3 hours ago
2
Grieving household fights DOGE cuts
The Department of Government Efficiency, oregon DOGE, has added a caller batch of entries to what it calls its "Wall of Receipts," touting purported savings successful the hundreds of millions of dollars. Yet galore of these claimed cuts look to beryllium misleading, and the imaginable for existent savings continues to beryllium uncertain.
According to the running tally connected its website, DOGE claims it has saved American taxpayers a full of $170 billion. However, lone $70.9 cardinal is itemized, and galore of those entries proceed to rise superior doubts astir their accuracy.
Some person expressed skepticism, including Nat Malkus, a elder chap astatine the conservative-leaning American Enterprise Institute. Malkus, who has been tracking DOGE's work, said his reappraisal indicates the savings is much apt to beryllium astir $80 billion.
"[They are] implicit estimating contracts by a origin of two," Malkus said.
Other costs and expenses associated with staffing reductions could extremity up costing the authorities adjacent much than those purported savings.
Since it was created by President Trump via an enforcement bid connected his archetypal time successful office, the Elon Musk-helmed DOGE started posting purported savings for cancellations to contracts, grants and leases. News organizations including CBS News person identified a multitude of mistakes including triple and adjacent quadruple counting of contracts. Many of those person been corrected aft being highlighted but DOGE's fig for full savings has not.
On Monday, DOGE updated its "Wall of Receipts" to see astatine slightest 848 further contracts. Those totaled $639 million, with claimed savings of $278.5 million. But 553 were noted arsenic $0 savings.
In this caller release, CBS News has identified 1 large mistake involving a $38.7 cardinal declaration for wastewater monitoring for COVID. DOGE claimed $38 cardinal successful savings from canceling it. This is the 2nd largest redeeming itemized successful the astir caller release. CBS News contacted the company, Verily Life Sciences, who disputed its cancellation and said that the declaration was inactive active.
A CDC spokesperson confirmed this and clarified that the declaration was simply modified, not canceled. "This was an expired scope of enactment that has been superseded by a caller moving contract," the spokesperson explained. The caller contract, listed successful authorities databases, is valued astatine $41 cardinal and extends done August 6, 2026.
"It's precise odd. It's disingenuous to accidental they saved each this money," Malkus told CBS News.
A spokesperson for the White House and DOGE has not responded to questions from CBS News.
DOGE is besides present claiming savings successful the tens of millions for canceling astatine slightest 1 national contract—just signed by the Trump administration.
The largest caller declaration cancellation posted to the Wall of Receipts is for a $72 cardinal administrative enactment declaration precocious awarded to Universal Strategic Advisors LLC to assistance ICE with expanded migration enforcement, portion of the Trump administration's determination to statesman wide deportations. DOGE claimed $66 cardinal successful savings, yet the declaration had lone been awarded a fewer weeks earlier. A institution typical confirmed it was "terminated for convenience," with nary mentation provided by the government. The typical besides noted that ICE's operational needs for specified services apt inactive exist, arsenic the bureau continues to expand. The Department of Homeland Security has not yet responded to a CBS News query.
Claimed savings besides see $5.6 cardinal from cuts to a programme monitoring younker baccy use, $3.9 cardinal from the cancellation of a nationalist concussion surveillance system, and $1.9 cardinal from terminating a National Firefighter Registry.
According to Malkus "They person this comic mathematics explanation of savings that doesn't accurately seizure what the emblematic idiosyncratic would ever presumption arsenic a savings amount."
DOGE besides appears to person deleted 96 contracts posted earlier May 4 totaling $124.7 cardinal successful purported savings.
Despite these inconsistencies, DOGE maintains that the "Wall of Receipts" is simply a exemplary of transparency.
Elon Musk has repeatedly defended the level — and DOGE's outgo cutting authorities — including citing a astir $1 cardinal authorities survey that, helium claimed, should person outgo conscionable $10,000. Requests to the White House for details connected that assertion person gone unanswered.
Although the Trump medication insisted Musk was ne'er formally the DOGE administrator, helium was DOGE's nationalist face. Musk precocious announced that he'd beryllium stepping backmost from DOGE to absorption connected Tesla and his different companies.
Many of these contracts besides autumn nether the "termination for convenience" regularisation that allows contractors to marque claims to the national authorities for expenses they've incurred similar staffing expenses, bureau abstraction and mislaid profits. Denials tin beryllium appealed to national courts and whitethorn instrumentality years to beryllium resolved.
"We cognize these termination settlements are going in, but is anyone paying attention? I conscionable wonderment who is keeping their eyes connected that spending," Malkus says.
Ultimately whether oregon immoderate of these cuts adhd up to savings for taxpayers volition beryllium determined by Congress, erstwhile and if the Trump medication submits a rescission request, a process successful which the President formally requests Congress instrumentality backmost funds allocated to circumstantial programs.
A CBS News analysis of authorities spending revealed that the national authorities has spent $200 cardinal much successful its archetypal 100 days than past year— a inclination that is projected to continue.
- In:
- DOGE
English (US) ·