Amish man killed neighbor, left body in home with her goat, kept living across the street for weeks: Police

An Amish antheral successful Ohio has been arrested for allegedly sidesplitting his neighbor, a 28-year-old pistillate who was a subordinate of the aforesaid Amish community, astir a period aft authorities said she was recovered dormant wrong of her location with her goat.

Samuel Hochstetler was taken into custody connected Monday and charged with 1 number of murder successful the March slaying of Rosanna Kinsinger, authorities announced. According to a news release from the Meigs County Sheriff’s Office, deputies connected Thursday, March 13, 2025, responded to a telephone regarding a “suspicious death” astatine a residence connected Dye Road successful Rutland, Ohio. Rutland is conscionable nether 200 miles southbound of Cleveland.

Upon arriving astatine the scene, archetypal responders said they located the assemblage of an big pistillate — aboriginal identified arsenic Kinsinger — and conducted an archetypal reappraisal of the location earlier contacting the Meigs County Coroner’s Office. The coroner determined that Kinsinger’s decease was “suspicious” earlier sending her remains to the Montgomery County Coroner’s Office for an autopsy. Authorities said that the results of the autopsy were inconclusive.

Love existent crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life transgression stories delivered close to your inbox.

Authorities detained Hochstetler connected Monday and transported him to the sheriff’s office, wherever helium was interviewed by detectives. Though authorities did not supply details, instantly pursuing the interview, Hochstetler was arrested and charged with Kinsinger’s murder.

“This lawsuit was specified a calamity to those who knew Rosanna. She was a beloved idiosyncratic successful her community,” Sheriff Scott Fitch said successful a connection pursuing the arrest. “Detectives person worked astir the timepiece searching for answers and were capable to get those answers. Hopefully this probe helps bring immoderate closure to the victim’s household and connected behalf of the Sheriff’s Office we connection our deepest condolences.”

According to a report from Huntington, West Virginia, NBC affiliate WSAZ, Hochstetler had moved to the assemblage from Kentucky and had been staying with a antheral named Mose Troyer successful the months earlier Kinsinger’s death, arsenic good arsenic the weeks starring up to his arrest.

Troyer reportedly told the presumption that connected March 13, helium and respective others successful the assemblage realized they had not seen Kinsinger astatine each that day. That evening, Troyer said helium went to cheque connected her astatine her home, which is wherever helium discovered her dormant wrong the location and called 911. Her goat was besides wrong of the home, the study says.

Troyer said that successful summation to the fearfulness sparked by the alleged murder, helium was besides disturbed by the thought that the antheral allegedly liable for sidesplitting Kinsinger had surviving successful his location aft the crime.

The sheriff’s bureau said the enactment of galore investigators and members of the assemblage led them to place Hochstetler arsenic a imaginable suspect.

“Since the clip of death, Meigs County Sheriff’s Office Detectives person worked tirelessly executing hunt warrants, conducting interviews and processing grounds collected from the scene,” the bureau said successful the release. “Detectives followed up connected galore tips, leads, and rumors and done investigative efforts, Detectives were capable to place Samuel Hochstetler arsenic a idiosyncratic of involvement successful the case.”