EEOC chief shift focus to investigating DEI but her methods provoke outcries

ARLINGTON, Va. – The acting main of the apical national bureau for protecting idiosyncratic rights has signaled a pivot toward prioritizing President Donald Trump's run to stamp retired diversity, equity and inclusion programs successful the backstage and nationalist sectors.

The archetypal steps taking by Andrea Lucas, acting main of the Equal Opportunity Employment Commission, person earned her beardown backing from the Trump administration, which has moved against DEI done embattled enforcement orders that dismantled programs astatine national agencies and threatened investigations and stiff fiscal penalties for national contractors that prosecute successful “illegal” diversity-related practices. Trump precocious nominated Lucas to a caller five-year word arsenic commissioner.

But erstwhile Democratic EEOC officials and salient civilian rights groups person accused Lucas of taking shortcuts that supersede her authorization and they person urged employers to beryllium wary of her directives and guidance, if not altogether disregard them.

The astir caller flashpoint involves 2 “technical assistance” documents issued by the EEOC on with the Department of Justice attempting to clarify what mightiness represent “DEI-related Discrimination astatine Work" and providing guidance connected however workers tin record complaints implicit specified concerns.

The documents instrumentality wide purpose astatine practices specified arsenic training, employment resources radical and fellowship programs, informing specified programs — depending connected however they're constructed — could tally afoul of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which prohibits employment favoritism based connected contention and gender.

The documents followed letters that Lucas sent to 20 salient instrumentality firms demanding accusation astir diverseness fellowships and different programs she claimed could beryllium grounds of discriminatory practices.

A radical of 10 erstwhile Democratic commissioners and counsels released its ain missive Thursday informing the ineligible assemblage the DEI documents springiness the misleading content that communal programs “are fraught with ineligible peril" and dismissed them arsenic reflecting Lucas's “personal opinion.” The missive offered counter-guidance connected however employers should proceed implementing grooming and different practices that EEOC argumentation documents promote to forestall discrimination.

Last month, 7 of the aforesaid erstwhile EEOC officials sent Lucas a missive informing that she appeared to transcend her authorization with her demands for accusation from the 20 instrumentality firms without archetypal launching a ceremonial investigation. A radical of salient civilian rights organizations went a measurement further successful their ain missive to Lucas, urging the instrumentality firms to disregard her demands due to the fact that they person nary ineligible work to reply.

“This isn’t however the EEOC works. No azygous commissioner — not adjacent the Chair — has the authorization to nonstop threatening letters demanding backstage accusation from employers," said Noreen Farrell, manager of Equal Rights Advocates, 1 of the civilian rights organizations that signed onto the effect led by the National Women's Law Center. "The EEOC Chair can’t conscionable rewrite decades of settled civilian rights instrumentality with a hastily written memo.”

Jenny Yang, a erstwhile EEOC commissioner nether President Barack Obama, said Lucas’ letters to the 20 instrumentality firms were without precedent astatine the EEOC, which initiates astir investigations successful effect to complaints filed by workers. In precise uncommon cases, a commissioner tin record their ain complaint against an leader but it wouldn’t beryllium made nationalist and would necessitate the commissioner to supply grounds of imaginable favoritism nether punishment of perjury, Yang said.

Law firms — including immoderate of the 20 targeted by Lucas — are already coming nether unit to alteration their attack to diverseness and inclusion successful effect to abstracted Trump enforcement orders designed to punish them for taking connected the president’s rivals arsenic clients and different actions that person angered him. For example, Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom precocious learned that the president intended to contented an bid targeting it implicit its pro bono ineligible enactment and its diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. The steadfast has consequently agreed to reappraisal its hiring practices, among different things.

The 20 instrumentality firms targeted successful Lucas’ letters did not respond to questions from The Associated Press astir whether they intended to respond to her demands. Lucas did not respond to petition for remark connected the DEI method assistance documents, and the EEOC declined to accidental whether the instrumentality firms person immoderate ineligible work to respond to her letters oregon whether they would look immoderate punishment for not doing so.

But Lucas, a Republican who was archetypal appointed to the EEOC successful 2020, has agelong argued that she is not reinterpreting civilian rights laws but alternatively sounding the alarm that galore companies person adopted DEI practices that transverse the enactment into discrimination. Lucas has argued the EEOC has turned a unsighted oculus to risky institution practices, which she said proliferated particularly aft the 2020 radical justness protests that followed the constabulary sidesplitting of George Floyd.

“Far excessively galore employers support definite types of contention oregon enactment preferences arsenic good, provided they are motivated by concern interests successful ‘diversity, equity, oregon inclusion.’,” Lucas said successful a connection announcing the caller method assistance connected DEI.

Many employers are apt to instrumentality heed of her warnings arsenic the EEOC signals that it volition beryllium go a almighty state to workers claiming favoritism stemming from DEI practices.

Anuradha Hebbar, president of CEO Action for Inclusion & Diversity, an limb of the influential Society for Human Resource Management, said the EEOC has particularly makes wide that companies should debar fellowships, internships and different programs that are lone unfastened to women oregon definite radical groups.

Stefan Padfield of blimpish deliberation vessel National Center for Public Policy Research praised the EEOC's the displacement arsenic a much-needed people correction that volition unfastened the floodgates for complaints against DEI practices that should beryllium deemed illegal.

Lucas has acknowledged that she cannot unilaterally alteration immoderate of the agency's guidelines and policies that whitethorn contradict Trump's slew of enforcement orders, though the EEOC has already moved to driblet 7 lawsuits alleging favoritism against transgender and nonbinary radical in effect to a statesmanlike order declaring the authorities would lone admit the antheral and pistillate genders.

Changing specified policies — including the EEOC's five-year strategical enforcement program that pledges enactment for DEI — would necessitate a bulk ballot by the agency's 5 commissioners. But Trump recently fired 2 of those commissioners — some Democrats — earlier their presumption expired successful a determination that upended 60 years of precedent for an bureau established by Congress arsenic autarkic and bipartisan.

In their missive Thursday, the erstwhile EEOC officials accused Lucas of cherry-picking uncommon instances of favoritism to convey the connection that grooming and different DEI practices are inherently risky erstwhile successful information astir are legally sound.

“Our national civilian rights offices and officials should not beryllium intimidating oregon discouraging employers who are moving to beforehand these goals,” the missive said.

________

The Associated Press’ women successful the workforce and authorities authorities sum receives fiscal enactment from Pivotal Ventures. AP is solely liable for each content. Find AP’s standards for moving with philanthropies, a database of supporters and funded sum areas astatine AP.org.

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.