kick me. What are you doing to do? … combat soiled if you person to."

When the assailant enactment down the weapon to handcuff Jackie, she turned her father's proposal into action.

Jackie Brown: And I conscionable threw my value into him … caught him disconnected defender and helium fell against the wall. …

Jackie Brown: And helium said, "I'm gonna termination you, you f****** bitch."

Jackie Brown: … each of a abrupt helium pulled retired a hunting weapon … And helium slashed maine …

Peter Van Sant: Where'd helium slash you?

Jackie Brown: Across my near palm.

Jackie Brown: … and again, I shoved him, and I conscionable ran retired of the garage.

Jackie Brown: … and I sprint down the alley …

Peter Van Sant: … are you reasoning he's close down you?

Jackie Brown: Absolutely, yes. … I was screaming for help.

Jackie Brown: So, I'm flying down the mediate of the road  …

A neighbour heard the commotion and called police. It wasn't agelong earlier Everett P.D. officers detained a antheral down by the railroad tracks, not acold away. They needed Jackie to place him. 

Jackie Brown: … erstwhile we pulled up, I looked and … we were this acold away. And I said, "That's not him." … helium wasn't wearing thing that I described.

Peter Van Sant: So, you're reasoning they got the incorrect guy.

Jackie Brown: They got the incorrect guy. Yep.

She started to leave, but thing wrong Jackie caused her to crook around.

Jackie Brown: And I – I said, "Say thing to me." And I said it again truly large and helium turned and helium said, 'What the f*** bash you privation maine to say?" And arsenic soon arsenic helium said that I knew it was him.

Peter Van Sant: Wow.

Jackie Brown: I lunged for him.

Peter Van Sant: You lunged for him?

Jackie Brown: I lunged for him.

Her attacker – past 21-year-old Mitchell Gaff – was arrested.  Police aboriginal recovered his duffle bag, which contained the apparel helium had worn during the attack. Gaff was convicted of battle with a deadly weapon. But, arsenic a first-time offender, helium was sentenced to 1 twelvemonth of enactment merchandise and 5 years of probation. 

Peter Van Sant: What was that similar for you to cognize helium was retired connected the street?

Jackie Brown: Awful, awful. He got to transportation connected with his life, and it changed excavation forever.

Combing done the lawsuit file, Logothetti began connecting the dots. She realized that Mitchell Gaff was inactive connected probation for the Jackie Brown battle erstwhile Judy Weaver was murdered successful June 1984. By the extremity of August, Gaff struck again.

Det. Susan Logothetti: … this location close here, is the location wherever the teenage sisters, Angela and Myra, were attacked and assaulted by Mitchell Gaff successful August of 1984.

Det. Susan Logothetti: Angela was 14. Myra was 16.

It was adjacent to midnight. They were some asleep: Angela connected the surviving country sofa … Myra down the hallway successful her chamber …

Det. Susan Logothetti: … the beforehand doorway was unlocked …

Mitchell Gaff slowly, silently, crept into the house, says Logothetti, collecting cords for ligatures and a weapon from the kitchen.

Det. Susan Logothetti: After helium recovered the items helium wanted, successful — wrong the home, helium went to Angela first.

Angela: … helium grabbed maine by my hairsbreadth and pushed my caput backmost and had a weapon to my pharynx and said if you scream, I'm going to slit your throat.

In a 1996 interrogation connected "60 Minutes Australia," Angela and Myra, past 27 and 29, relived the astir terrifying two-and-a-half hours of their lives.

Myra: … immoderate cloth was shoved each the mode down my throat, and a gag was enactment on, and a pillowcase thrown implicit my head.

And then, Mitchell Gaff tied up the teenage sisters.

Det. Susan Logothetti: … and helium proceeds to rape each of them …

Peter Van Sant: Was it headed toward a sidesplitting past of 2 young girls?

Det. Susan Logothetti: One 100 percent. … He grabs a stroke dryer and uses the cord to strangle Angela.

Myra: … but he's choking her, right? He's sidesplitting her and it's my content that he's going to termination her. And my absorption was to support her, of course.

Myra took her escaped limb and started kicking him and screaming.

Myra: … helium mislaid power and came implicit and conscionable bushed maine to a pulp. …

Angela: He went implicit to commencement hitting her, and I conscionable each the abrupt got up. Got up and conscionable took disconnected retired the door.

Peter Van Sant: She comes retired of that beforehand door. She's sprinting. Where does she go? …

Det. Susan Logothetti: She comes close implicit present to this house, her neighbor's location implicit here.

That gave Angela clip to tally for assistance …

Angela: I was naked. … and I ran acr — down my gait each the mode through, crossed the thoroughfare to the next-door neighbour …

Det. Susan Logothetti: She couldn't recognize wherefore she couldn't scream. And she realized that this blow-dryer cord was inactive wrapped tightly, knotted astir her neck. So, she took the stroke dryer …

Angela: … and started hitting their doorway with the stroke dryer that was astir my neck. 

Peter Van Sant: And what does Angela shout?

Det. Susan Logothetti: "He's sidesplitting Myra. He's sidesplitting Myra."

Horrified neighbors called police.

Det. Susan Logothetti: … and turned conscionable successful clip to spot Gaff tally retired the beforehand doorway … afloat bare … and tally disconnected into the darkness.

Myra and Angela had saved each other.

Mitchell Gaff was arrested astir a week aboriginal successful September 1984. Married with a large wife, Gaff was convicted of aggravated rape and served 10 years successful prison. Considered excessively unsafe to release, helium was sent to McNeil Island successful Washington for therapeutic treatment, and, possibly, indefinite civilian detention.

Tom Junod: The lone mode that these guys could get retired was to person radical that they were nary longer a threat.

Tom Junod has authored dozens of acclaimed articles and written his archetypal book, a memoir. In 1995, helium profiled Mitchell Gaff for GQ Magazine. Junod spent respective days with the antheral prosecutors person called, "The Boogeyman," and was struck by his mellow demeanor.

Peter Van Sant: Did you ever spot connected his face, successful his eyes, a flash of danger?

Tom Junod: I saw a flash of vacancy. … erstwhile you look into the eyes of a shark, they don't look similar they hatred you. They look similar they don't attraction astir you. … And that was Mitchell Gaff.

Gaff was released successful 2018, having spent 23 years successful civilian confinement and successful therapy.

Det. Susan Logothetti: There were immoderate professionals determination … who did deliberation that they had cured him.

Since then, Logothetti says, Gaff became a Buddhist, joined a man and changed his sanction to Sam Wise Price. 

Logothetti said Gaff, present successful his 60s, appears to beryllium surviving a peaceful life. But knowing his convulsive past, Logothetti shifted her absorption backmost 40 years to the Judy Weaver execution and that DNA breakthrough linking Gaff to her killing. But Logothetti said she present needed a caller illustration to fastener him up for good. Logothetti had a plan, that centered connected a instrumentality of chewing gum.

Susan Logothetti: I truly thought it was a agelong shot.

The chewing gum sting

It was bold, ingenious and risky.

Peter Van Sant: … the detective usually goes successful with a SWAT team. You're present equipped with bubble gum. Is that right?

Det. Susan Logothetti: We had gum. Yeah.

Detective Susan Logothetti believed Mitchell Gaff had gotten distant with murdering Judy Weaver for astir 40 years. She was going to alteration that. But archetypal she had to beryllium it. 

Det. Susan Logothetti: This is … items that we utilized successful the gum ruse.

And proving it meant coming up with a program to cod caller DNA from her premier fishy — a program that progressive going undercover to fool Gaff into sampling immoderate chewing gum.

Det. Susan Logothetti: … we were gonna correspond a steadfast vigor gum enactment that we were launching astatine Safeway. And it was called —

Peter Van Sant: What was the sanction of this company?

Det. Susan Logothetti:  — Energy Gum.

They knew from surveillance that Gaff seldom near the home. So, they decided to spell to him.

Det. Susan Logothetti:  I tried to doll up a small spot that time … hoping that would assistance our chances.

On the greeting of Jan. 17, 2024, 3 detectives, clad successful their Zolt Energy T-shirts, knocked connected Mitchell Gaff's beforehand door.

Det. Susan Logothetti: And helium kinda opens the doorway a ace … and we commencement giving our gum excitement spiel.

Det. Susan Logothetti (holding sticks of gum): This is what the gum looked like.

They gave him 4 unmarked pieces to comparison 2 flavors, watermelon and tropical fruit. 

Det. Susan Logothetti: Gaff went with it. He chewed that gum. … it was similar helium was astatine a vino tasting … He was talking astir the notes of this and hints of that.

Peter Van Sant: … you're benignant of a gum sommelier …

Det. Susan Logothetti: Oh, yeah. … I'm penning notes. "Oh, oh." … helium got into it.

After each tasting, helium would spit the gum into a instrumentality held by 1 of the different detectives.

Det. Susan Logothetti: … I could spot the saliva coming retired of his mouth, connected the gum, successful the container.

Peter Van Sant: Exactly what you needed to bash a DNA test.

Det. Susan Logothetti: Yes.  

After astir 30 minutes, they said their goodbyes. Logothetti instantly sent the chewed gum to the transgression laboratory and the results came backmost successful grounds time.

Det. Susan Logothetti: Everything was confirmed arsenic acold arsenic the DNA. There was vaginal swabs … her shirt, the ligatures. …

Peter Van Sant: They each matched to Mitchell Gaff.

Det. Susan Logothetti: They each matched.

Police showed up astatine The Lucky Lunchbox, Gaff's favourite meal spot looking for Sam — Mitchell Gaff's caller name.

OFFICER (bodycam): There's immoderate detectives that would similar to speech to you down astatine the constabulary presumption ...

MITCHELL GAFF: That's interesting.

OFFICER: Yes.

MITCHELL GAFF: Know what it's about?

Det. Susan Logothetti: … helium was wholly disconnected guard.

OFFICER (bodycam): Uh, earlier we fto you in, we conscionable gotta pat you down for weapons …

OFFICER: I'll clasp your sandwich …

MITCHELL GAFF: Do I need, uh, similar ID oregon anything, or?

OFFICER: Eh, no. We cognize who you are.

When they get astatine the section sheriff's office, Gaff is led up the stairs to the interrogation room.

Detective Logothetti, whom Gaff didn't look to admit arsenic the Zolt gum tester, yet has him wherever she wants him. She mildly broaches the taxable astatine hand.

DET. LOGOTHETTI: Hi. I'm Susie Logothetti …

DET. LOGOTHETTI: … well, you must, you know, wonderment wherefore we're here.

MITCHELL GAFF: Oh, yeah. 'Cause close now, yeah, my anxiousness and my adrenaline are disconnected the chart. I'm like, what the hell.

DET. LOGOTHETTI: OK. …

MITCHELL GAFF: I'm frightened what this is astir due to the fact that beatified crap. I've been retired – retired for a while. I've done thing and –

Detectives Logothetti and Karen Kowalchyk backmost disconnected the taxable until Gaff can't instrumentality the suspense immoderate longer.

MITCHELL GAFF: Why are we here?

DET. LOGOTHETTI: What — um.

MITCHELL GAFF: Why are we here?

Peter Van Sant: You didn't reply that?

Det. Susan Logothetti: No.

Peter Van Sant: OK. You privation to clasp off?

Det. Susan Logothetti: I did clasp off.

Instead, she steers the speech to the crimes helium was convicted of.

Det. Susan Logothetti: I wanted him to speech astir however helium picked women that helium raped.

MITCHELL GAFF (police interview): … I hatred to enactment it successful benignant of terms, but you ever spot the mode a feline gets excited by speedy question oregon thing and — and it — and it — it triggers something? It's benignant of similar that. Something triggered, you know?

He says helium ne'er attacked anyone helium knew. It was easier that way.

MITCHELL GAFF (police interview): … radical were not people, they were objects. It's conscionable a — if I had to admit humanity. If I had to admit a personhood. Would person been harder to do.

He starts talking astir the nighttime helium sexually abused the teen sisters. Even though 1 of the sisters says helium stalked her aft spotting her astatine a section angiosperm shop, Gaff denies it.

MITCHELL GAFF (police interview): … I didn't person anyone picked out. … I ne'er met them. I ne'er saw them. I did not cognize …

Logothetti doesn't situation his account, though she knows from her conversations with the sisters that helium is lying.

Det. Susan Logothetti: Mitchell Gaff … portion helium was raping Myra and Angela told her, "I came present for you, but I couldn't walk up the small treasure that was connected the couch," meaning her sister.

He does admit, however, that helium would person killed them if Angela hadn't made that escape.

MITCHELL GAFF: I deliberation I had, yeah. I deliberation I had decided that I needed to termination them ...

The detective past circles backmost to Judy Weaver.

DET. LOGOTHETTI: There is … an incidental successful — that happened successful Everett where, uh, determination was a CODIS deed to your DNA. And that's kinda what brought america present today. …

DET. LOGOTHETTI: I mean, bash you person immoderate thought what it could person been linked to?

MITCHELL GAFF: No. I committed respective rapes, truthful I don't know.

Mitchell Gaff could spot wherever this speech was going.

MITCHELL GAFF: I don't cognize however hard I should effort to convict myself.

DET. LOGOTHETTI: What bash you mean by that?

MITCHELL GAFF: Well, I evidently bash not privation to spell backmost to situation for thing that happened 40 f****** years agone … I'm conscionable f****** heartbroken.

Det. Susan Logothetti: I gave him a transcript of … the warrant.

DET. LOGOTHETTI: … springiness you a transcript of that. …

MITCHELL GAFF: This says "murder."

DET. LOGOTHETTI: Yeah.

Det. Susan Logothetti: And past helium went into denial mode. He was like, "what? …Wait a minute, this says murder. I didn't termination anyone."

MITCHELL GAFF: Nobody died. I mean, she was fine.

DET. LOGOTHETTI: … the happening is, is she wasn't fine. Um, I deliberation you cognize that heavy down.

DET. LOGOTHETTI (shows a photograph of  Judy Weaver): … determination she is.

MITCHELL GAFF: … nary idea. I don't cognize who that is.

DET. LOGOTHETTI: OK. …

DET. LOGOTHETTI: I mean, there's gonna beryllium DNA each implicit her body.

MITCHELL GAFF: OK. … I don't retrieve this, but OK. I truly don't. Um.

The detectives instrumentality DNA swabs.

MITCHELL GAFF: This is truly bad. This isn't a rape, this is f****** murder. So, deliberation I should astir apt person immoderate ineligible advice.

DET. LOGOTHETTI: … astatine this point, you're going to beryllium placed nether apprehension for the execution of Judith Weaver.

The elusive slayer undone by a portion of chewing gum.

Detective links Mitchell Gaff to 2nd acold lawsuit murder

In January 2025, Detective Susan Logothetti was successful the heavy of the Judy Weaver execution probe and preparing for trial. The past happening she expected was this voicemail:

KEN VESEY (voicemail): My sanction is Ken Vesey. … My woman was murdered … connected July 12 of 1980. You guys person stumbled through, done perfectly thing astir it.

Logothetti had ne'er heard the sanction Ken Vesey before. But that didn't halt her.

Det. Susan Logothetti: I called him instantly … I fto him cognize that … I was unfamiliar with the case. And I — I was hoping you could archer maine more.

And so, helium did. Ken described successful horrifying item uncovering his 21-year-old woman Susan Vesey hogtied connected the level of her bedroom, sexually violated and strangled.

Det. Susan Logothetti: I said to him, I request to spell get your wife's file, and I'm gonna telephone you back. … I spent each nighttime speechmaking the file. During that time, I talked to Ken Vesey a lot.

Ken Vesey had lived nether a shadiness of uncertainty for much than 40 years arsenic a fishy successful his wife's murder. But Logothetti saw the sinister signature of different antheral successful those pages — Mitchell Gaff. It was each there: the strangulation, the electrical cords —

SUSAN LOGOTHETTI (showing evidence): This would person been portion of the cervix ligature arsenic good …

PETER VAN SANT (holding ligature): So, this went ..  astir her neck?

SUSAN LOGOTHETTI: It did.

— the apparel chopped off.

SUSAN LOGOTHETTI: So, these are Susan's jeans that she was wearing the time of …

Det. Susan Logothetti: I called the forensic idiosyncratic … and I asked, tin I nonstop immoderate grounds up successful this 1980 lawsuit to beryllium compared with Mitchell Gaff's DNA that we got successful the gum ruse?

The reply was yes. Three months later, the study was successful her inbox. Mitchell Gaff's DNA was each implicit the Susan Vesey transgression scene.

One of the archetypal calls Logothetti made was to Ken Vesey. 

Det. Susan Logothetti: I said, "We got him." I said, "It is – it was Mitchell Gaff."

Prosecutor Craig Matheson, who was preparing for proceedings successful the Judy Weaver case, instantly deed Mitchell Gaff with a 2nd charge: the execution of Susan Vesey.

Prosecutor Craig Matheson: So it was astatine that point, you know, crippled on.

But Matheson and his co-counsel Sarah Johnson knew the Vesey lawsuit would beryllium tough.

Prosecutor Sarah Johnson: We didn't cognize if determination was anyone live who had been successful the transgression country who could speech astir what they saw … But thankfully, Mike Perin was determination and helium remembered everything.

Mike Perin was a young detective astatine the time.

Peter Van Sant: What bash you spot arsenic you participate the apartment? …

Det. Mike Perin: I saw the worldly that makes nightmares. … The idiosyncratic who we aboriginal identified arsenic Susan Vesey was connected her backmost … deceased. … motion that she'd been abused sexually and astir apt tortured also.

Det. Mike Perin (emotional): Whoever did that had a batch of hatred … There's immoderate things that humans aren't meant to see. … this is 1 of those times. It's an representation that is, it's arsenic wide present arsenic it was 47 years ago.

Detective Perin aboriginal learned that Susan's 2-year-old girl and 3-month-old lad Josh had been recovered live successful the apartment; Josh connected the furniture adjacent to wherever his parent laic dead.

Det. Mike Perin: … conscionable to this day, I convey God that helium spared some the children.

Ken Vesey was the 1 who called 911. At the time, Ken and Susan were getting backmost unneurotic aft a little split. He told detectives helium had worked the graveyard displacement astatine a state presumption the nighttime of the murder. When helium returned to the flat astir 10:30 the greeting of July 12, the doorway was locked. He climbed up the balcony and entered the apartment. He grabbed a weapon to chopped immoderate of the ligatures off 

Det. Mike Perin: He tried to bash some mouth-to-mouth and thorax compressions. That didn't work. It was mode excessively late.

Peter Van Sant: Your instinct told you what astir Ken's communicative … Was helium credible to you?

Det. Mike Perin: He was credible. … helium was arsenic upset arsenic immoderate quality I've ever seen.

Despite having an airtight alibi – witnesses corroborated helium was astatine enactment – immoderate detectives connected the lawsuit continued to judge Ken someway was the killer.

Paula Keeler: I knew it couldn't beryllium Ken. He loved her. She was the emotion of his life, you cognize …

Paula Keeler and Susan Vesey were champion friends since childhood.

Paula Keeler: We were psyche sisters. … determination was a batch of unconditional emotion betwixt the 2 of america … she was a pistillate who loved beingness and loved radical …

And who ever longed to beryllium a mother.

Paula Keeler: Susan was precise loving, nurturing mother, a precise caring mother, precise attentive parent …

Susan Vesey turned 21 connected July 11, 1980 – the time earlier she was discovered dead. The 2 friends, who astatine the clip lived 4 hours apart, spoke connected the telephone for the past clip connected Susan's birthday.

Paula Keeler: We would ever say, "I emotion you," and those were her past words to me.

Decades passed without answers — 45 years of heartbreak earlier Det. Logothetti made her breakthrough.

Paula Keeler: … she recovered him. She recovered him.

Mitchell Gaff pleads guilty

Jackie Brown: … it's changed my life.

Myra: I'm acrophobic to beryllium unsocial …

Angela: He knows however overmuch we're hurt. He did it to us.

They were antithetic ages from antithetic walks of life. Some lived.

Peter Van Sant: How fortunate bash you consciousness contiguous that you are alive?

Jackie Brown: Very lucky. Very, precise lucky.

Some didn't.

Paula Keeler: It's a immense loss.

But they each had 1 happening successful common: a antheral named Mitchell Gaff. 

Prosecutor Sarah Johnson: I would accidental that Mitchell Gaff is the worst transgression that I've ever travel crossed successful my enactment of work. … Not lone the fig of crimes that he's committed, but conscionable the scope of however genuinely unspeakable each of his crimes were.

Mitchell Gaff was yet slated to basal proceedings for the murders of Judy Weaver and Susan Vesey successful September 2026. But it would ne'er happen. He pleaded blameworthy 5 months earlier it was scheduled to start.

Prosecutor Craig Matheson: I deliberation helium saw the spot of the lawsuit and — and knew what was going to hap if we ended up successful beforehand of the jury.

One period aft his blameworthy plea, Mitchell Gaff appears successful tribunal for sentencing.

Lead authoritative Craig Matheson makes his lawsuit for 61 years down bars. He begins with the predatory randomness of the murders.

PROSECUTOR MATHESON (in court): Susan Vesey is dormant due to the fact that her beforehand doorway was unlocked … Judy Weaver made the mistake of arriving location conscionable arsenic the suspect drove by, and she caught his attraction …

Matheson spells retired his motive: getting pleasance from watching them endure and die.

PROSECUTOR MATHESON: … to satiate his intersexual appetite.

PROSECUTOR MATHESON: He had already taken from them everything that helium could person wanted, yet helium inactive decided to termination them both.

Defense Attorney Heather Wolfenbarger counters with what she claims are mitigating circumstances: his property — and his years of therapeutic attraction portion incarcerated.

DEFENSE ATTORNEY HEATHER WOLFENBARGER: … and yet we present person this idiosyncratic who is astir 70 years aged …

DEFENSE ATTORNEY WOLFENBARGER: He is simply not the aforesaid idiosyncratic that helium was then.

DEFENSE ATTORNEY WOLFENBARGER: … we're asking for, we're just—just to enforce the statutory, mandatory minimum of 20 years.

Friends and families of Susan Vesey and Judy Weaver past code the quality toll.

Judy's nephew, Ernest Bennett, describes seeing his parent – Judy's sister – collapsed successful grief aft proceeding the news.  

ERNEST BENNETT(in court): I locomotion down the hallway … to spot my ma connected the level connected her knees, hands implicit her head, screaming, yelling, crying, sobbing uncontrollably … That infinitesimal is burned into my memory. It has ne'er near me.

Susan Vesey's champion friend, Paula Keeler, is inactive haunted by the details of Susan's convulsive death. 

PAULA KEELER (in court): There are nary words that tin afloat seizure what Sue endured successful her last moments … Her 2 young children were present. Her children were present. While they survived physically, their lives and each of our lives were permanently changed.

Susan's son, Josh Vesey – the 3-month-old babe who was successful the country erstwhile his parent was killed – met america extracurricular the location wherever the transgression occurred and described a antithetic benignant of grief.

Josh Vesey: I'm grieving ne'er having immoderate representation of her, right? I ne'er had a mother's unconditional love.

And helium watched his father, Ken Vesey, unrecorded nether the crushing presumption of guilt. 

Josh Vesey: … the suspicions were ever determination … And helium was ever a fishy … It was astir apt the worst infinitesimal of his beingness that helium had to relive each azygous time for 46 years.

In a cruel twist, Ken Vesey would ne'er get the accidental to look his wife's slayer arsenic a vindicated man.

Det. Susan Logothetti: … connected July 12 of 2025 … the aforesaid time Susan was found, 45 years to the day, Ken Vesey died.

Lastly, Jackie Brown, Mitchell Gaff's archetypal known victim, gives her statement. 

JACKIE BROWN (in court): I nary longer play euphony oregon the vigor successful my house. I indispensable beryllium capable to perceive each small noise. … Your Honor, my nightmare occurred 47 years ago, but it seems similar yesterday. … I anticipation your condemnation keeps him successful situation until his death, Your Honor. Thank you.

Mitchell Gaff, who present goes by the sanction Sam Price, besides addresses the court.

MITCHELL GAFF: I travel to you earlier to instrumentality afloat accountability for my actions, behaviors, and crimes related to the 1980 and 1984 rapes and murders …

But helium puts immoderate of the blasted connected drugs and intoxicant and claims helium is simply a changed man.

MITCHELL GAFF: … during the past 40 years successful my hunt for sobriety, sanity, and spirituality, I person spent implicit 30 years successful Buddhist survey and Zen meditation.

Paula Keeler: I don't deliberation he's remorseful astatine all. I deliberation he's conscionable moving the tribunal strategy to get retired of it what helium could get retired of it.

Author Tom Junod — who spent hours with Gaff successful the 1990s reporting that communicative for GQ Magazine astir a therapeutic programme for incarcerated enactment offenders — believes Gaff conned his therapists into releasing him, portion helium fundamentally remained the predator helium ever was.

Tom Junod: … 1 of the things that you can't hide was that helium was cruel. He was a sadist, and helium got disconnected connected sadism.

Judge Edirin Okoloko sentenced Mitchell Gaff to 50 years successful situation — astatine his age, a certainty that helium volition dice down bars. For the archetypal clip successful 47 years, Jackie Brown believes she tin reclaim what she'd mislaid – possibly adjacent commencement listening to euphony again. 

Jackie Brown: I volition hide it now. I'm determined with the condemnation that Judge Okoloko enactment connected Gaff this clip …

Paula Keeler hopes Susan Vesey tin present shed the calamity that overshadowed her life.

Paula Keeler: I don't privation her to beryllium defined by however she near this world. I privation her to beryllium defined by the astonishing idiosyncratic that she is, what she stood for successful her beingness and what she lived for portion she had the abbreviated beingness that she had.

As the sentencing proceeding ends,  Logothetti approaches the antheral she pursued arsenic relentlessly arsenic helium pursued the women helium attacked.

Det. Susan Logothetti: It was important for maine to handcuff him myself. … He was a — a predator of women … I conscionable felt similar for his victims, a pistillate should beryllium the 1 putting the handcuffs connected him and walking him into custody wherever helium wasn't gonna beryllium escaped again.

---

Produced by Mead Stone  and Liza Finley. Greg Fisher, Cindy Cesare and David Dow are the improvement producers. Michael Loftus and Gabriella Demirdjian are the tract producers. Mead Stone, Atticus Brady and Michael Baluzy are the editors. Patti Aronofsky is the elder producer. Nancy Kramer is the enforcement communicative editor. Judy Tygard is the enforcement producer.

This communicative published first connected CBS News astatine 10:57 p.m. connected Oct. 17, 2026.

In:

• 48 Hours
• Cold Case
• Murder
• Washington