DOGE trumpets unemployment fraud that government already found

NEW YORK – The latest authorities discarded touted by billionaire Elon Musk's cost-cutting Department of Government Efficiency is hundreds of millions of dollars successful fraudulent unemployment claims it purportedly uncovered.

One problem: Federal investigators already recovered what appears to beryllium the aforesaid fraud, years earlier and connected a acold greater scale.

In a station past week connected X, the societal media tract Musk owns, DOGE announced “an archetypal survey of unemployment security claims since 2020” recovered 24,500 radical implicit the property of 115 had claimed $59 cardinal successful benefits; 28,000 radical betwixt the ages of 1 and 5 collected $254 million; and 9,700 radical with birthdates much than 15 years successful the aboriginal garnered $69 cardinal from the government.

The tweet drew a predictable party-line absorption of either skepticism oregon cheers, including from Musk himself, who said what his squad recovered was “so crazy” helium re-read it respective times earlier it sank in.

“Another unthinkable discovery,” marveled Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer, who repeated DOGE’s findings to President Donald Trump successful a Cabinet gathering past week.

Chavez-DeRemer’s recounting of the alleged fraud, including claims of benefits filed by unborn children, drew laughter successful the Cabinet country and a absorption from Trump himself.

“Those numbers are truly bad,” helium said.

But Chavez-DeRemer needn't look further than her ain department’s Office of the Inspector General to find specified fraud had already been reported by the benignant of national workers DOGE has demonized.

“They’re trying to rotation this communicative of, ‘Oh, authorities is inefficient and authorities is anserine and they’re catching these things that the authorities didn’t catch,’” says Michele Evermore, who worked connected unemployment issues astatine the U.S. Department of Labor during the medication of erstwhile President Joe Biden. “They’re uncovering fraud that was marked arsenic fraud and saying they recovered retired it was fraud.”

The Social Security Act of 1935 enshrined unemployment benefits successful national law but near it to idiosyncratic states to acceptable up systems to cod unemployment taxes, process applications and mete retired support.

Though states person astir implicit power implicit their ain unemployment systems, peculiar alleviation programs — astir notably widely expanded benefits enacted by the archetypal Trump medication astatine the outset of the COVID pandemic — inject much nonstop national engagement and a flood of caller beneficiaries into the system.

In regular times, authorities unemployment systems execute “very well, not truthful good and terribly,” according to Stephen Wandner, an economist astatine the National Academy of Social Insurance who authored the publication “Unemployment Insurance Reform: Fixing a Broken System.” With COVID slamming the system and creating a flood of caller claims that states couldn’t handle, Wandner says galore much were “quite terrible.”

Trump signed the COVID unemployment alleviation into instrumentality connected March 27, 2020, and from the precise commencement it became a magnet for fraud. In a memo to authorities officials astir 2 weeks later, the Department of Labor warned that the expanded benefits had made unemployment programs “a people for fraud with important numbers of imposter claims being filed with stolen oregon synthetic identities.”

That aforesaid memo offered an enactment for states trying to support a idiosyncratic whose individuality was stolen to fraudulently cod unemployment benefits. To sphere a grounds of the fraud but support guiltless radical from being linked to it, states could make a “pseudo claim,” the memo advises.

Those “pseudo claims” led to records of toddlers and centenarians getting checks. The Labor Department's inspector wide tallied immoderate 4,895 unemployment claims from radical implicit the property of 100 betwixt March 2020 and April 2022, but different departmental memo explained that the filings stemmed from states changing dates of birth to support radical whose identities were used.

“Many of the claims identified ... were not payments to individuals implicit 100 years of age, but alternatively ‘pseudo records’ of antecedently identified fraudulent claims,” the 2023 memo says.

A Labor Department spokeswoman did not respond to questions astir Musk's findings and DOGE gave nary details connected however it came to find the expected fraud oregon whether it duplicates what was already found.

Though DOGE ostensibly looked astatine longer timeframe than national investigators antecedently had, it tallied conscionable $382 cardinal successful fake unemployment claims, a tiny fraction of what investigators were already aware.

In 2022, the Labor Department said suspected COVID-era unemployment fraud totaled much than $45 billion. The Government Accountability Office aboriginal said it was acold worse, likely $100 cardinal to $135 billion.

“I don't deliberation it's quality to anyone,” says Amy Traub, an adept connected unemployment astatine the National Employment Law Project. “It's been wide reported. There've been aggregate legislature hearings.”

If DOGE's newest allegations person an aerial of familiarity, it's due to the fact that they echo its anterior findings of about Social Security payments to the dormant and the unbelievably old. Those were mendacious claims.

That makes DOGE an imperfect messenger adjacent erstwhile fraud has occurred, arsenic with unemployment claims.

Jessica Reidl, a elder chap astatine the blimpish deliberation vessel The Manhattan Institute, is simply a fiscal blimpish who truthful champions rooting retired national discarded she has written 600 articles connected the subject. Though she believes unemployment security fraud is rife, she has occupation accepting immoderate findings from DOGE, which she says has acted ineffectively and perchance illegally.

“When DOGE says impossibly aged dormant radical are collecting unemployment successful immense numbers, I go skeptical,” Reidl says. “DOGE does not person a bully way grounds successful that area.”

Traub said the burst of pandemic-era unemployment fraud led states to instrumentality caller information measures. She questioned wherefore Musk’s squad was trumpeting aged fraud arsenic if it’s new.

“Business leaders and economists are informing astir a earthy recession, truthful it’s earthy to deliberation astir unemployment,” says Traub. “It’s an onslaught connected the representation of a critically important programme and possibly an effort to undermine nationalist enactment connected unemployment security erstwhile it couldn’t beryllium much important.”

___

Matt Sedensky tin beryllium reached astatine msedensky@ap.org and https://x.com/sedensky.

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.