3 hours ago
4
Questions implicit Texas flood informing systems
As the decease toll climbs successful cardinal Texas from catastrophic flooding implicit the vacation weekend, galore are wondering however the tragic event could person been prevented and who is to blame.
President Trump has declared a large catastrophe for the authorities of Texas pursuing flood waters that person claimed more than 80 lives truthful far. At slightest 27 campers and counselors from Camp Mystic, a summertime campy for girls, were killed successful the flooding.
The tempest dumped up to 20 inches of rainfall connected immoderate areas, and Guadalupe River astatine Kerrville roseate much than 20 feet successful conscionable an hr successful the aboriginal greeting of Friday, July 4. Many officials person begun to constituent fingers arsenic to wherefore the waters roseate truthful quickly, with truthful small warning.
During a July 4 property conference, Nim Kidd, the main of the Texas Division of Emergency Management, said the forecast his bureau received connected Wednesday successful beforehand of the tempest predicted respective inches of rain, but that "the magnitude of rainfall that fell astatine this circumstantial determination was ne'er successful immoderate of those forecast."
Kerrville metropolis manager Dalton Rice reiterated that sentiment successful the aforesaid property conference, saying the storms that deed the areas "dumped much rainfall than what was forecasted."
But erstwhile the aforesaid officials were asked why exigency managers didn't bash more to alert the nationalist and evacuate campers successful the area, they didn't person a wide response, stressing that they were focused connected the missing victims.
Vehicles beryllium submerged arsenic a hunt and rescue idiosyncratic looks done debris for immoderate survivors oregon remains of radical swept up successful the flash flooding connected July 6, 2025 successful Hunt, Texas.
Jim Vondruska / Getty Images
According to Kerr County Judge Rob Kelly, a apical section authorities official, the country does "not person a informing system," and authorities were shocked by the ferocity of the floods.
The country is prone to flooding, and transcripts of their meetings amusement Kerr County commissioners discussed whether to instal an outdoor flood informing strategy respective times successful caller years, but hadn't done truthful owed to the cost.
Timeline of forecasts and warnings
The day earlier the catastrophe struck, the National Weather Service bureau successful Austin/San Antonio issued a flood ticker connected July 3 astatine 1:18 p.m. CT that included Kerrville. The alert stated: "Rainfall amounts of 1 to 3 inches with isolated amounts of 5 to 7 inches are possible."
But a convergence of thunderstorms sent the rainfall totals higher, and h2o levels successful the Guadalupe River adjacent Kerrville skyrocketed from 0.34 feet astatine 11:45 p.m. CT connected July 3 — good beneath flood signifier — to a raging 34.29 feet by 6:45 a.m. connected July 4, according to the U.S. Geological Survey.
A CBS News investigation of the exigency upwind alerts successful the authorities of Texas recovered determination were 22 warnings from the National Weather Service for Kerr County and the Kerrville area, wherever the astir catastrophic flooding occurred.
The archetypal informing to residents occurred astatine 1:14 a.m. CT connected July 4, urging radical to debar flooded roadways, but not calling for evacuations. A somewhat earlier announcement was issued up of midnight for Bandera County, which is adjacent to Kerr.
The archetypal upwind exigency alert sent by the National Weather Service with urgent connection instructing radical to "seek higher crushed now" was sent astatine 4:03 a.m. CT, according to CBS News reappraisal of each alert sent to cellphones from July 2 to July 5. At this constituent the stream was rising, astir 1.74-feet high. But determination were nary alerts sent to cellphones successful the country by Kerr oregon Bandera section authorities officials. The lone accusation the nationalist could lone trust connected was National Weather Service announcements that were sent successful the mediate of the nighttime and aboriginal morning.
During the astir captious hours — from 5 a.m. until astir 7 a.m. CT, erstwhile the stream roseate from 1.82-feet to 34.29-feet due to the fact that of the 5-10 inches of rainfall that had fallen — the National Weather Service sent retired 3 captious cellphone messages to Kerr County, which includes Camp Mystic, saying "This is simply a PARTICULARLY DANGEROUS SITUATION. SEEK HIGHER GROUND NOW!"
Some Kerrville residents told CBS News they received nary telephone warnings earlier the flood hit, oregon that they don't wage overmuch attraction to the upwind warnings they bash receive.
"We get alerts regularly astir flash flood warnings," Kerrville nonmigratory Heidi Easton told CBS News. "I benignant of conscionable swipe … due to the fact that it usually doesn't mean much."
The Integrated Public Alert Warning System, known arsenic IPAWS, is bundle utilized to nonstop exigency substance alerts to cellphones, but nary were initiated by Kerr County, according to CBS News' analysis. The lone notifications sent to the nationalist were the ones from the National Weather Service.
Meteorologists support National Weather Service forecasts
Local officials person claimed the forecasts were not accurate, and the astir utmost rainfall totals did transcend what was predicted. But galore experts person travel retired and defended the enactment of the National Weather Service.
"There person been claims that NOAA/NWS did not foresee catastrophic TX floods--but that's simply not true," said clime idiosyncratic Daniel Swain of UCLA in a societal media post, "This was undoubtedly an utmost event, but messaging rapidly escalated opening ~12 hrs prior."
An aerial presumption implicit the Guadalupe River connected July 6, 2025 successful Kerrville, Texas, aft dense rainfall caused deadly flooding.
Getty Images
Concerns astir staffing and fund cuts astatine the National Weather Service person been successful the quality since the Trump medication took bureau successful January.
The San Antonio and San Angelo upwind forecasts offices, which issued warnings for the affected areas, are presently operating with 23 meteorologists connected staff, according to national officials for the National Weather Service. The 2 offices person a combined full of 10 vacancies, including a informing coordination meteorologist successful San Antonio, leaving them somewhat abbreviated of being afloat staffed. The informing coordination meteorologist plays a important relation successful coordinating with section officials astir terrible upwind emergencies.
Texas Gov. Gregg Abbott was asked astir concerns implicit staffing levels and fund cuts astatine the National Weather Service during a Sunday property league and said helium "knows nothing" astir its staffing, though helium said helium did talk to Kristi Noem, the caput of the Department of Homeland Security, astir budgeting for upwind offices. Abbott said determination are plans to clasp a peculiar league of the Texas State Legislature to analyse what happened successful Kerrville.
When asked if the national authorities should prosecute backmost much meteorologists, President Trump said, "I truly wouldn't, I deliberation not." He spoke to reporters connected Sunday astir the Texas flooding, saying, "Nobody expected it, cipher saw it."
But the White House defended the enactment of the National Weather Service to CBS News and shared galore reports of statements from different meteorologists, including Jason Runyon, who works for the National Weather Service and said that its bureau successful New Braunfels, which contributes forecasts for Austin, San Antonio and different areas affected by the flooding, had other unit connected work during the storms.
"The National Weather Service upwind forecasts offices successful San Angelo and San Antonio got ithe forecast right," said Tom Fahy, the legislative manager for the National Weather Service Employees Organization, the national that represents upwind work workers. "The forecasters did their jobs."
But Fahy has taken contented with immoderate fund cuts enacted by this administration. He told CBS News that reduced backing for captious upwind programs focused connected the past level of warnings disseminated to the nationalist are to blasted for overmuch of what happened successful Texas.
"Tragically, radical volition die" if backing and accrued staffing of meteorologists and different unit are not restored, helium told CBS News.
Some of the programs Fahy cited that person been suspended subordinate to coordinating betwixt NWS meteorologists and state, local, and region exigency absorption officials and nationalist information officers. He besides raised interest astir cuts to probe labs that are liable for studying catastrophic upwind events to amended recognize wherefore they hap and however the nationalist tin beryllium amended prepared for them.
"This comes down to the warnings and much staff," Fahy told CBS News, "This is wherefore we bash this grooming stuff, and that's wherefore backing has to beryllium restored to fortify collaborative exercises with the exigency absorption assemblage to forestall tragedies similar this weekend."
English (US) ·