A US-led effort to end the war in Ukraine looks favorable to Russia, but mixed signals emerge

TALLINN – The discussions person taken spot in an ornate Kremlin hall, connected the polished marble of St. Peter’s Basilica and successful a famously contentious league successful the Oval Office of the White House.

What’s emerged truthful acold from the Washington-led effort to extremity the warfare successful Ukraine suggests a woody that seems apt to beryllium favorable to Russia: President Donald Trump has sharply rebuked Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, echoed Kremlin talking points, and indicated Kyiv would person to surrender territory and forego NATO membership. What’s more, helium has engaged successful a rapprochement with Moscow that was unthinkable months ago.

More recently, Trump has offered mixed signals — societal media posts that possibly Russian President Vladimir Putin is stringing him along — and a woody has yet to materialize.

While the optics truthful acold person been successful the Kremlin’s favor, nary proposals that were enactment distant person been cemented.

And connected Wednesday, Washington and Kyiv signed an agreement granting American entree to Ukraine’s immense mineral resources that could alteration continued subject assistance to the state nether ongoing attacks from Russia.

Dialogue and aligned imaginativeness

One summation for the Kremlin is that Washington is talking again to Moscow aft years of highly strained ties pursuing its 2022 penetration of Ukraine — and not conscionable astir the war, said Nikolay Petrov, elder probe chap with the New Eurasian Strategies Centre deliberation tank.

Russian officials and authorities media from the precise commencement of discussions with Trump’s officials sought to underscore that Ukraine was lone 1 point connected the immense docket of the “two superpowers.” Trump and Putin talked successful March astir Ukraine but besides the Middle East, stopping the proliferation of strategical weapons and adjacent organizing hockey games betwixt the countries.

Russia's main authorities TV transmission reported that the gathering betwixt Putin and Trump envoy Steve-Witkoff showed that Moscow and Washington were gathering “a caller operation of the world” together.

In this sense, “Putin already got a portion of what helium sought” — the optics of Russia arsenic a state that is connected par with the U.S., Petrov said.

Trump has said Crimea, the Ukrainian peninsula Moscow illegally annexed successful 2014, “will enactment with Russia,” and outlines of a bid connection his squad reportedly presented to Kyiv past period seemingly included allowing Russia to support power of different occupied Ukrainian territories. Trump, who had a contentious gathering with Zelenskyy successful the Oval Office connected Feb. 28, lashed retired astatine him for publically rejecting the thought of ceding land, and besides said that Kyiv was improbable to ever articulation NATO.

All of these person agelong been Moscow’s talking points, and Trump’s usage of them suggested his administration’s imaginativeness was aligned with the Kremlin’s.

Trump besides seemingly puts much unit connected Kyiv than Moscow successful trying to scope a bid woody and appears anxious to instrumentality to a much mean narration with Russia and its “big concern opportunities," said Sam Greene of King’s College London.

“Is determination immoderate portion of this that doesn’t look similar a triumph for Russia? No,” Greene adds.

So far, it's lone talk

But truthful far, each of this has remained thing but rhetoric, with presumption of a imaginable colony inactive precise overmuch “in the air,” says Sergey Radchenko, a historiographer and a prof astatine the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies.

Moreover, determination are inactive demands by some Russia and Ukraine that would beryllium hard to reconcile successful immoderate benignant of bid settlement.

Ukraine refuses to cede immoderate onshore and wants robust information guarantees against aboriginal aggression, perchance involving a contingent of peacekeepers -– thing a fistful of European nations person been discussing and Russia publically rejects arsenic a nonstarter.

Russia, successful turn, demands that it holds onto the territory it has seized arsenic good arsenic nary NATO rank for Ukraine. It besides wants Kyiv to “demilitarize,” oregon importantly trim its equipped force.

Radchenko sees the second arsenic a large sticking constituent successful bid talks, due to the fact that a strong, viable service is important for Ukraine to support itself.

“If determination are restrictions connected the kinds of weapons Ukraine tin person (from the West) oregon the size of the army, past it volition beryllium precise hard to get them to judge this benignant of agreement,” helium said.

Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov seemingly raised the stakes further this week by saying that planetary designation of regions annexed from Ukraine by Russia was “imperative” for a bid deal.

Achieving that remains unclear, fixed that dozens of countries person decried the annexations arsenic violating planetary law.

What if the US walks away?

Some analysts judge it is successful Putin's involvement to prolong the warfare and support making gains connected the battlefield.

Trump, Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio person threatened to lavation their hands of the bid effort if determination is nary advancement soon.

Putin, successful an evident motion of willingness to support talking, announced this week a 72-hour ceasefire starting May 8 for Russia's Victory Day vacation that marks the decision of Nazi Germany successful World War II.

Zelenskyy dismissed the motion arsenic a further effort by Putin astatine “manipulation” to drawstring on the U.S., saying a ceasefire should statesman instantly and past longer.

Greene noted that the Russian ruble and markets person been doing amended precocious implicit expectations of a bid woody and U.S. businesses and investors coming back, "and determination whitethorn beryllium a terms to beryllium paid” for pulling retired the rug from nether that.

The larger question is what happens connected the battlefield if the Trump medication withdraws from the bid effort.

“When the Trump medication says they’ll locomotion away, we don’t cognize what that means. Does that mean they locomotion distant from negotiations and support supporting Ukraine?” Greene said.

Greene says that Ukraine astir apt doesn’t consciousness assured that the U.S. stepping backmost from the process means that Washington volition support supporting Kyiv, adding that Russia whitethorn not beryllium definite of the Trump medication ending aid, either.

“I deliberation it’s precise hard for the Kremlin to cipher the risks of dragging this out,” helium said.

And U.S. Treasury Secretary Sctott Bessent said the mineral deal "signals intelligibly to Russia that the Trump medication is committed to a bid process centered connected a free, sovereign, and prosperous Ukraine implicit the agelong term.”

A batch depends connected whether Europe tin measurement up and capable immoderate gaps successful U.S. aid.

If Trump walks distant from the bid effort and inactive pursues normalizing relations with Russia, lifting sanctions, “this volition magnitude to a large breakthrough” for Putin, but it's not a given, Radchenko says.

That would beryllium an uphill conflict for Trump arsenic “there’s a batch of legislature sanctions that are predicated connected the warfare successful Ukraine,” Greene notes.

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.