Decision to remove fluoride from Miami-Dade waters signals divide between commissioners

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, Fla. – Miami-Dade County commissioners voted Tuesday to region fluoride from the county’s drinking water, reversing a decades-old nationalist wellness measurement that section dentists and nationalist officials accidental has helped forestall bony decay since 1958.

Miami-Dade District 7 Commissioner Raquel Regalado, who oversees the county’s Water and Sewer Department, opposed the move.

“They made this determination without a heavy dive into the subject and without talking to experts. It is simply a governmental determination that was made,” Regalado said.

The adjacent measurement successful the process involves decommissioning parts of the county’s h2o attraction facilities that person agelong adjusted people occurring fluoride levels to optimal standards for dental health.

“We person 30 days to instrumentality retired the h2o completely,” Regalado said. “We commencement with eliminating the contracts of purchasing of the fluoride and uncovering idiosyncratic who wants to bargain the fluoride from us.”

Fluoride has been added to Miami-Dade’s h2o proviso for implicit 65 years arsenic a nationalist work aimed astatine reducing dental decay successful children and adults. Experts pass removing it could pb to accrued dental problems, peculiarly for low-income families.

“We cognize arsenic of 80 years of probe that it is harmless and effectual to forestall bony decay due to the fact that it strengthens dental enamel,” said Dr. Beatriz Terry, contiguous past president of the Florida Dental Association.

“I can’t judge we are having this treatment close now, due to the fact that it is specified a large nationalist work — having fluoride successful the h2o was the archetypal enactment of defense.”

Terry said parents should crook to fluoridated toothpaste and rinses, but emphasized that topical applications aren’t arsenic effectual arsenic systemic ingestion.

“Topical fluoride exertion does not conscionable the aforesaid needs arsenic systemic ingestion of fluoride truthful it won’t beryllium the same,” she said. “But if they’re seeing an uptick successful decay, they request to beryllium notifying their authorities officials.”

Miami-Dade would not beryllium the archetypal assemblage to reverse fluoridation, and experts accidental past shows that decay often rises sharply aft removal.

“My interest is we are going to person a higher incidence of decay — it has been shown,” Terry said. “There are different states, countries that person tried this lone to spell backmost and enactment fluoride successful the water.”

One specified illustration is Calgary, Canada, which removed fluoride successful 2011 lone to ballot to reconstruct it aft dental infections astatine Alberta Children’s Hospital roseate by 700%, with fractional the cases successful children nether five.

In Juneau, Alaska, and elsewhere, probe has shown a astir 25% summation successful cavities pursuing fluoridation cessation. Click here to reappraisal a 2016 survey connected this trend.

Back successful Calgary, a plebiscite held successful 2021 showed 62% of voters supported putting fluoride backmost into the city’s water.

In Buffalo, New York, Terry said immoderate residents are suing their section authorities implicit accrued decay.

“Parents request to beryllium informed,” Terry said. “Recognize that the experts, the dentists are the ones pushing for fluoride. If it were atrocious for you, we would beryllium successful favour of taking it out. Actually, that would summation our business, right? We are doing it due to the fact that we judge that arsenic a profession, preventative attraction is astir important.”

Regalado echoed ineligible concerns:

“I judge the region should not person done this,” she said. “I deliberation they are stepping into a people action. All the counties who person done this successful the past person been sued and volition beryllium sued, truthful I deliberation we are exposing our residents to litigation unnecessarily.”

To assistance offset the impacts, Commissioner Roberto Gonzalez’s bureau shared a database of low-cost and escaped dental resources for families:

The American Dental Association states that assemblage h2o fluoridation is “safe and effectual successful preventing bony decay for some children and adults,” and nationalist wellness decisions should trust connected the “collective value of technological evidence.”

Critics of the decision accidental authorities leaders person relied connected fringe oregon flawed studies to warrant their stance. One specified study linked fluoride vulnerability to little IQ successful children, but was based connected levels much than doubly the U.S. regulatory limit.

Florida Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo has acknowledged that fluoride helps fortify enamel but precocious told commissioners that the contented was “new” to him.

He suggested providing escaped toothpaste alternatively of fluoridating the water.

“There are 2 types of fluoride and they are some critically important,” said Dr. Richard Mufson, an oral surgeon based successful Aventura. “You can’t conscionable accidental let’s hide the systemic and conscionable bash topical due to the fact that that is not astir arsenic bully — you request both.”

Mufson warned of the semipermanent wellness consequences of untreated cavities, which tin pb to facial infections, hospitalizations, and successful immoderate cases, death.

“Cavities are a atrocious occupation due to the fact that they go bigger cavities,” helium said. “That develops into perchance a facial corruption and hospitalizations and IV antibiotics and adjacent death.”

State lawmakers passed a measure that would prohibition the nationalist wellness instrumentality of assemblage fluoridation statewide. It awaits Gov. Ron DeSantis’ signature. Click here for much information.

Copyright 2025 by WPLG Local10.com - All rights reserved.