6 hours ago
4
Why Elon Musk is stepping backmost from DOGE
Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency, oregon DOGE, says it has saved $160 billion done its propulsion to basal retired wasteful oregon fraudulent authorities spending. But that effort whitethorn besides person travel astatine a outgo for taxpayers, with a caller investigation from a nonpartisan probe and advocacy radical estimating that DOGE's actions volition outgo $135 cardinal this fiscal year.
The investigation seeks to tally the costs associated with putting tens of thousands of national employees connected paid leave, re-hiring mistakenly fired workers and mislaid productivity, according to the Partnership for Public Service (PSP), a nonpartisan nonprofit that focuses connected the national workforce.
PSP's estimation is based connected the $270 cardinal successful yearly compensation costs for the national workforce, calculating the interaction of DOGE's actions, from paid permission to productivity hits. The $135 cardinal outgo to taxpayers doesn't see the disbursal of defending aggregate lawsuits challenging DOGE's actions, nor the interaction of estimated mislaid taxation collections owed to unit cuts astatine the IRS.
DOGE has sought to slash national spending by urging authorities workers to judge a deferred resignation plan, which allowed galore employees to clasp afloat wage and benefits done September without working. Another 24,000 authorities employees who were fired arsenic portion of the betterment effort person since been rehired aft a tribunal ruling.
Other agencies besides person rehired immoderate workers aft mistakenly firing them, specified arsenic bird flu experts who were dismissed by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. Federal workers person besides had to instrumentality connected tasks specified arsenic documenting their weekly accomplishments, which has lowered productivity, Max Stier, president of the Partnership for Public Service, told CBS MoneyWatch.
"We haven't seen overmuch absorption connected the discarded [DOGE] is creating," Stier told CBS MoneyWatch astir his group's determination to analyse the costs of DOGE's cuts. "This is an effort that was created to code waste, but we were seeing the opposite."
"Ultimately it's the nationalist that volition extremity up paying for this," helium added, noting that helium expects the taxpayers costs to turn aft different DOGE cuts instrumentality effect.
The White House took contented with the analysis.
"The continued attempts to sow uncertainty successful the monolithic accomplishments of this never-before-seen effort to marque authorities much businesslike speaks much astir the illegitimacy of those peddling these falsehoods than bully enactment of DOGE," White House spokesperson Harrison Fields said. "The American nationalist are successful lockstep with the president's ngo and volition not beryllium swayed by much lies coming from the bequest media."
Why occupation cuts could rise costs
The IRS, which is readying connected cutting roughly 40% of its workforce, could forego $323 cardinal successful taxation gross implicit the adjacent decennary owed to little taxation compliance and a diminution successful audits, according to an estimate from the Yale Budget Lab.
To beryllium sure, the DOGE cuts could wage disconnected implicit time, with a leaner, much focused national workforce. For example, the nonstop savings from those layoffs volition magnitude to $38 cardinal implicit 10 years, the Partnership for Public Service estimated.
But Stier maintains that the costs for taxpayers could turn arsenic they ripple done the economy, specified arsenic reductions successful backing of wellness and subject research. One analysis by researchers astatine institutions including the University of Maryland and University of Pennsylvania estimates that cuts to wellness probe volition effect successful a $16 cardinal yearly economical loss, with 68,000 jobs lost.
"One tin ever ideate a occurrence occurring, but nary of this makes consciousness connected truthful galore antithetic levels," Stier said.
DOGE's "wall of receipts"
DOGE keeps a moving nationalist tally of the national wealth the task unit says it has saved, posted connected its website successful what is called a "wall of receipts." But immoderate of those savings person been overstated, a February CBS News investigation found.
At the aforesaid time, DOGE's $160 cardinal successful savings is acold little than Musk's antecedently stated extremity of shrinking yearly authorities spending by $2 trillion, oregon astir one-third of the national budget. Many experts accidental that acold much ambitious nonsubjective is improbable to beryllium achieved without cutting large national programs similar Social Security and Medicare, which President Trump has vowed not to touch.
Musk said Tuesday that he'll curtail his enactment astatine DOGE starting successful May. His determination comes arsenic Tesla, the electrical conveyance shaper helium runs, saw a 71% plunge successful first-quarter nett and a 20% diminution successful conveyance income arsenic immoderate consumers snubbed the marque owed to objections to Musk's authorities work.
Musk said helium inactive plans to walk 1 to 2 days a week connected DOGE-related work, focusing connected eliminating authorities waste.
"I'll person to proceed to support doing it for the remainder of the president's word to marque definite the discarded and fraud doesn't travel roaring back," helium said during Tesla's first-quarter net telephone connected Tuesday.
Aimee Picchi is the subordinate managing exertion for CBS MoneyWatch, wherever she covers concern and idiosyncratic finance. She antecedently worked astatine Bloomberg News and has written for nationalist quality outlets including USA Today and Consumer Reports.
English (US) ·