A jury is deciding the fate of an Australian woman accused of 3 murders by mushroom poisoning

MORWELL – A assemblage successful Australia began deliberations Monday successful the triple execution trial of Erin Patterson, accused of sidesplitting her estranged husband’s relatives by deliberately serving them poisonous mushrooms for lunch.

Three of Patterson’s 4 luncheon guests — her parents-in-law Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail’s sister Heather Wilkinson — died successful the infirmary aft the 2023 repast astatine her location successful Leongatha, astatine which she served idiosyncratic beef Wellington pastries containing decease headdress mushrooms.

She is accused of attempting to execution the fourth, Heather’s hubby Ian Wilkinson, who was gravely sick but survived.

During the nine-week Supreme Court proceedings successful the authorities of Victoria, Patterson gave evidence successful her ain defense. The 50-year-old parent of 2 faces beingness successful situation if convicted.

Jury indispensable determine if mushroom navigator meant to kill

It isn’t disputed that Patterson served her guests the toxic mushrooms oregon that the repast killed them. But the assemblage indispensable determine whether she meant for them to die.

Prosecutors successful the case, which has gripped Australia for 2 years, said the accused pistillate researched, foraged and served the mushrooms deliberately and lied to investigators to screen her tracks. Their lawsuit against Patterson included that she disposed of a nutrient dehydrator aft the fatal repast and reset her telephone aggregate times.

The prosecution said she lied astir having a dire aesculapian diagnosis to guarantee her guests attended the lunch, cooked idiosyncratic pastries to debar poisoning herself, and faked symptoms to marque it look arsenic though she fell ill, too.

But Patterson’s lawyers said the poisoning was a unspeakable mishap caused by a pantry mix-up of store-bought and chaotic mushrooms, which she didn’t cognize they were decease caps. The defence lawsuit was that Patterson wasn’t arsenic sick arsenic the different diners due to the fact that she induced vomiting aft the repast owed to an eating disorder.

The accused lied to the constabulary that she had ne'er foraged mushrooms oregon owned a dehydrator retired of panic, her lawyers said. Patterson denied telling her luncheon guests she had a confirmed diagnosis of cancer.

Prosecutors offered nary motive

Justice Christopher Beale spent 4 days summarizing the lawsuit to jurors earlier their deliberations began, urging them not to beryllium swayed by bias oregon prejudice, oregon by sympathy for the families of those who died. Patterson’s lies, immoderate of which she admitted during her evidence, could beryllium utilized to measure her credibility but didn’t mean she was blameworthy of murder, Justice Beale said.

Prosecutors didn’t connection a motive for the alleged killings and weren’t required to. But they suggested a deteriorating narration betwixt the accused and her estranged husband, Simon Patterson, arsenic good arsenic her exasperation with her erstwhile in-laws, which she expressed to friends connected societal media months earlier the deaths.

The defence said Erin Patterson had a affirmative and loving narration with her luncheon guests, who included her children’s lone surviving grandparents, and that she had nary crushed to termination them. Justice Beale highlighted successful his summary of the lawsuit the fleeting and insignificant quality of the past disputes.

Simon Patterson was invited to the fatal luncheon but didn’t go.

Jurors volition stay sequestered

A 14-member assemblage has been proceeding the case, but 12 were selected by ballot Monday to determine the verdict. The assemblage volition stay sequestered, meaning they volition enactment unneurotic successful court-appointed accommodation until they scope a unanimous decision.

The lengthy proceedings successful the municipality of Morwell, Victoria, has drawn queues of radical anxious to ticker proceedings each day.

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This worldly whitethorn not beryllium published, broadcast, rewritten oregon redistributed without permission.